News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by Barrin92 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:29PM (#26346997)
force protocols to be open would just about do it. People would trivially write cross-service applications on top and we could have an internet where people can freely move data around. Apple and Google would be delegated to the backend and users could choose the clients they want. It's honestly so trivial and uninvasive of a regulatory matter it's ridiculous. We're stuck in the 19th century railroad industry.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by azinman2 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:57PM (#26347364)
So, someone (who?) comes out with a standard, and then everyone just freezes capabilities then? Nothing evolves? Or if it does, it does so very unequally? Already in this announcement is the non-transfer of Live Photos because presumably Google doesn't support it. Apparently they also have a 20k per album cap, which at that point you get different behavior than you're expecting. These are just a few examples of where things go wrong.

If we're going to legislate anything, I believe the right way is to force complete data export is made available via a reasonable API/process, which then allows people to independently evolve & progress, and competitors will then need to support (or not) what comes out on the other side. But customers then know they can always extract or simply backup their data themselves if needed.

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by Barrin92 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:08PM (#26347528)
>and then everyone just freezes capabilities then? Nothing evolves? Or if it does, it does so very unequally?

every client provider can do whatever they want, that'd be the beauty of it. Someone could write a stripped down, privacy respecting Facebook client and charge users five bucks instead of running ads, if that's what users want. Someone could offer a chronological news-feed free of algorithmic meddling, or one that you can fine-tune however you like. That'd would simply be developer and user choice. Just think of RSS-readers or podcast apps or email clients. They're not all equal, but that's a feature, not something gone wrong.

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by leadingthenet on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:15PM (#26347641)
> every client provider can do whatever they want

I feel like you're missing his point a bit, which is that sure they can do whatever they want, but it would be within a well-defined and highly regulated system, and would need to conform to an interface that would be difficult to change and evolve.

A bit like how IRC never really got updated with features people like to see in newer IM apps, like conversation history, read receipts, sending images and videos, threading, and so on. Or HTTP. Or email. Federation always leads to ossification.

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by lrem on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:19PM (#26348500)
I think you missed an important link here: opening the API is not the same as making a good standard. The latter tends to take years. The former... Well, Google internal APIs often have minor changes every couple weeks. And the standard of documentation is more or less "go read the code". Opening those would not be useful. I don't know if Facebook is any better. But their motto is "move fast and break things", so I'm skeptical.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by Barrin92 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:35PM (#26348718)
don't forget that there will be competition on the protocols as well, I'm not just arguing for protocols as a means for more innovation on the client side, but also more competition on the backend itself. If data becomes portable, which is one side effect of protocols, competition on standards itself intensifies. So if Google and Facebook are bad stewards of their APIs, there is room for competition to emerge. Google does stuff that sucks on their end? Use existing APIs to migrate over to dropbox or whatever, tell your users. In an open market there is an incentive for good standards.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by lrem on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:03PM (#26361370)
I, uh, can't grok competing protocols as a good thing.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by dwighttk on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:25PM (#26347776)
But I already have and use an rss reader
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by puszczyk on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:13PM (#26347614)
What does the Facebook get out of it?
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by Barrin92 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:18PM (#26347677)
absolutely nothing, it would subject their applications to genuine competition (they could of course still offer their own client) and destroy their walled garden, which is the entire point. The purpose such regulation is to benefit consumers, developers, and the health of the market overall. not Facebook. I assume they would be kicking and screaming.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by chipotle_coyote on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:58PM (#26348999)
> it would subject their applications to genuine competition (they could of course still offer their own client) and destroy their walled garden, which is the entire point.

Hmm. At least in the case that the OP was taking about -- third-party Facebook clients -- I don't think it would "destroy their walled garden" any more than third-party Twitter clients did back when those were meaningfully a thing. Standardized APIs aimed at enabling full-featured third-party social network clients wouldn't really contribute to a robust market in competing social networks; they'd just contribute to a robust market in, well, third-party social network clients.

What it seems to me you want is a couple steps beyond data portability, which honestly really isn't enough on its own. What I actually need is a way to import the user's social graph from Facebook or Twitter. That's arguably how Instagram bootstrapped its success initially: if you gave it your Twitter account, it would download all your followers/following info. (And, of course, that's why Twitter shut down that API after that.)

"But doesn't that violate GDPR?" someone is raising their hand to say, and: yes. GDPR as written does help protect privacy, but it's also an incredible boon to social network incumbents: it under it, your social graph can't be treated as your data, because by definition it contains personally identifiable information about all your contacts. For your regulation idea to be meaningful, GDPR and similar privacy regulation around the world would have to be overhauled -- if all the "open API" can do is import/export my personal data sans social graph, it becomes little more than a backup mechanism and a convenient way to fill out registration forms.

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by oarsinsync on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:17PM (#26347656)
> Already in this announcement is the non-transfer of Live Photos because presumably Google doesn't support it.

Google Photos definitely supports Live Photos, I've successfully uploaded and shared lots of Live Photos via the Google Photos for iOS app.

Which then raises the question of why doesn't the tool support it?

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by kemayo on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:50PM (#26348910)
Assuming that they're using the Google Photos API for this, maybe the upload media API calls [1] don't trigger whatever handling is needed for Live Photos? The Google Photos app might be doing something undocumented/unavailable-in-the-public-API that triggers the Live Photo behavior, since a Live Photo is two associated pieces of media.

Or Apple might just not be uploading the videos that accompany the photo for some reason.

[1]: https://developers.google.com/photos/library/guides/upload-m...

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by jwagenet on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:54PM (#26348949)
Just spitballing here: when I copy photos from my iPhone via usb to pc there are two files: the image and a .mov for a Live Photo. My guess is the metadata is lost when exporting to google photos, like usb, so you lose the “Live Photo”.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by fishywang on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:01PM (#26347422)
An interface doesn't necessarily limit what the implementation can do. An implementation can well be a super set of the interface (some open standard it supports), with additional features that's not in the interface.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by barnabee on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:28PM (#26347807)
Forcing the protocol to be open and documented and free for any user that can use the official site/client to connect to doesn’t have to mean forcing a standard. You might want to require o rubies compatibility with old versions and deal with obfuscation or unnecessary changes as anti competitive behaviour, but otherwise just ensuring that anyone can create and sell or give away clients, interoperability and import/export tools, etc. would be an excellent step in the right direction. With no obvious downsides.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by coldtea on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:33PM (#26348683)
>So, someone (who?) comes out with a standard, and then everyone just freezes capabilities then? Nothing evolves?

Hopefully yes. Most "progress" is towards worse services and more user data minining and ads.

But if needed, they can always innovate. But they'd still have to be able to export to the standard format (even if it can hold less than their full features).

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by lupire on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:14PM (#26347620)
HTML had been a standard for about 25 years and it doesn't seem to be stagnant.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by drstewart on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:55PM (#26347341)
>It's honestly so trivial and uninvasive of a regulatory matter it's ridiculous

You can't honestly believe this. Even if one agrees with making some things open protocols, potentialy by law (messenger, social networks), stating "it's trivial" to do such a thing is just the height of hyperbole.

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by simonh on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:15PM (#26347642)
I’m afraid some people really do seem to believe this. Hard to understand, I know. Fixed, regulator defined protocols everyone would be forced to use. Sheesh.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by d0mine on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:08PM (#26347521)
http was open once and technically it is open now. Soon the complexity of the protocol will allow only the major corporations to implement it (and it is unclear whether that complexity helps most people).
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by somethingwitty1 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:54PM (#26347322)
There is a lot of secret sauce in protocols. Those decisions can have serious positive/negative implications on performance and features. Making those easily available to everyone could potentially destroy a business.

Don't get me wrong, I've had to reverse engineer my share of proprietary protocols to get behavior I wanted (and would have loved to see them be open), but I don't think I can get onboard with the idea that requiring open protocols is trivial or noninvasive.

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by lupire on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:16PM (#26347643)
The secret sauce in Apple/Google photos is not the API for accessing the data.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by somethingwitty1 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:25PM (#26348590)
But we aren't discussing just these specific APIs/protocols (and I haven't look at them, so I'd have to take your word on that), we are discussing this generally.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by ezekg on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:28PM (#26347812)
It kind of baffles me that people really want so much regulation. We already have more than enough of it.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by AmericanChopper on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:49PM (#26347259)
> It's honestly so trivial and uninvasive of a regulatory matter it's ridiculous.

At what point do you become compelled to start transforming your web application into an open protocol?

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by barnabee on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:31PM (#26347853)
Certainly any company that relies on “safe harbor” style protections or sells online services (alone or bundled with software) as a subscription should be required to fully open and document the protocol.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by AmericanChopper on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:06PM (#26348315)
But most SaaS companies don’t make protocols, they make web applications. So I’m not really sure what’s implied by these trivial-to-implement protocols. Having a functional and well documented API isn’t a protocol. An open protocol would be more like a situation where any vendor could implement an “iCloud service”, and any “iCloud client” could connect to any vendors service.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by barnabee on Sunday March 07, 2021 @04:24AM (#26374450)
I don’t agree here. A web application API, properly documented and exposed to any client a participant wants to use becomes a protocol for that service, there’s no difference between CalDAV and the Google Calendar web app’s API except that one is documented, rarely changes, and if offer by a service provider would generally allow any client that implements it to connect, and the other is undocumented and it’s probably against the terms of service to build your own clients. The goal should be to force every API for these providers to meet some minimal definition of a protocol, not to define government mandated standard protocols or force interoperability between services.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by AmericanChopper on Sunday March 07, 2021 @09:02PM (#26381656)
Your definition removes all distinction between the concept of a protocol, and the concept of an API. Google Calendar doesn't implement the Google Calendar Protocol, there is no standards body involved in determining how Google Calendar works, you're not free to go an implement your own Google Calendar compatible service, and Google can change Google Calendar without consultation with anybody. There is no definition of protocol where a single-service API, designed, implemented and published by a single party is a protocol. Google Calendar implements an API.

If your argument is that companies should be compelled to publish good API documentation, and allow any client to connect to them, then aside from creating a completely unnecessary system of regulatory moats, and aside from using the wrong words to describe this idea, you're likely to run directly into a 1A violation.

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by xmprt on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:09PM (#26348357)
I think smaller companies tend to have the most open protocols (to the point that it almost becomes a security risk) because they don't have resources to work on unnecessary obfuscation. The protocols might not be documented anywhere but if a website is able to access a backend endpoint then someone else will be able to access that endpoint too.

Nothing in the parent comment says anything about requiring good documentation or 100% backwards compatibility.

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by AmericanChopper on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:41PM (#26350777)
You seem to be talking about APIs rather than protocols.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by pydry on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:54PM (#26347311)
Maybe at the unicorn mark.