News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by Barrin92 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:08PM (#26347528)
>and then everyone just freezes capabilities then? Nothing evolves? Or if it does, it does so very unequally?

every client provider can do whatever they want, that'd be the beauty of it. Someone could write a stripped down, privacy respecting Facebook client and charge users five bucks instead of running ads, if that's what users want. Someone could offer a chronological news-feed free of algorithmic meddling, or one that you can fine-tune however you like. That'd would simply be developer and user choice. Just think of RSS-readers or podcast apps or email clients. They're not all equal, but that's a feature, not something gone wrong.

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by leadingthenet on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:15PM (#26347641)
> every client provider can do whatever they want

I feel like you're missing his point a bit, which is that sure they can do whatever they want, but it would be within a well-defined and highly regulated system, and would need to conform to an interface that would be difficult to change and evolve.

A bit like how IRC never really got updated with features people like to see in newer IM apps, like conversation history, read receipts, sending images and videos, threading, and so on. Or HTTP. Or email. Federation always leads to ossification.

Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by lrem on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:19PM (#26348500)
I think you missed an important link here: opening the API is not the same as making a good standard. The latter tends to take years. The former... Well, Google internal APIs often have minor changes every couple weeks. And the standard of documentation is more or less "go read the code". Opening those would not be useful. I don't know if Facebook is any better. But their motto is "move fast and break things", so I'm skeptical.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by Barrin92 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:35PM (#26348718)
don't forget that there will be competition on the protocols as well, I'm not just arguing for protocols as a means for more innovation on the client side, but also more competition on the backend itself. If data becomes portable, which is one side effect of protocols, competition on standards itself intensifies. So if Google and Facebook are bad stewards of their APIs, there is room for competition to emerge. Google does stuff that sucks on their end? Use existing APIs to migrate over to dropbox or whatever, tell your users. In an open market there is an incentive for good standards.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by lrem on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:03PM (#26361370)
I, uh, can't grok competing protocols as a good thing.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by dwighttk on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:25PM (#26347776)
But I already have and use an rss reader
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by puszczyk on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:13PM (#26347614)
What does the Facebook get out of it?
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by Barrin92 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:18PM (#26347677)
absolutely nothing, it would subject their applications to genuine competition (they could of course still offer their own client) and destroy their walled garden, which is the entire point. The purpose such regulation is to benefit consumers, developers, and the health of the market overall. not Facebook. I assume they would be kicking and screaming.
Re:Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google ... by chipotle_coyote on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:58PM (#26348999)
> it would subject their applications to genuine competition (they could of course still offer their own client) and destroy their walled garden, which is the entire point.

Hmm. At least in the case that the OP was taking about -- third-party Facebook clients -- I don't think it would "destroy their walled garden" any more than third-party Twitter clients did back when those were meaningfully a thing. Standardized APIs aimed at enabling full-featured third-party social network clients wouldn't really contribute to a robust market in competing social networks; they'd just contribute to a robust market in, well, third-party social network clients.

What it seems to me you want is a couple steps beyond data portability, which honestly really isn't enough on its own. What I actually need is a way to import the user's social graph from Facebook or Twitter. That's arguably how Instagram bootstrapped its success initially: if you gave it your Twitter account, it would download all your followers/following info. (And, of course, that's why Twitter shut down that API after that.)

"But doesn't that violate GDPR?" someone is raising their hand to say, and: yes. GDPR as written does help protect privacy, but it's also an incredible boon to social network incumbents: it under it, your social graph can't be treated as your data, because by definition it contains personally identifiable information about all your contacts. For your regulation idea to be meaningful, GDPR and similar privacy regulation around the world would have to be overhauled -- if all the "open API" can do is import/export my personal data sans social graph, it becomes little more than a backup mechanism and a convenient way to fill out registration forms.