Apple doesn't mind if users turn off the data feed to Facebook, but obviously they don't want users disabling the same data feed to their advertising network.
Apple is of course still performing data collection for targeted iAds, but that's the reason they don't call it "tracking."
If you go to Settings > Privacy > Apple Advertising on iOS it tells you so:
"The Apple advertising platform does not track you. It is designed to protect your privacy and does not follow you across apps and websites owned by other companies. You have control over how Apple uses your information."
Note that I'm not necessarily agreeing that what Apple does doesn't fall under the description of "tracking." Just pointing out why Apple calls what Facebook does "tracking" but not their own iAds.
My first question would be... why? What's their motivation?
Facebook has to track users to make money, it's their entire business model.
The same is not true of Apple, who make almost all their profits from hardware sales and are worth over $2 trillion.
Going out of their way to get a third party to secretly spy on users on their behalf sounds like far more effort and risk than it's worth to me. It's not like they're desperate for extra cash.
And it's not like it'd be impossible to find out if it was indeed the case. iOS gets reverse engineered all the time. I can see all the traffic my iPhone sends through my DNS logs. If this hypothetical third party was embedded in iOS spying on user activity, it'd be spotted quite easily and quickly.
So I ask again, why would Apple do that? Aside from being a total PR nightmare it'd be straight up illegal.
I trust Apple because I don't see what reason they have to lie when they've built a multi-trillion dollar business without tracking their users already.
So it's a matter of making a call between using vendors we know for a fact are tracking you, some of which have lied about it (see, hard to keep these things secret), or one that at least claims not to and has a lot to lose if caught out.
It seems unlikely Apple is going to outright lie about something like that considering it could open them up to serious legal liability (CCPA, GDPR, etc).
It would of course be good for Apple to call their own behavior "tracking" as well, because that's what it is; that is the most accurate word for what is happening. "Personalized ads" do not accurately reflect what is happening because ads can be personalized in lots of different ways, only some of which involve user tracking.
But I don't think that has anything to do with Facebook's argument. Facebook's argument here isn't "everyone wants to exploit users, but only Apple is getting to do it", their argument is that users like tracking, that the tracking Facebook does is not exploitative. Well if that's the case, then if you show users a dialog that asks them whether or not they want to be tracked and there's a "yes" button and a "no" button, then users who do want to be tracked will click "yes."
When I say that the options are shown on equal terms, I mean that neither option is privileged for Facebook. It's exactly the same amount of work for a user to opt into Facebook tracking as it is for them to opt out if it. That means that Facebook can't blame application defaults for consumer behavior, consumers are actually making a real choice here.
It’s not possible to de-personalize Facebook, its whole knowledge graph is built around identities. Permission to use that data can be managed internally but it’s always gathered and processed initially as personalized.
But the advertising industry desperately doesn't want to acknowledge that. They want to stick their heads in the sand and ignore that most users don't want to see anything that they're making. They want to argue that most users are benefiting from ads, even though that's clearly not true.
A system that aligned incentives between advertisers and consumers, where advertisements themselves actually needed to justify themselves and inform/entertain users enough that they provided positive value to the viewer -- that system would look very, very different from the advertising world we have today.
I think that disconnect is why you see people in the advertising industry fighting about ideas like users' Right to Filter, or why they're so paranoid about users having more control over which ads they see. Advertisers know that nobody likes ads and that for the average consumer, their ads aren't providing any kind of actual value. There's no incentive for most online advertisers to make ads that improve the quality of anyone's life -- the biggest incentive in the current system is to alter consumer behavior against their will regardless of whether that ad helps or hurts the viewer.
It was always laughable (?) the hoops you had to go through to turn on various aspects of privacy in their settings. And it was constantly changing, requiring users to constantly go back into settings to turn off yet another flag that was introduced default-on.
They seem to have known very early on that user's would not appreciate their crap.
Since we can’t ask users what they meant, it’s not something we can know.
For more skepticism about the over-interpretation of survey results: https://carcinisation.com/2020/12/11/survey-chicken/
Would you argue that increasingly targeted advertisement is enough of a net good that the choice to avoid it should be gone?
Does that sound right?
But you might compare to what browsers do these days for visiting websites with fishy-looking certificates. They don’t just put up a dialog, they heavily discourage it, because the assumption is that many users would say “yes” just to get rid of the dialog.
If they want to take the position now that their users don't understand what "tracking" even is, then Facebook was lying before when they said they had informed consent from their users to do that tracking.
The advertising industry regularly wants to have its own cake and eat it too on this point. They want to say that users understand and consent to the system, but also that users are too uneducated or lazy to acknowledge that consent in any way.
And to a small extent, there is a grain of truth here: most users don't understand the full extent of what tracking is and how companies are targeting them. But that's not a point in the advertising industry's favor. Companies like Facebook acknowledging that users don't know what they're opting into or out of only makes it more obvious just how inadequate their click-through TOSes and privacy FAQs always were.
The “will of the people” is something of a myth. Votes go in and the algorithm makes a decision. Do you feel represented when the decision isn’t what you wanted?
But it’s not an argument against elections because I’m not claiming I have a better idea. We do need some peaceful way of making decisions that people will accept. A legitimate, accepted process beats chaos, and new processes aren’t easily adopted.
I think this is true for a lot of people on social media. They're there for the people and topics they care enough about to explicitly opt into. Ads and recommendations can fuck right off.
They have done this for decades, with google paving the way, by slowly and surely chipping away at peoples privacy. People then just give in over time, amplified by single sided terms of service that allow them to pretty much change anything at any time.
This is hopefully one of the major turning points where this kind of behaviour will no longer be tolerated. Expose privacy. Make it explicit. Let people actually decide.
Apple's change doesn't make tracking opt-in or opt-out, it forces users to make a choice, with both choices being equally easy to make. It's a perfect compromise between default privacy and default tracking -- presenting the user with an unskipable dialog that makes sure that neither option is buried in a setting someplace, that presents both options on equal terms.
So Facebook wants to argue that it's a worse experience for consumers if they're not being tracked, but the truth is that they know a large portion of users don't want the experience that Facebook is offering. That's why Facebook is scared. Not because Apple is bullying users into being private, not because (in this case) they're attacking the Open web, but because Facebook knows that when users are presented with a clear choice that makes it equally easy to opt into or out of tracking, they choose to opt out.
Advertisers are always saying that people want what they're offering. But they are so stinking scared about being asked to prove it.