News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Justin.tv launches TwitchTV: A destination site for eSports by thomasgerbe on Monday June 06, 2011 @01:56PM (#2625636)
"Better than real sports"

rolls eyes

Re:Justin.tv launches TwitchTV: A destination site for eSports by justin on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:13PM (#2626949)
The slogan is more tongue-in-cheek than any sort of commentary on sports viewing. We like watching real sports in the office Justin.tv too.

I don't think any sports viewers are going to show up on TwitchTV and then cry themselves to sleep because they saw the slogan.

Re:Justin.tv launches TwitchTV: A destination site for eSports by jmtame on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:02PM (#2625654)
Have you ever watched the interesting casters like Husky Starcraft? It gets intense, much more exciting to watch than golf or NASCAR.
Re:Justin.tv launches TwitchTV: A destination site for eSports by thomasgerbe on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:59PM (#2625917)
I watch Starcraft games narrated by HD and am definitely engrossed.

My point is not that it's boring but rather it's an annoying comparison. I like watching Starcraft games and the Stanley Cup playoffs. For a site to tell me that one is better than the other is unnecessary.

I like HackerNews better than Digg. Does HN need the slogan: Better than Digg?

Re:Justin.tv launches TwitchTV: A destination site for eSports by jmtame on Monday June 06, 2011 @05:41PM (#2626826)
I don't think Hacker News has any interest in comparing itself to other news sites, but direct comparisons have been used successfully in advertising before. I don't think it's annoying in this case because nerds are typically just not drawn to the whole sports scene (at least the ones I know). I see this more as a message to nerds saying "hey we are running this type of sports broadcasting that doesnt suck because it's not boring. By the way, it's going to be huge--tons of people are already watching."

It's not really a direct comparison though, this is more of a category comparison of esports vs traditional sports. It's not like JustinTV is saying "our site is better than MLG and GOMtv combined!" I see them as promoting esports in general, which is actually very good for the gaming scene overall.

Re:Justin.tv launches TwitchTV: A destination site for eSports by sawyer on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:11PM (#2625694)
Starcraft 2 is a great competitive game that requires sport like skill to excel at. Husky's definitely one of the most energetic casters but you should check out Day[9]'s Daily podcast for a glimpse behind the curtain.

http://blip.tv/day9tv

Re:Justin.tv launches TwitchTV: A destination site for eSports by hristov on Monday June 06, 2011 @07:42PM (#2627260)
I think the gp comment was rolling his eyes, not because Starcraft is bad, but because the term "better than real sports" implies that competitive Starcraft is not a real sport.
Re:Justin.tv launches TwitchTV: A destination site for eSports by timsally on Monday June 06, 2011 @03:04PM (#2625948)
120,000 spectators came to an outdoor stadium in Busan, South Korea, to watch StarCraft at the 2005 SKY Pro League final -- roughly 50,000 more than attended the Super Bowl in 2009. In Korea, Starcraft is the second most watched sport after Soccer. You can roll your eyes, but I think you are lacking in knowledge about this market. In some places, people do indeed believe that Starcraft is better than real sports.

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/digitalnation/virtua...

Re:Justin.tv launches TwitchTV: A destination site for eSports by thomasgerbe on Monday June 06, 2011 @03:32PM (#2626139)
My point isn't that people aren't entitled to feel that one is better than the other. My point is that it's egregious to feel that one HAS to be better than the other.

It'd be like my brand of iced tea having the slogan, "Better than Nestea" or if my J.Crew shirt said, "better than Target."

Like I said in another comment, I love watching the Stanley Cup playoffs and watching Starcraft games narrated by HDStarcraft. But I don't need for a company to tell me explicitly that one is better than the other, because that doesn't matter to me and it just spurs fruitless fanboyism that I detest.

Re:Justin.tv launches TwitchTV: A destination site for eSports by kmgroove on Monday June 06, 2011 @03:56PM (#2626281)
You mean in one place that offers very little (if any?) real sport competition? More people in Korea would be watching a successful South Korean soccer team then even the biggest of star craft 2 events. The market is small, the market is tiny. It only seems large because of the internet. In reality the market for spectator e-sports is very small (and beyond star craft it is pretty much non-existent). The only way e-sports will ever become a profitable market beyond niche is to engage it at the casual player with accessible leagues/ladders/ and tournaments for all. Blizzard kind of does it but they don't provide a good interface for it in my opinion. All others who try have failed pretty hard. Beyond sc2 e-sports have been declining and failing left right and center. And absolutely nothing that I see coming from game companies give me faith that this will change. Star craft 2 is a nice niche but it does not represent the e-sports market as a whole. That market is tiny, and largely ignored and at the current time requires real innovation. In my opinion the real money in e-sports (when it finally does get big) will not be spectating at all, it will come from little Johny paying 5$ a month to play in a very well run, exiting, competitive and fun casual league. Someone just needs to build it right.
Re:Justin.tv launches TwitchTV: A destination site for eSports by dpcan on Monday June 06, 2011 @03:48PM (#2626233)
Ticket price? Stadium Size?

More people go to A LOT of things than the Super Bowl, but that's because getting in to the Super Bowl is no easy or cheap task.

Does not compare.