News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by kryogen1c on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:03PM (#26241380)
> Things in the past which were labeled misinformation

I know that item-level thinking like this is necessary to gain emotional traction with people, but this issue is just so obvious at a systems-level.

the idea that we, right now the instant youre reading this, have discovered 100% of what there is to learn and 0% of what we know is wrong is so painfully, horrifically, obviously stupid (we've had computers for thirty years now, we're probably good for ETERNITY, right?). we both WANT and NEED a mechanism for dissenters and disinformation. misinformation is combat with MORE discussion, not less!

scientific consensus is not arrived at when every scientific paper says the same thing. this is a fundamentally wrong view of science and also reality. on any given topic, the corpus includes opposing conclusions. eventually we figure out why and discern the underlying principles.

to say anything but this is to make the existential case that people are not to be trusted with their own free will.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by shakezula on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:53PM (#26242033)
> misinformation is combat with MORE discussion, not less!

I wholeheartedly agree, but how do you get the other side to listen?

The saying goes something like "You can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into."

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by colpabar on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:21PM (#26242381)
> How do you get the other side to listen?

Pretend you think like them, and make arguments that go against that thinking. Unfortunately, the way the media exists today this never happens, and both sides just attack strawmen in ways that get people to click their headlines and listen to their talking heads.

I think it's disingenuous to paint the entire "other side" as unreasonable, but I may be misinterpreting what you mean by "other side" here. There will always be unreasonable people, and I don't have a solution for them. However, I think _a lot_ of people are very tired of being demonized for disagreeing. Not every republican is a rabid tea partier, and not every democrat supports antifa.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by kbenson on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:41PM (#26243264)
> Pretend you think like them, and make arguments that go against that thinking.

Both sides have attacked the trustworthiness of the other. You can't convince someone of something when they think you're lying, or will lie and dissemble to get what you want, and nothing you say can be taken at face value because it's all a con to get some other goal which you claim to not want.

There has been such a concerted effort to so malign the other side that's it's less about clear communication than it is trust. It's got more in common with soldiers inpast wars being encouraged to use terms like krauts, gooks and chinks and those being used as stereotypes to explain the behavior and motivations of the other side than anything else, IMO.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by kaibee on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:28PM (#26243099)
> I think it's disingenuous to paint the entire "other side" as unreasonable, but I may be misinterpreting what you mean by "other side" here. There will always be unreasonable people, and I don't have a solution for them. However, I think _a lot_ of people are very tired of being demonized for disagreeing. Not every republican is a rabid tea partier, and not every democrat supports antifa.

There's a lot of fundamental issues that are just not limited to "rabid tea partiers", global warming and the pandemic/masks just to pick two.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by leesalminen on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:16PM (#26242324)
It basically doesn’t matter if you get the other side to listen or not. Open and free discussion is out there for those who want to partake. There will always be zealots who choose not to.

Censoring opposition in order to be heard more loudly doesn’t work. In an IRL discussion, if you start talking over someone forcing them to stop talking, they’re going to shut down and never listen to anything you have to say.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by shakezula on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:32PM (#26243149)
It matters very much when that other side has the control of your government.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by leesalminen on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @05:53PM (#26244112)
Luckily that changes every 4 or 8 years.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by rayiner on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:21PM (#26242385)
The purpose isn’t to get “the other side to listen.” Its to get moderate to listen, and to make sure the other side feels heard. That procedural aspect of free speech is at least as important, if not more so, than the truth-finding aspect of free speech.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by nitsky on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:08PM (#26242235)
I have heard this expression rephrased as "Logic is useless against those who reject it".

However, in my experience, both sides are logical, they just start from different axioms.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by shakezula on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:31PM (#26243138)
This is my experience as well, but I've also noticed that both sides do not adhere to their base axioms with the same tenacity, and the issues can be a spectrum of adherence to their claimed base beliefs.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by s1artibartfast on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:54PM (#26242740)
Assume good intentions, respect them as individuals, and listen to what they have to say even if you disagree.

These are basic tenants of productive debate.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by lotsofpulp on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:09PM (#26242921)
Sometimes. I know people who only care to maximize for themselves and their immediate tribe, and could not care less what happens to others not useful for them.

It is naive to play the game as if others aren't interested in capturing an outsized share of the winnings. And obviously they're not going to officially state their motives.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by s1artibartfast on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:47PM (#26243333)
I'm not convinced any other strategy of discourse is a winning one. Competing disinformation campaigns are a race to the bottom where everyone looses. Also, sometimes people simply want different things.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by shakezula on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:28PM (#26243110)
I completely agree with these points - but that's not what I'm saying. I'm saying what do you do when your partner in debate completely ignores all of those things, but has equal say in the outcomes?
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by s1artibartfast on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:40PM (#26243253)
Agree to disagree, vote on it, and sometimes loose. Part of being in a democracy is that sometimes you dont get what you want, even when you are sure you are right.

Change can be slow, even for good ideas. If you have faith in humanity and democracy, then you believe good ideas will prevail in the end. There were US abolitionists in 1770 and the civil rights movement ended in 1970.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by shakezula on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:46PM (#26243325)
And when the problems require solutions in decades and not centuries to be agreed on? What then?

I used to have a lot more faith in our democracy but I can't help but feel lately like something has fundamentally changed, and the system is just catching up to that. What changed? I have no idea, but something feels _different_ from before.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by s1artibartfast on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @08:47PM (#26245612)
I think that is a tough question. If the pace of democratic change is too slow, there aren't a lot of options. Essentially strip people of their voting rights and install a undemocratic government.

I hear your concern, but I think that the biggest change is that people have become accustomed to immediate change and more cynical overall. Democracies don't make sense unless you believe that people are good and correct ideas will ultimately prevail.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by markkanof on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:06PM (#26242897)
There is also a problem with approaching this type of dialog as one side vs. the other. People are all over the spectrum with their opinions on various issues. You might have a disagreement on one particular issue, but it's likely that you also have some common ground on other things. Use that to relate to people and try to influence their thinking to your point of view. It's not a war where you are trying to destroy "the other side".
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by ajwin on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:04PM (#26242876)
> I wholeheartedly agree, but how do you get the other side to listen?

The only way is to stop preaching and listen to them. Really listen. This is how Daryl Davis converted the KKK according to his own accounts?

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by lurquer on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:51PM (#26242699)
> I wholeheartedly agree, but how do you get the other side to listen?

Re-education camps seem to be the go-to solution for many totalitarian regimes.

I’m not being a smart-ass... the desire some have for others to agree with them can itself be a pernicious thing.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by shakezula on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:29PM (#26243115)
Maybe "agreement" isn't what I meant as the goal - only progress. Fair point to address that they're not equal.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by alsetmusic on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @06:40PM (#26244590)
>> misinformation is combat with MORE discussion, not less!

> I wholeheartedly agree, but how do you get the other side to listen?

I don’t think there’s any winning some people over.

My mother had a very problematic stat about police violence and racism last summer. I was able prove it wrong by getting the real stat in five seconds with a Google search. The source is well known and reputable. She refused to stop clinging to her source.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by asdfasgasdgasdg on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:25PM (#26243068)
For me, a good start would be to provide evidence that people have had their minds changed because information gets discussed more. E.g. you could demonstrate that the qanon phenomenon became less popular, not more, after it began getting wide media attention. (Unfortunately in this instance the opposite is the case. You have an uphill battle ahead trying to demonstrate your position empirically.)
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by shakezula on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:30PM (#26243127)
Q is a really interesting conspiracy theory to bring up. It seems to be at the other end of the "valley" of conspiracy theories - it's almost like the most brazenly unbelievable ones are the ones that somehow gain the most traction.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by leesalminen on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @05:51PM (#26244081)
It combined several long running conspiracy theories into one. Because they had been around for so long individually, combining them somehow made them more believable. Connecting seemingly disparate dots together added credibility because it explained everything conspiracy theorists believed.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by ardy42 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:09PM (#26242245)
> misinformation is combat with MORE discussion, not less!

The problem with that idea is that it takes more effort to debunk a lie than to tell one. It also takes more effort to absorb a debunking than a lie. That's why disinformation works.

Here's an example: JFK ate babies occasionally, and the media hushed it up. Oswald was actually a secret high-level CIA operative, and was so outraged by this that he assassinated JFK for it.

It took me two seconds to write that. How much effort would it take you to debunk it?

It's just not practical to put all the burden of combating misinformation on each individual's shoulders. It's also necessary to stop the spread of misinformation. That doesn't need to be done by a central authority, but people who've been convinced by a lie will perceive that as "censorship" by one.

> scientific consensus is not arrived at when every scientific paper says the same thing. this is a fundamentally wrong view of science and also reality. on any given topic, the corpus includes opposing conclusions. eventually we figure out why and discern the underlying principles.

Scientific consensus is also not arrived at by publishing literally every crackpot idea, and answering each with "more discussion." Science has several mechanisms for "censoring" bullshit and misinformation (e.g. peer review), and it couldn't function without it. "More discussion" is saved for cases where those mechanisms failed.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by rayiner on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:33PM (#26242513)
> Scientific consensus also not arrived at by publishing literally every crackpot idea, and answering each with "more discussion." Science has several mechanisms for "censoring" bullshit and misinformation (e.g. peer review), and it couldn't function without it.

What counts as a "crackpot idea?" We don't have to dabble in hypotheticals about JFK eating babies. We have real examples from current political events that show we're not talking about "slippery slopes" here. We have rolled down the slope with stunning speed.

In March 2020, the Surgeon General suggested that wearing masks was effective to prevent spread of COVID was a crackpot idea: https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/485332-surgeon-general... ("Seriously people- STOP BUYING MASKS! They are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus[.]").

10 months later, the Surgeon General is calling that same assertion a "myth": https://twitter.com/surgeon_general/status/13189727242078986... ("There is a currently circulating MYTH suggesting masks don’t work to prevent spread of COVID-19.").

I have a degree in aerospace engineering--I totally get that scientific understanding evolves. But it doesn't evolve like that. The truth is that the Surgeon General's March 2020 statement was ill-advised and overly-certain, and so was the October 2020 statement. Whether masks are effective at limiting the spread of COVID is quite uncertain. Mask-wearing rates vary quite dramatically between countries with similar COVID death rates: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/07/08/face-off.... By June 2020, the U.S. had mask-wearing rates of 75%. Denmark, Sweden, and Norway were under 20%. Out of those, Sweden and the U.S. have death rates (per population) 5-10 times higher than Denmark and Norway.

Despite that uncertainty, I think most people worried about "misinformation" would use mask-denialism as a motivating example for why restrictions are needed. So what are the restrictionists really advocating for here?

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by NortySpock on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:53PM (#26242718)
And it was damned foolish to say "masks don't work" if what they wanted the public to understand was "please leave surgical and N95 masks for healthcare workers. We are exploring the effectiveness of cloth masks".

THAT would have been honesty, it would have explained the reason they didn't want the general public using masks, and it would have hinted at an alternative while not directly confirming masks work (or don't work).

NOT TO MENTION that the CDC probably could have asked South Korea, Taiwan, Japan, or any other country where mask usage was common, "How well do masks work?" and been pointed at a few relevant studies, right? But no, they make a very fishy statement to the public claiming masks don't work for normal people.

/rant Sorry. You hit a nerve. Pretty frustrated that the CDC would throw away its credibility like that.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by pen2l on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:49PM (#26242672)
> The issue is actually pretty uncertain, and government bodies are making categorical statements for political reasons

I think it's more complicated than just politics, as I was saying elsewhere (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26139732), public health officials advised against mask-wearing for general public initially for a very particular reason (possible shortages for medical frontline workers). As far as public healthy policy is concerned, where you cannot pass a certain threshold of complexity in communicating best practices to grandmas around the nation, masks work is a good enough message and it stands on pretty solid science: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.07.31.20166116v...

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by CivBase on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:51PM (#26242698)
> It took me two seconds to write that. How much effort would it take you to debunk it?

How long would it take you to establish enough credibility to be able to make an accusation like that and have people actually take your word for it? There might be a few nutters out there who are so predisposed to hate JFK that they'll believe anything negative about him, but most people - even those who dislike him - would rightfully question such an outlandish statement made by someone with no credentials.

Dishonest people retain credibility when their supporters are trapped in echo chambers designed to keep the truth out. Censorship is a powerful tool for establishing and maintaining echo chambers. We need to fight echo chambers, not promote censorship.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by ardy42 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:56PM (#26242759)
> How long would it take you to establish enough credibility to be able to make an accusation like that and have people actually take your word for it?

Keep this in mind: Q is literally some dude on 4chan/8chan with a tripcode.

> There might be a few nutters out there who are so predisposed to hate JFK that they'll believe anything negative about him, but most people - even those who dislike him - would rightfully question such an outlandish statement made by someone with no credentials.

I make no claim that my example lie is a good example of misinformation/disinformation. It was only meant to show the asymmetry of effort implicit in "more discussion."

The key thing about getting a lie to stick is to hitting the right emotional buttons with it. And it's so easy broadcast lies nowadays that you can even discover those buttons stochastically, by just throwing random lies out there and seeing what sticks.

Furthermore, if your goal is not to convince anyone of anything in particular, but to just to gum up a society (which is the goal of disinformation, properly understood), you don't event need to find particular lies with a broad appeal across society. You just need enough lies that enough people fall for one or two.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by CivBase on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:01PM (#26242836)
I believe it is reasonable to speculate that QAnon members are generally trapped in extreme, right-wing echo chambers. Echo chambers enable people to retain undeserved credibility.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by ardy42 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:08PM (#26242908)
> I believe it is reasonable to speculate that QAnon members are generally trapped in extreme, right-wing echo chambers. Echo chambers enable people to retain undeserved credibility.

That's not true, for instance:

https://www.startribune.com/conspiracy-theories-of-qanon-fin...

> Conspiracy theories of QAnon find fertile ground in an unexpected place – the yoga world

> QAnon's conspiracy theories have taken root among yogis and other adherents of natural medicine.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by CivBase on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:14PM (#26242964)
I'm not sure how that demonstrates QAnon members are not generally trapped in right-wing echo chambers. Are yoga practitioners exempt from right-wing echo chambers?
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by ardy42 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:27PM (#26243086)
> I'm not sure how that demonstrates QAnon members are not generally trapped in right-wing echo chambers. Are yoga practitioners exempt from right-wing echo chambers?

I suppose a significant number of yoga teachers/influencers could be secret dittoheads, but the idea kind of beggars belief.

One of the interesting things about QAnon is that it offered on-ramps to groups outside the stereotype of people would go for such a theory (e.g. "save the children"). People in right-wing echo chambers were definitely more susceptible, but it's a mistake to be reassured by that.

Also, particular echo chambers aren't some kind of primordial entity. They start all the time and they often grow. So even if something like QAnon requires one, that just means there's one more step.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by CivBase on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @05:05PM (#26243538)
Are yoga practitioners usually liberal? Is that a thing? My perception has always been that yoga communities tend to attract those interested in "alternative medicine", a group which certainly has its own share of echo chambers. Given the apparent ideologically-insular nature of both groups, I'm not surprised that there would be overlap between the them.

Echo chambers are not a new phenomena, but they have certainly become more powerful with the rise of the internet. Never before have we been so easily able to surround ourselves with groups of like-minded individuals. But what I find even more concerning are algorithmically-driven content feeds which are tailored to suite the preferences of each individual user.

Algorithmically-driven, tailored content feeds basically automate the creation of echo chambers. It all sounds well and good to the user - after all, they get access to more of the type of content they prefer. However, those feeds almost inevitably learn to always provide the user exclusively with content that reinforces their preexisting ideas and opinions. They'll eagerly spread things like QAnon if it results in increased user engagement.

I don't think there's anything particularly special about QAnon compared to any other politically-charged conspiracy group. I think they just got lucky and once they passed a certain threshold of popularity, the algorithms did what they do best.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by cassalian on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:52PM (#26243389)
So you'd like to make lying illegal...? I have an amendment to show you, it's actually the very first one!
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by temp8964 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:24PM (#26242411)
Your example actually tells something. Nobody would believe your JFK baby eating story. It is easy to write a fake story, but it is not easy to have lots of people believe your fake story. "Misinformation" can spread because they seem plausible to enough people, not because they are "bullshit" like your example.
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by parineum on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:52PM (#26242713)
> "Misinformation" can spread because they seem plausible to enough people

Conspiracy theories are only believed by those who already mistrust the target. If there's a lot of conspiracies revolving around something/someone, you have a trust problem.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by mcguire on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:43PM (#26243299)
How about Jewish space lasers?
Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by drwiggly on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:46PM (#26242638)
The problem with your calling this example out, is that people will believe this stuff if down the rabbit hole enough.

Jan 20th Biden and Harris were supposed to be arrested and their pedo evidence was suppose to be shown to all, along with evidence of election fraud.

The next one is what March 7th?

A lot of people think an ancient all powerful being will re-appear and lift up adherents on high, and punish "bad" non believers.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by josephorjoe on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:51PM (#26242700)
I wish you were right, but you are not. It is very easy to have lots of people believe a fake story.

QAnon conspiracy theories are incoherent and absurd yet are embraced by thousands and cause needless harm to many.

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by JKCalhoun on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:46PM (#26242641)
> It is easy to write a fake story, but it is not easy to have lots of people believe your fake story.

I thought so too before Pizzagate, Q-Anon....

Re:Letters from House members to cable providers [pdf] by jesseryoung on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @03:50PM (#26242688)
Perhaps a better example: Jewish people are telling you the earth is round so that way they can distract you from the fact they're kidnapping children and drinking their blood.

A fantastic video on the topic of difficult to debunk, but easy to produce content https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JTfhYyTuT44.