I was really worried when I visited Singapore and took their 'tourist' tour. They put you in a bus, drive you around all jetlagged and give you orange juice on the beach. Completely surreal.
What really put me off was their unconditional love for their government. The woman 'tour guide' in the bus just couldn't stop thanking the government for giving them so much. It was unhealthy. Yet they don't own anything and they live in towers. Sure it was really pretty but it freaked me out a little. I felt a deep communism in this pro-capitalist ex-colony.
I'm no die hard capitalist but I prefer the australian way of owning my own life and freely talking crap of the government.
The only form of speech that enjoys some protection is political speech. So whilst Australian's can freely talk crap about the government, Australia is far from a beacon of free speech.
I come from New Zealand, and although there's a lot of rivalry between Australia and New Zealand, I nevertheless consider Australia to be a second home -- even though I've only been there twice.
What is enshrined in law, however, is that certain types of speech are a criminal offence. Further, there is no constitutional impediment to Parliament passing legislation which criminalises other forms of speech.
I'm no trespasser and trouble maker, but I can tell you that anybody is free to do whatever they intend to in Australia, so as long as it doesn't impair other people doing so. In other words, you're as free as you can be without causing damage to others. I'm not sure what you're referring to though.
On my way home I saw dudes roller-blading half naked in the city. I call that freedom. Do you have examples?
The statement "anybody is free to do whatever they intend to in Australia, so as long as it doesn't impair other people doing so" is as absurd as it is false.
There are reams of legislation to prevent you from doing everything from arriving unlawfully by boat, to lying about your income, to using a wire carriage service to cause offence.
As to speech, here is a simplistic example: Let's say I walk into Federation Square and say to you "Go and burn down the Parliament, you useless white cunt!" Depending on who takes offence to my comments I can be:
a) Issued an on the spot fine for AUD$238.50 for using language likely to cause offence in a public place.
b) Prosecuted for racial vilification.
c) Prosecuted for sedition.
The fact that all but a) are highly unlikely does nothing to progress the case that "anybody is free to do whatever they intend to in Australia".
In the comment to which you replied I'm merely countering the claim that "anybody is free to do whatever they intend to in Australia, so as long as it doesn't impair other people doing so", with respect to speech.
Mind you, I did admit the example was simplistic, but it captured the essence of the three most contentious classes of prohibited speech without verbosity.
The only claims I have made with respect to free speech are that:
a) Australians have no constitutional right to free speech.
b) There are laws that criminalise certain kinds of speech.
c) There is no constitutional impediment to the creation of new laws which criminalise other forms of speech.
d) Political speech enjoys some protection.
If free speech only covers things that others might find acceptable, then it is completely meaningless.
And talking about free speech: Have a look at the Internet censorship laws in Australia!
Gender equality is not rooted in Western culture. It sucked being a woman equally in Glasgow, Shanghai & Algiers. Gender equality was spread with difficulty and imperfectly over a decade in throughout liberal democracies and communist countries. It skipped the third world, but gender equality is no more part of Spanish culture then it is Qatari.
Same for "western" democracy, western medicine and a big chuck of western values.
It wasn't cool to criticize kings or dictators anywhere at some point.
This wasn't always the case, but that doesn't disqualify the current situation.
Most of those things did not happen elsewhere. Hence my comment above.
I am by no means an expert on the politics there at all, but if one thinks that the us political system is not more corrupt at the highest levels then is simply delusional -- yet life is good for most of us in the US.
I think that one can create a bit of there reality and are not 100% subjected to the douchebaggery of their government, same goes for singapore -- just dont make the cardinal mistake (which applies equally globally) of being poor.
I've never even been to Singapore, but I know some people that used to work there. They loved it so much that they put lots of energy and time into getting back.
I don't know what Singapore do right, but I have never heard anyone be so enthusiastic by some place they didn't grow up(/study).
It is one of my favorite cities on the planet.
I took a sabbatical in 2000/2001 for six months and backpacked through asia - I spent 2 months in singapore then as well.
The laws and strictness of the place is greatly exaggerated from my perspective -- if your not doing crazy stuff, you have nothing to worry about.
The city is AMAZING -- and is the FUTURE of cities; they have taken massive infrastructure projects to prepare for more than doubling their population by 2020 - and they build massive underground connective malls and walking causeways.
The city has an incredibly high density of plant life (trees and greenery) and it makes an impact when you visit. Many of the buildings have a large setback from roads where they have trees and grass and planters between the buildings and roads. This is really a wonderful civil engineering trait of the place and makes the city much more beautiful than dense urban dirty environments we see in american cities.
In my opinion, if you ever watch much anime -- Singapore is the city that will most closely resemble that which you see in anime.
I love Singapore - the only thing I dont like is how freaking hot/humid it can get.... and the cost of living.