News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by moralsupply on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:07AM (#26213959)
Bitcoin is mostly mined using excess energy, or "cheap" energy, which improves the efficiency and costs of energy production, making it surprisingly "green".

Bitcoin requires less energy on a per-store-of-value basis than Gold and Silver.

Bitcoin requires less energy on a per-store-of-value basis than credit cards and the banking system in general.

Yet Bitcoin is frowned upon by environmentalists, as if Bitcoin was a company and they could use political power to shut it down.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by PragmaticPulp on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:25AM (#26214095)
The idea of cheap, “excess” energy that keeps Bitcoin mining operations running 24/7 is a myth.

Bitcoin is, and always will be, additive on top of the world’s energy consumption. Every Terawatt of energy that goes into Bitcoin is a Terawatt of energy that isn’t being put into the grid to send to homes or industries or other users. No one is choosing to build power plants in the middle of nowhere without a way to send that energy into the grid.

The grid is not perfectly efficient, but it’s still better to transfer that energy through the grid than to keep a coal plant running somewhere else because Bitcoin is (hypothetically) consuming the new renewable energy sources coming online.

The key is to remember that no one is waking up and wondering if they should run their Bitcoin miner or charge their Tesla. Both happen independently, and it’s not hard to see that miners run 24/7 regardless of energy demand fluctuations elsewhere.

This idea of unused, surplus energy that somehow can’t be connected to the grid is a myth perpetuated to whitewash the absolutely massive (country-scale) energy consumption of Bitcoin.

Not to mention, none of us can buy video cards right now because they’re all being consumed to mine other cryptocurrencies. Discussion forums are full of people swapping tips for mining with their GPUs to offset the cost.

There is no angle on this in which we can ignore the 120,000 Gigawatt energy consumption of Bitcoin and the additional energy consumption of all the other crypto currencies popping up in its wake.

Frankly, at this point it’s depressing to see this trope repeated so often on HN, where usually the users would have enough intellectual curiosity and engineering sense to read up on the basics of power transmission and marginal energy costs before repeating such an obviously flawed argument. I’m afraid everyone’s personal financial investment in cryptocurrency is clouding judgment on the topic when all of the facts are right in front of us.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by gruez on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:36AM (#26214177)
>Every Terawatt of energy that goes into Bitcoin is a Terawatt of energy that isn’t being put into the grid to send to homes or industries or other users.

Not really. Electricity is tough to transport over distances and interconnects are expensive and have limited capacity. That's why new hampshire's retail cost for electricity is 17 cents/kWh[1] but quebec only pays 5.8 cent/kWh

[1] https://www.eia.gov/electricity/state/

[2] https://www.energyhub.org/electricity-prices/ (7.3¢/kWh converted to USD)

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by _Microft on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:43AM (#26214258)
China manages to transfer 10+GW of power over 3000km with losses of ~3%/1000km just fine. [0]

It is the infrastructure we are going to need anyways to geographically balance varying supply and demand with increasing amounts of (intermittent) renewable energy on the grid.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by gruez on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:51AM (#26214335)
> China manages to transfer 10+GW of power over 3000km with losses of ~3%/1000km just fine. [0]

Against how much power usage? California has 10GW[1] of north/south transmission capacity against 80GW[2] of installed capacity.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26187166

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_California

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by PragmaticPulp on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:56AM (#26214375)
The bottom line is that their transmission lines were built in conjunction with power plants.

They weren’t building power plants in the middle of nowhere without any plan to get that energy back into the grid, to where it needs to be. There wasn’t an excess of power plants sitting idle with no way to send their power into the grid until Bitcoin came along to consume it.

Mining is, however, negating any potential environmental offset of those plants by consuming the energy before it can be sent to other locations that are still dependent on fossil fuels.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by PragmaticPulp on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:42AM (#26214247)
Transmission costs are not the only reason why people in different regions pay different prices for retail energy. Retail prices include far more than the pure generation and transmission costs. You can’t use those numbers to assume transmission is the primary driver of cost.

The actual cost of sending power across the grid is relatively low.

The Wikipedia page on power transmission is a good place to get an introduction: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_transmission

Specifically:

> The cost of high voltage electricity transmission (as opposed to the costs of electric power distribution) is comparatively low, compared to all other costs arising in a consumer's electricity bill. In the UK, transmission costs are about 0.2 p per kWh compared to a delivered domestic price of around 10 p per kWh.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by gruez on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:00AM (#26214401)
> Transmission costs are not the only reason why people in different regions pay different prices for retail energy. Retail prices include far more than the pure generation and transmission costs. You can’t use those numbers to assume transmission is the primary driver of cost.

You're right, although an alternate source shows that the same difference exists for residential to large power (50,000 kW+) customers. Presumably for large power customers the cost of electricity becomes a bigger factor compared to other expenses.

https://www.hydroquebec.com/data/documents-donnees/pdf/compa...

>> The cost of high voltage electricity transmission (as opposed to the costs of electric power distribution) is comparatively low, compared to all other costs arising in a consumer's electricity bill. In the UK, transmission costs are about 0.2 p per kWh compared to a delivered domestic price of around 10 p per kWh.

There's selection bias going on here. Power is expensive to transmit over long distances, so power authorities opt to build local power plants, so that the expensive long transmission lines aren't built and therefore aren't being factored in.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by maxerickson on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:13AM (#26214004)
It's pretty unlikely that the majority of energy consumed is truly 'excess', it's just not how energy generation and distribution works.

There can certainly be periods of time where it is excess, it's just hard to believe it's typical for there to be zero dispatchable sources operating on the grids supplying the power.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by PragmaticPulp on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:32AM (#26214155)
Realistically, miners aren’t going to turn the equipment off as long as the ROI is positive, however narrowly. When it the ROI becomes too small to mine, they’ll sell the equipment to someone else who can run it cheaper.

The mining equipment is also diffusing into the hands of people who don’t pay their own energy bills. I’m part of an IT forum where network admins are constantly sharing stories about employees trying to hide mining equipment in the office to use the free power and cooling for pure profit. Similar situation in school dorms.

The idea of miners turning these things on only during rare times of excess grid capacity is a myth. They’re running 24/7 and they’re consuming energy that would otherwise be sent to the grid to offset fossil fuel consumption elsewhere.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by PartiallyTyped on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:21AM (#26214067)
Could you provide some links for these:

> Bitcoin is mostly mined using excess energy, or "cheap" energy, which improves the efficiency and costs of energy production, making it surprisingly "green".

> Bitcoin requires less energy on a per-store-of-value basis than Gold and Silver.

As for

> Bitcoin requires less energy on a per-store-of-value basis than credit cards and the banking system in general.

Bitcoin supports at many orders of magnitude less transactions on the ledger than the banking systems [1] and needs 10 minutes to add a new block to the ledger [2] and ETH about 10-15 seconds[2]. In contrast, according to this [3], in 2019 there were on average 100M visa transactions in the US alone, per day, so around 5 orders of magnitude more transactions in just the States, excluding MasterCard, paypal and every other system.

Now, there are better alternatives, ETH uses proof of stake, there are also papers on proof of space [4]. Personally I'd like to move to something decentralised and away from the banks as much as possible.

[1] https://charts.bitcoin.com/btc/chart/transactions-per-block#...

[2] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/b/block-time-cryptocurren...

[3] https://www.cardrates.com/advice/number-of-credit-card-trans...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proof_of_space

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by pyrale on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:12PM (#26215172)
> ETH uses proof of stake

AFAIK they have pledged to move to proof of stake for quite some time now, without delivering so far.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by dtech on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:12AM (#26213998)
Bitcoin is not even close to a replacement of banking and debit/credit cards. If bitcoin fulfilled those roles, it would use a lot more energy than the current system because of how energy-intensive transactions are due to the required mining.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by xur17 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:00AM (#26214402)
I keep hearing this repeated in threads about Bitcoin, and it's just flat out wrong. Bitcoin's energy usage does not scale based on the number of transactions. Its energy usage scales based upon the value of the block reward and the efficiency of mining operations.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by lalaland1125 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:06PM (#26216633)
It's not wrong. Bitcoin's energy usage does scale based on usage; it scales based on the value of money flowing through the system (in order to secure a certain transaction volume, you need electricity usage that corresponds to the value of those transactions). In order for Bitcoin to replace banks, it would have to consume an incredible amount of electricity.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by xur17 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:23PM (#26216797)
That is simply not true. I don't think you understand how Bitcoin works.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by lalaland1125 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @05:26PM (#26217914)
If the electricity usage falls below a certain fraction of the value going through the network then double spending attacks become a significant risk. Bitcoin only works on the assumption that the electricity usage (and hardware usage) is too high to make double spending attacks feasible.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by MrMan on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:35AM (#26214169)
If a bitcoin is functionally equivalent to a dollar you still need the entire stack of the financial industry, bitcoin doesn't in any way obviate finance
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by moralsupply on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:16AM (#26214030)
Bitcoin can't handle the amount of transactions the banking system can handle at the moment.

For it to scale to that level it requires an L2 solution (eg. Lightning), in which case energy consumption is not going to increase.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by PragmaticPulp on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:35AM (#26214165)
What’s the argument for using L2 networks on top of Bitcoin instead of simply using one of the other cryptocurrencies that was designed from the start to handle transaction volume?

Why do we need a separate currency for sending money around anyway?

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by moralsupply on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:43AM (#26214254)
The argument is that Bitcoin work very well as a store of value, and is proven (10+ years in operation with little-to-no incidents, despite a huge amount of attempts to attack the network). It doesn't need to be "perfect" in every front.

L2 solutions still transact the same tokens as their L1 counterparts.

Other solutions may potentially be "better" technically, but that doesn't mean they are proven in the long run, and the on-ramp, corporate, etc. infrastructure is not in place for them.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by jcranmer on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:48AM (#26214311)
> (10+ years in operation with little-to-no incidents, despite a huge amount of attempts to attack the network).

Shame about all of those hundreds of millions of dollars worth of Bitcoin that have been stolen. Come to think of it, while I haven't crunched the statistics, it wouldn't surprise me if your money were more likely to be stolen if you kept it in Bitcoin than a boring bank account.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by moralsupply on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:36AM (#26214790)
Is that because of the Bitcoin protocol or because people are dumb and lost their coins?
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by jiveturkey on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:58PM (#26219221)
does it matter?
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by Ekaros on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:19AM (#26214047)
Why would L2 solutions use less energy than current banking, payment processing and transactions solutions? Or with other services related be at least in same ballpark?
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by moralsupply on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:21AM (#26214063)
L2 doesn't require mining, only channels maintained with relatively low processing capabilities
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by MrMan on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:36AM (#26214179)
Why don't we use dollars
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by moralsupply on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:43AM (#26214265)
We do use dollars, the last time I checked...
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by mgberlin on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:12AM (#26213999)
[citation needed]

But really, I'm interested in these arguments, please let me know where I can learn more. Especially regarding the idea that it uses less energy than the current banking system.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by tonfa on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:25AM (#26214098)
> Especially regarding the idea that it uses less energy than the current banking system.

I guess this one is pretty clear, OP was only comparing to gold/silver (I have no idea how it compares in practice).

To be comparable to banking, bitcoin should probably first reach the level where it can provide the same functionality (payment, fractional banking, etc.). (And then prorated as even if it were to provide the functionality, it would have to scale by several orders of magnitude to replace banking)

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by moralsupply on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:20AM (#26214057)
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by mgberlin on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:26AM (#26214101)
That's a completely ridiculous answer and makes it clear you have no idea what you're talking about. 1) Gold has nothing to do with banking transactions, I've lived my whole life without ever touching a spec of gold. 2) Is about the energy consumption of bank branches. My bank doesn't even have branches. You're comparing apples to... tires or something.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by moralsupply on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:36AM (#26214178)
So your bank has no offices, no people, no nothing to make it work?

Do you think that corporations don't require buildings, computing resources, transportation, etc. to exist?

As for the link about gold, read my original comment.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by jcranmer on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:45AM (#26214283)
And you are willing and able to tot up those statistics for the people who make Bitcoin miners and other machines running nodes? And the buildings that house those, etc.? As long as you are not, it's still an improper comparison.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by texasbigdata on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:11AM (#26213987)
I’m a beginner but is your energy comment in perpetuity or at current point? Specially in 2734 or whatever due to the verification of Bitcoin transactions each requiring energy, as long as the transaction cost of non-Bitcoin was lower than Bitcoin in the long run (maybe the “you’re long dead” long run run) wouldn’t coin use more energy? Sorry for n00b question
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by vmception on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:10AM (#26213982)
Yeah people harp on and on about the amount of energy instead of the source of energy

turns out those entire countries in their favorite analogy also use a smaller amount of energy than many industries

the source is more important either way