News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by bitcharmer on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:04AM (#26205109)
Awesome, it was Metallica who started the whole nonsense behind today's state of DMCA. Finally getting some taste of their own medicine.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by splaytreemap on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:19AM (#26205246)
Metallica almost certainly still got paid, so I doubt they care much. Blizzard is probably furious.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by kzrdude on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:40AM (#26205451)
Maybe they'd need to be paid twice - is there a way to license the music for online streaming? And was it done as part of the contract in this case?
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by Mc_Big_G on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:23PM (#26205927)
Metallica is probably not in it for the $ much these days. I'd wager it's more about ego, so this probably stung. Deservedly.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lawnchair_larry on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:45PM (#26206123)
As a teenager, I thought I had a right to enjoy their work without paying for it. But this attitude surprises me from adults. Why don’t bands deserve to be paid for their product?
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:48PM (#26206147)
I want to pay artists for their work. I don't want to lease the bytes representing my access from a company, and then have them vanish later, because some kind of licensing agreement changed. Metallica was a huge driving force and public supporter behind the shitshow behavior. Do you like rootkits? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootk...
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by Hydraulix989 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:05PM (#26206836)
I wasn't aware Metallica ever rootkit'd anybody? I already knew about the Sony incident that you linked.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:07PM (#26206853)
The point is that efforts to prevent piracy, pushed by Metallica and obviously the recording companies at large, can be harmful, and it's possible to want to support artists but to prefer that they don't take measures which actively hurt consumers.

This is the same community that really hates ebook lending, and it's very much the same set of consumer-limiting control over intellectual property that curtails piracy but also makes things really inconvenient for the legitimate customer. I'm surprised but also not that people aren't able to think about this as more than a (false) dichotomy.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by Hydraulix989 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:13PM (#26206899)
Again, Metallica did not rootkit anybody. How are they hurting legitimate consumers of their work? Rootkits are not mere inconveniences, they are intentional data breaches. Obviously spreading mis-information using this particular false example is going to distort peoples' understandings of Metallica's actual stance and actions. Hacking consumers directly vs. using the court system to shut down an illegal piracy application is a very real dichotomy.

Properly implemented DRM is fine! Spotify has been a huge success, for example. Watching Netflix fully brings the convenience of streaming to legal content consumption. The only inconvenience here is that you can no longer pirate anything.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by ubercow13 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:35PM (#26207070)
I wouldn't say that DRM is 'fine'. For example there is no legal way to watch my blu-ray movies on my PC, on which I use Linux. Similarly Netflix 4K doesn't work at all on Linux or even on Windows unless you are using a specific web browser.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:36PM (#26207081)
Oh, right amazing point - it hadn't even floated to the top of my memory that I can't actually even pay anybody to watch Netflix if I'm using the wrong operating system. DRM utopia, indeed.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:23PM (#26206990)
> Again, Metallica did not rootkit anybody.

And, to use a facile and touchy example, Donald Trump didn't revolt at the capital.

But fine:

> what is a very real dichotomy

Help me out here - why are the only two choices: 1. rampant piracy 2. automated systems that allow corporations to trivially take down content, legitimate or not, with generally no recourse unless you get e.g. Google's attention on twitter?

Why are people so convinced there's no middle ground here, and that everybody with an opinion that #2 is perhaps a little problematic must be totally pro-piracy?

> Properly implemented DRM is fine!

Perhaps the argument is that we don't yet live in the land of properly implemented IP controls. I didn't realize we'd reached utopia; I'll go back to buying ebooks and reusing them across whatever devices I please.

Spotify and Netflix are great examples of exactly proof that a convenient form of consumption will get paying customers, and I was certainly more willing to buy MP3s when they stopped coming with DRM attached to them. The fact these work does not somehow render the point that, well, the original article, occurs, as a result of these things, and that it's ironic that it happens to Metallica, who would probably prior to this have been pleased that an automated system takes down anything approximating Enter Sandman.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by Hydraulix989 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:36PM (#26207080)
You originally stated that Metallica rootkitted people.

That's a ridiculous wholly non-analogous example. Trump clearly incited the riot, there were recordings as proof, and resultant court cases. I assume (and hope) that this is also your understanding of what actually happened with Trump.

In this case, it doesn't even come close. For example, Metallica wasn't even signed on the record label that did the rootkit. Metallica had literally no involvement any hacking of their fans' operating systems.

You're stating a different dichotomy now. The original one you proposed was whether it is possible to be against online piracy without attacking consumers' data.

I'm happy to entertain your other more reasonable arguments that you have later written as follow-ups, but your original post directly accusing Metallica of rootkits is just flat-out untrue.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:50PM (#26207195)
> That's a ridiculous wholly non-analogous example. Trump clearly incited the riot, there were recordings as proof, and resultant court cases. In this case, it doesn't even come close.

I'm just making the point that Metallica not rootkitting anybody is in no way an argument that they are neither in favor of that drastic a measure nor that they did not encourage or provide justification for the recording industry to do the same.

> You originally stated that Metallica rootkitted people.

No, I made a leap from "lobbying for and publicly whining about piracy" to "efforts to curb that include rootkits and other less horrible inconveniences". I'm sorry if that leap felt too extreme, next time I'll make the pit stops along the lines of "things don't work offline" and "things disappear without you knowing" and "things using otherwise standard formats aren't readable on your non-blessed device".

Whether Metallica directly rootkitted anything (which was never stated, it was just juxtaposed as an example of how this POV can hurt consumers in the end) doesn't really matter. Let's pretend that nobody ever rootkitted anybody.

How is this dichotomy different? My original, according to you:

> The original one you proposed was whether it is possible to be against online piracy without attacking consumers' data.

My recent restating:

> Help me out here - why are the only two choices: 1. rampant piracy 2. automated systems that allow corporations to trivially take down content, legitimate or not, with generally no recourse unless you get e.g. Google's attention on twitter?

Hm. Option 1 is online piracy, 2 is attacking consumers' data. Sounds pretty similar? Or do I need to be really literal and exact and use the same words?

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by Hydraulix989 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:58PM (#26207265)
Again, I agree with these newly changed words.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lawnchair_larry on Saturday February 20, 2021 @05:59PM (#26208843)
Your arguments on this whole thing are completely nonsensical. None of what you’re claiming to be mad about has anything to do with Metallica. You’re basically complaining that you can’t freely use the work of artists without compensating them.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:17PM (#26209005)
I'm not, and I'm sorry that you struggle to see anything but black and white. I'm not complaining about paying artists. The ability to pay them is 100% unrelated to the complaint that enforcement technologies can harm the consumer. I'm sorry that you're not seeing that, but I'm not sure how much more explaining can possibly help here. If you can find a sentence from me that, anywhere, says or even implies "I shouldn't have to pay for music/tv/ebooks", I'll be shocked. I'm glad you came back after your nonsensical police parallel to make this comment, though.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lawnchair_larry on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:03PM (#26206816)
Metallica had nothing to do with what your issue is then. Not a single thing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_compact_discs_sold_wit...

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:06PM (#26206838)
Metallica lobbied and was publicly the face of anti-piracy sentiment, and are therefore very much responsible for my issues AND their own, in this scenario.
[dead]
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:10PM (#26206874)
Or maybe just engage the statement on its merits instead of trying to create a strawman.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lawnchair_larry on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:25PM (#26209079)
Your whole argument is a straw man. You’re blaming Metallica suing napster for a sony rootkit. It’s nonsense.

I pirated the shit out of music on napster. But Metallica was still right to shut it down. I didn’t have any right to that music. I didn’t have any right to the $10 people paid me to burn CDs of napster content for them either.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:29PM (#26209117)
Cool. I don't have a right to free music either. I pay for music, as I mentioned. But I'm frustrated to see that you rabidly think that any critique of how we enforce anti-piracy means that I don't think artists deserve income.

Here's a twist for you. I work on a team responsible for, among other things, DRM for a major streaming video company. I believe in paying for multimedia. Please stop making assumptions about me that are not at all implied by my comments (that I steal artists' work).

Also, it looks like the majority of HN readers understood what I was saying, and found your argument to be nonsense, so maybe... let's just let it go? I don't care to keep explaining this to you and you don't care to perceive any degree of nuance, whether the fault is mine in explaining or not.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by ubercow13 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @03:03PM (#26207309)
I wouldn't like the police to rootkit my PC if that's what you're asking.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by VWWHFSfQ on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:52PM (#26206198)
well the industry corrected itself by pushing a la carte subscription music services which is what the freedom fighters hate but it turns out it's exactly what the people wanted all along.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by mrgordon on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:43PM (#26206642)
Nobody said it’s what the people wanted all along. I miss the days where my songs don’t just disappear from Spotify because they renegotiated a contract. But there’s no risk of being sued and it’s cheap enough so it’s easy to subscribe even if it’s not your preferred solution
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:33PM (#26206536)
I think it's pretty valid to want to pay a price for music, and then take that file wherever you go, without having to reconnect to update a license (I both pay for a subscription to Spotify and mp3s a la carte).

Of course, that's also available today, but that's not really relevant to the problem being discussed, which is: it's possible to want to pay artists, while also finding overzealous enforcement of the DMCA problematic.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by ulisesrmzroche on Saturday February 20, 2021 @08:42PM (#26210038)
I don’t think so. You have no right to ownership just because you buy the song. You didn’t commission it, you didn’t write it, produce it, market it, and so on. All you did was pay a couple dollars. In effect, all you’re doing is buying a license to play the song for personal use, not the right to keep the file forever.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @09:03PM (#26210158)
This is a weird take. There are stores that literally grant you that right, today. I'm pretty sure that even in the US, a court is not going to grant a musician the right to force you to delete the MP3s you bought off Amazon music. What is the basis for your belief that you don't have a right to the file you bought? Or are you disagreeing with the existence of stores that operate that way? Or with... basically the entire history of hard copy distribution, like cassettes, CDs, vinyl...
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by ulisesrmzroche on Saturday February 20, 2021 @09:15PM (#26210228)
https://www.zdnet.com/article/who-owns-your-digital-download...

Amazon actually will delete music from your hard drive.

5. Reservation of Rights

Except for the rights explicitly granted to you in the Terms of Use, all right, title and interest in the Service, the Software and the Digital Content are reserved and retained by us, our Digital Content providers, and our licensors. You do not acquire any ownership rights in the Software or Digital Content as a result of downloading Software or Digital Content.

And yeah I do disagree with the license of hard copy distribution. I don’t think just because I buy a book I can do whatever I want, even burning it.

I really think the supposed harm to consumers is vastly exaggerated in HN; on the other hand, the harm to artists and creators is serious, especially to those without the privilege of patronage.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @09:23PM (#26210268)
That article spends its whole time talking about whether you can transfer the rights. From your source, for example:

You may copy, store, and burn iTunes Plus Products as reasonably necessary for personal, noncommercial use.

All of the agreements cited are pretty clear that you can copy and store the bytes for your own use.

I agree with the thrust that "purchasing" music is certainly weirder with these overreaching legal agreements (and I think it's more fraught when it comes to video or video games), but I disagree with the perspective that:

A) That this is a lease of the music

B) That that condition is justified because you didn't create an exclusive commission.

It seemed to me that, legality aside (and forgive me if I'm misunderstanding), you were asserting that customers have no business expecting indefinite access to an MP3 they paid for, and I... disagree, but if the recording industry wants that to be the case, they're welcome to yet another scenario where pirates have a better customer experience than paying customers.

Blech, an edit: What I have seen that applied to is subscription-based music, where the license agreement around whether that song is available for subscription changes. Is there an example of this happening to a "purchased "song or album? I've never seen an effort by a publisher to reclaim hard-drive-bound songs that have been paid for (and I imagine spicy legal cases about expecting refunds).

Edit again: I realize I'm sort of meandering. My point is only that it's not unreasonable to expect that, I agree that licensing agreements for digital purchases of all kinds have surprising details about what you actually "own".

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by ulisesrmzroche on Saturday February 20, 2021 @09:33PM (#26210309)
Lol give me time to respond, I’ve already changed my post ten times.

Jk, I don’t care. Thanks for arguing in good faith, that’s not something that ever happens in this forum, I do appreciate that.

E: Like i said, I do think that unless you explicitly buy the rights to a song, you don’t own it, you’re leasing it. Probably the only reason (judging by music lawyers behavior) to have the ability to a sort of ownership to physical media is because they had no way of stopping you from doing anything you want with your copy. Of course, that’s a different story today, I’m sure given a time machine, that would not have been a precedent.

So that’s why I don’t like the argument from prior precedents, since it would not repeat given current tech.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @09:44PM (#26210361)
It's good to be reminded what we actually agree to. I find mp3 purchasing kind of hairy because it is certainly presented as a "buy" transaction rather than a lease. This is also true of video games and app stores, and then we get into fun situations where your google account gets banned for some reason and you lose, with no refund, all the apps you bought... I feel like the harm is great!

I am also sympathetic to the "creators'" perspective. How can you make a profit if people take whatever you made without compensation? I think part of my cynicism here is that the recording industry has long exaggerated and argued in poor faith about what the harm of a download is - conflating downloads with lost sales at a 1:1 rate, which... isn't quite right. And their approach for securing things can be problematic, I remember having a hell of a time with iTunes back with their DRM solution, hating that I couldn't just play the song I had paid for. If only I'd pirated from the start...

I think there's some axes along which things could be improved - the convenience axis - can I even buy (access to) the song without jumping through hoops? Can I pay to skip ads on whatever platform I'm using? How many different accounts do I need to get access to the music I'd like?

Edit: Agreed, I think if they can get away with having control at all times with the music you have available, they will... and it's hard for me to decide whether there will be backlash or just general acceptance in the same vein as the rest of the walled garden trends we've seen over the years.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by ubercow13 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:50AM (#26213105)
What's special about CDs or books in this sense compared to any other product? When I buy most other products I am not purchasing just a unilaterally withdrawable lease to use them in a manner controllable by the manufacturer.

If I purchase a Gucci handbag, I can do whatever I want with it even though it contains Gucci's trademark IP. It would be surreal for Gucci to be allowed to control what I wear it with, for example, or later take it off me. Nonetheless, owning the handbag does not give me ownership of their IP and it wouldn't make it legal for me to sell counterfeit copies of it.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by ulisesrmzroche on Saturday February 20, 2021 @08:37PM (#26210014)
But that implies you own the song, which you don’t. You’re always leasing access to the song. Just because you pay a couple dollars doesn’t mean you get to listen to it forever.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by blandflakes on Saturday February 20, 2021 @09:06PM (#26210174)
Already asked this, but where are you getting this interpretation? Not only is it now how most license agreements for music stores read today, it's also simply unreasonable.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by WarOnPrivacy on Saturday February 20, 2021 @04:04PM (#26207952)
> Why don’t bands deserve to be paid for their product?

The presentation suggests that Metallica goes unpaid for their product. I suspect there are many fat bank deposits that indicate otherwise.

What I feel is more important is that the assertion obfuscates the primary motivation in play. Wealthy and powerful copyright interests want to control what customers get to do with the product they purchase. This government-granted privilege isn't one that's enjoyed by the vast bulk of producers.

Worse, copyright gatekeepers have twisted the constitutional purpose of copyright - from encouraging the progress of science and the useful arts - into a pampered entitlement of never-ending profit.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lawnchair_larry on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:14PM (#26208978)
> Wealthy and powerful copyright interests want to control what customers get to do with the product they purchase.

No, this is not a story of the evil capitalist overlord oppressing the little guy. Save the hero narrative. Even the broke bands (which is most of them) want people to pay them for their work. The good news is there are actually a lot of them who don’t, and that’s their personal decision. You’re allowed to take it for free if they set their price at zero, but you’re not allowed to set their price at zero for them.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by WarOnPrivacy on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:19PM (#26215229)
> Even the broke bands (which is most of them) want people to pay them for their work.

Broke bands aren't who are paying legislators for ever-racheting copyright laws - each of which comes at the public's expense and further betrays the bargain between copyright holders and the public.

and - Corruption fueled copyright laws tend to favor powerful, wealthy gatekeepers (by design). For everyone else there are far better methodologies to making a living. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120210/02273417726/how-b...

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by dcwca on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:48PM (#26206158)
There are cases where it’s less important for bands to be paid for their music than it is to not sue children and not cripple consumer technology.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lawnchair_larry on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:20PM (#26209031)
Who in this discussion was advocating suing children?
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by dcwca on Monday March 01, 2021 @07:24PM (#26310394)
Metallica
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by zucker42 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:00PM (#26206258)
How exactly does what happened here -- hundreds of streams, including the official Twitch stream, muting themselves to avoid losing their careers or getting sued for absurd amounts of money -- contribute to bands getting paid?
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by ouid on Saturday February 20, 2021 @03:28PM (#26207630)
Lets say that all of the earths water becomes polluted except for an infinite well that only you have access to. Do you not have the right to get paid for it? Shouldn't you get paid something like the value added to humanity? So, everything? You should get paid everything?

What if the situation were different, and there where billions of people searching for infinite wells when all of the water became polluted and you were the lucky one to find it. Do you deserve everything now? How else were you supposed to have been incentivized to search for infinite wells if not for the possibility that everything would be yours upon finding it.

Alright, what if it weren't water? What if it were something that, instead of keeping you alive, just made life worth living? I reckon you probably couldn't get everything for it, but surely you could get a lot.

Does that seem like a bad system to you? I tell you what. I have a lot of money, I'll pay you to go searching for the infinite well of happiness (you can't survive on credit forever), and in exchange, it becomes mine when you find it, and then I can sell it for everything.

The premise that monopoly rights on distribution are necessary to incentivize the searching is pretty severely undermined by the fact that those monopoly rights are aggregated by companies which incentivize the searching via other means.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lawnchair_larry on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:06PM (#26208911)
You’re comparing a routine transaction of paying someone for their performance, to an unrealistic hypothetical involving the monopolization of a critical resource required to survive more than 3 days. It’s hard to take that argument seriously.

You’re misusing the word monopoly. Everyone has a monopoly on their own labor. But they don’t have a monopoly on music, and neither does Metallica. You’re not entitled to a man’s song and dance under any circumstances that don’t involve him entering into a mutually agreeable transaction with you. If this makes life not worth living, hopefully you can find someone else willing to accept your offer of giving them nothing in exchange for it. If you can’t, well, tough shit I guess. You still don’t deserve it for free. It’s not Lars’ problem if you will die without his music.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by ouid on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:06PM (#26215104)
I'm not talking about a transaction where someone performs for me, that's not what copyright refers to, I'm talking about an infinite well. And the comparison was between any infinite well and an infinite well of water. Granting someone scarcity rights on an unscarce resources is inefficient. Society would, instantaneously, produce a lot more value if all of the things that were free to reproduce were reproduced at the quantity demanded.

The question of copyright has ALWAYS been one of incentive, and I think my argument to that point is pretty clear.

Further, I am not misusing the word monopoly. Copyright is precisely monopoly distribution rights.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by VWWHFSfQ on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:48PM (#26206155)
no no no they're supposed to give their music away for free and then make money on concert tickets and t-shirts
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by sidpatil on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:47PM (#26206678)
That's essentially what most musicians end up doing when they stream on platforms like Spotify.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by Dirlewanger on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:55PM (#26206216)
People just can't let something from 21 years ago go, can they? The band's done a complete 180 on everything regarding digital distribution, and it's been this way for years (I'm sure owning their masters and own label has something to do with it). You want a real culprit who actually thoroughly abused (and still to this day) the DMCA? Get mad at the RIAA.

Also, if it weren't Metallica, it would have been someone else; virtually every big artist at the time felt the same way but didn't speak up.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by capsulecorp on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:36PM (#26206562)
I think many people don't buy their "complete 180", as that only came after their massively failed campaign. I have no doubt that if these guys were successful in their initial endeavor there would have never been a 180 as you call it. So really, there's not much to praise about a group who tried their hardest to do the wrong thing, and settled for the alternative when they failed measurably. Glad this happened to them, well deserved.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by AdrianB1 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:06PM (#26206840)
They maybe did an 180, but they did not undo what they did, the effects are visible today and they are at fault. No, people cannot just let something go in such circumstances.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by sidpatil on Saturday February 20, 2021 @05:45PM (#26208708)
> People just can't let something from 21 years ago go, can they?

Tell that to the media industries lobbying to extend copyright terms to virtually infinite duration. The "something" they can't let go of from 21 years ago is the copyright on the material, of course.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by michalstanko on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:24PM (#26206457)
Not sure why are you downvoted. It's hard to find a similarly popular band sharing more stuff online for free these days than Metallica. Besides, the entire Napster thing was about a song "I Disappear" being available through Napster BEFORE it was even finished and sent to CD manufacturing, and, don't forget, it all happened in 2000. It has not been on their radar for about 20 years now. Hating based on skimming headlines of inaccurate articles is surely easier than trying to understand the band's motives.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by jcpham2 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:30PM (#26207038)
I guarantee you people still volunteer their time to bootleg anything this band does on the internet, forever.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by throwmusician on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:01PM (#26206796)
As artists, why shouldn't Metallica get paid for their work?

I can't believe the audacity of people thinking they should just be able to steal others' (by virtue of copying) music.

The people I know in the music industry are some of the hardest working that I know...

And to be clear, Metallica was never against online streaming / downloading, only illegal piracy.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by cush on Saturday February 20, 2021 @03:16PM (#26207521)
Because fair use laws exist and educators like Rick Beato get screwed by these over-censoring algorithms.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by capsulecorp on Saturday February 20, 2021 @03:31PM (#26207652)
Piracy isn't stealing, it may be illegal, but it does not fit the definition of stealing. Saying piracy is theft, is an antiquated line of thinking that anyone with common knowledge of digital products knows to be false.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lillesvin on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:14PM (#26209467)
Not the person you're replying to, but "steal" has been used in that sense for a long, long time—also long before the internet—e.g. "stealing ideas", so arguably it fits the definition just fine.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by capsulecorp on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:21PM (#26209516)
"Stealing ideas" is also incorrect. A long running misconception doesn't make it not a misconception.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lillesvin on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:53PM (#26209744)
Come on. Following that logic you'll be hard pressed to speak a full meaningful sentence about a topic because, not surprisingly, language evolves!

"Steal" has been used as "copy" long enough that it's part of the standard usage now (and has been for a long time), just like "literally" being used as an intensifier, or "cool" meaning "good" as opposed to referring strictly to temperature.

And it's likely not even a misconception (like "a napron" => "an apron" was) but rather a conceptual metaphor (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conceptual_metaphor), which is what helps you understand that you shouldn't be afraid of cutting yourself on someone's "sharp wit", and that you don't need to bring a ladder shopping even though "prices are rising".

Hell, even "conception" (as in "misconception") was originally only used for talking about literal pregnancies, the metaphorical extension didn't come about until the 14th century (source: https://www.etymonline.com/word/conception). Or is that okay? If so, how old does a semantic extensions have to be to be accepted into the lexicon?

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by capsulecorp on Saturday February 20, 2021 @09:05PM (#26210166)
> not surprisingly, language evolves!

It sure does, did I say otherwise or was that just the easiest straw-man you could attack? I contend the word in its current form is evolved to not include piracy. Not surprisingly, evolution of language can go many ways, not just the way which supports your argument. Cheers!

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lillesvin on Saturday February 20, 2021 @10:19PM (#26210515)
First, it's only a strawman if you think accepted cognitive metaphor theory is wrong and the concrete form of "steal"/"theft" did not come before the more abstract mappings...

And are you really saying that "steal" has evolved away from also including "stealing ideas" and similar (including "piracy")? Because that's demonstrably false simply by pointing to the original argument you made complaining that people are using "steal" in the "wrong" way. I'm curious, though, do you have some data to back up that claim? (I'm assuming no—or something anecdotal at best—but on the off chance you have something, please, share!)

You are aware that general use defines language and what's considered correct, right? How you feel about it as an individual doesn't really matter in the grand scheme of things unless you manage to affect general usage of the term "steal" to no longer include "piracy".

You're obviously not arguing in good faith—e.g. by cherry-picking what you respond to (out of context even ... while missing the point) while completely ignoring other arguments. I'll refrain from taking further part in the discussion if that pattern continues because it's frankly a waste of time and effort.