News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by Dirlewanger on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:55PM (#26206216)
People just can't let something from 21 years ago go, can they? The band's done a complete 180 on everything regarding digital distribution, and it's been this way for years (I'm sure owning their masters and own label has something to do with it). You want a real culprit who actually thoroughly abused (and still to this day) the DMCA? Get mad at the RIAA.

Also, if it weren't Metallica, it would have been someone else; virtually every big artist at the time felt the same way but didn't speak up.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by capsulecorp on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:36PM (#26206562)
I think many people don't buy their "complete 180", as that only came after their massively failed campaign. I have no doubt that if these guys were successful in their initial endeavor there would have never been a 180 as you call it. So really, there's not much to praise about a group who tried their hardest to do the wrong thing, and settled for the alternative when they failed measurably. Glad this happened to them, well deserved.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by AdrianB1 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:06PM (#26206840)
They maybe did an 180, but they did not undo what they did, the effects are visible today and they are at fault. No, people cannot just let something go in such circumstances.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by sidpatil on Saturday February 20, 2021 @05:45PM (#26208708)
> People just can't let something from 21 years ago go, can they?

Tell that to the media industries lobbying to extend copyright terms to virtually infinite duration. The "something" they can't let go of from 21 years ago is the copyright on the material, of course.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by michalstanko on Saturday February 20, 2021 @01:24PM (#26206457)
Not sure why are you downvoted. It's hard to find a similarly popular band sharing more stuff online for free these days than Metallica. Besides, the entire Napster thing was about a song "I Disappear" being available through Napster BEFORE it was even finished and sent to CD manufacturing, and, don't forget, it all happened in 2000. It has not been on their radar for about 20 years now. Hating based on skimming headlines of inaccurate articles is surely easier than trying to understand the band's motives.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by jcpham2 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:30PM (#26207038)
I guarantee you people still volunteer their time to bootleg anything this band does on the internet, forever.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by throwmusician on Saturday February 20, 2021 @02:01PM (#26206796)
As artists, why shouldn't Metallica get paid for their work?

I can't believe the audacity of people thinking they should just be able to steal others' (by virtue of copying) music.

The people I know in the music industry are some of the hardest working that I know...

And to be clear, Metallica was never against online streaming / downloading, only illegal piracy.

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by cush on Saturday February 20, 2021 @03:16PM (#26207521)
Because fair use laws exist and educators like Rick Beato get screwed by these over-censoring algorithms.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by capsulecorp on Saturday February 20, 2021 @03:31PM (#26207652)
Piracy isn't stealing, it may be illegal, but it does not fit the definition of stealing. Saying piracy is theft, is an antiquated line of thinking that anyone with common knowledge of digital products knows to be false.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lillesvin on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:14PM (#26209467)
Not the person you're replying to, but "steal" has been used in that sense for a long, long time—also long before the internet—e.g. "stealing ideas", so arguably it fits the definition just fine.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by capsulecorp on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:21PM (#26209516)
"Stealing ideas" is also incorrect. A long running misconception doesn't make it not a misconception.
Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lillesvin on Saturday February 20, 2021 @07:53PM (#26209744)
Come on. Following that logic you'll be hard pressed to speak a full meaningful sentence about a topic because, not surprisingly, language evolves!

"Steal" has been used as "copy" long enough that it's part of the standard usage now (and has been for a long time), just like "literally" being used as an intensifier, or "cool" meaning "good" as opposed to referring strictly to temperature.

And it's likely not even a misconception (like "a napron" => "an apron" was) but rather a conceptual metaphor (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conceptual_metaphor), which is what helps you understand that you shouldn't be afraid of cutting yourself on someone's "sharp wit", and that you don't need to bring a ladder shopping even though "prices are rising".

Hell, even "conception" (as in "misconception") was originally only used for talking about literal pregnancies, the metaphorical extension didn't come about until the 14th century (source: https://www.etymonline.com/word/conception). Or is that okay? If so, how old does a semantic extensions have to be to be accepted into the lexicon?

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by capsulecorp on Saturday February 20, 2021 @09:05PM (#26210166)
> not surprisingly, language evolves!

It sure does, did I say otherwise or was that just the easiest straw-man you could attack? I contend the word in its current form is evolved to not include piracy. Not surprisingly, evolution of language can go many ways, not just the way which supports your argument. Cheers!

Re:Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch by lillesvin on Saturday February 20, 2021 @10:19PM (#26210515)
First, it's only a strawman if you think accepted cognitive metaphor theory is wrong and the concrete form of "steal"/"theft" did not come before the more abstract mappings...

And are you really saying that "steal" has evolved away from also including "stealing ideas" and similar (including "piracy")? Because that's demonstrably false simply by pointing to the original argument you made complaining that people are using "steal" in the "wrong" way. I'm curious, though, do you have some data to back up that claim? (I'm assuming no—or something anecdotal at best—but on the off chance you have something, please, share!)

You are aware that general use defines language and what's considered correct, right? How you feel about it as an individual doesn't really matter in the grand scheme of things unless you manage to affect general usage of the term "steal" to no longer include "piracy".

You're obviously not arguing in good faith—e.g. by cherry-picking what you respond to (out of context even ... while missing the point) while completely ignoring other arguments. I'll refrain from taking further part in the discussion if that pattern continues because it's frankly a waste of time and effort.