News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by uoaei on Friday February 19, 2021 @07:05PM (#26199762)
A right to free speech, and freedom from employer discrimination due to political beliefs.
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by bobbylarrybobby on Friday February 19, 2021 @07:06PM (#26199767)
“My employer is doing something wrong” is not a political belief
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by thundergolfer on Friday February 19, 2021 @07:13PM (#26199830)
Can you elaborate?
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by mc32 on Friday February 19, 2021 @07:23PM (#26199944)
Not the OP but I’d say reporting a company for breaking the law isn’t political even though laws stem from the political process.
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by thundergolfer on Friday February 19, 2021 @09:19PM (#26200864)
Thanks for reply. I can see where you're coming from I think, but reporting or not reporting the law being broken is political exactly because, as you say, laws stem from the political process, but also because law enforcement is a socio-political activity.

I do see what though, as it's supposed to be accepted as a basic premise of society that we set laws and follow them, and all accept the responsibility of ensuring that those laws are followed.

Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by dukeofdoom on Friday February 19, 2021 @07:19PM (#26199892)
Google manipulates search results to favour certain political beliefs. Censors people on youtube for expressing counter view points. And quite likely has enough power to skew elections. Plenty of what they do wrong is political in nature. And should be open to criticism.
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by NikolaeVarius on Friday February 19, 2021 @07:46PM (#26200146)
I seem to remember Google being criticized for having a disproportionate amount of left leaning employees pushing a left agenda while simultaneously being criticized for showing/pushing right/far right content on youtube. So which is it?
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by Viliam1234 on Friday February 19, 2021 @08:18PM (#26200400)
Could it be both?

The left-wing employees may have the political power within the company, but the algorithm maximizing clicks could end up recommending right-wing content because more users click on it.

Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by NikolaeVarius on Friday February 19, 2021 @08:22PM (#26200438)
The original claim was that Google uses their political power to push leftish views and censor right/far right views, so that particular claim is not consistent
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by dukeofdoom on Friday February 19, 2021 @08:52PM (#26200676)
You have to be wilfully blind to think that tech companies are some sort of benevolent, apolitical, neutral arbiters of truth. Here's a direct article from Today confirming that tech companies are coordinating censorship with your government.

https://nypost.com/2021/02/19/white-house-working-with-socia...

Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by throwaway3699 on Friday February 19, 2021 @08:45PM (#26200619)
You can push left wing views while still having more people choose right wing recommendations. There's a kind of feedback loop which pushes people to different viewpoints.
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by Viliam1234 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @08:28AM (#26203941)
Different politics can correlate with different web usage. Either directly, e.g. because of different type of censorship on different websites, or indirectly e.g. because politics correlates with social class, and social class correlates with web usage.

So maybe YouTube is relatively more popular with right wing, and Twitter with left wing... which would make the average YouTube user more right-wing than the average of the population (and the average Twitter user more left-wing that the average of the population).

It could even be some statistical artifact. Maybe the audience is divided 50:50, but e.g. left-wing users are more likely to produce their own videos. That would mean that right-wing videos have on average more views per video.

It could be an artifact of censorship itself: suppose that e.g. extreme right-wing is 5% of population, and they produce 5% of videos. But half of those videos are removed by YouTube. If they keep using the same search terms, the surviving videos will have twice more views per video. And if then YouTube moderators freak out and delete half of those, the views of the remaining half will double again, feeding a spiral of hysteric moderation and extreme popularity of the few surviving fringe videos. (And it doesn't help if the content-agnostic algorithm predicts -- correctly -- that the popularity of these videos is likely to skyrocket.)

Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by ineedasername on Friday February 19, 2021 @07:08PM (#26199784)
Unfortunately, free speech protections are generally to protect you from government action that may suppress speech, while private entities have a lot more discretion.
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by oblio on Friday February 19, 2021 @07:08PM (#26199788)
Free speech is almost purely limited to interactions with a state. Why are people trying to shoehorn it into everything?
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by vorpalhex on Friday February 19, 2021 @07:11PM (#26199814)
Free speech is a moral value. The First Amendment is limited to the Government.
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by rayiner on Friday February 19, 2021 @08:46PM (#26200629)
We also learned about “First Amendment values” in law school. This idea that there is no moral component associated with the First Amendment is a new and weird one.
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by tptacek on Saturday February 20, 2021 @06:45PM (#26209252)
One of the first things the founders did was to pass the Sedition Act of 1798, so whatever the moral component of the First Amendment is, it wasn't as clear as it's made out to be today.
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by idlewords on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:44PM (#26215956)
It was the Alien and Sedition act and closely tied to a fear of foreigners, and of national collapse in general, before the country had had time to gel. You can squint and hold it up to the light and see it as a principled diagreement over free expression, but that's pretty ahistorical.

The important point here is that limits on speech and free expression in American discourse have traditionally gone hand in hand with a fear of foreign influence. If anything, that gives more of a moral edge to the argument over free speech, not less.

Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by tptacek on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:16PM (#26216734)
Yeah, I'm referring specifically to the Sedition Act of 1798 (one of 4 "A&S" acts), which was not principally used against foreigners --- and, in fact, was exploited by its opponents (notably Jefferson) to persecute political adversaries.

"Are we bound hand and foot that we must be witnesses to these deadly thrusts at our liberty?" (The thrusts were words on paper.) "Are these approaches to revolution and Jacobinic domination to be observed with the eye of meek submission? No, sir, they are indeed terrible; they are calculated to freeze the very blood in our veins. Such liberty of the press and of opinion is calculated to destroy all confidence between man and man."

The target of this speech, by a proponent of the Sedition act, was Benjamin Franklin Bache, a printer and native son of Pennsylvania.

My point is just that I'm deeply skeptical of moral principles encoded in the Constitution. I think it's a good system, a set of functional and useful institutions, not something I would want to fuck with, &c. Maybe not my moral north star, though.

Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by vorpalhex on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:09AM (#26211502)
Bill of Rights was 1791. That's like judging Obama era policies based on Trump changing them.
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by tptacek on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:10PM (#26215154)
I don't understand that you're trying to say, but of course my point is that the authors and ratifiers of the bill of rights immediately turned around and abrogated them.
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by oblio on Saturday February 20, 2021 @10:44AM (#26204936)
How is free speech a moral value? Speaking your mind, honesty, bravery are moral values:-)
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by vorpalhex on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:59AM (#26205663)
Free speech is at it's core dangerous speech. It's speech in favor of trans rights when nobody supports it. It's speech calling attention to inequality nobody wants to hear. It's speech that's unfavorable to the government and our neighbors.

Safe speech isn't free speech. Free speech is the engine of change for things like trans rights, same sex marriage, equal protection under the law and even evolution being taught in schools.

If you do not hold free speech as a moral value, if you don't feel a moral duty to use speech that may be censored or unfavored, then you don't agree with using speech to fix social problems.

Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by oblio on Sunday February 21, 2021 @08:18AM (#26213236)
Dangerous because of what? Because of government action? That's regular free speech. Because of the actions of powerful persons? We have other actions covering their possible retribution.

Why exactly is free speech something important in the private arena?

I still don't think it's a moral value on its own.

[dead]
Re:Margaret Mitchell fired from Google by SuoDuanDao on Friday February 19, 2021 @09:41PM (#26200993)
I'm a little conflicted on this one. On the one hand, it seems like a clear case of 'live by the sword, die by the sword'. On the other hand, maybe a bunch of gun-toting conspiracy theorists speaking up for these professional ethicists would be the hand of friendship that could breach a deep but narrow chasm in public life.

But realistically, I imagine if a gun-toting conspiracy theorist showed up, someone like the article subject would scapegoat them for another month of comfortable employment, so she's probably exactly where she needs to be.