News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by sydd on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:00PM (#26156759)
What's going on with all the Uncle Bob hate nowadays? I last heard about him ~6-8 years ago when people were preaching his sentiments about clean code and TDD.

I agree with some of his stuff, e.g. he was the one who convinced me how important tests are.

Also the blog author is exaggerating in lots of places e.g.: "Safer Languages: The ‘Dark Path’." In the linked article he says "It’s not the fact that Swift and Kotlin are statically typed that has me concerned. Rather, it is the depth of that static typing." (I myself don't agree with Uncle Bob, I think nullable types are an awesome thing)

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by overgard on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @02:19PM (#26157648)
I think it's partially that he reminds me of a motivational speaker that end of the day just ends up saying things that are incredibly simplistic and not really useful. His message is basically "unit tests are good!", and it's like, cool, got anything else? Youre famous for this? I also think the "uncle" thing comes across painfully pretentious. I'm 35, if you're not actually my uncle I'm sure not calling you that.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by eitland on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @04:17PM (#26158911)
> I also think the "uncle" thing comes across painfully pretentious. I'm 35, if you're not actually my uncle I'm sure not calling you that.

It's a well known idiom:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob's_your_uncle

You might not think it's funny but it seems a lot of people so.

Also: if anyone gets annoyed by it then for a lot of people that seems to make it even funnier.

Just saying.

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by staticassertion on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @03:31PM (#26171317)
I think it's just really dated and comes across weird.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by wglb on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:46PM (#26210880)
I think that is a different idom.

The sense of "Uncle" in Uncle Bob is someone that is older than you and may or may not know more than you do, but is authoritarian about it.

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by barbarbar on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @12:09AM (#26162950)
Awesome - thank you. I had no idea. I suppose there are a lot of sayings like that in different languages. Which does not make much sense unless you know that language.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by overgard on Friday February 19, 2021 @03:17PM (#26197532)
Hah fair enough I had no idea! Today I learned.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by commandlinefan on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @02:34PM (#26157787)
> unit tests are good

Well I sure wish more people would get the damned message - maybe if enough people listened he wouldn’t have to keep saying it.

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by overgard on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @02:41PM (#26157852)
Funny paradox though: if they were that useful he probably wouldn't need to say it all the time :) (To be clear I'm not anti-unit test, they're fine, but they're a very small part of a much larger picture)
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by tedivm on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:10PM (#26156879)
He's been really active lately pushing his methods and insulting people who don't agree with him. He's also thrown a few tantrums over the last year or so that gotten him more negative attention.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by worik on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @02:48PM (#26157944)
That was the way, once upon a time.

I really like his stuff, I disagree with him a lot, good. I cannot be bothered with people I agree with all the time, boring

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by tedivm on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @03:03PM (#26158108)
There's a difference between engaging people in conversation over disagreements and flat out insulting people. Grown men throwing temper tantrums is never pleasant and should not be encouraged, and to be honest it was never "the way" for most people.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by worik on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @07:21PM (#26160865)
I agree with you, really.

I do like his style, but not because it is a good style, or should be emulated. But because it is entertaining, and is getting rare (among people worth listening too, anyways)

By "the way" I mean the alpha males of days gone by who were so certain of their correctness that... they acted like Uncle Bob

Big Swinging Dicks

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by sydd on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @03:23PM (#26158338)
Not really a rare thing among programmers, see Linus Torvalds :)
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by mannykannot on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:26PM (#26157048)
For one thing, on Stack Overflow there's a steady drumbeat of replies and comments that take Martin's writings and aphorisms as being the alpha and omega of software quality.

Martin has a lot of good advice (along with some dubious attitudes) for someone relatively new to programming, but he most definitely does not have the last word on the issue.

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by henricao on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:34PM (#26157143)
Wait, why do you consider this article "hate"? It gives many examples of supposedly bad advice and makes a point to say they are wrong.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by addicted on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @03:00PM (#26158077)
I just wanted to point out that this article is from 2017, so it’s definitely not part of some sort of recent hate fest.

Edit: The title should probably include the “(2017)” tag.

[dead]
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by gred on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:44PM (#26157254)
I heard he said something positive about Richard Stallman once. /s
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by trianglem on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:10PM (#26156878)
Name one product he has successfully created. The dripping self victimization is disgusting.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by dang on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @05:27PM (#26159553)
We've banned this account for repeatedly breaking HN's guidelines and ignoring our repeated requests to stop.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by zarkov99 on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:28PM (#26157066)
He as written many useful books and identified a core set of principles for good design. That is much harder than being a cog in the building of a successful product.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by anthonygd on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:45PM (#26157267)
That's an entirely circular argument and doesn't prove anything about Uncle Bob.

Question: Why should I listen to Uncle Bob? Answer: Because he wrote a book telling you what to do.

He's got some un-controversially good opinions but he also has some opinions that are just plain stupid. Since his opinions don't compile and aren't testable, it's not easy to rate their over all value.

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by zarkov99 on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @02:35PM (#26157797)
It would be circular but for the word useful, which implies that, at least for some people, including me, some of what he said compiled and worked..
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by count on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:51PM (#26157327)
Are we sure they're good design principles? Have they been used to design and build something successful?

I think that's the source of consternation: he preaches, and has religious fervor, but what has his principle set built (even if it's not him doing the building!)? I honestly don't know the answer there...but it's definitely not obvious. It frames his arguments are 'just trust me', which rubs a lot of people wrong.

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by zarkov99 on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @02:32PM (#26157773)
Not all of them, but the SOLID stuff is pretty, well, solid.
[dead]
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by casselc on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:26PM (#26157049)
This article is from 2017.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by bmurphy1976 on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:43PM (#26157246)
The HN submission and the comments are from today.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by zabzonk on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:07PM (#26156840)
> What's going on with all the Uncle Bob hate nowadays?

Sensible people have always hated him and his bullshit - what products has he ever produced? I remember when he started posting his nonsense on Stack Overflow - boy, did he run out of there with his tail between his legs.

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by dang on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @05:29PM (#26159576)
Please don't post personal invective like this to HN. Maybe you don't owe $UNCLE any better, but you owe this community better if you're posting to it, because the global effect of this kind of thing is destructive of what we want HN to be.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by jancsika on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:35PM (#26157156)
Hm, I just checked the user page for an "Uncle Bob." It looks like he had 6 accepted answers out of a total of 10.

On all but one of the accepted answers a lot of the comments are simply kudos. Plus on most of his non-accepted answers, he has comments thanking him for his answer.

If I had judged StackOverflow by this user page alone, I would probably would have been persuaded to use StackOverflow. :)

Where's the "tail between his legs" post you are referring to?

https://stackoverflow.com/users/73476/uncle-bob

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by rovolo on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @03:04PM (#26158133)
I'm guessing they're referring to the fact that he only answered questions from March to October 2009. That's a short time, but we shouldn't really expect people to donate time answering questions on SO either.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by Jtsummers on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @03:54PM (#26158693)
TBF, I think a lot of us joined it in the early days, contributed a bit, found it not to our liking or that it wasn't where we wanted to spend a lot of time for some reason, and moved on. Someone moving on after a few, apparently, positive encounters doesn't really indicate anything other than that they moved on.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by zabzonk on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:43PM (#26157247)
> Where's the "tail between his legs" post you are referring to?

I didn't mention a post. He came to stack overflow, posted a few answers for which he obviously expected instance acceptance, and then, once he realised that no-one particularly wanted anything to do with him, immediately disappeared.

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by jancsika on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @04:15PM (#26158881)
I don't find evidence for the claim that he expected instant acceptance for any of the posts he made. What's your evidence for that claim?

I also don't find evidence that "no-one particularly wanted anything to do with him." Especially given that the majority of his answers were the accepted answer, why do you claim this?

Finally, what's the relevance of him "immediately" ceasing his posts? Users of crowd-sourced services have all kinds of usage patterns for all kinds of reasons. Frankly, I find fatuous to notice a sudden lack of use and jump to the conclusion that it must be due to the user having been humiliated or shamed (which is what "tail between legs" refers to).

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by zarkov99 on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:26PM (#26157045)
Really? Is that you criteria for whether someone knows something worthwhile about programming? What did Stroustrup create? How about Dijsktra? Tannenbaun? Herb Sutter? There is more than one way to contribute to the advancement of the state of the art and Martin has done plenty to advance it.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by zabzonk on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:29PM (#26157081)
> What did Stroustrup create?

Are you serious?

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by zarkov99 on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @02:36PM (#26157804)
Maybe C++ could be considered a product, but that did not seem to be what the OP meant.
Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by buescher on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @05:54PM (#26159841)
I'll take Knuth's ideas on goto over Dijsktra's any day, not just because Knuth has been the better thinker and writer, but also because he wrote TeX and other software.

Remember when structured programming was going to fix everything? Well, neither do I, but it still had a ton of momentum as a panacea when I was learning to program. Grown-ups with access to real computers would sniff at our BASIC machines and quote Djikstra at us.

Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017) by eitland on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @04:23PM (#26158983)
> Sensible people have always hated him

Sensible people should have a rather high bar for hating people.

> what products has he ever produced?

His impact hasn't so much been physical products as teaching.

He has taught a lot of useful stuff. For me there is one particular conference 12 or so years ago that I still thibk of again and again.

It is about refactoring methods and it was brilliant and by following the resulting code becomes much easier to reason about. Some reason needs ro be applied, but less than if I hadn't learned those ideas.