News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by ignoranceprior on Sunday February 14, 2021 @06:53PM (#26137464)
how I imagine (straw) hyper-capitalists think:

"why is poverty bad? not because we have empathy for poor people, nah, just because poor people are not being optimally productive worker bees"

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by solveit on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:00PM (#26137494)
Why do you spend time imagining how straw men think?
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by ruined on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:38PM (#26137715)
when people ignore moral or ethical concerns due to ideology or simply different goals, it's useful to have evidence supporting an argument that fits into their worldview, so compromise or progress is possible.

that said, this straw man is pretty fleshy. there are definitely plenty of bosses who don’t care about or at least don’t prioritize the misery of their poor employees, for reasons concerning their own profit. in the absence of government action or mass labor action, i’m happy this study exists.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by imtringued on Monday February 15, 2021 @05:34AM (#26141319)
Why is that wrong? Even the greediest human on the planet with zero empathy for others would be forced to care about others.

The real problem is that a lot of people think the exact opposite.

"If I can drag others down, I can protect or increase my wealth."

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by fatsdomino001 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @06:56PM (#26137478)
Keep in mind capitalism has lifted more people out of poverty than any other system.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by andrepd on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:04PM (#26137525)
How so? That sounds like overreaching conclusions. You might as well say "monarchy is responsible for the scientific and industrial revolutions", or "Christianity has created the Renaissance", just because those pairs of complex changes in society and history happened concurrently in time.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by DC1350 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:08PM (#26137538)
Because nobody with money gave a shit about the global poor until they realized they could be used for cheap labour. The ability to collect the surplus value of their work encouraged investment in poor regions
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by andrepd on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:17PM (#26137598)
> Because nobody with money gave a shit about the global poor until they realized they could be used for cheap labour.

They did. It's called slavery. It's only when that finally became mostly unacceptable (remember there are still millions of enslaved persons worldwide), that they had to turn to paying them wages of a dollar a day (slavery with extra steps).

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by DC1350 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:43PM (#26137745)
The transition from slave ownership to slavery as a service is truly one of the most disruptive innovations of the last 200 years.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by imtringued on Monday February 15, 2021 @05:49AM (#26141436)
Working for income is not slavery. You can always go join open source ecology and build your own civilization from scratch.

Forced work in a prison could be considered slavery depending on the reason for the arrest and the financial motives of the owner of the prison.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by andrepd on Monday February 15, 2021 @06:01PM (#26148780)
> Working for income is not slavery. You can always go join open source ecology and build your own civilization from scratch.

No, you can't, because you need to eat tonight, not tomorrow or the week after or next quarter. And you need to pay bills, your house, etc. So the labour market is not in effect free.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by imtringued on Monday February 15, 2021 @05:44AM (#26141399)
Slavery is not very capitalist. In fact, it's closer to corporate welfare than capitalism (aka socialism except for corporations). Involuntary labor hurts everyone. It's highly inefficient.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by throwanem on Sunday February 14, 2021 @06:59PM (#26137492)
I've heard this claim before, but I've never seen it substantiated. Would you like to do so?
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by bbreier on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:30PM (#26138055)
It depends entirely on how you define poverty- typically these claims are based on a figure of $1.90 per day as the threshold for "extreme poverty", and you can use the World Bank's calculator to verify that they are true here: http://iresearch.worldbank.org/PovcalNet/povOnDemand.aspx

But it doesn't tell the whole story. Could you survive on $2 per day? The implication of this claim is that you are not in "extreme poverty" at that threshold, but I'm not sure many people would agree.

The next natural step is to ask where the line really should be drawn? For many reasonable numbers, we can see that number has been rising in the past few decades. You can set your own inputs on the linked calculator based on where you believe the poverty line should be drawn and decide for yourself.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by Mountain_Skies on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:12PM (#26137570)
The difficulty is going to be around definitions. There are claims that communism has killed X million people, where both the definition of communism and what constitutes cause are very loose. On the flip side you have people who advocate for communism who claim it's never been tried and everything that has ever called itself communism wasn't true communism. You'll face the same issue with capitalism.

The confounding factor I see here is what do we call China? They've experienced an incredible increase in wealth under their communist system but is what they have really communism? It certainly has lots of attributes of both theoretical capitalism and western capitalism as practiced mixed in with communist concepts. Whatever it is, China, for better and worse, is a very different country than it had been because in part due their hybrid economic system.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by DC1350 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:45PM (#26137766)
Chinese people only became wealthy after major economic reforms that abandoned anything related to communism except for the name and aesthetic
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by bbreier on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:40PM (#26138107)
For some definitions of communism... in the US, many would have us believe that universal health care is a key component of communism and China still has plenty of that.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by imtringued on Monday February 15, 2021 @06:12AM (#26141587)
I don't think capitalism is incompatible with government run services. Some services are so fundamental that everyone needs them and thus demand is very easy to predict. Adding profit incentives to basic needs just adds friction and inefficiency since the transaction is involuntary.

Private industry is really, really good at innovation (e.g. discovering new drugs and treatments) and providing optional goods and services but most people just want a basic level of service and they want a funding structure that does not misalign incentives.

For example, optional basic health insurance doesn't work because poor people will quit the insurance program while they are healthy and then only unhealthy people will stay and bear the full cost. This raises the cost for poor unhealthy people and then they quit insurance and get denied access to care. Finally only the wealthiest people will have health insurance.

Capitalism is just a tool that's used to achieve certain outcomes. It just happens to work more often that it fails. Nothing more, nothing less. If a different tool works just as fine or better then it can be used selectively in areas where it's superior. Blind faith to any tool is stupid.

Communism on the other hand tends to fail by default and because it requires external forces to make it work, it breeds authoritarianism and then everything goes bad.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by bbreier on Monday February 15, 2021 @10:42AM (#26143728)
Completely agree with you. I was just pointing out that the public discussion of universal healthcare in the US tends to demonize it as a path to Leninism or Maoism, in contrast with the claim that China now has nothing resembling communism. At no point was I advocating for communism (or any other economic system).
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by acta_non_verba on Sunday February 14, 2021 @09:19PM (#26138340)
China doesn’t have universal healthcare free at the point of use.

The UK, a capitalist country, does.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by bbreier on Monday February 15, 2021 @10:46AM (#26143774)
I'm not sure how this relates to my claim
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by u678u on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:14PM (#26137579)
Generally the last few decades as capitalism has swept the globe poverty has dropped dramatically in the poorest countries. https://yaleglobal.yale.edu/content/globalization-reduced-po...

Western Europe vs Eastern Europe, N Korea vs S Korea, Colombia vs Venezuela, USA vs Russia - its pretty standard that the workers in the Capitalist countries have a better quality of life than those in the Communist ones.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by Aunche on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:14PM (#26137946)
It's not so much capitalism as much as having good economics. Communism was economically advantageous to serfdom. Capitalism was economically advantageous to communism, which is why China's economy boomed after they started to embrace a market economy.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by yulker on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:02PM (#26137508)
And created the very context for that poverty to exist in the first place as an extension of post ag society.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by refurb on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:54PM (#26137827)
“By curing 99% of cancers you created the very context for people dying of cancer.”

Making some people rich doesn’t create poor people. They were poor before.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by chordalkeyboard on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:41PM (#26137736)
I’m fairly sure the academic consensus is that agriculture created poverty.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by pbourke on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:48PM (#26137781)
What do you mean? There was ample poverty before the advent of Capitalism.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by upbeat_general on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:19PM (#26137606)
I think this is the classic correlation != causation.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by socialdemocrat on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:17PM (#26137962)
Since it is pretty much the only system used today, that is kind of hard to avoid.

But on a serious note, the command economy of the Soviet Union did surprisingly well despite its profound number of flaws.

Literacy rates, economic output, educational levels, scientific output etc was significantly improved in Soviet times, relative to the Czar area which after all was capitalist.

This all happened despite the fact that:

1. They had a bloody and destructive revolution. 2. Their country got laid to ruins by the German invasion. 3. They had to rebuild the country after WWII with most of the healthiest and youngest members of society dead. Yet they pulled that off surprisingly well.

Yes if you compare Soviet growth to a number of other countries it was not always stellar, but considering that these countries had not received the same kind of devastating blows, it was still quite remarkable.

China is another good example. India and China had the same GDP per capita in the 1940s. China had a destructive Japanese invasion and then a bloody civil war. Then Mao did the crazy cultural revolution setting them back even more.

Despite all this China has 3x the GDP per capita of India. All despite the fact that India had democracy, private property and capitalist enterprises in this whole period.

Even today almost all key industries in China are fully or partially owned by the state. Such as construction, energy, banking etc. Yes China has lots of private enterprise as well. But they got growing rapidly long before these dominated the economy.

No, economy has pulled as many people out of poverty as China, and they did that with what can best be described as hybrid system. The Chinese economic miracle had been ongoing for many years before private property was actually made legal in China.

NOTE: I am not advocating these kinds of system as they are dictatorships. But I think they are worth pondering before people push the truthism that capitalism is so superior as an economic system and that alternatives cannot perform. The evidence seems to suggest that other systems can work and perhaps the best systems are hybrid systems.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by imtringued on Monday February 15, 2021 @06:27AM (#26141687)
>Despite all this China has 3x the GDP per capita of India. All despite the fact that India had democracy, private property and capitalist enterprises in this whole period.

This is a recent phenomenon that started in the 90s. China was essentially flat until 1993 (that's when India and China's GDP per capita started diverging).

Remember that article about a feed processing company in India not getting a permit to build a factory because he has to rezone land because all land in India is zoned for agriculture by default? The problem wasn't the bureaucracy. It was the corruption. The founder had to go to 14 different offices and one third of them didn't even process his forms because he refused to pay bribes. He had the bribe money but he refused out of principle and that heavily delays the start of the company.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by ajmadesc on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:20PM (#26137985)
Can we have a list of systems to choose from?
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by wyre on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:15PM (#26137587)
Advancements in technology lifts people out of poverty. There is no proof these advancements in tech would not have realized without capitalism.

If anything China and the USSR turning their agrarian societies into world powers in the course of a few decades says otherwise. Whether or not the authoritarianism needed to accomplish this is worthwhile is another discussion. That said it is theoretically possible to achieve a more equal society without authoritarianism.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by pbourke on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:51PM (#26137807)
This is a tremendous non sequitur. Being a world power and the level of poverty within a country have little to do with each other.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by wyre on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:23PM (#26138002)
Can you give me an example? The only world power I can think of with high levels of poverty is the US, but I live here so I don’t have experience in other world power countries.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by acta_non_verba on Sunday February 14, 2021 @09:22PM (#26138361)
India and China are both super powers with large populations of extremely impoverished people.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by AnimalMuppet on Monday February 15, 2021 @12:38AM (#26139455)
The USSR could produce enough nuclear weapons to keep pace with the US, but they couldn't produce toothpaste for their people. When that sank in for Gorbachev, he decided that something was fundamentally broken with the USSR economy.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by cpursley on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:58PM (#26137851)
The late USSR frequently had to import its own grain and other food stuffs as it could not produce enough; it's one of the reasons USSR failed. And in the early USSR millions of people literally starved to death (holdimor). Today, despite all it's issues, modern capitalist (more or less) Russia is the largest wheat producer in the world. Not sure about China.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by wyre on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:34PM (#26138078)
I’m not trying to defend the USSR but afaik the USSR failed because of Gorbachev lowered the amount of power of the state. I’m also pretty sure Holdimor was anti-Ukrainian state management holding wheat from them and less about its economic system.

China did have a huge famine due to state powers making the wrong choice.

I can’t speak about wheat production but I don’t think it has much to do with bringing people out of poverty if the state is still able to provide for its citizens.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by djrobstep on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:40PM (#26137730)
Keep in mind capitalism systematically creates poverty by depriving income to the ~50% of the population that are not full time workers (children, elderly, sick, disabled, unemployed, students, etc).
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by chordalkeyboard on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:10PM (#26137914)
> capitalism systematically creates poverty by depriving income to the ~50% of the population that are not full time workers

What income are they depriving them from? If they aren’t working, how could anyone deprive them of an income that doesn’t exist?

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by djrobstep on Sunday February 14, 2021 @09:04PM (#26138243)
??? That is literally what deprivation means - the thing you need is absent.

The deprivation is enforced through a large government program called "property law".

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by chordalkeyboard on Sunday February 14, 2021 @09:09PM (#26138275)
> That is literally what deprivation means - the thing you need is absent.

“Deprivation” is the act or process of removing. You’re claiming someone removed the income, but they haven’t done anything to create an income. There’s no income from which to deprive them because they haven’t done anything to generate an income.

> The deprivation happens through a large government program called "property law".

That doesn’t make sense, the way I understand it, property law codifies the rules around the things that people own. That’s preventing owners from being deprived. You’re asserting that laws which forbid depriving people of property are the mechanism by which they are deprived? How does that work?

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by djrobstep on Sunday February 14, 2021 @09:15PM (#26138308)
> but they haven’t done anything to create an income

"People who don't work full time should starve" is ideology, not some law of physics.

> There’s no income from which to deprive them

There is plenty. US GDP is trillions a year.

> How does that work?

Property law creates property ownership. Ownership assigned to one person is deprived from others.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by AnimalMuppet on Monday February 15, 2021 @12:53AM (#26139549)
Then hand over the computer you're typing this on. It doesn't belong to you, and I've got some people who want to use it.

That is, I'm pretty sure that on some level you operate as if private property is both normal and right, no matter what your theory says...

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by djrobstep on Monday February 15, 2021 @02:36AM (#26140127)
Self ownership (control over your own body) is in fact the opposite of property ownership, because property enforcement requires violently restricting the bodies of others against for consent.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by readflaggedcomm on Monday February 15, 2021 @02:07AM (#26139971)
That is personal property, not private property.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by chordalkeyboard on Monday February 15, 2021 @03:29AM (#26140431)
What’s the difference? Who appointed you the arbiter of property classes?
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by chordalkeyboard on Sunday February 14, 2021 @09:40PM (#26138468)
> "People who don't work full time should starve" is ideology, not some law of physics.

“People are entitled to other people’s labor” is ideology as well. However claiming that someone has been deprived of something that never existed in the first place is just nonsense.

> There is plenty. US GDP is trillions a year.

So you’re suggesting we deprive people of their income because of your ideology?

> Property law creates property ownership.

Negative, ownership creates property law.

> Ownership assigned to one person is deprived from others.

So how do you justify assigning ownership to certain people? What gives you the right to deprive people of their income?

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by djrobstep on Sunday February 14, 2021 @11:49PM (#26139216)
> “People are entitled to other people’s labor” is ideology as well.

You make a powerful critique of capital income and inheritance law.

> So you’re suggesting we deprive people of their income because of your ideology?

You're the one advocating we systematically deprive people of income. I'm the one advocating everybody receive an income.

> Negative, ownership creates property law.

Libertarian ideology has broken your brain. Property law is a government program - it requires enforcement to exist, aka the law.

> So how do you justify assigning ownership to certain people?

The principles of egalitarianism.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by chordalkeyboard on Monday February 15, 2021 @12:26AM (#26139403)
> You make a powerful critique of capital income and inheritance law.

You must have missed the part about entitlement to others’ labor, as inheritance is a transfer initiated by the owner of the property, and capital income is a voluntary exchange by all parties.

> You're the one advocating we systematically deprive people of income.

No, that was you who suggested that US GDP could be expropriated from its owners and redistributed to your favored recipients.

> I'm the one advocating everybody receive an income.

Yes, exactly. You’re advocating that some men with guns confiscate the income of the working class and give it to people whom you have deemed more deserving. You haven’t justified this, however.

> Property law is a government program - it requires enforcement to exist, aka the law.

Property is temporally and logically antecedent to property law.

> The principles of egalitarianism.

According to egalitarian principles, you have no such right.

> Libertarian ideology has broken your brain.

Less of this, please. Make your case on the merits or move on.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by djrobstep on Monday February 15, 2021 @01:02AM (#26139595)
> as inheritance is a transfer initiated by the owner of the property

Incorrect, dead people cannot own things. Inheritance is a government program that redistributes property to rich children based on what their parents wrote on a piece of paper.

> expropriated from its owners and redistributed to your favored recipients

You are very confused. People do not own what they are taxed. When a person is taxed and the money given to eg a social security recipient, that's not violating ownership, that's enforcing ownership. That money is literally the property of the SS recipient. The law is very clear on this.

> You’re advocating that some men with guns confiscate the income of the working class and give it to people whom you have deemed more deserving.

No, that's what you're advocating, by supporting enforcement of status quo capital income laws.

> Property is temporally and logically antecedent to property law.

It isn't. You can say the statue of liberty is your property - but until that's enforced by somebody (via initiation of force or threats thereof), it is meaningless. Property is the biggest government program there is.

> According to egalitarian principles, you have no such right.

Yes I do - I'm simply enforcing my view of property rights.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by chordalkeyboard on Monday February 15, 2021 @01:35AM (#26139789)
> Incorrect, dead people cannot own things.

That is precisely why they initiate the transfer while they are alive by making a will.

> People do not own what they are taxed. When a person is taxed and the money given to eg a social security recipient, that's not violating ownership, that's enforcing ownership. That money is literally the property of the SS recipient. The law is very clear on this.

Then it sounds like the people aren’t entitled to the income that you want them to. What’s your justification for changing the law on property?

> No, that's what you're [...].

> It isn't [...].

This is tiresome. You’re just contradicting me by insisting on your framing of the circumstances without any justification or addressing my arguments. I get it, you (apparently) don’t like it when someone has more than someone else and you want people to run around continuously taking and giving so that no one ever has much more than anyone else. Hopefully one day you can see that this amounts to people enforcing their view of property on everyone else, which is quite the hierarchy and not the least bit egalitarian. I’m sure you’re ready with a devastating rebuttal (“no u”) but the part where people own what they own and obtain through voluntary exchange, and we prohibit taking people’s stuff and rearranging it without their consent, is the one with the egalitarian social ideals imbedded into the fabric of it. Because people have to agree to things, so essentially the poorest person has the same power as the wealthiest. And obviously you can see that in no way can we make the same egalitarian observations about a system that constantly looks at what you own and decides if its “too much” or not. So this is easy to demonstrate in any kind of good faith discussion but when people just contradict you it never gets beyond the part where I say something and you contradict it, so its usually a waste of time. But I appreciate you interacting with me up to this point and please feel free to engage with the substance of my remarks at any time.

> You can say the statue of liberty is your property - but until that's enforced by somebody (via initiation of force or threats thereof), it is meaningless.

Surely you can see this is not the case. Who would they be enforcing my claim of ownership against, unless someone else also claimed to own the Statue of Liberty? So we haven’t even enforced it yet, but we already have the idea of ownership. You see, there wouldn’t be anything to enforce unless we conceived of an idea of ownership. This is what it means for ownership to precede enforcement.

> I'm simply enforcing my view of property rights.

Good luck.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by djrobstep on Monday February 15, 2021 @05:35AM (#26141333)
> That is precisely why they initiate the transfer while they are alive by making a will.

A will is not a transfer. The law is very clear on this. The government gets the property, then redistributes it to the rich kids via a nanny state program called "inheritance law".

> What’s your justification for changing the law on property?

To increase fairness and justice. What's your justification for not?

> this amounts to people enforcing their view of property on everyone else

Every possible political system does this, except the "grab what you can" world where there is no property at all. So why is yours "voluntary" and mine isn't.

> people own what they own and obtain through voluntary exchange

Property isn't voluntary. It is coercively enforced by the state.

> we prohibit taking people’s stuff

It's literally not their stuff. Tax law is very clear on this.

Me: This stuff rightfully belongs to A, because of egalitarianism. You: This stuff rightfully belongs to B, because it belongs to B.

You're doing a basic circular argument.

This is the thing with libertarianism - it's just pure status quo bias. "This person rightfully owns it because they own it". Nothing to do with freedom, because property is coercive, nothing to do with anti state because property is run by the state - just allegiance to existing property owners.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by chordalkeyboard on Monday February 15, 2021 @01:06PM (#26145280)
> To increase fairness and justice.

It’s not fair for you to decide what other people own. Its injust for you to have that much control over other’s property.

> What's your justification for not?

According to you I am changing the law, same as you. Fairness and justice.

> A will is not a transfer. The law is very clear on this.

Thats not really the case, and I’m unconcerned aboit statutes that were written by oligarchs. A will is a valid transfer.

> Every possible political system does this

You’re not in a position to decide what is and is not possible.

> Property isn't voluntary.

Yes it is.

> It is coercively enforced by the state.

So what if you (incorrectly) believe this to be the case? You can’t imagine a possible political system without coercive enforcement so you’re unable to criticize property on this basis.

> It's literally not their stuff.

In any system of fairness and justice it is.

> Me: This stuff rightfully belongs to A, because of egalitarianism. You: This stuff rightfully belongs to B, because it belongs to B.

You: This stuff rightfully belongs to A, because of egalitarianism. Me: Its not egalitarian for you to dictate what other people rightfully own. That would be a hierarchy with you at the top.

> You're doing a basic circular argument.

No, I’m applying egalitarian principles to your proposed authoritarian restructuring of society.

> This is the thing with libertarianism - it's just pure status quo bias. "This person rightfully owns it because they own it".

Who cares about libertarianism? I’m sharing the joys of egalitarianism with you. Quit trying to dictate the world to the rest of us and embrace the pluralism of egalitarianism.

> Nothing to do with freedom, because property is coercive,

But you like coercion, so to you this isn’t a problem for libertarianism.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by djrobstep on Monday February 15, 2021 @07:27PM (#26149552)
It seems you're just confused on a basic level about how property works - property is coercion. It is literally the initiation of coercive violence on people who enter certain areas or touch certain objects (or threats thereof).

> ...for you to dictate ... that would be a hierarchy with you at the top ... your proposed authoritarian restructuring of society ... Quit trying to dictate the world to the rest of us

Once again, you're confused on a basic level - what makes my proposed system more authoritarian than yours? You want property law enforced with one particular distribution, I want it enforced with another particular distribution. What makes my distribution authoritarian and yours not?

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by chordalkeyboard on Monday February 15, 2021 @08:21PM (#26149872)
> It seems you're just confused on a basic level about how property works - property is coercion.

No, property is a social construct that humans use to denote who has exclusive rights over the disposition of a thing.

> It is literally the initiation of coercive violence on people who enter certain areas or touch certain objects (or threats thereof).

No, property is literally a social construct that humans use to denote who has exclusive rights over the disposition of a thing. Coercion comes afterwards, when people seek to enforce this norm on people who dispute it.

> Once again, you're confused on a basic level - what makes my proposed system more authoritarian than yours?

The hierarchical nature of the relations. Your system has people who have the power to grant and confiscate all the property in society. Since property is the right to determine the disposition of a thing, your system results in the ruling class exerting property rights over everything.

> You want property law enforced with one particular distribution

False. I am not specifying the distribution that is enforced.

> I want it enforced with another particular distribution. What makes my distribution authoritarian and yours not?

You’re choosing the distribution that is enforced, whereas I’m advocating for a distribution that is collectively decided absent coercion. My distribution is the emergent result of repeated interaction under egalitarian social norms. Your distribution is a hierarchical imposition of your preferred distribution.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by djrobstep on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @07:07PM (#26160680)
> No, property is literally a social construct that humans use to denote who has exclusive rights over the disposition of a thing. Coercion comes afterwards, when people seek to enforce this norm on people who dispute it.

Me: "Water is wet" You: "No, water is a type of matter. Wetness comes afterwards, when people touch it."

You are being so pedantic and incoherent that you're "not even wrong".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong

You're wasting both your and my time here if you cannot accept basic, obvious realities like the fact that property requires enforcement.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by chordalkeyboard on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @09:03PM (#26161712)
> Me: "Water is wet" You: "No, water is a type of matter. Wetness comes afterwards, when people touch it."

You: “water is hot because boiling it requires heating it up” Me: “there is water at many temperatures and not all of it is boiling”

> You are being so pedantic and incoherent that you're "not even wrong".

I’m sorry you think its pedantry to examine the literal facts of the issue under discussion. However there is a big difference between the idea of property and the means one chooses to enforce property norms on people who do not subscribe to them, and if you don’t see this (or fail to comprehend the significance) then I can understand why you’re confused.

> You're wasting both your and my time here if you cannot accept basic, obvious realities like the fact that property requires enforcement.

You’re wasting both your and my time here if you’re unable to question things you have taken for granted. If it’s so basic and obvious then demonstrate it, rather than arguing by assertion.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by djrobstep on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @10:37PM (#26162343)
Name a property right that meaningfully exists absent enforcement or threats thereof.

Give a single concrete example.

Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by chordalkeyboard on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @11:32PM (#26162718)
Name a water molecule that can’t be boiled. Give me a single example.
Re:How Poverty Makes Workers Less Productive by imtringued on Monday February 15, 2021 @06:36AM (#26141752)
>"People who don't work full time should starve" is ideology, not some law of physics.

If you don't work then where do you expect your food to come from? I don't work full time and I don't starve so please keep the petty details out.