Does harming them make you uncomfortable because you have an easier time relating to them? Or is it because they are possibly intelligent enough to blame humans for what we've been doing to them, and that makes you uncomfortable?
Either way, intelligence can't be bar to use, because that argument would exclude mentally retarded humans from enjoying human rights as well.
That may sound harsh, but I strongly believe humanity should stop and think on the why for a moment.
Are we doing something because it is right, because the alternative makes us feel bad, or because doing so will make us look better? The first motivation is altruistic, the other is egoistic, and the last egotistic. Do all three align in this case? What about other examples?
I imagine even reflecting on one's own motivations will be uncomfortable to some. It certainly was to me.
Edit: Also I don't believe any of these motivations are inherently bad, but often one is dishonest about which one it really is.
I don’t really feel like debating in this manner, so all I will say is that I have a problem with any animal being mentally, physically, or emotionally abused, neglected, etc. by humans, regardless of intelligence.
I don't think anyone argues that it's okay to inflict pain and suffering on animals. We do inflict pain and suffering on factory-farmed animals, but most people oppose it (at least in a half-assed verbal manner; people say they don't like it but still buy products made in that way, in the same way people say they care about slavery and racism and inequality and exploitation of the third world but don't change their consumer behaviour to avoid supporting those things.)
Anytime they opt for cheap chicken meat instead of at least free range one, any time they buy cheap crappy farmed salmon instead of wild catched one, they say loud and clear they just couldn't care less. People that buy cheap fruits instead of BIO ones. And so on.
Stop acting like mankind is a bunch of saints oppressed by evil corporations, we are often lazy and oblivious when it suits us and can come up with endless stream of excuses for why so.
In fact buying everything bio/organic, free-range, artisanal, etc is sometimes just used for wealth-signalling.
It doesn't work. A few people choosing to go vegetarian or vegan changes nothing. Something like 80% of people who try it revert to meat within a year. It's the same with people choosing to stop driving. If you try it you'll just notice nobody else gives a shit and you're making this huge sacrifice while they continue to have fun. Anything like this can only work if we all do it together.
I argue they do.
> It's the same with people choosing to stop driving.
Depends on where you live. If there is good public transport infrastructure, more people may decide not to drive.
I don't even own a car, and not because of some environmental reasoning, but because it's more of a hassle than it's worth. I fully understand that this is not possible if ones lives in the US however.
So instead of prying people from their cars, the solution is probably to have good alternatives.
However not every indulgence has good alternatives.
And lastly, it's not the same. Your comparison is completely disingenuous. You may need a car. It is a utility. But you don't need meat.
> If you try it you'll just notice nobody else gives a shit and you're making this huge sacrifice while they continue to have fun.
If it is your stated belief that it is wrong to eat certain meat, and you do so anyways, you're just a massive hyprocrite. What others are doing doesn't even factor into it. Justifying your own behavior with what someone else is doing is just whataboutism.
I thought similar things after watching the documentary Blackfish (which is excellent.) Some of the orca behaviour documented in that film - in captivity and in the wild - is remarkably intelligent; some of the most obviously-intelligent behaviour I've seen from any non-human animal.
Ants are very intelligent. Is it okay to destroy their societies just because they don't look pretty and we can't emphasize with arthropods?
You seem to be advocating that torture of the few could help the many, but that has not been the case. The southern resident orcas, those that primarily seeded entertainment orcas in the U.S., are potentially nearing extinction.
https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/environment/the-or...
http://www.orcanetwork.org/Main/index.php?categories_file=Lo...
https://www.king5.com/mobile/article/news/local/orca-capture...
Orcas as a whole (the species not specific pods) aren’t marked as endangered and number in the tens of thousands. The SRKs are endangered and that’s terrible but I would say the overall orca species and even other marine life benefit from greater awareness and consideration from people having been able to appreciate them directly in places like SeaWorld.
I recall reading that they would seal out humans
I also have a suspicion that orca intelligence possibly matches that of humans.