Couldn't agree more. I've made a deliberate effort to not buy into the craze with swombat.com. Anything that can't be restyled as a text link which blends into the no-graphics minimalist style of the site just ain't gonna happen.
One small concession I've made is that I show the reddit upvote widget for people who have come directly via Reddit. Like that's helped me. ;-)
What really impressed me about the Google implementation is that it collects the information about all the buttons on the page, and then fires off a single call to retrieve all information necessary to build them out (the /rpc call that seems to happen after just about everything else). That happens later in the page lifecycle, so the +1 button seems to take a bit longer to come up, but because it's all firing off at once it seems to result in a smoother overall page load experience. While I don't have a good unit test in front of me, I've often felt like pages stall out on Facebook widgets, and as far as I can tell, that's not really a concern with +1. The actual iframe loads are quite quick, the iframes are small, and are obviously built to render ASAP. The heavy lifting occurs much later. The Facebook widgets have seemed to be to be built with the assumption that there will ever only be one per page (heavy iframe document, multiple external scripts that will have to load in serial), resulting in pretty terrible bloat when you had multiples.
That said, in all fairness, in some quick tests tonight, the Facebook widgets seem to be far better-behaved than they were a few months ago, so it may be that my complaint is no longer relevant.
[1] http://pagespeed.googlelabs.com/#url=http_3A_2F_2Fdl.dropbox...
Edit: Not really a complaint, but an observation - the like.php widget has an XHTML 1.0 doctype, which requires closing tags for non-empty elements. An HTML4 or HTML5 doctype would make that valid, though.
smart loading is not about showing first, especially in the context of widgets i.e. not the main content of the site.
I don't quite understand how you can do a like button "better". If by that you mean the number of current users, I disagree that Google should stop competing just because there are more people on FB.
If I understood the article correctly, that isn't true. According to Google, your friends/contacts will see your +1s in their search results, meaning they'll have an additional hint at choosing the best result for them.
Google has one thing to offer its competitors don't - they can use the +1 button as a signal for their search algorithms.
As good as sharing a site on Facebook/Twitter is, it causes only a "momentary" increase in traffic. On the other hand, if the +1 button actually helps a site improve its rankings in Google, it could cause a sustained increase in traffic, something most websites will look very kindly on.
On the other hand, the fact that adding a +1 will cause much less of a single, highly visible high-impact traffic spike will mean its effects are harder to feel, which might make people consider it less important.
All in all, the war over widgets is just beginning.
Can anyone clue me in?
I've been pretty happy with the improvement caused by http://www.disconnect.me/, especially on my relatively high-latency WiMax connection at home. It still lets you load e.g. facebook.com, but only when you actually go there on purpose, not as a widget in another page.
Strongly agree in that respect. Using the browser on my (android) phone has become increasingly unpleasant in recent months, because the address bar flashes up with every little data packet that comes in. Don't want to single out any particular firm or group of firms, but the signal:noise ratio seems to be in freefall lately.
I don't read techcrunch anymore because pageloads on my netbook have hit 20 seconds before I can scroll the page. Hacker news IIRC is still less than 250ms. Facebook is about 2 seconds till usability, but is still loading shit in the background, which hits it on par with MSN and Yahoo.
I don't get why a tech site like techcrunch would think it's acceptable to have such an absurdly long load time. Facebook lost me when page loads for every page took too long and they were only seconds. 1/3 of a minute back when I was learning to make my own websites was considered death, you wouldn't expect anyone to sit through the load.
It's this sheepish behavior of bloggers that lowers the quality of their content as well. Just gathering random people's friends isn't the smartest strategy to monetize content. Good quality content+seamless payments should replace this model.
This has happened before, first it was the syndication format craze with icons for RSS, RSS 2.0, atom, xml, etc. Then it was the aggregator craze (Digg, Reddit, StumpleUpon, etc) and now it's the social craze (Facebook, Twitter, etc).
There's a clear need for sharing what you like, from the perspective of the user and the publisher. I've put these buttons into my design, but I'd rather see the browsers' favorites revamped into a searchable database that allows easy sharing and get rid of this madness.