Your first point is that this basic concept has been so successful that governments have felt the need to regulate it to combat its adverse effects, which is a risk Airbnb is pretty well aware of. In fact, all of the adverse effects you list are true of hotels as well, except for "shorting cities on their hotel taxes". If municipalities eventually decide to force Airbnb to charge hotel taxes, that would diminish their appeal but probably not destroy the business. Hugely successful companies like Amazon are facing similar problems.
Your second point is essentially that the idea of providing an online marketplace to remove inefficiencies of brokerages is not a new one, and therefore Airbnb should not be "overly" congratulated. But we're not congratulating Airbnb for the novelty of the idea, but for building a business which is apparently worth a billion dollars. Many hugely successful startups have ideas which might be obvious.
As for your third point, there might be something legitimate there. I don't know anything about VRBO vs. AirBNB in terms of traction and customer satisfaction, but it appears from one of your other replies that your only evidence is anecdotal. My personal anecdotal evidence is that everyone I know has been very happy with using AirBNB.
Which is to say, Airbnb says you have to have do due diligence yourself (which some people won't do, and will have bad experiences), whereas VRBO filters for you, but you will end up paying more on average.
That's to say, if asking which business model is better, I think you have to go 100% with Airbnb. Giving users more power makes them like you better in the long run, and even if there are more flakes, there will also be 10x more enthusiasts (potentially even celebrities which become investors/advisers). Customer enthusiasm isn't something you can immediately capture via looking at reviews, but I think the market is closer to the truth in its valuation then you are in your "call out."
As you point out, there are negative consequences to this. These are serious, and I don't want to dispute any of them. But I do want to point out a positive consequence.
Recently I needed to stay for two weeks in Princeton, New Jersey for a mathematics conference. I learned to my horror that the only hotel within walking distance of the university is uber-fancy, and costs like $200 a night. If it wasn't for services like AirBNB (I used Craigslist, but would use AirBNB now), I would have had to pay $2800 for accomodation, or rent a car which I would have otherwise had no use for. (Or perhaps there are other options of which I am ignorant.)
Pardon my cynicism, but this is what I believe the people living in Princeton want. They enjoy the small town ambiance, even if it is vaguely faked, and presumably through their city council they push strong zoning regulations which make it impossible to build hotels, and therefore impractical to visit on business.
(N.B. None of this is even remotely unique to Princeton, but that is the one experience I have personally had which sticks out.)
There is a flip side to this (if I bought a $500K house perhaps I would want strict zoning too), but I still hate it. With AirBNB, rentals cost what the market will bear. AirBNB is bringing good old-fashioned free market capitalism where, IMHO, it belongs. I hope they are a wild success.
I know it's an unusual situation, but it makes me wonder if it's really "all downside" so to speak. (And I had a goal of being a city planner at one time, so I am plenty familiar with the fact that out-of-town owners and the like can be very detrimental to a community.)
For example in my nearest city (Cambridge, UK, which is both highly techie and touristy), Airbnb returns 38 results, VRBO 0. I tried various US and European cities and got a common pattern.
http://www.fastcodesign.com/1663349/infographic-of-the-day-a...
I believe a more accurate way to phrase this is that the short-term rental market provides a more accurate valuation of the property.
High prices are complaint only for the buyer; the seller will be glad that his condo is now valued correctly.
Anecdotally there's a significant problem in the UK with some rural regions becoming significantly hotels for the wealthy. People like them so buy properties as second homes, maybe to live in a 5-10 days a month at maximum and sometimes far less.
The work available locally can't support the prices such customers are willing and able to pay, so the community becomes significantly weighted towards the old (who bought before the prices rose) and the absentee second home owner. This starts reducing the demand for local services (shops, schools, public transport) through a lower active population which makes the community less and less viable for full time living and....
'True markets' may optimise for supply and demand but they don't always for maximum societal good.
The comment has some very compelling points to consider. None of us, and nothing we create is so beyond constructive criticism that intelligent contrary opinions can be rejected outright.
You may have had a tough day, but god help us all if we start believing our own bullshit 24/7.
Seriously, they don't deserve all this hype and buzz.
1. They haven't build a billion dollar business, they are only valued at that. There's a bid difference.
2. Ordinary homeowners have and had many other options to rent their properties - Short term rental brokers and VRBO are just two of them. Craigslist in another one. Airbnb alone cannot take that as their success.
3. Perhaps they have provided better accommodations than their competitors. Do you have anything to support that?
4. The internet itself is destabilizing the entrenched markets.
5. And here's the reason I responded, because I am most interested in the work that they are doing to address the social and local government issues. Please provide something to support that. Google doesn't have anything..
http://www.google.com/search?q=airbnb+address+local+issues&#...
Nor does Airbnb themselves
This one is a bit unfair, though I don't know about the rest. "The Internet (TM)" doesn't just destabilize industries in an abstract sense, it destabilizes them by a set of real companies that take market share from entrenched competition, and by allowing that entrenched competition to sometimes improve themselves in the new market (which doesn't happen as often as you'd think). It's not "The Internet (TM)" that gets credit, it's those companies.
http://www.google.com/trends?q=airbnb%2C+vrbo&ctab=0&...
Google trends airbnb v. vbro.
See previous post on the topic.
http://apps.ycombinator.com/item?id=2333475
See charlie4real comments.
Finally, all my friends who rent space in their residences do so with VRBO. Across the board they say that after using and comparing both services, VRBO is a superior service than Airbnb for those wanting to have short term rentals in their house. So while this may not be representative, it sure seems informative.
I support AirBnB 100% however I have not had good experiences with it in Los Angeles so far. Lots of spammers, strange anonymous people emailing me trying to either low-ball my offer or asking if they could throw a party or something at my spot. No thanks.
So, to what do I think Airbnb's success comes from? I think it's Airbnb's marketing / hype / buzz that has been carefully choreographed to maximize their valuation. And to this, I congratulate Airbnb on their latest success, and to a dance well done.
Firstly, the idea of short term residential rentals is not new. Long before Airbnb major cities, Paris, London, New York, and Toronto were dealing with the issues and the problems of short term / nightly residential rentals. In fact the latest condo boom in Toronto has been ascribed to international investors buying condos explicitly for this quasi-hotel rental market. Many cities have been passing local laws trying to prohibit this type of rental use for residences because they carry a whole host of problems. Some of those include -- emptying the downtown core of residences, artificially increasing housing costs for residents, removing the stability and security that comes from having permanent and community-invested residents, shorting cities on their hotel taxes, providing unlicensed locations for short term illicit activities, etc. So by increasing the market in these short term rentals, the communities will also feel the increase in the unfortunate side effects of these short term rental impacts. These are long term market problems that Airbnb will have to address.
Secondly, it's not a new idea because in the recent past, these rentals were managed by hotel brokers. So in that respect, Airbnb major idea is simply to replace the traditional broker that used to handle the short term rentals with a direct owner to renter model. Across the internet we see great success in online services removing brokerage inefficiencies to various markets, and for this they should be congratulated, but not overly so.
And finally, about their execution. Airbnb is not the market leader. In fact --http://www.vrbo.com/ is. This is what amazes me the most. Vrbo (I have no professional relationship or otherwise) regularly get better reviews in online discussion boards comparing the two services. Their price structure is much more competitive, their review structure is much more robust, in fact aside from Airbnb's more sophisticated visual design, Vrbo leads in many segment of this space.
So, to what do I think Airbnb's success comes from? I think it's Airbnb's marketing / hype / buzz that has been carefully choreographed to maximize their valuation. And to this, I congratulate Airbnb on their latest success, and to a dance well done.