This is absolutely not the case. Google’s biggest ad clients achieve pretty incredible ROI (called ROAS) on each dollar they spend. And they track these obsessively—I supported a large travel client that had a small (but highly skilled) engineering team dedicated exclusively to their SEM bidding and monitoring systems.
The reason digital advertising is so valuable is pretty exclusively related to attribution and tracking. If companies weren’t sure they could make so much money with their spend, their budgets would absolutely drop.
Example: I type “housing insurance” into Google and the “organic” results are dominated by the mega insurance companies.
Without targeted advertising, the ads are also dominated by mega insurance companies because they have the biggest advertising budgets.
With targeted advertising, I can see an ad from a provider specific to my location that I didn’t know existed who offers way better rates because of the different risk pool.
The same applies for thousands of other products/services that are localized.
Similarly, the ads for someone interested in DIY vs someone who is happy to pay for skilled labor are drastically different when you search “drywall repair”.
You're talking about geo targeting here, which imo should still be possible. That's an in-the-moment targeting akin to an advertiser choosing to show their ad on a local news site. This doesn't require extensive tracking and profiling of users.
Google doesn't need to "Track and target" me personally to know that a web request I make comes from a specific location. Knowing I bought cycling shorts last week isn't going to increase the relevance of that search. Likewise, the reverse is true.
FWIW, have you tried searching for something like Drywall repair? Google's results for that type of search are almost identical to what you get on DDG, you just have to scroll past a page of Google garbage first.
Also... it's not too tremendously difficult to type "Drywall repair in Hoboken NY", that's what I do by default regardless.
As Ted, I don’t want my ads wasted on people that want to repair things themselves. As a customer who doesn’t care how it gets fixed, I don’t want an ad for Home Depot.
While Ted might find it convenient to target people based on whether they are wealthy homeowners who hire contractors or DIY guys, I have no interest in sharing that information with Google (or Facebook). It's neat for Ted, not so neat for me.
Other things which might result in "better" advertising which I don't like:
- Companies scanning my license plate while I'm at Home Depot.
- Someone camping the county building permits office with a video camera and facial recognition software.
- The phone company forwarding my phone records to advertisers.
All of these are similarly invasive to Google & Facebook's tracking and equally disgusting.This is all particularly true since just buying the Adword for "Drywall Repair" in my area, would likely yield the exact same results without tracking.
'Google garbage', aka Google Maps listings (which DDG also has above their search results, although it uses Apple Maps).
Saving that DIY enthusiast a single modification of their google search is not worth narrowing their entire experience of the web for, or worth giving up their privacy for.
And to OP’s original point. If your business relies on invading the privacy of others, your business should not exist
Sure, but let’s be clear that it is a trade off. If you’ve ever seen non-techies Google things, they don’t provide the contextual clues that we instinctively know to include. The majority of the population just types in “drywall repair” and expects the computer to know what they “obviously mean”.
When you are looking for housing insurance and Facebook shows you divorce attorneys, because they know you’re gonna need one pretty soon, that is a spend that would be affected.
This is how small businesses figure out their advertising budget. Where are our customers coming from, or more importantly, where are they not coming from, so we know where to spend or not spend our limited resources?
But I’m not surprised this isn’t pointed out more often. The hardcore privacy zealots really blow up when you try to explain that it’s mostly innocuous.
Apologies for the crude analogy, but if I install a camera in your bathroom and say, "okay, technically I could watch you poop, but the only reason I'm actually doing this is to figure out when you're out of toilet paper", that explanation won't leave you satisfied.
Similarly, if someone is tracking me across the web and trying to link my identity across multiple sites/devices, I don't really care whether or not they're worried about attribution. The concerns about attribution are secondary to the fact that they're still watching everything I do online.
Also, please remember that this conversation is very specifically about Facebook's access to the Apple IDFA, not about general web tracking or other data vacuuming issues. The fact that these two separate issues get conflated is part of the problem.
Which is used to uniquely identify me across apps, a totally equivalent level of tracking as identifying me across websites. It is the same result, just on a different platform.
And all of this data gets combined and utilized with the "other data vacuuming issues" you're talking about. You can't treat those like isolated issues, the unique identifiers across websites/apps enable the data vacuuming.
You're arguing that these identifiers aren't primarily being used to build profiles, that they're mostly innocuous, and then you're saying that the fact that profiles are being built and data vacuuming is happening is a separate issue that's not relevant to the current conversation? No, the data vacuuming wouldn't be possible to nearly the same degree without persistent identifiers. That makes it relevant.
> is not comparable to a quasi-anonymous unique value traveling from my computer to another.
You're arguing about a matter of degree. The point I'm making is that violating my privacy doesn't become automatically OK just because the advertising industry promises me they won't look at the extra data they're getting. And I think the reasoning behind why it's not OK is the same in both scenarios -- because in both scenarios, it's not reasonable to trust the person gathering that data to keep it secure or to never misuse it.
People bring up "quasi-anonymous" as if it's some kind of perfect defense that puts these identifiers into a separate category of information, but it's not. If it was actually anonymous, you wouldn't need to put the "quasi" in front of it. But if it makes you feel better, I'll put a camera in your bathroom and then disassociate the video stream from your home address or name, and then I'll blur your face with an AI. Then the video stream will be quasi-anonymous too. I promise I won't ever try to link it to a real identity, you can trust me.
The point is, it is a violation of my privacy to track every website I visit and every app I use. The reason why a company is doing that doesn't matter.
It's not a "Quasi-anonymous" token the moment it's tied to your Facebook account... which is exactly 100% the point here. Facebook wants to be able to tie your off Facebook activity to your Facebook account.
Also, there are some incredibly private things which happen on people's phones. If I went to the courthouse or a DUI lawyer in town, I don't want Facebook to know this. If I have to install an app due to parole restrictions, this shouldn't be a thing Facebook finds out about.
There are piles of other private activities which people keep in the apps they use.
The intent is almost always to convince people to purchase something where they otherwise wouldn't purchase it - by a mix of catching them in a vulnerable moment, and brainwashing them with repeated exposure over time. It's malicious.
And that's better?
As a side point, I don't see why attribution tracking requires any form of cross-site tracking or fingerprinting. It seems like it would be pretty trivial to implement this without all the privacy issues (i.e. just direct the ad to domain.com/ad123 and track the user on-site from there).
[0] Before someone comes in to correct me, I know I'm handwaving here. The point stands.
It seems very relevant to me. The larger privacy problems wouldn't be quite as bad if there was no way to tell what device an app was running on or who was using it. That seems like it would limit data collection in a pretty significant way.
You don't seem to understand what the implications of the IDFA are. Facebook uses the IDFA to tie your activities together. It is one of the fundamental ways they collect all this data.
This is why they are fighting so hard to maintain it.
Way to lose all credibility.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/augustinefou/2021/01/02/when-bi...
Matthew Inman posted about this https://twitter.com/Oatmeal/status/923250055540219904
As an aside, this also reflects on the honesty of their ad campaign about supporting small business. If they really cared about small business they wouldn't make them pay to reach the audience they created on their platform.
Anyway paying FB's mafia style extortion probably isn't the solution.
It's their job to figure out how to best advertise, not mine to hand it to them on a silver platter at my own expense. This is my data, information about me, which they are stealing without my knowledge and profiting from. If someone asked me if they could snoop around in my personal affairs for money, the price would be a hell of a lot higher than the big fat zero I get in return here.
Whatever Google or Facebooks' advertising ROI is, does not make it ethical or interesting to me.
Credit cards get the benefit of knowing where I shop, but at least I know when and how they are getting that information. Likewise, cellular service. It's a price we pay for ubiquitous access to information. But I would cut them bot off as well if there were some way I could.
It's parasitic and it's zero benefit to me.
Or, flipping it: if some advertisers are extremely effective, that pushes up the price for the ones that aren't.
Yet overall advertising spend is relatively flat. It's just shifted from one media to another.
Advertising will not collapse. Companies budgets for advertising is fairly flat as a percentage of revenue. Who get advertising dollars will shift, but even there, not too much.
Nor will we see more advertising. Sites have already bloated sites beyond the capacity of what most people will accept.
What will likely happen is more special interest content will continue to slip behind paywalls... much as it was in magazines and specialist journals you paid for prior to the web.
What could be the end result? I give the algorithms my bank account and they are responsible for restocking my fridge, refilling prescriptions to purchasing books and investing in my stocks?
Some aspiring product manager (of course another algorithm in training) is furiously jotting down all of the above...
(Note I said 100 units, not 100 units over time - since even now, people tend to get paid monthly, and subscriptions tend to bill monthly, it's only natural to factor out time from the equation...)
I know you’re painting a picture of a dystopian future, but isn’t this basically how health insurance works in the USA today?
I’m not sure about that. A lot of advertising is about appearances and superficial things. Example. Do we need cars in the US to get from place to place (NYC, etc excepted) Yes! Does it have to have bells and whistles? No. Can an entry level car do the job in the great majority of cases? Does it have to be a “luxury” brand? Or an upscale model?
Spending would go down. Good, bad? That’s another discussion.
Much of the advertising industry isn't about getting you to choose Company A's product rather than Company B's, or to choose the deluxe version rather than the entry-level one; it's about getting you to buy things you would never even have considered otherwise, and certainly have no "need" for.
I would like to know how this conclusion was reached. By that logic, the advertising industry would not really need individual targeting at all
You're right, they don't. But the point is not to argue that ad relevancy itself is bad. In a vacuum, improved ad relevancy is good! However, the improved relevancy of individually-targeted advertisements is not offset by the social detriment of user tracking.
To use an example, on a Facebook group for gamers, it would be fine and dandy for Facebook to establish a market where PC hardware and video game companies bid to show ads to users browsing the group page. Note that this doesn't have to involve advertisers receiving any identifiable data about who the ad was shown to, and nor does it have to involve Facebook tracking your behavior online in order to show ads based on other sites you've visited, e.g. gaming communities on Reddit. The targeting is as simple as "show the game ads to the people in the game group"; it's extremely coarse demographic-based targeting that doesn't require any sort of persistent user profiling. It's no more of a privacy issue than back in the old-timey days when a company would buy an ad in an enthusiast magazine.
Spot on.
How good or relevant adverts doesn't matter if the way the information is collected is by unethical. If you went to a store and while you were shopping, an employee attached a tracking device to your car, it would clearly be a violation of your rights and you'd be rightly pissed. The equivalent of this happens all the time with software on your phone.
Yet here we have people defending Facebook and Google for trying to protect their spy-monopoly.
Agreed, this is where the incentives of the users are misaligned with the incentives of the ad tracking companies. But users don't have a choice, hence individual ad tracking.
That model favors small publishers (as niche advertisers flock to niche publications) and disadvantages large generic publishers (social networks, email clients, portals).
I agree. Advertisers would have to go back to contextual targeting, identifying websites that are likely to appeal the target audience, rather than simply buying the audience programmatically on Google's ad network
I disagree. Currently, targeted advertising is able to hold a premium over non-targeted advertising. The more targeted, the higher the premium. Facebook wants to keep up in the arms race with Google (and others) in how targeted it can be.
This premise seems wrong to me. It assumes that advertising is always a net positive, regardless of how targeted it is.
As someone who runs a company that built apps and have spent ZERO on advertising and PR, I can tell you that is usually not the case.
In fact, the biggest component of user acquisition cost is the untargeted advertising. Much better to reduce that cost to zero by increasing the viral k-factor and user retention. Those two metrics matter way more than advertising. If you can reduce the ad spend per user, or per customer, you are BETTER off, not worse.
For example, Google adwords nor any other advert network offers NO WAY of targeting MacOS, only iOS and Android, so we couldn’t make any money advertising our Calendars for Mac app.
And trust me we experimented with all kinds of monetization in that app:
https://www.bbc.com/news/amp/technology-43386918
Original article was im ArsTechnica: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/03/there...
https://www.google.com/search?q=qbix+mining&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-...
Consider what would happen if you outlawed individual-targeted advertising. Ad relevancy falls overall. What then?
Would ad companies like Google make less money? Not really. Overall advertising budgets are not dominated by the effectiveness of advertising, but by adversarial spending by their competitors. Companies have to spend money on ads because the competition is spending money on ads. It doesn't matter how absolutely effective the campaign is, as long as it's relatively more effective than your rival's.
Would consumers spend less money? No, a consumer has a budget that is independent of the relevancy of the ads they see.
The advertising industry thrived for a long time in the absence of individual user tracking. It could do so again.