News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by kibwen on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:21PM (#25992469)
Companies obsess about these metrics because they don't want their ROI to be less than their competitors', because that would put them at a competitive disadvantage. It's not in doubt that individual-targeted advertising is more effective than than the alternatives; by eliminating user tracking you would be decreasing ROI across the board, but that's fine because, again, all that you're fighting for is a higher ROI than your competitors. And to reiterate, it's not like consumer dollars are just vanishing into the ether; every dollar a consumer makes either gets spent or saved, and regardless of the ROI of a specific ad campaign they've still got to buy dish soap or diapers or what have you. Just because advertising ROI drops does not mean that the company revenue/profit will drop; if it did, that probably means another company has better ROI (and if they can do so, and as long as they're not tracking users, then good for them!).
Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by kortilla on Monday February 01, 2021 @02:42PM (#25992748)
This model is based on the assumption that ads are for things the consumers already know about. This is not correct.

Example: I type “housing insurance” into Google and the “organic” results are dominated by the mega insurance companies.

Without targeted advertising, the ads are also dominated by mega insurance companies because they have the biggest advertising budgets.

With targeted advertising, I can see an ad from a provider specific to my location that I didn’t know existed who offers way better rates because of the different risk pool.

The same applies for thousands of other products/services that are localized.

Similarly, the ads for someone interested in DIY vs someone who is happy to pay for skilled labor are drastically different when you search “drywall repair”.

Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by somedude895 on Monday February 01, 2021 @03:07PM (#25993076)
> Without targeted advertising, the ads are also dominated by mega insurance companies because they have the biggest advertising budgets. > With targeted advertising, I can see an ad from a provider specific to my location that I didn’t know existed who offers way better rates because of the different risk pool. The same applies for thousands of other products/services that are localized.

You're talking about geo targeting here, which imo should still be possible. That's an in-the-moment targeting akin to an advertiser choosing to show their ad on a local news site. This doesn't require extensive tracking and profiling of users.

Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by kortilla on Monday February 01, 2021 @11:41PM (#25997512)
Fair enough, it’s not clear what level of profiling we’re eliminating. That’s why I also gave the example of a DIY profiled customer vs a “pays for handymen” profiled customer.
Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by ogre_codes on Monday February 01, 2021 @06:29PM (#25995577)
> Similarly, the ads for someone interested in DIY vs someone who is happy to pay for skilled labor are drastically different when you search “drywall repair”.

Google doesn't need to "Track and target" me personally to know that a web request I make comes from a specific location. Knowing I bought cycling shorts last week isn't going to increase the relevance of that search. Likewise, the reverse is true.

FWIW, have you tried searching for something like Drywall repair? Google's results for that type of search are almost identical to what you get on DDG, you just have to scroll past a page of Google garbage first.

Also... it's not too tremendously difficult to type "Drywall repair in Hoboken NY", that's what I do by default regardless.

Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by kortilla on Monday February 01, 2021 @11:43PM (#25997523)
You didn’t read my drywall example close enough. It’s not location specific, it’s specific to the type of customer. Should we be advertising a hardware store or should we be advertising “Teds drywall repair service”?

As Ted, I don’t want my ads wasted on people that want to repair things themselves. As a customer who doesn’t care how it gets fixed, I don’t want an ad for Home Depot.

Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by ogre_codes on Tuesday February 02, 2021 @12:27AM (#25997711)
I find it unlikely Google presents drastically different results (or adverts) for someone who is interested in DIY versus someone who might be looking for a contractor. Mostly because it's a terrible thing for Google to try and guess.

While Ted might find it convenient to target people based on whether they are wealthy homeowners who hire contractors or DIY guys, I have no interest in sharing that information with Google (or Facebook). It's neat for Ted, not so neat for me.

Other things which might result in "better" advertising which I don't like:

  - Companies scanning my license plate while I'm at Home Depot.
  - Someone camping the county building permits office with a video camera and facial recognition software.
  - The phone company forwarding my phone records to advertisers.
All of these are similarly invasive to Google & Facebook's tracking and equally disgusting.

This is all particularly true since just buying the Adword for "Drywall Repair" in my area, would likely yield the exact same results without tracking.

Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by judge2020 on Monday February 01, 2021 @09:49PM (#25996933)
> you just have to scroll past a page of Google garbage first.

'Google garbage', aka Google Maps listings (which DDG also has above their search results, although it uses Apple Maps).

Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by mrcartmenez on Monday February 01, 2021 @06:26PM (#25995555)
There’s a big difference between localisation of ads (which the industry has always achieved) and targeted ads that know you are interested in DIY vs hiring a contractor.

Saving that DIY enthusiast a single modification of their google search is not worth narrowing their entire experience of the web for, or worth giving up their privacy for.

And to OP’s original point. If your business relies on invading the privacy of others, your business should not exist

Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by kortilla on Monday February 01, 2021 @11:47PM (#25997536)
> Saving that DIY enthusiast a single modification of their google search is not worth narrowing their entire experience of the web for, or worth giving up their privacy for.

Sure, but let’s be clear that it is a trade off. If you’ve ever seen non-techies Google things, they don’t provide the contextual clues that we instinctively know to include. The majority of the population just types in “drywall repair” and expects the computer to know what they “obviously mean”.

Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by biztos on Monday February 01, 2021 @04:00PM (#25993856)
I don’t think these examples require individual targeting at all, but I agree with your point.

When you are looking for housing insurance and Facebook shows you divorce attorneys, because they know you’re gonna need one pretty soon, that is a spend that would be affected.

Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by olex on Monday February 01, 2021 @03:10PM (#25993132)
On both examples, the user can trivially reach the desired search outcome by manually adding their location or "diy"/"for hire" to the search query, without the search engine needing to know a single thing about them.
Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by kortilla on Monday February 01, 2021 @11:48PM (#25997541)
Agree, but the users don’t know to include that. And Google became dominant because they learned how to attach that context automatically.
Re:Facebook testing notification to users about Apple privac... by dillondoyle on Monday February 01, 2021 @06:51PM (#25995777)
It would get rid of a lot of verticals that only run with positive ROAS. Ecommerce, political donations, etc. We won't spend on direct to donate ads unless the ROI is strong and I know that is not possible without FB and their data.