Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition
by nickb on Monday July 28, 2008 @09:55PM
(#259913)
If it's a minor blip, how do you propose they now fix the problem? I see it is as so systemic and flawed that the only solution is to scrap it altogether.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition
by Harj on Monday July 28, 2008 @10:28PM
(#259935)
so a system that has worked fine for over a decade should be completely scrapped because of one unprecedented event?
Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition
by nickb on Tuesday July 29, 2008 @02:17AM
(#260171)
So how do you fix these outliers? Dark Knight is still #1 and The Godfather is still #3.
Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition
by breck on Thursday July 31, 2008 @01:08PM
(#263187)
My point is you don't. The system is still working fine. If Godfather sank to #300, then there would be something to fix. Even with all of the shenanigans of Dark Knight fans, the result on Godfather's rankings is a minuscule blip that could be explained by chance and should have no effect on whether someone thinks Godfather is a movie worth watching.