News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition by breck on Monday July 28, 2008 @08:06PM (#259835)
This mob mentality, brought on by a significant event (in this case, the release of The Dark Knight), causes a total breakdown in a system that is otherwise fairly accurate, useful, and trustworthy.

I wouldn't call this a "total breakdown in the system". I would call it a minor blip. I mean, ultimately the system recommends what movies to watch. If someone isn't going to watch the Godfather now that it's ranked #3 instead of #1, then the person is flawed, not the system.

Otherwise, this was an interesting post. I have been astonished that TDK is #1. Didn't realize people were also downvoting other movies to keep it there.

Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition by william42 on Monday July 28, 2008 @08:40PM (#259858)
The flaw in the system isn't that The Godfather was bumped down. The flaw is that people are rating the Godfather down to the point at which it changed its ranking with respect to other movies.

And you're right, it's not a major flaw for a movie ranking system. But let's suppose something similar to the IMDB system(which would be an approval/range voting system) is used in an election, and the first place gets President, the second choice getting Veep. With an election, you don't have real-time rankings like IMDB, but you have something similar--polls. And that's even worse, since there's a few points of inaccuracy. Strategically worded polls could change the results of an election.

Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition by unalone on Tuesday July 29, 2008 @12:17AM (#260043)
But that change is a blip in and of itself. Godfather has been bumped down before. Happened with Lord of the Rings. It climbs back up after the initial wave.
Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition by brokenladder on Thursday July 31, 2008 @01:28AM (#262717)
Score Voting (aka Range Votiing) and Approval Voting are actually the best voting methods, especially when you take strategic voting into account. http://rangevoting.org/StratHonMix.html

In this case, even if the election result changed, you'd still get a candidate who was rated relatively well by the average voter, so the results would not be that much worse. Now consider that other voting methods react much worse to strategic voters, _and_ that score voting is as good with a great number of strategic voters as other systems are with 100% honest voters, and this whole argument falls flat.

Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition by nickb on Monday July 28, 2008 @09:55PM (#259913)
If it's a minor blip, how do you propose they now fix the problem? I see it is as so systemic and flawed that the only solution is to scrap it altogether.
Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition by Harj on Monday July 28, 2008 @10:28PM (#259935)
so a system that has worked fine for over a decade should be completely scrapped because of one unprecedented event?
Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition by nickb on Tuesday July 29, 2008 @02:17AM (#260171)
So how do you fix these outliers? Dark Knight is still #1 and The Godfather is still #3.
Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition by breck on Thursday July 31, 2008 @01:08PM (#263187)
My point is you don't. The system is still working fine. If Godfather sank to #300, then there would be something to fix. Even with all of the shenanigans of Dark Knight fans, the result on Godfather's rankings is a minuscule blip that could be explained by chance and should have no effect on whether someone thinks Godfather is a movie worth watching.
Re:When the 'Wisdom of Crowds' turns on itself: IMDB Edition by Harkins on Tuesday July 29, 2008 @02:13PM (#260879)
This also happened when Wall-E came out.

In any case: yes, bugs should be fixed.