News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by stonecraftwolf on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:39AM (#25958338)
This fails spectacularly when the point of disagreement is one’s humanity, for example. I’m a lot less active here than I would be otherwise, and I know that’s the case for a lot of others who belong to groups that HN considers fair game. I largely consider it a hostile place to me and people like me, and because of this moderation attitude, it’s first mover dominance in certain areas is actively harmful. And no, I’m not going to expose myself by revealing by what aspects of my identity are regularly dehumanized on HN.

Social cooling is just as much a phenomena on HN. By its very nature, it’s invisible unless it affects you directly. HN loses plenty of voices it’s never aware of.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by CivBase on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:30AM (#25959068)
I have never seen anyone on HN questioning another person's humanity. That's pretty messed up if it has happened.

I understand why you wouldn't want to provide any additional details, but it's also hard to take your claims at face value given my own experience. Perhaps you could share examples which do not compromise your own identity?

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by minikites on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:18PM (#25965990)
>I have never seen anyone on HN questioning another person's humanity.

It's subtle and masked by the "politeness", that's the trick.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by belval on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:32PM (#25966084)
Not the OP you were responding too, but a lot of the threads on immigration will have those types of personal attacks I don't have a specific one but they usually devolves in people against immigration being called sociopaths.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by walkedaway on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:12PM (#25970800)
Take a simple browse through a thread about Trump or his supporters for one example. There are many, many other examples as well.
[dead]
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by Jordrok on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:36PM (#25965752)
Of course, downvotes and disagreement are hardly an attack on a person's humanity.

After all, what's more human than having stupid opinions?

[dead]
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by srean on Saturday January 30, 2021 @04:51AM (#25967754)
One can lead a horse to the water but not make it drink it. After many a 'leading' it can become tiresome and a times pointless to have a discussion where the participants have strongly held incompatible beliefs.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by briefcomment on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:12AM (#25968450)
So then it makes sense to disappear comments? Downvoting wouldn’t be bad if comments remained, but only a few downvotes net will bury a comment point. Make it 50 downvoted net at least.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by CivBase on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:07AM (#25969641)
Downvotes are not moderation, a censorship speech, or a statement anout the user's humanity. Votes are just a measure of popularity within a community.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by briefcomment on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:50AM (#25969999)
If downvotes grey out and eventually disappear comments, they are moderation.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by dang on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:31PM (#25974864)
Anyone can click on the timestamp link of a downvoted comment and get taken to a page where the text is fully readable. Yes it's an extra hop, but that's a small price to pay for an immune system.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by briefcomment on Saturday January 30, 2021 @09:01PM (#25975046)
I don't know. Seeing a greyed out post undeniably biases me against it, regardless of what the content actually is. It takes mental effort to give it fair consideration.

Not sure if you've done this analysis yet, but I wouldn't be surprised if downvoted posts are mostly unpopular opinions, and not necessarily incorrect facts or egregiously bad takes.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by dang on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:51AM (#25976704)
That's far from the case.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by briefcomment on Sunday January 31, 2021 @07:35AM (#25978342)
Ah ok. Any reason not to start greying comments out at a lower threshold of net downvotes?
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by dang on Sunday January 31, 2021 @03:26PM (#25982242)
I'm not sure I understand, but it seems like you mean greying out fewer comments, i.e. restricting it only to those which are more heavily downvoted? Unless we added some other visual indicator, that would be the same as ignoring the first 1 or more downvotes. I'm not sure that's a good idea because there's a lot of signal in comments being at 0 points, -1, etc., given that they start out at 1.

Two things are true: (1) not all downvoted comments deserve that status; (2) most downvoted comments do deserve that status. #1 sucks, but #2 is really important. The benefit of displaying #2 outweighs the cost of #1, which is not to deny that cost.

Of course it would be vastly better to only have the #2 comments displaying as downvoted, but with a community mechanism like downvoting, there's unfortunately no way to have only the benefit and not the cost. Moderation can help, though (we'll often restore comments that are unfairly downvoted) and maybe there's a place for something like vouching to return a comment to a neutral state.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by briefcomment on Sunday January 31, 2021 @06:15PM (#25983594)
That's what I meant.

I'm not sure if -1 points is really a great signal. That could mean only two people disliked your post, and that kind of small buffer greatly disadvantages unpopular opinions. I would think a post that is really problematic would probably amass at least net 10 downvotes.

Do you take volume of total votes into consideration, e.g., do you treat a post with 2 downvotes the same as a post with 10 upvotes and 12 downvotes? I would think a post with a sizable number of upvotes would be more likely to be an unpopular opinion rather than a really problematic post. Maybe the threshold for greying could be lowered for posts with a sizable number of upvotes.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by dang on Sunday January 31, 2021 @07:35PM (#25984218)
Unfortunately I don't think those assumptions hold. It would be easier if they did, but a lot of comments (including bad ones) just don't get that much vote 'coverage'.

I will look at this more closely though, because it would be interesting if there were a noticeable difference: "do you treat a post with 2 downvotes the same as a post with 10 upvotes and 12 downvotes". Thanks!

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by briefcomment on Sunday January 31, 2021 @08:00PM (#25984391)
Thank you!
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by pmiller2 on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:53PM (#25966224)
You also get downvotes if you dare to question capitalism or the "free market." This isn't just an issue for right wingers.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by cudgy on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:20AM (#25958913)
Totally understand the desire to not tip off personal details. However, it would be nice to hear what you consider to be blind spots on HN. I have found discussions here to be far more professional, courteous, and productive than most any other forum. Are there examples of better discussion forums? If so, how are they better?
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by xupybd on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:51PM (#25964432)
I've seen this argument before and agree that some people do this. But often and sadly I think it's a case of both sides not understanding each other. Often one group has a moral code that excludes the others choices. Taken to an extreme this can be a problem. And if that person is a close relative it can be a problem but at some point you just have to be okay that some strangers in the internet think your political leanings, lifestyle choices, religious beliefs, natural tendencies, etc are wrong. There are probably things they believe that you think are wrong. But if we stop trying to be right all the time we can just find a way to live peacefully and cooperatively.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by AnimalMuppet on Friday January 29, 2021 @07:32PM (#25964714)
I'd urge you to reconsider. There are plenty of people here who don't agree with someone being dehumanized, no matter who they are. If it happens here, we want it to stop. We don't see much of that happening. But if it is happening and we're just blind to it, if someone doesn't tell us, then we can't fix it.

Now, we can't totally fix it, the way HN currently works. If I make a point denying your humanity, that post can be downvoted to death, flagged, and I can be banned. But the post is still there, and everyone with showdead on can still see it. So, depending on how sensitive you are to what was said, "fixing" it may not actually be fixing it.

You have your own reasons for deciding what you do. But I'd at least suggest that you give us some kind of hint, so that we can try to make HN better.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by FusionX on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:14AM (#25958817)
I was sincerely hoping to hear your side. I wish your response wasn't this vague.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by stonecraftwolf on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:19AM (#25958903)
I get it. But I also don’t have much of a tolerance any more for dealing with abuse, and it’s not possible to be open about this stuff without also making yourself vulnerable to that abuse. I wish there was a solution to that, not least because I wish I could participate more frequently and more openly, but if there is a solution beyond moderation for this purpose I haven’t figured it out yet.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by belorn on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:26AM (#25959023)
An option is to use a throwaway account for comments that would leak personal information if linked to a main account or personalized username.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by ThrowawayR2 on Saturday January 30, 2021 @10:26AM (#25969801)
Be careful about assuming that a throwaway account guarantees anonymity. Based on what HN moderators have said in posts to users misusing throwaway accounts to violate the HN guidelines, they are able to link throwaway accounts to primary accounts. That necessarily implies if HN suffers a severe security breach, all throwaway accounts may be linkable to the main account which would reveal the email address on the main account, if present, and enable researching of the user's identity based on posts on the main account.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by AnimalMuppet on Friday January 29, 2021 @07:04PM (#25964550)
That's an option... but if the person behind the throwaway account still receives abuse, it doesn't matter that the abuse didn't come down on their main account. It's still abuse aimed at them as a person, and it still hurts just as much.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by raarts on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:37PM (#25964315)
Aren't you able to provide examples that you've seen happening to others in this site?

Because if not nobody knows what you're referring to, and you could just as well haven't made the comment in the first place.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by Leparamour on Saturday January 30, 2021 @03:13AM (#25967296)
>Aren't you able to provide examples that you've seen happening to others in this site? Because if not nobody knows what you're referring to, and you could just as well haven't made the comment in the first place.

Why the aggressive tone?

You could activate "showdead" in the settings and watch any thread with controversial/political topics yourself.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by danaliv on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:59AM (#25976734)
Just want to say: I feel you.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by dang on Saturday January 30, 2021 @08:35PM (#25974891)
"HN" isn't a person or even a coherent group. It can't "consider" anything anything. If you mean that a subset of HN users post things as horrible as you're describing, that's no doubt true, as it is on any large, open internet forum. When the long tail meets the bottom of the barrel, it generates dreck. The vast majority of it gets downvoted and/or flagged and/or moderated and/or autokilled. Some still gets through, and we ask people to tell us about those cases so we can moderate them. We can't see everything that gets posted here.

That subset of users is not representative of the community, or even close to 10% of it. If I'm wrong about that I'm open to changing my mind, but that would require real data. People's generalizations about HN are unreliable. The unreliability is proportional to the passion and confidence of the pronouncement. Typically, someone has seen a few egregious cases (or even just one) and then makes a generalization from them. The pain of running into egregious comments is real and needs to be taken seriously (and I'm sorry that you don't feel that we do—that really sucks). But the generalization is a non sequitur.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...

It even used to be a sport on Twitter for awhile to find the most egregious HN comments that hadn't been moderated yet and then pass them around as examples of things the HN moderators "agree" with (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...). But of course we don't. Anyone can look through the moderation comments and if they find even one example of us doing anything other than trying to get people to recognize and respect each other's humanity, I'd like to see it. We've written thousands of emails trying to do the same.

The assumption that we see everything that gets posted here is false (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...), as is the assumption that there's any way to stop anyone from making an account and posting what they choose. It takes time for moderation mechanisms to kick in. That's the way an open forum is, and if you think about it, it's rather amazing that HN isn't dominated by such shit.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by danaliv on Sunday January 31, 2021 @02:25AM (#25976890)
I don’t know if I’m reading this correctly, but it comes across to me at least as defensive, and is probably not going to encourage people who are already feeling vulnerable to come forward with specific evidence. I’m also not sure you’ve fully understood the complaint. I can’t speak for stonecraftwolf of course, so I can’t be sure about that. I suspect my own experience is similar though, because I’m hearing echoes of an experience I have here too.

The issue that I’ve experienced here isn’t, strictly speaking, a failure of moderation. It’s more an occasional failure of culture. For the most part discussions go very well here, and I see the hard work you do to make that happen. In fact if someone were to ask me to name the best and hardest-working moderators on the internet, you would come to mind first. There are, however, some topics where the tone of the whole discussion—not individual posts, but whole discussions—is toxic to the point where I have to take a HN breather. If you’d like, I can send you examples of these as I see them in the future.

It’s difficult to address this in a framework where the unit of moderation is an individual comment. A more significant challenge, and one that I think isn’t talked about nearly enough, is that the kind of toxicity I sometimes see here is of a subtle (but no less poisonous) sort. I suspect, in fact, that recognition of it might be difficult unless you’ve become attuned to it as a survival mechanism after experiencing it over and over throughout one’s life. I’m not necessarily saying “there’s no way for you to see it unless you already know it,” which would be tricky indeed—but I’m not ruling out the possibility either. In any case my point is that there is a holistic view that gets lost when we dive into the weeds of individual comments, and in my experience at least, the hurt happens at that holistic level.

I hope this is helpful, and does not feel accusatory; I have nothing to accuse you of, and I very much appreciate being able to work these issues out in good faith. Thanks again for all the hard work you do.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by dang on Sunday January 31, 2021 @03:22PM (#25982195)
> If you’d like, I can send you examples of these as I see them in the future.

That would be great! And thank you for the thoughtful reply.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by invalidOrTaken on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:08AM (#25966676)
Are you a product manager?
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by karmakaze on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:18AM (#25958880)
I wasn't aware of this before, but can fully believe its existence. Even things like Apple, Java, or .Net incite personal or anti-personal reactions--you can probably guess which are which.