News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by dang on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:51AM (#25976704)
That's far from the case.
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by briefcomment on Sunday January 31, 2021 @07:35AM (#25978342)
Ah ok. Any reason not to start greying comments out at a lower threshold of net downvotes?
Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by dang on Sunday January 31, 2021 @03:26PM (#25982242)
I'm not sure I understand, but it seems like you mean greying out fewer comments, i.e. restricting it only to those which are more heavily downvoted? Unless we added some other visual indicator, that would be the same as ignoring the first 1 or more downvotes. I'm not sure that's a good idea because there's a lot of signal in comments being at 0 points, -1, etc., given that they start out at 1.

Two things are true: (1) not all downvoted comments deserve that status; (2) most downvoted comments do deserve that status. #1 sucks, but #2 is really important. The benefit of displaying #2 outweighs the cost of #1, which is not to deny that cost.

Of course it would be vastly better to only have the #2 comments displaying as downvoted, but with a community mechanism like downvoting, there's unfortunately no way to have only the benefit and not the cost. Moderation can help, though (we'll often restore comments that are unfairly downvoted) and maybe there's a place for something like vouching to return a comment to a neutral state.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by briefcomment on Sunday January 31, 2021 @06:15PM (#25983594)
That's what I meant.

I'm not sure if -1 points is really a great signal. That could mean only two people disliked your post, and that kind of small buffer greatly disadvantages unpopular opinions. I would think a post that is really problematic would probably amass at least net 10 downvotes.

Do you take volume of total votes into consideration, e.g., do you treat a post with 2 downvotes the same as a post with 10 upvotes and 12 downvotes? I would think a post with a sizable number of upvotes would be more likely to be an unpopular opinion rather than a really problematic post. Maybe the threshold for greying could be lowered for posts with a sizable number of upvotes.

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by dang on Sunday January 31, 2021 @07:35PM (#25984218)
Unfortunately I don't think those assumptions hold. It would be easier if they did, but a lot of comments (including bad ones) just don't get that much vote 'coverage'.

I will look at this more closely though, because it would be interesting if there were a noticeable difference: "do you treat a post with 2 downvotes the same as a post with 10 upvotes and 12 downvotes". Thanks!

Re:Facebook is banning leftwing users like me by briefcomment on Sunday January 31, 2021 @08:00PM (#25984391)
Thank you!