After driving Model 3 for a couple of years, I have to say that the touch screen is not a usability problem. The controls I need to have quick access to are not on the touch screen, and the ones that are on that screen, are controls I would have to take my eyes of the road and look for anyway.
I will have to grant that they have gone a bit overboard with putting controls in the touch interface, and I still don't get why the glove box opening button is in the touch UI, but that isn't a problem by any means.
I was a bit skeptical of the Model 3 UI, before I got it. But for me it is clearly a step up in usability from the "a million little buttons with weird symbols that who knows does what", and while that view of traditional car interfaces might be a bit unfair. So is all the "any touch screen UI in a car is bad", sentiment going around. Touch interfaces can work well in a car, as long as you don't need to use it for the drive task, but only for auxiliary tasks that don't need, and shouldn't be split seconds tasks.
(not hit them with the high beams)
How do you turn on defog if the windshield becomes obscured?
these are the kinds of things I think about.
The model S is a little better but it isn't perfect either, it has the same problem: defog and changing the temperature on climate control has to be done carefully by looking over and down. Now it will get more of these issues heaped on like turn signals windshield wipers and more.
On my Model Y, it is a simple pull of the left steering wheel stalk to do that, the same on all other cars I've previously owned. On my prior car, flashing the non-bright lights would've required turning an awkwardly positioned dial that also controls fog lights and running lights. That is easier than the touchscreen method but still poor UX while driving.
flashing on/off/on/off means "turn on your headlights" or "speed trap ahead"
My main complaint on our Model 3 is the windshield wiper control. The Auto setting is terrible at actually detecting rain so I can't use it. The manual adjustments require multiple taps and it hides itself again after a few seconds.
A Model 3 in Europe works like this:
- Three presses for fog light control, where you might need it immediately due to weather and altitude changes
- Utterly rubbish rain/drizzle sensing and wipers that can only be switched on for one motion via stalks. Only way to get them constantly going manually is A SWIPE and button press in a moving car when visibility has already dropped.
That's just two of the worst, I won't go into the problem with their new UI (last big update) which has completely ruining the minimal ergonomics that existed for figuring out your speed/regen/etc.
The problem is that it's one of those things where it's best to be a thief among honest people. People want to drive cool cars, regardless of safety. However, they do not want other people driving unsafe things to crash into them.
So we end up in this weird situation where consumers are demanding the exact same things they want safety boards to ban. Some people want these new Knight Rider steering wheels, but they don't want people using drag tires on the road. The people that want to use drag tires on the road don't want people to have the Knight Rider steering wheels. So we end up with demand for both, and safety commissions trying to ban both.
One: the customers want this
Two: the customers are conditioned into buying this by coercive marketing
I don't believe that Tesla customers asked for this change, so I'd tend more towards the second viewpoint.
It's much like the smartphone market: we're constantly told that the market doesn't want small or thick phones, but the market isn't given the choice.
edit: typoed.
I am mostly concerned on lack of crumple zones for the vehicle. Given it's planned weight and performance collisions will be deadly for other vehicles.
Should we not bother with drunk drivers before they cause an accident as well? Surely there are safe drunk drivers out there.
Ah, the old paradox of prevention. We don't need no stinking sea dykes, last storm tide we had was in 1962.
(The US is fairly unique in that most states will allow you to take an easy written test and then immediately drive a >200hp motorcycle. That's not a common situation in most of the world, so please don't use that as a counterargument. 16 year olds owning 1000+hp ferraris/koenigseggs is also effectively banned by upfront cost and insurance premiums; the edge case of very rich people doing it exists but is, again, an edge case)
> I'd love to see what your clothes look like. I assume either none of your clothes has any adaptations for fashion over function OR you're gullible and moronic?
There's a reason why we don't wear ties in manufacturing plants.
You mean like calling people gullible and moronic?
>There's a reason why we don't wear ties in manufacturing plants.
There's a reason why we don't call everyone who wears ties gullible and moronic. There's a reason we don't condemn ties.
TFA quite specifically does not condemn yokes in all situations. They work in some (racing) and not others (everyday drivers).
Not sure which of gullible and/or moronic applies to you, but at least one does.
Here is an F1 racing wheel - used in some of the highest (not lowest) performance driving.
https://www.popsci.com/f1-racing-steering-wheel-complicated/
Airbus moved away from yolks on their planes as part of a move towards greater automation, with great success. Same arguments were made there BTW.
The market for utilitarian design is high. Tesla's for example have some of the LOWEST injury rates per mile driven. The whole package (which is how this all should be judged) is safer than many cars driving on the roads today.
A design that for example allows someone to drive faster than 10MPH (which clearly reduces safety) should be condemned?
I condemn this type of absolutely ridiculous over the top language use and this ridiculous absolutism.
This is addressed in the article:
"And indeed Formula One and many other forms of on-road racing feature steering wheels that look like oversized Batarangs. The thing is, those cars offer swift steering ratios, needing as little as 180 degrees of rotation to turn from the left-most steering extent to the right. Your average street car? Try 900 degrees of rotation from full left to right. That's two and a half turns. More rotation means slower turning, yes, but it also means more precision and frankly greater safety. A razor-sharp steering rack is a great thing on the racetrack."
[0]: https://forums.tesla.com/discussion/113303/steering-and-brak... [1]: https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/does-the-s-steer-by-...
Unless your commute involves a closed course, how is this remotely relevant? Better yet, TFA specifically addressed this point.
It's worth remembering that an F1 racing car is not road legal and are not driven in traffic.
I've personally never seen someone pull out of a parking space in an F1 single-seater.
It's also worth remembering that, unlike Tesla, the author of the article never did any real usability tests for the steering yoke design...
Note this is also why big rigs usually have an additinal rotating handle attached to their wheels, since their ratios are very loose due to their weight and thus may need to turn their wheel 10+ times.
Anyway, big rigs have loose steering because they need precision at highway speeds. The point is to minimize accident risks due to physics rather than any purely mechanical limitation.
The opposite is actually true. Big rigs have loose steering so that the driver will Not jack knife the truck in a panic situation.
A tighter steering rack is Much more precise. Street tires, and especially racing tires, work best (have the most grip) at very narrow slip angles.
Here's a Wikipedia about the "friction circle" as racers call it. "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circle_of_forces#:~:text=From%..."
Here's a Great video shot at the Nürburgring showing an astonishing lap record of the Porsche 919 Hybrid race car, precision personified... Enjoy!
Semi’s air suspension seats bounce around quite a bit which prevents them from keeping their hands steady. So, they need to dampen the input from such motions at highway speeds as race car style steering with would be counter productive in terms of precision. Which is why they have to turn the wheel so much.
It’s also useful for mechanical leverage should power steering go out.
Now I'm not saying I have ever driven a car with the insane performance of an F1 car. I did however walk away from an offer for a fully funded season to race a Swift DB6 (2 liter) after I had tested in that year's national championship winning car. What a fucking car, I loved that car! There were two reasons why I walked away from that offer: Mainly because I am Not brilliant at learning new race tracks. And the faster and more expensive the race car--the less time you have to learn a new circuit and get into your racing rhythm (I suspect this is because I did not race as a child. I was in my twenty's when I started going to racing schools and racing). And the second reason is I was 33 years old at that time; I had a wife, a newborn baby, a contracting business, and a mortgage.
However; I was arguably the fastest Formula Ford driver in America on any given day. I beat a National race winner's lap time by .4 of a second a lap using the exact same car race car in back to back sessions.
For years and years.. and YEARS--all I thought about was how to be a better driver. Every sport I played was done to improve either my balance (driving at the limit, is in good part--feel and balance), my concentration and my strength.
My point is I have some idea of what is required to drive a F1 car. I really don't to put anyone down here: but the fact is a racing driver Would Never Ever buy a self-driving car. And trust me unless you own fire proof underwear and can drive 100 mph on a snow covered road (with winter tires of course. Racers' employ a particular eye technique coupled a steering tactic gives us so much more time to make decisions when we drive. Plus we can drive a car sideways while whistling a happy tune) you would have a hard time imagining just how good GOOD really is.
Launch control, dual clutch transmissions yeah we love that stuff it let's us drive quicker.
Traction control, automatic braking, lane departure systems we hate shit. And No real racer would buy any car where those systems can't be turned off. I turn them off my on car ALWAYS and MOST ESPECIALLY in the Snow, Ice and rain... that shit is off--because I'm FAR better at controlling the car than those systems are.
This whole problem is actually to do with what the public wants. Designers are delivering exactly what they want. And customers are ruined by conditioning from marketing that "touchscreens are better! who wants those stupid buttons and dials", bean counters are getting their bonuses because they just replaced expensive buttons/dials (with automotive reliability ratings) with a $13 touchscreen a bunch of software to control stuff. So, we're never going to get out of this.
The market for utilitarian design is vanishingly small. The public is depressingly gullible and moronic.