News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by ckastner on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @04:42PM (#25934389)
Revenues of $10.7bn are a notable improvement. However, even if one would add a zero to that number, it would be less than VW's and Toyota's combined revenue, yet Tesla is valued almost three times as much as those companies combined.

There's one paragraph on FSD, basically an empty statement of "we're iterating". That sounds realistic.

Back in April 2019 (Autonomy Day), Musk predicted that they will have a million robotaxis on the road in 2020.

Solar deployments up 18% to 205MW, which is totally negligible. Total new solar in 2020 globally was projected to be around 140GW.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by tejohnso on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:00PM (#25934632)
TSLA left the land of sound fundamental investments long ago.

It is comfortably enjoying life in the land of exuberant speculation.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by ericmay on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:05PM (#25934686)
Yea... but what exactly are sound fundamentals? (Not directed at you, just topical).

Is Apple at 40x P/E (which is a very simple and over-used metric) still fundamentally sound? Amazon? I think the rule of thumb was always 12x. Ok so what company is that? Intel?

I think what we're seeing is the result of excess capital. Items like accredited investor definitions lock people out of the VC space so if you can't buy a house because they are too expensive or sold before they hit market... what else are you going to do with your money? Some return looks a lot better than no return...

Granted, Tesla does have an extremely high valuation but, well, who cares? I think that's the general sentiment. It's a speculative investment.

* Disclaimer I own a small amount of Apple and Tesla shares and have a positive outlook on the future of both companies. Use your own judgement when investing or considering things you read on the Internet

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by threeseed on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:15PM (#25934822)
Apple and Amazon are ridiculously profitable, highly diversified, corporate, fiscally stable and aren't a prism of the CEO's whims and machinations.

I wouldn't consider Tesla to have any of those characteristics.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by Kranar on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:28PM (#25934990)
Funny because honestly 10 years ago people said very similar things about Apple under Jobs that people say today about Tesla under Musk. One big difference is that Twitter exists, so now you get to hear directly from certain CEOs outside of highly polished and rehearsed presentations, whereas 10 years ago the public never got that chance.

And don't get me started about what people said about Amazon's profitability and fiscal stability 10-15 years ago. Amazon's PE ratio was around 4000 whereas Tesla's is 1500.

My speculation, and that's all it is, speculation, is that for the most part people invest in companies that they want to see succeed and by investing in it, they become a kind of participant in the future growth and success of the company. It's mostly a place for people to park their money in a venture that they want to see flourish. There is no magic formula you plug into an Excel spreadsheet and get out a perfect stock price, there is no metric that can reliably be used to press a button to invest. You see a company working in an area you are interested in and that has a chance to succeed in, you have a positive feeling about the company, its products, its people, then you invest.

Good luck finding a stable, fiscally responsible and reliable company that ticks off all the fundamental indicators, a CEO who is a rock who never offends anyone or anything, and has a stock that does more than barely beat the rate of inflation and maybe pays out a measly 1-2% dividend.

The reality is that if the degree to which you value a stock is based on its PE ratio and other naïve but nice sounding metrics, then to be blunt you're no more sophisticated an investor than the people blowing their money on GME.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by ericmay on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:43PM (#25935166)
To piggyback off of your GME point I’d say even less sophisticated. At least they saw the opportunity and understand what they’re doing.

But I enjoyed reading your comment that the comment above and think it’s good to have a healthy discussion about the topic. It’s awesome!

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by xiphias2 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @12:36AM (#25938609)
Actually the same group of people (r/wallstreetbets) was crowding Tesla before it went up. Anyways I'm watching GME all the time, having a lot of fun and hoping for at least 1 bankrupcy.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by threeseed on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:56PM (#25935315)
> Good luck finding a stable, fiscally responsible and reliable company that ticks off all the fundamental indicators, a CEO who is a rock who never offends anyone or anything, and has a stock that does more than barely beat the rate of inflation and maybe pays out a measly 1-2% dividend.

You mean like every single, successful startup ?

Almost all of whom are run by CEOs who act professionally, are careful about their public statements and don't have the net worth to keep paying out SEC fines.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by ericmay on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:38PM (#25935708)
Let us know when we can invest. I don’t make enough money to be an accredited investor.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by killtimeatwork on Thursday January 28, 2021 @06:26AM (#25940606)
> The reality is that if the degree to which you value a stock is based on its PE ratio and other naïve but nice sounding metrics, then to be blunt you're no more sophisticated an investor than the people blowing their money on GME.

Or, the stock market is in a huge, 1929-style bubble and that's why the P/E numbers don't make sense. People don't want to even consider that though, because of what it'd do to their investments. Considering how many people have the money in the markets nowadays, this collective magical thinking can go on for some time. At some point though the value of the stock becomes detached from the actual company and its profits, and the stock becomes just a fiat token that people trade, like crypto.

BTW one scenario that can play out in the upcoming years is that the inflation finally catches up with the money printing, which increases the nominal profits of companies (as the dolar value of every product they sell increases), and the P/E numbers will again normalize. No idea how likely that is though.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by playingchanges on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @09:59PM (#25937588)
I think you’re right but just to put another spin on the point we are also in a zero to negative interest rate environment. Where’s all that would be bond money gonna go if not Apple.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by bryanlarsen on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @04:53PM (#25934518)
Toyota's Enterprise Value is $350B, VW's is $230B and Tesla is $840B. That's not triple both combined.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by nemetroid on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @04:57PM (#25934577)
Presumably, then, the GP comment is not referring to enterprise value.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by georgeecollins on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:05PM (#25934684)
Well it should. Market cap is meaningless for companies with a lot of debt (industrial companies typically). And if you don't understand that you will make a lot of meaningless comparisons.

Also, if you believe in efficient markets (and lets admit this is a hard week to do that) then you know that companies are valued based on future profits, not future revenues. Google and Ford had very similar revenue in say, 2019. But there enterprise values were completely different because of gross margins and profits.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by reitzensteinm on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:54PM (#25935287)
You have to be careful when making a blind comparison, though, because a lot of debt VW and Toyota have is related to their financial service divisions. They're going to receive lease payments to service it.

If you were evaluating a bank that had $1tn in deposits and issued $800bn of home loans and had $200bn in cash, the $800bn figure of debt minus cash just doesn't mean that much, and people don't typically calculate EV for banks.

So say Tesla buys that bank - does their EV double to ~$2tn?

IMO, the only meaningful way to compare EVs is to unwind the financial divisions valuing them like financial companies, then compare what's left.

It's not all rosy, though, because even after unwinding financial services from these companies they've still got a lot of debt. And EVs do pose a risk that the value of the leased ICEs cars will plummet. If it happens very rapidly, that could well be an existential threat.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by bryanlarsen on Friday January 29, 2021 @12:06PM (#25959590)
That's a great example. They have $1T in debts (the deposits), and $1T in assets (the cash + home loans owed them). To simplify our example, let's assume that some of those home loans are in trouble so the "continuing business" part of the company is worth $0, that the expected profit from those loans exactly balances the expected interest expenses on their deposits. So their market cap is $0.

Market cap is $0, EV is $800B. So is the company worth $0 or $800B? *Both answers are right*. You have to specify worth to who before getting an answer. To the economy it has almost a trillion dollar impact, to an investor it's worthless.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by reitzensteinm on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:06PM (#25963322)
But in the case of a car company owning a bank, neither market cap or EV are good answers for comparison. The first lets debt cloud the intrinsic value of the manufacturing operation, and the second dumps the value of six months worth of production onto the calculation for no real reason.

VW has 133 billion euros of receivables for its leases. If we talk about Tesla's worth in comparison to VW by comparing EV, we're essentially discarding that line item - worth double the market cap of GM.

And as I said above, if Tesla buys this $0 market cap $800bn EV bank, why should it change the relative value of the car companies to each other? Using your method, it does.

To put it another way, when Tesla took on $500m in debt to offer Model 3 leases - did the business really change in any material way? If they financed $10bn 3/Y leases this year - would the value of the company bump up by 1% compared to if they used a leasing partner?

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by nemetroid on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:16PM (#25934834)
I don't disagree.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by ckastner on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:44PM (#25935183)
I was indeed referring to market cap, but even acknowledging the sibling comments and going by enterprise value, the situation still appears incredulous for a company that is, as of yet, an emerging car manufacturer, a possible FSD contender, and an energy niche player.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by baking on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:11PM (#25934766)
"Tesla is valued almost three times as much as those companies combined."

He didn't say market cap, he said "valued" and you need to consider debt financing in making a fair comparison of market value.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by avrionov on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:18AM (#25939118)
Tesla stock price is high, but compared to the other car manufacturers they look quite good:

- Tesla increased their revenue in a year where Toyota and VW saw a significant decline in their revenue.

- Tesla can produce 1M electric cars at the end of this year.

- Ford, BMW, MBZ, GM, and Fiat are not going to produce any meaningful number of electric cars this year.

- Japanese car manufacturers are completely missing (They have great hybrid models, but not pure BEVs).

- The only serious competition is the Chinese manufacturers, VW and Hyundai / Kia. VW will have to deal with the cannibalization of their own business by BEVs. Same with Hyundai / Kia.

- Tesla is taking business not only from auto manufacturers, but also from dealerships, gas stations, and insurance (this is a very small part, but it will increase).

- Most of the Tesla killers failed to make a significant dent. I don't expect 2021 to be the year of the Tesla killer, although there is a slight possibility that ID.3 and ID.4 will sell enough to endanger Tesla.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by 11thEarlOfMar on Thursday January 28, 2021 @07:07AM (#25940845)
>> VW will have to deal with the cannibalization of their own business

Great point. Tesla revenue will grow substantially, VW et al will maintain sales, except for the portion of their sales lost to Tesla. Also, it's a major capital investment for VW that they otherwise wouldn't have to make.

This is one of several reasons why it's not meaningful to compare their stock prices.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by tahoeskibum on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:20PM (#25934889)
You would've made the same comparison between Apple and Nokia back in 2008. If you've ever driven a Tesla, you'll realize that it is a paradigm shift just like the iPhone was back in 2008 relative to Nokia.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by dogma1138 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:53PM (#25935276)
If you’ve driven an EV from Audi, Porsche or BMW you’ll see how it’s not. Tesla feels like a $100 Android from AliExpress compared to an iPhone.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by rasz on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:16PM (#25938094)
Have you? Because Audi EV might look like luxurious hotel when stationary, but start driving and you quickly realize its EV for the old people made to feel like petrol car.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by dogma1138 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @05:30AM (#25940258)
Yes I have, it’s actually pleasant to drive and steer, it handles like a luxury sedan and it feels like one unlike a Tesla which feels cheaper than what Prius did 15 years ago.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by rasz on Thursday January 28, 2021 @06:46PM (#25951194)
Just to be sure we are both talking about e-tron suv, right? It handles like a modern work truck, or almost 20 year old weakest spec Cayenne after loading it up with !500 kg! of bricks. Its great if you are an older gentleman and your main requirements are nice soft plushy seats, think American land yachts (Cadillac) in the 70-80s. Infotainment also takes me back 20 years - Voice control doesnt understand the name of second biggest city in a central European country, and is unable to plot a 300 km route from the capital to the second biggest city (after entering it manually with on screen keyboard, it wouldnt work otherwise) on half a charge, gives up looking for chargers claiming there are none. We are ~1000km from the place the car is manufactured, and it doesnt recognize mayor cities and is unable to direct me to a charger.

Yes, the trim quality is excellent, doesnt change the fact its "EV for the old people made to feel like petrol car". Its a Nokia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_N82 industry leading finish quality, outdated specs.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by dogma1138 on Friday January 29, 2021 @09:32AM (#25957563)
I don’t know what you drove by I drove the 2020 Audi sportback in the UK and it didn’t feel like an old man’s car.

As far for the navigation system again no issues, a 1000km from where the car was manufactured could be anywhere in Europe form rural Portugal to Bratislava that has no baring on the quality of the vehicle itself.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by rasz on Friday January 29, 2021 @08:45PM (#25965182)
2019. Did they finally added one pedal mode in 2020? Cars for old people feel nice to sit in, but bad to drive. etron is a heavy pig. It feels like any other luxury petrol car. Navigation is an issue if you are selling car in EU while it cant navigate there, talks in broken localization and doesnt understand basic commands.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by ChuckMcM on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:23PM (#25934934)
Or Blackberry/RIM but the same. Basically the market has priced in that while existing car manufacturers have more sales, they are essentially dying and they need to come up with a car that is competitive to the Tesla electric offerings to compete. And so far they haven't shown the ability to do that.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by threeseed on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:03PM (#25935385)
> And so far they haven't shown the ability to do that

You do know that the best selling EV in Europe isn't a Tesla ? https://i.redd.it/m6z20txyyvd61.jpg

Also Porsche Taycan is better in almost every single way than a Tesla: 800V architecture, driving dynamics, interior/exterior design, polish etc. Likewise the VW ID 3/4 is very much on par with a Model 3.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by ckastner on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:00PM (#25935351)
> Basically the market has priced in that while existing car manufacturers have more sales, they are essentially dying

Please. They're not even close to dying.

> and they need to come up with a car that is competitive to the Tesla electric offerings to compete

And they are doing exactly that. VW alone already has $86bn spending committed to its EV lineup.

You associate the existing manufacturers with a Blackberry/RIM situation, but that is simply not the case.

This is more of an Apple/Android type of situation. Apple triggered this paradigm shift, and dozens of others (Samsung, Motorola, etc.) followed suit almost immediately.

Sure, it's going to take existing car manufacturers a few years to catch up. Just as it will take Tesla a few years to ramp up production to competitive numbers.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by orange_tee on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:45PM (#25935196)
And who are they going to sell them too? The people who buy Teslas are Tesla fanbois not generic EV customers. And a car company like Honda cannot generate the kind of hype theater that Tesla can, especially not in the US.

Other car manufacturers cannot replicate Tesla's success because their customers are different and generic EVs are not a good value preposition for most of these customers.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by ChuckMcM on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:24PM (#25935597)
I would be interested in hearing how you reason to the statement that the "Other car manufacturers customers are different."

As I see it, there are just "car customers." And they are a diverse population, from those who need maximum reliability and economy to those for whom their vehicle is an extension of their need for attention. But as diverse as they are, they form a single set, known in marketing parlance as the "total addressable market."

When you write, "The people who buy Teslas are Tesla fanbois ..." it reminds me when people would say "The people who buy a computer for their home are nerds ..." I expect that both of these statements were solidly true at one point, and then became less and less true over time as the diversity of people who felt the product in question was the right choice increased.

So what I see in Tesla's results, and their history, is that they created a niche product that many people didn't understand the need for. But over time, as more and more have been shipped, more people can see the benefit.

For example, here is a real anecdote. As an anecdote it means nothing of course, but for me it felt significant. My neighbor just bought a model 3. They had been in the camp that these things were a fad, a toy, a ridiculous idea, and "what about the range, and who wants to wait an hour to fill up?" kind of things. But another neighbor has one as well and has had it for a couple of years now. And we all talk and that neighbor was chuckling that they didn't even know the price of gas anymore since they hadn't been to a gas station in over a year! In those discussions, the range of the model 3 was such that they charge at home, and even on very "busy" days never have to plan to stop at a charging station. That is because in "real life" they never drive more than 200 miles in a day, and they never cannot fully recharge over night. Once the lightbulb went on about the reality of this, my other neighbor got their own Model 3.

It was, for me, seeing one of the general pool of customers switch over from "only gas is okay" to "this could work for me." And that was instructive.

Given the volume ramp reported by Tesla, I would not be surprised if this "conversion" experience were happening at an accelerating pace.