News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by bryanlarsen on Friday January 29, 2021 @12:06PM (#25959590)
That's a great example. They have $1T in debts (the deposits), and $1T in assets (the cash + home loans owed them). To simplify our example, let's assume that some of those home loans are in trouble so the "continuing business" part of the company is worth $0, that the expected profit from those loans exactly balances the expected interest expenses on their deposits. So their market cap is $0.

Market cap is $0, EV is $800B. So is the company worth $0 or $800B? *Both answers are right*. You have to specify worth to who before getting an answer. To the economy it has almost a trillion dollar impact, to an investor it's worthless.

Re:Tesla Q4 2020 Earnings by reitzensteinm on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:06PM (#25963322)
But in the case of a car company owning a bank, neither market cap or EV are good answers for comparison. The first lets debt cloud the intrinsic value of the manufacturing operation, and the second dumps the value of six months worth of production onto the calculation for no real reason.

VW has 133 billion euros of receivables for its leases. If we talk about Tesla's worth in comparison to VW by comparing EV, we're essentially discarding that line item - worth double the market cap of GM.

And as I said above, if Tesla buys this $0 market cap $800bn EV bank, why should it change the relative value of the car companies to each other? Using your method, it does.

To put it another way, when Tesla took on $500m in debt to offer Model 3 leases - did the business really change in any material way? If they financed $10bn 3/Y leases this year - would the value of the company bump up by 1% compared to if they used a leasing partner?