News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by nbzso on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @08:20PM (#25923107)
Speaking of real ergonomic and health in my humble opinion, the designs with Concave keywell (Kinesis/Dactyl) are the way to go. I have jumped on to Kinesis Advantage 2 and all my wrist pain is no more.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by denimnerd42 on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @08:36PM (#25923228)
The Kinesis Advantage is the single greatest product I've ever purchased for my health and career.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by avindroth on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @09:06PM (#25923425)
I'd go all the way and also add dvorak (programmer's) to the mix. But if somebody goes out of the way to buy an ergonomic keyboard, they are probably fiddling around with keymaps, too.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by andredz on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @10:15PM (#25923818)
I sometimes use http://programmer-dvorak.appspot.com/ to practice. The ergonomics of accentuation is inconvenient, but this probably solves the problem: https://github.com/N0rthw1nd/Latin-Dvorak
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by avindroth on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @10:47PM (#25924001)
I could never get my head around the numbers. I just have a custom layout where for 1,2,3,9,0 they are without shift, and for 4,5,6,7,8 they are with shift. So for me shift 1 is &, but shift 4 is 4. It actually works really well.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by nbzso on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @09:17PM (#25923495)
Advantage have Brown/Red Cherry and SmartSet Programming Engine: Dual-Layer layouts with secondary actions embedded in the “Keypad” layer US Version: Windows/Mac/PC Switchable (extra keycaps included) International Versions: Extra Windows keycap included One-touch, onboard key remapping so you can customize the layout to suit your typing style and preferences Heavy-duty, on-the-fly macros up to 300 characters long. Choose from 9 playback speeds and add timing delays to ensure proper playback. Native Dvorak layout which can be customized independently of the default QWERTY layout. All settings are saved to the keyboard’s 4MB flash memory.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by srcreigh on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @10:28PM (#25923883)
After ~1.5 years using emacs keybindings in IntelliJ, I couldn't code for more than 20 minutes without pain.

I no longer have any extended pain due to:

1. Modal editing. I use the boon package for emacs, but basically vim

2. Sticky keys. Basically, I don't have to hold down any modifiers, I just press Ctrl then press N for example. Or two Ctrl to lock it, NNNNNN, then Ctrl to return to normal. On macs this is in the Accessibility app under Keyboard. It doesn't work so well with Shift + mouse scroll though.

3. Kinesis advantage 2

4. Dvorak

I still sometimes get a bit of pinky pain since I shift and ctrl with my pinkies. With sticky keys, modal editing, and mechanical switches in the Advantage 2, it's not really a problem.

I learned that the macbook keyboards aren't that bad if I use modal editing and sticky modifier keys. Also I need to be careful to avoid so-called "ulnar deviation" of my wrists. This means I lift my wrists, let my fingers hang down more, so I can keep the wrists neutral while hitting shift etc.

I don't think Dvorak helps much, but I still like it. It was intentionally put together. I think it helped to learn Dvorak and the concave key well of Advantage 2 at the same time. I never learned qwerty on the Advantage 2 or Dvorak on macbook keyboard. I want to try the programmer's dvorak layout as well for lisp.

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by __mharrison__ on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @10:45PM (#25923980)
This is similar to my setup.

Similar to a Jedi building your own light saber, you should build (and customize fw) for your keyboard :)

When I built my ergodox, I put the Norman layout on it. I use emacs bindings almost everywhere, so control is under a thumb.

(I'm still tweaking and considering a gergoplex when I get to stay travelling for training again)

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by dan-robertson on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:11AM (#25926790)
I found the thumb keys were particularly useful for emacs ergonomics: I just have a big thumb key for each of Control and Meta with a smaller thumb key for the other one and shift on each side. I also remind some keys I use often to move them away from the corners. This entirely gets rid of emacs pinky for me. The only issue is I don’t have so many keys but I don’t really need a lot of them (home, end, delete, pgdn) as shortcuts usually suffice.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by alasdair_ on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @11:09PM (#25924154)
I love the Kinesis (I own two of them). I just wish they made the exact same keyboard but in a split model.

As an aside, if you buy a Kinesis, look at getting the “LF” version of the Advantage, it comes with Cherry MX Reds instead of the defaults and the difference is enormous.

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by nefariousoctopi on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @07:04AM (#25927188)
I definitely agree. One thing to note about Kinesis Advantage 2 is that it is really massive compared to other keyboards. I didn't realize before getting one for myself and seeing it on my desk.

Second thing is that quite frankly at that price point Advantage looks a and feels a bit flimsy (especially the middle part between the key wells) though it has seemingly no impact on typing.

And lastly, I have a bit broader shoulders than average and I need hands a bit more apart than the key wells on Kinesis and maybe a bit more tilted sideways (well at least I think, I am not a doctor). It is orders of magnitude better than it used to be on a regular keyboard, but I still have sore muscles around shoulder blades and back of my neck sometimes.

All of these issues seem to be solvable by a split. I still hope that Kinesis would release a split concave keyboard by themselves since among all of the concave keyboards it is by far the most user friendly (no assembly required, no QMK compiling, remapping is doable on the keyboard itself), but I am starting to oogle the likes of Dactyl, Dactyl-ManuFrom or Bastyl[1] (which is modified Dactyl with less DIY required for more $$).

If I go the DYI way I am also thinking about mounting trackball on it similar to the Tracktyl (trackball helped me immensely with my wrists). What I am a bit afraid of is that once I start doing customizations I'll need/want something easily modifiable/adjustable to experiment with quickly. This design [2] in combination with Bastyl-like flexible PCBs seems like a neat idea I'd like to try.

Be not mistaken, Advantage is, not entirely unlike a good office chair or a mattress, still worth every penny, but IMO the split concave keyboards are the "future future". I would not even think of building a keyboard before Advantage, but now I do and there is no turning back for me.

[1]: https://www.hidtech.ca/?product=bastyl

[2]: https://deskthority.net/viewtopic.php?t=11734

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by pabloarteel on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @08:58PM (#25923371)
Around that topic of ergonomic tools, I've been wanting to try a vertical mouse.

As a designer, my right hand is over the mouse a lot of the time. I have a chronic pain on my right wirst, although, I not certain of the cause.

Anyone her has experience with this?

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by fpgaminer on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @11:28PM (#25924296)
Different things work for different people. Your only real option is to try all the options and see what works best for you personally. Luckily for wrist pain, the options are all cheap. Things to try:

Vertical mouse or trackball; they're all fine, you can get a "nice" one after finding what works first.

Wrist braces.

Wrist stretches.

Exercise; most weightlifting will improve your grip strength which helps some people.

Ergonomic chair; pain in the wrist can sometimes be caused by issues in the shoulder, which often result from a poorly placed arm rest. This is hard to notice as your shoulder might feel fine. Worth double checking.

Reduce stress; some amount of wrist pain can be caused by mental stress which results in tension and blood flow problems.

Laptop; your desktop environment might be great, but maybe you use a laptop too, and you're slowly destroying your wrists on its tiny form factor.

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by elteto on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @09:12PM (#25923463)
Same here. The vertical mouse has helped a lot. I've tried a few and settled on the one I liked the most. You should definitely give it a try. Be aware that it will take you a couple of days to adjust, just stick with it.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by sdfin on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @09:39PM (#25923616)
Some months ago I was feeling some pain in my right wrist, and by buying and using a vertical mouse the pain ceased.

Right now my belief is that non-vertical mice are badly designed and I see no reason to use a non vertical one again.

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by mleonhard on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @10:38PM (#25923947)
Switching to a vertical mouse cleared up my arm pain. I tried many vertical mice. Evoluent's wired vertical mouse has been my favorite since 2009. Each new version is essentially the same, just with different surface finishes.

Years later, I got wrist pain in both hands. Switching to a tenting keyboard solved it. I've used the GoldTouch V2 for 7 years now.

Do not try 3M's vertical mouse with the thumb button. I used it for a few months and developed severe pain in my thumb. Fifteen years have passed and my thumb still occasionally clicks when I bend it, due to that injury.

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by denimnerd42 on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @09:04PM (#25923409)
Yeah I found the Evoluent to be perfect for me. I actually had to give up mousing with my right wrist as it got too badly damaged. So now I use my left hand with a vertical mouse. Was an interesting transition period.

I think you will notice a loss of precision though. For example I could never play an FPS at my best with a vertical mouse. But for $80-100 definitely worth a try for your health.

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by nunez on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @09:11PM (#25923453)
Absolutely love them. Won’t ever go back to a regular mouse if I can avoid it.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by teamonkey on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @05:56AM (#25926666)
A vertical mouse, combined with a wrist and elbow brace helped me immensely, where a trackpad or thumb-ball made my RSI much worse. Even just a cheap one is an improvement, but the more vertical the tilt, the better. The one I use now is the one that's rebranded by half a dozen suppliers on Amazon.

The thing that's hard to remember with a vertical mouse (and mice in general) is that you're supposed to move your arm, not your wrist. Getting used to that was more of an issue than the orientation of the mouse.

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by benhurmarcel on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @08:04AM (#25927694)
I tried the Anker Vertical Mouse, the Logitech Vertical, the Evoluent VerticalMouse 4, the Logitech Ergo (trackball), and Logitech M370 (trackball).

In the end my favorite is the Logitech Ergo with the "Plus" stand. The version that includes the stand is only sold in the US so I imported 2 of them. I got rid of all the others.

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by ekianjo on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @09:32PM (#25923573)
Vertical mouse is great. I used to have wrist pain after long hours of work but now its much better with the vertical mouse.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by ahelwer on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @09:10PM (#25923448)
Mice, as in things you drag across a desk surface, are a complete dead end ergonomically. Trackballs are the answer. I like the Kensington vertical trackball. The only thing that moves is your thumb. Those small precise wrist movements kill you.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by coryrc on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @10:00PM (#25923736)
I moved to a trackball, a large one. Made my wrist hurt after a ~week, so I went back to a regular mouse (which has never caused me pain) or, my favorite, using the trackpoint (but unless I want to shell out crazy money and wait a while can't get a split keyboard version, so it's only when using the machine away from my desk).
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by yellowapple on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @09:28PM (#25923545)
Seconded. I'm partial to Logitech's MX Ergo; I feel like fully vertical is a bit of an overcorrection, whereas the Ergo lets my hand rest diagonally, which feels a fair bit more natural and comfortable. Bought one on a whim for work, and I've enjoyed it enough that I bought a second one when I switched jobs this year.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by perlpimp on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @10:04PM (#25923754)
tbh magic mouse pad with three finger drag has transformed my interaction with computer and Cooler Master master keys M(that they don't make anymore) given me numpad and cursor keys and navigation/edit keys very close. It is like 1/2 more ergonomic this way.
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by cutthegrass2 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @08:01AM (#25927668)
Curious to know whether anyone uses QWERTY on the Kinesis Adv. I've tried switching to it a number of times (from a standard 87key board), even getting unto >60wpm consistently, but its use in terminal sessions was always frustrating. Not being able to type "cd" with the index and middle finger of the left hand means I always felt super slow in the terminal.

Should I have persevered? Is this a typical frustration of moving to a split ortholinear layout board using QWERTY?

edit: spelling

Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by nunez on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @09:09PM (#25923442)
I tried using a Kinesis Freestyle Bluetooth with the tents and pads; it was very comfortable but I still encountered wrist pain because of the keys being mushy. I’m going to try the mechanical version; I am hoping for better results
Re:Split keyboards and how to build them by TaylorAlexander on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @08:28PM (#25923163)
I built a dactyl manifold but still haven’t set up the layers to my liking. I’m back on my normal keyboard and wrist pain persists, but I suppose I should put some time in to adjusting to the dactyl.