News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by JMTQp8lwXL on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:46AM (#25901339)
38,000 people die annually in auto accidents. Car manufacturers should never get away with it. Two incidents with 200+ fatalities indeed is tragic, but automobiles are nearly two orders of magnitude worse in death counts. We should be 100x more serious about automobiles.
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by krsdcbl on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:54AM (#25901402)
I think you are conflating causes here. A faulty aircraft where design issues led to a rare incident is something completely different than the quite common traffic deaths mostly originating from asverse conditions an reckless driving of a traffic participant.

Traffic accidents are not mainly caused by a certain car model being sold with faulty breaks, and airplane crashes are incredibly rare occurances.

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by JMTQp8lwXL on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:02AM (#25901462)
I don't think it's a conflation because it's a moral question and a judgment of how we view death. I know multiple people that have died in car accidents. I know nobody who's died in a plane crash. Even if the FAA made the wrong call here, why do we give outsized influence and attention to events that cause relatively few deaths?

In other words: what is the greater moral tragedy, losing 40,000 of your fellow citizens at the hands of aggressive or uneducated or unskilled drivers, or 400 deaths largely due to corporate cost cutting? My mental framework suggests we should optimize for addressing maximal number of deaths, but we rarely make that choice.

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by ClumsyPilot on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:18AM (#25901569)
Are they actually safer?

"In cars, one person died per 5.5 million passenger hours traveled, versus one death per 6 million passenger hours in commercial airline flights-a slim difference at best!"

Also , I can't cross london by plane, so what do I do with that information?

This whole argument smells of whataboutism of sorts 'well if cars kill so many people we shouldn't give boeing such hard time for killing a few"

https://observer.com/1998/03/driving-versus-flying-the-debat...

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by sokoloff on Monday January 25, 2021 @06:14AM (#25901932)
Do we generally use cars and planes to pass time (if so, measure deaths per hour) or to transport people to a different location (if so, measuring deaths per mile seems a lot more sensible)?
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by ClumsyPilot on Monday January 25, 2021 @07:02AM (#25902216)
I am approaching it from the scientific standpoint - which of the two measurements is an actual independant variable, and which is an artifact of the measurement? If the planes go twice slower, would their deaths per kilometer stay the same, or would deaths per hour? I am willing to bet it's the latter.

In that case planes have the same chance of failing (mechanically or through human error) as cars do. It is very difficult to increase that safety factor, maybe impossible.

The conclusion to draw from that, is that you can't point at car manufacturers and blame them for producing unreliable / bad quality machines.

On the other hand, measurement per kilometer implies that as a traveller you should use a plane where possible, but obviously they can't replace car in a daily commute.

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by sokoloff on Monday January 25, 2021 @07:53AM (#25902561)
Airliners rarely crash in cruise, so doubling the hours in cruise is likely to almost halve the crash rate per hour with no significant change in crashes per flight (and therefore per kilometer).

Maybe it makes the crew a little more fatigued on descent and approach to landing, likely partially offset by it making air travel less appealing to pax, resulting in fewer people per fatal accident.

[0] https://www.theglobalist.com/when-do-planes-crash/

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by notahacker on Monday January 25, 2021 @08:10AM (#25902706)
Your 'scientific standpoint' misses out the fact an average commercial aircraft has two orders of magnitude more people on board than an average car. Based on your deaths per hour stats we can reasonably assume the chance of fatality-inducing failure from a given flight hour is roughly two orders of magnitude less than an hour in the car.

When I'm boarding an aircraft, I care more about that than how many people would die with me.

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by ClumsyPilot on Monday January 25, 2021 @10:11AM (#25904003)
I am not clear on that - are you saying that if you were to somehow hypothetically replace all your car travel with plane travel for an equivalens amount of time, your chance of death would go down by 100x? I am just thinking about it, and I don't think that it works out that way.
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by notahacker on Monday January 25, 2021 @01:34PM (#25906842)
tbf I'm assuming that what the article calls "passenger flight hours" is more accurately described as "flight hours by a passenger airliner", based on the figure looking very wrong otherwise. Looking at ICAO's figures for that year there were 0.03 fatalities per 100m passenger km from airliners, so dividing through by a sensible average kph figure gives something in the region of 0.2 fatalities per passenger hour, or 30x safer than the car with sober driver. (You get to 100x quite easily by avoiding using airlines based in regions that contribute disproportionately to aviation accidents)

This is of course abstracting away from details like the aircraft travelling 10x further and walking to the airport, but the real problem is aircraft not serving the routes you want to drive. General Aviation is a lot more dangerous than commercial flights, especially when it involves clumsy pilots ;-)

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by sokoloff on Monday January 25, 2021 @02:52PM (#25907870)
I'm reading the article as an airliner flying for 1 hour and carrying 100 passengers as counting as 100 "passenger flight hours" (not 1).
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by notahacker on Monday January 25, 2021 @03:10PM (#25908103)
That would be a use of the term more consistent with aviation norms, but then the quoted figure would be very wrong (or based on a very different category of aircraft than the commercial airliners we're discussing here
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by croes on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:10AM (#25901512)
400 because they grounded the 737 Max. Imagine a car sometimes driving to left if you steer right. Would you blame the driver or the manufacturer. BTW count the hours people drive and compare them to the hours people fly and than look at the death rate.
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by notahacker on Monday January 25, 2021 @07:54AM (#25902567)
> Imagine a car sometimes driving to left if you steer right. Would you blame the driver or the manufacturer.

We don't need to imagine this. There's a car called a Tesla which sometimes unexpectedly and fatally decides to steer in a different direction, and its management invariably blame the driver. Weirdly, HNers not only generally don't want Tesla's entire management and design team to be fired, they actually tend towards defending their approach...

Edit: would love it if the people who apparently disagree could make some arguments why Tesla's fatality-inducing electronic driver support system deserves a different response to Boeing's

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by ReptileMan on Monday January 25, 2021 @09:38AM (#25903556)
We had the BMW SUV that hardened the wheel to prevent roll over and that meant lower chances of avoiding heads on collision.
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by nyolfen on Monday January 25, 2021 @09:44PM (#25911811)
for an analogous situation, it would be a car manufacturer that removed some previously-included safety feature, and made the car autopilot against your command when it malfunctioned
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by oblio on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:15AM (#25901549)
> My mental framework suggests we should optimize for addressing maximal number of deaths, but we rarely make that choice.

Who says we aren't?

Modern cars have much, much better passive safety systems and active safety systems are light years of what was available before, and improving rapidly.

One random example: I have a Volvo V40 and I can barely see around the A pillar. And I see this in all modern cars. I don't remember feeling the same way about cars from 20-30 years ago. I'm quite confident that if the V40 would roll over, even at somewhat high speed, my chances of getting out relatively unscathed would be better than even those in a sports car from, say, 30 years ago.

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by ljf on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:34AM (#25901684)
The deaths stopped because 'we' demanded that they stop flying. Who would make that choice in your model?
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by sumedh on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:20AM (#25901582)
> I know multiple people that have died in car accidents.

Did they die because the car had issues or was it some other reason?

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by JMTQp8lwXL on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:25AM (#25901621)
Does it matter how they died if the outcome is the same, is the question I wish I would've posed earlier. One was due to drunk driving. The other two, I'm not privy to the full details. It could have been, but statistically I would suppose not; most are human error, I'd presume.

I'd further suppose that simply put, it's easier to stop 400 deaths due to a failure to regulate than it is to change the driving habits of citizens, and that's why --even if one is 100x worse-- it doesn't draw the attention, and it makes me feel like my loss doesn't matter, even though others are far more likely to experience the loss I did, rather than the main post subject, and I will admit that shaped my view entering the discussion.

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by sumedh on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @01:33AM (#25913187)
> Does it matter how they died if the outcome is the same,

That is like saying oranges and apples are the same because they are fruits.

It matters how they died because the car victims died due human error not because the car was defective, the plane victims died because of the plane itself was defective.

If the planes were not ground many more people who have died and people on ground if the plane fell on them.

Would you drive in a car which is known to crash into walls?

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by cm2187 on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:17AM (#25901563)
And if you look at deaths by drowning it dwarfs those numbers. Though people get worked up with terrorism, plane crashes and rare diseases.
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by ogogmad on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:42AM (#25901739)
Deaths from rare diseases are "fat tailed". Meaning that if you found out there were millions of excess deaths in a given year, then a new disease is a lot more likely to be the reason than car crashes.

Are deaths from terrorism fat tailed? Terrorists can get access to biological weapons, the electricity grid, the water supply, a skyscraper with thousands of people in it, the parliament building of a country... I think it is fat tailed.

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by cm2187 on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:48AM (#25901778)
If a disease causes millions of deaths it is not a rare disease. There has been a grand total of about 200-ish cases of the mad cow disease cumulatively. Though it terrorized people for years.
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by ogogmad on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:53AM (#25901799)
Maybe you're right, but I heard similar claims about Covid and Ebolavirus when they were still rare. People were saying early last year that you're more likely to die from a car accident than from Covid. So your earlier comment reminded me of that. Perhaps I misunderstood you.
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by gobrewers14 on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:57AM (#25901421)
> 38,000 people die annually in auto accidents...

This argument is nonsensical. https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Not_as_bad_as

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by tjungblut on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:48AM (#25901352)
How many of them die because the car is malfunctioning?
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by kungito on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:54AM (#25901404)
I'd say a more fair phrasing would be "how many of the die from reasons out of their control"? At first I thought this would even out the car and plane fatalities, but actually you can greatly reduce your risk in plane fatalities by avoiding 737 Max while you cannot know who is going to drive into your lane
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by JMTQp8lwXL on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:50AM (#25901369)
Some non-zero amount, though not 100%. But if a life is a life, and we can only lobby politicians for so many things, we could probably reduce more deaths by having higher standards for licensing. And our lobbying efforts could save magnitudes more lives.
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by doix on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:58AM (#25901434)
What really shocked me when speaking to my american colleagues is that you guys have no equivalent of an "MOT". In the UK, for a car to be road legal it needs to hava passed some safety checks. From what I understood, that doesn't exist over there?

Anyone can go, buy a $100 car from some guy on craigslist and drive it around. I'd wager that makes a big difference to road fatalities.

That and the drunk driving. I guess it depends on the place, but in Austin it was awful. I was out drinking with some guys from work, we had maybe 6 beers? Then they all walked back to the office, got their cars and drove home. It made me much more paranoid about crossing the road.

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by jfk13 on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:28AM (#25901646)
> you guys have no equivalent of an "MOT"

It depends on the state: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_inspection_in_the_Unit...

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by tialaramex on Monday January 25, 2021 @10:06AM (#25903929)
Most car accidents are private vehicle use. So it makes sense to compare those against GA (General Aviation, ie not commercial) accidents.

The accidents are much more similar, both in frequency (they happen all the time, with little public interest) and causes.

People fly their planes while drunk or ill, they fly planes that haven't been properly maintained, they fly when the weather is awful and it's recommended not to, they don't have good plans for what they'll do if anything goes wrong, they haven't practised skills they know they might need... and most of the time they came back down safe. But not always.

When people say "Plane crash" they're normally thinking about Scheduled Aviation, at the far end of the safety categories from GA. If you bought tickets to go from one place to another at a particular time, that's scheduled aviation, the aeroplanes used, the crews flying them, even the company operating them is far more closely regulated and as you'd expect the result is far greater safety.

I'd suggest comparing these accidents to bus crashes. A crash in which a greyhound smashes into a gorge and everybody dies would make the TV news, just as a crashed jetliner would. Like the plane, that bus was required to be properly maintained, its driver underwent training including periodic refreshers, and the company operating it is under much more scrutiny than some random guy in a pick-up.

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by kwanbix on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:12AM (#25901527)
That is totally different. Boing did lots of bad decisions to try to fight the Airbus Neo which was much more fuel efficient than their current airplanes.

All of the decisions led to huge changes on the MCAS. But basically nobody was told about it, so pilots didn't know how to react to the changes.

I won't repeat the whole thread, but you can check here:

https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1106934362531155974.html

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by tgv on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:54AM (#25901399)
While the numbers don't lie, your response is in another domain. Are these 38k deaths (which is USA only) caused by manufacturer error, preferably the same model? If not, you're polluting any meaningful discussion.
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by ulfw on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:09AM (#25901504)
The vast majority of car crashes are user error, not manufacturer fault. If it were the latter, you bet there would be inquiries.
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by ramraj07 on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:57AM (#25901419)
It is not just a numbers game. The suits in the offices of Boeing and FAA wantonly misled and hid data that undermined the safety of a plane which was clearly a bad idea to begin with. If a similar incident is uncovered in the auto industry they should also be held accountable to the same extent. Automakers are constantly forced to recall their cars for faults which are not even deliberate so it looks like that system is at least somewhat working. We cannot excuse Boeing with such whataboutism especially safety is at stake.

Flying on an absolute sense is an insane activity. As Louis CK put it, you're "sitting on a chair, IN THE SKY!" The only reason we take it for granted is the Stellar safety record (which is even better than cars?). If all you do is just match the safety profile of ground transportation, the optics of the combination of perception and real events would just grind this industry down. In some ways it's actually bad for the industry in the long term but these suits and their next quarter bonuses don't care about that! Only the public can.

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by wombatmobile on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:50AM (#25901370)
Are you saying 38,000 automobile deaths are caused by defects that the manufacture neglected to fix or warn customers about?

Of course not. So that's a false parallel i.e. whataboutism.

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by eecc on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:57AM (#25901427)
Uh, isn’t “whataboutism” more like: replying with a totally different subject that supposedly has more merit to discussion? False parallel feels a different thing to me
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by wombatmobile on Monday January 25, 2021 @06:53AM (#25902156)
I’m not sure. Perhaps one is a descendant of the other?

I think whataboutism is like

She says The storming of the Capitol was wrong because people died and our institution’s citadel was trashed

And he says

What about the BLM protests - xxx people died and yyy buildings were vandalised at a cost of zzz millions

It seems to be some kind of parallel, but not to draw an analogy - rather to excuse an action by making a distraction out of a superficially similar form(?)

Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by eecc on Monday January 25, 2021 @08:14AM (#25902740)
Hmm, seems like your take is more correct: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
Re:Boeing 737 Max cleared to fly again 'too early' by BelenusMordred on Monday January 25, 2021 @06:28AM (#25902004)
> 200+ fatalities

It was 355 people killed plus one on the response dive team for JT610.