News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by hugh3 on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @07:26PM (#2582133)
At some value in excess of ten billion dollars? I won't be buying.

Sure, they're making huge profits right now. But prices should reflect future earnings potential, and what are they going to be doing in ten, twenty, thirty years from now?

They were the first folks to stumble across the secret of making addictive social games. But I see these as a fad, not a long-term trend. There's only so many variations on [ * ]ville you can play before you get bored of it, and only so many times you can be talked into spamming all your friends.

Sure, maybe they'll keep on adapting and having hit after hit. But what are their real advantages? A few programmers who sort-of know how to make a sort-of good game, and some rather nebulous slice of social graph. Compare to some game publishers who have a lot of experience in making many profitable games instead of a little bit of experience making a couple of variations on just one:

Activision/Blizzard: $12.87 billion

Electronic Arts: $7.75 billion

Take Two Interactive: $1.38 billion

If it's 1967, you might want to buy RCA Records, but you don't want to buy The Monkees. The record company can keep on adapting to changing fashions and business conditions and will keep putting out hits for decades to come, but the band will have a brief revenue spike and then vanish.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by nikcub on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @08:17PM (#2582308)
Zynga has already innovated outside of the ville games, since Farmville was their second big hit after Texas Hold'em. Texas Hold'em is still ranked 4th[1], and if you look at who the developers are of the top games, Zynga completely kills the competition.

They were not the first company with simulation games either, which suggests that they have a secret formula figured out for how to build and market these games. The restrictions Facebook places on viral marketing hurt everybody else and only put Zynga further ahead.

As for IP, the reason why Pincus is a shareholder in Facebook, along with Reid Hoffman, is because Facebook licensed social networking patents from him. He has been in the field for a long time, long before the mainstream press was hot on 'social', and he has significant IP holdings in the space, which are with Zynga.

The other companies you point out are now being prices in the same way music and movie studios are - ie. as hit-based businesses. Gaming budgets have become so large, and so much of it is tie-ins and licensing, that for each of these companies it is one or two big hits or franchises plus dozens of big misses. They are all big, large and inefficient companies - again, no different to the music and movie studios.

The only one of the three performing well is Activision, and that is mostly because of the recurring revenue from the Blizzard merger. Prior to that they were also in a lot of trouble (at the time of the merger they were worth $18B, now $12B). EA has been bleeding money for years and unsure what to do - even their big old hits such as Guitar Hero and the FIFA franchise are costing them money. Take-Two hasn't made a profit in 3 of the past 4 years, and is currently valued at less than the revenue it receives from a single release of GTA - so the market has no confidence in them at all.

It is actually the traditional gaming houses who are having trouble producing constant hits. If Activision lost World of Warcraft tomorrow they would be in a world of trouble. EA and Take-Two already are. The virtual goods market is showing no signs of slowing down, $2B last year and growing at 50%+. This is as big a shift in the gaming market as arcades to consoles was, with EA being the only one of the three making a decent effort in the new market (4th largest, but almost 10 times smaller than Zynga)

Zynga, which represents the 'new model' is over 1,000 employees (vs 7,600, 7,600 and 2202 respectively) and near $2B this year in revenue (vs 4.47B, 3.5B and 0.7B respectively), and while there is a chance that their valuation will enter over-blown territory, there is little doubt that they are absolutely killing the old gaming companies atm. It might not be Zynga that is #1 in 10 years time, but it will be somebody - and atm nobody is even challenging Zynga in this space - but you seem to be arguing against a shift that is by all accounts very real.

Edit: and on the issue of Hold'em - with the government shutting down the online poker sites in the USA it has seen a spike in play, which means it will be in a very good position if UEGA is repealed or if poker is found by a court decision to not be gambling.

[1] http://www.appdata.com/

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by hugh3 on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @08:57PM (#2582426)
Zynga has already innovated outside of the ville games, since Farmville was their second big hit after Texas Hold'em.

Texas Hold 'em is a pretty minimalist form of "innovation". Take a popular card game and put it on facebook? Brilliant!

The virtual goods market is showing no signs of slowing down, $2B last year and growing at 50%+.

This is exactly what I don't believe can be sustained. There's only so long that people are willing to keep buying things that don't actually exist (hey, speaking of which, we haven't had a bitcoin article in a while...)

It might not be Zynga that is #1 in 10 years time, but it will be somebody - and atm nobody is even challenging Zynga in this space - but you seem to be arguing against a shift that is by all accounts very real.

Lots of folks are challenging Zynga in this space. Any one of 'em could have the next big hit, the thing that grabs the attention of a bunch of kids bored with clicking on cows... something with gameplay elements that are actually fun -- a game rather than a Skinner box.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by nikcub on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:28PM (#2582506)
> There's only so long that people are willing to keep buying things that don't actually exist

The same argument was made about digital music, digital movie distribution, etc. ie. people want to buy 'real' things. All that virtual goods means for Zynga is that they have established a freemium model for gaming. It has come full circle from the shareware days - where the first x levels or episodes were free while playing the game further and deeper involved paying for it.

It means that gamers no longer have to pay out $50-100 for a game that they might not even enjoy, it gets a lot closer to paying for the direct entertainment the user receives.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by ignifero on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:46PM (#2582548)
Agree to that, the virtual goods economy is here to stay.
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by ignifero on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @08:30PM (#2582356)
The only innovation zynga did was changing the logos of other games (Farmville=Farm town, mafia wars=mobwars, cafe world=restaurant city, it's as if there's mass brain damage in that company and they can't come up with a single original idea). They are also among the most aggressive game euthanizers: they have shut down all their games that did not generate tons of cash, much to the chagrin of their players.

Let's not forget they have an exclusive agreement with facebook, the terms of which we don't know; not a very fair advantage.

Also, zynga and old gaming houses have different audiences, so i 'm not sure they're killing anyone

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by ansy on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:01PM (#2582433)
I think what you're saying is that Zynga is so good at business it succeeds fantastically despite its products. That translates to a great company in Wall Street terms.

Look at McDonalds. McDonalds certainly didn't invent the hamburger. McDonalds probably never made the best hamburger. But it sure as hell found a way to make money off hamburgers like nobody before.

Those other companies, those are the less capable small fries with handfuls of loyal customers while Zynga is busy expanding its empire to every street corner.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by TillE on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:11PM (#2582467)
That's a good analogy. But McDonald's has a couple of huge advantages that Zynga doesn't.

The first is physical space - they are omnipresent. On the internet, everyone can be everywhere. The second is branding. People know FarmVille. Do they know Zynga? Probably not.

In Zynga's market, anyone could release a great game and have a massive success with little investment. McDonald's has serious momentum; it's utterly impossible to imagine a scenario where a competitor shows up and quickly puts them out of business. Same thing applies to Facebook. Does it apply to FarmVille? Again, I'd say no.

If you see this type of game as a fad, or a mere precursor to much better games that will be offered for the same price (free), Zynga's position is quite precarious.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by Klonoar on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:58PM (#2582570)
The fact that people know Farmville, but not Zynga, doesn't actually mean much. Zynga has been able to shuttle players on to new games and releases very successfully just from advertisements in their then-current swath of properties.

You could play their games and probably never give two shits about the company behind it.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by hugh3 on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @10:27PM (#2582616)
Yeah, but how long can they really keep that up? You can shuffle people from Sim-farm to Sim-town to Sim-restaurant to Sim-space-station to Sim-mafia to Sim-factory-that-makes-little-models-of-factories but someday they're gonna stop paying attention. Games come and go, game genres come and go on a somewhat longer but still finite timescale.
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by Klonoar on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @11:26PM (#2582727)
I'm not debating you on that, since I agree with you. I simply wanted to point out the issue with your point about people not knowing Zynga and that possibly being an issue for them (i.e, it's by and large not).

Even if people knew Zynga I get the sense it wouldn't make a huge difference; their games aren't quite immersive enough to inspire the type of brand loyalty you'd see with Nintendo/Blizzard/etc.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by ignifero on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:19PM (#2582489)
I hate analogies, but i have to note that McDonalds invented the fastfood business. Zynga has shown inability to demonstrate innovation and acts opportunistically. If they shut down today, they 'd be instantly replaced by other existing social games. "A business that makes nothing but money is a poor business".

That's just the view i have of them. It would be nice if we could have the opinions of a Zynga employee.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by far33d on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @11:47PM (#2582768)
I would normally chime in but this thread feels like a witch hunt with a lot of people who don't know what they are talking about pretending to be experts.
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by rudiger on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @01:07AM (#2582957)
"People who don't know what they're talking about pretending to be experts" pretty much sums up Hacker News.
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by ignifero on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @07:18AM (#2583570)
having an opinion hardly makes one expert
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by nikcub on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:30PM (#2582509)
> McDonalds invented the fastfood business.

It can be argued that Zynga invented the new freemium and social gaming model - ie. pay for the entertainment you get. They also pioneered a lot of the marketing and the in-game viral aspects.

This is why they can release average or even clone games and still find hits - in the same way McDonalds can release a bad burger but because of their model still be a success.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by ignifero on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:43PM (#2582538)
No, no and no. Games like mob wars, farm town etc had these features already. If they pioneered something, it's "pushing facebook's communication channels to their limits"; I honestly cannot remember anything else.
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by ansy on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @10:19PM (#2582605)
To be fair with the analogy, McDonalds did not invent fast food. Drive ins and walk up fast food burger joints were everywhere before McDonalds started.

McDonalds just took efficiency to a whole new level. It used processes that pushed modern cooking equipment to its limits and invented a few new tools to fill the gaps. One store could serve and reach so many more customers every day for so much less than the competition. Combine that with repeatable best practices and an expansionist vision and you've got an empire.

By the same analogy, Zynga took that same social game model and jacked up conversion rates to the max. It pushed social networks to the limits and invented new tools to fill the gaps. It got more money from each user and had more users than anyone else. It took this formula and repeated it again and again with an expansionist vision.

Mob wars, farm town, etc looked the part, but the way those businesses operate isn't in the same league. Talk about physical presence, Zynga has multi-millions of users in 100% Zynga owned virtual real estate every day. All it needs to do is mention a new game to its millions of users and that game has an instant million user base. For a no-name competitor to do the same would require millions in marketing or a miracle.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by jcampbell1 on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:09PM (#2582461)
World of Warcraft is an Everquest knockoff. From an investment perspective, I am mixed about whether Zynga's lack of originality is a positive or a negative.
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by puredemo on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @07:46AM (#2583614)
"It's not who does it first, it's who does it second."
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by trotsky on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @07:53PM (#2582215)
It's hard to believe a company that only a couple of years ago was relying on scammy CPA deals to float itself and mostly churns out formulaic gamified skinner boxes for facebook users is looking at a public valuation north of $10B. I've been wrong plenty of times before, but I certainly won't be a buyer here, especially considering Eric Tilenius' comments last week that an appreciating IPO is a sign of a poorly priced IPO. Given lofty private valuations compared to existing gaming properties, the apparently opportunistic timing and a stated propensity to price at the top of the market it's hard for me to believe Zynga will even manage to keep pace with the S&P.
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by yid on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @07:34PM (#2582159)
I think your argument is that Zynga, essentially being a video game company like the other three you mentioned, can innovate itself out of the -ville space once people start getting bored out of it. While this is certainly possible, we haven't seen any hint of innovation from Zynga remotely at the level of Blizzard, etc. This makes their long term prospects questionable, and thus I would be wary of their IPO.

I also would be extremely wary of a company that is so reliant on a fickle third party for its very existence. Unless of course all this Zynga exuberance is at the prospect of a Facebook buyout...

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by hugh3 on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @07:43PM (#2582185)
My argument isn't that they can, it's just that they'll have to. I don't see any particular reason to suppose that they actually will, though, and that's why I personally wouldn't touch this deal with a ten-foot pole.

Unless of course all this Zynga exuberance is at the prospect of a Facebook buyout...

Does facebook have enough cash to buy Zynga at these valuations? I doubt it. (But they do have programmers who could clone Cityville in two weeks, and the ability to ban Zynga from their system with a few keystrokes if they felt like it...)

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by kmfrk on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @07:48PM (#2582196)
Another thing relevant to your argument is the brand value of the companies you mention. People initially buy Blizzard games, because they are Blizzard games.

Will it ever be possible for a company like Zynga to do the same? I generally find it hard to promote the company brand in browser- or mobile-based games.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by noahth on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @08:14PM (#2582298)
Zynga has proven their ability to cross-promote new games to their existing userbase again and again, most recently with FrontierVille and CityVille (although these games were - and still are - also bolstered by extensive advertising through Facebook ads, CPI campaigns, etc). They currently run 3 of the top 5 apps by MAU - CityVille, FrontierVille, & Texas HoldEm Poker, at about 90MM, 46MM, and 35MM MAU respectively. Even their "customer loyalty" Facebook Connect site (RewardVille) is a top-25 FB app (about 25MM MAU).

In my own experience, it's also the only FB games company that most laypeople (people who neither work in tech/social games nor play Facebook games) recognize.

It's hard to say whether they'll ever achieve the stature or reputation of a Blizzard, but I can't even think of many traditional game companies that enjoy the same type and intensity of customer loyalty that Blizzard does. Maybe Valve? Very few people buy every EA title but the Madden franchise has incredible loyalty... where does something like that fit into a comparison like this?

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by johnrob on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @08:03PM (#2582263)
What Zynga, Facebook, LinkedIn, Groupon (and other current hits) have in common is that they have found a way to serve customers all around the world. How many business can really do that? It's easy to underestimate them because we forget to multiply the value created times 6 billion (or whatever the current world population is).
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by ssharp on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @08:28PM (#2582348)
Groupon isn't reaching people like Zynga, Facebook, and LinkedIn can. Those three sites are, at their core, web-based through the entire business.

Groupon requires sales people linking with local businesses to offer coupons. Groupon cannot scale like those other companies. Anyone in Uganda can access Facebook by just going to Facebook.com, logging in, and start finding people. The same people in Uganda can look at the Groupon site, but they'd get no use out of it because the coupons aren't local.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by johnrob on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @08:33PM (#2582365)
True - but a sales office is all they have to add. There's no shipping of inventory that Apple or Honda have to deal with.
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by ignifero on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @07:42PM (#2582180)
The thing with Zynga, is they have zero innovation and zero IP capital. You might as well invest in a chinese ripoff and it would be the same. Sure they make tons of profits but they will never earn my respect. They stole everyone else's ideas, continuously spammed and manipulated their users, and did every horrible trick in the book. That's not hacker attitude; that's borderline criminal. To illustrate, here is a post in facebook's forum from Pincus himself, trying to make excuses for gambling ads they'd been running on games: http://forum.developers.facebook.net/viewtopic.php?pid=12983...

I would buy. I would sell before the end of the day though.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by noahth on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @08:42PM (#2582390)
I'm not saying that they're a paragon of virtue or anything, but if you don't have respect for Zynga's abilities then you're missing some really valuable insights. Sure, they "ripped off" the idea for almost every game they've ever made, but as many commenters here love to point out, it's not just the idea that matters, but the execution (setting aside for now the point that everyone steals ideas - remember when those jerks at Google "ripped off" the idea of a search engine?).

Zynga didn't just make another farm game, they used their familiarity with FB's viral channels to make it the biggest silly little farm game on the platform. Then they turned around and used that audience as a springboard for a number of other games that, while derivative, were simply the strongest distillations of their respective types.

I get it, everyone loves to hate Zynga, but the fact is that they are really good at what they do, and lots of people out there enjoy their games.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by ignifero on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @08:52PM (#2582413)
As an indie fb game developer, i 've been following zynga over the years. Their spam tactics were the reason that facebook started changing their platform policies every month. Zynga took advantage of the fact that facebook at the time was not enforcing its app policies (remember forced invites?) so they maxed out their reach by using shady tricks and consistently breaking or bending the ToS. I remember me and other devs complaining to facebook for months and nothing was ever done. When facebook started limiting viral channels, zynga was already too big to be touched.

In the process, they destroyed many indie developers and the fear of being wiped by zynga is still everpresent. Personally, i find it hard to love anything about them, even after years. I 'm not jealous of them or their profits, but i find it hard to wish them "good luck". Maybe if they had started their own social gaming network i'd give them some credit. Zynga is still a parasite on facebook.

Here is a relevant answer from a former facebook engineer: http://www.quora.com/Will-Zynga-leave-Facebook

Here's them posting fake reviews of their games: http://forum.developers.facebook.net/viewtopic.php?id=41577

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by hugh3 on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @08:59PM (#2582428)
I 'm not jealous of them or their profits

Y'know, I think it's perfectly legitimate to be jealous of their profits.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by narrator on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @07:53PM (#2582216)
IMHO, Zynga's moto should be "There's a lot of money in stupid".
Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by orangecat on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @12:34AM (#2582869)
The thing with Zynga, is they have zero innovation

From a technical perspective, that's true. The innovation is the application of psychology to extract money from their customers via software Skinner boxes. Arguably evil, definitely profitable.

Re:Zynga About to File for IPO by ignifero on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @07:49AM (#2602182)
But still hardly innovative behaviorism