> There's only so long that people are willing to keep buying things that don't actually
exist
The same argument was made about digital music, digital movie distribution, etc. ie. people want to buy 'real' things. All that virtual goods means for Zynga is that they have established a freemium model for gaming. It has come full circle from the shareware days - where the first x levels or episodes were free while playing the game further and deeper involved paying for it.
It means that gamers no longer have to pay out $50-100 for a game that they might not even enjoy, it gets a lot closer to paying for the direct entertainment the user receives.
Texas Hold 'em is a pretty minimalist form of "innovation". Take a popular card game and put it on facebook? Brilliant!
The virtual goods market is showing no signs of slowing down, $2B last year and growing at 50%+.
This is exactly what I don't believe can be sustained. There's only so long that people are willing to keep buying things that don't actually exist (hey, speaking of which, we haven't had a bitcoin article in a while...)
It might not be Zynga that is #1 in 10 years time, but it will be somebody - and atm nobody is even challenging Zynga in this space - but you seem to be arguing against a shift that is by all accounts very real.
Lots of folks are challenging Zynga in this space. Any one of 'em could have the next big hit, the thing that grabs the attention of a bunch of kids bored with clicking on cows... something with gameplay elements that are actually fun -- a game rather than a Skinner box.