News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by cheese_van on Saturday January 16, 2021 @05:50PM (#25806271)
In the context of the various US objections to China, de-platforming narrows one distinction between the Chinese authoritarian treatment of speech and the US's. While all nation-states are hypocritical to a degree, it certainly allows the Chinese to underline this hypocrisy, while providing cover and justification for their own lack of internet speech freedoms. Not a happy trend for free speech absolutists anywhere.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by Barrin92 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:17PM (#25807756)
I don't think there's anything that distinguishes the US more from China than a private platform being able to deplatform the president, rather than be bullied by him.

There is no hypocrisy here. The only relevant rights in the US are the rights of twitter to not be compelled to publish someone's speech, and freedom of association. That unlike in China, Trump is subject to the TOS of Twitter is as American and as free-speech faithful as it gets. The only shameful thing was that Twitter carved out exceptions for him because they were afraid of political retaliation over the last four years.

In fact having the government and the executive exercise influence over private business would make the US more like China, not less. When a politician is kicked off a platform for violating its terms it's not a violation of "free speech", it's the politician behaving like a five year old who says "mom, the other kids don't want me on the playground!" Free speech is not "in your face"-ism. It does not entitle anyone to scream on someone else's property.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by im3w1l on Sunday January 17, 2021 @03:30AM (#25809153)
While he has the chair for a few more days, he is for most intents and purposes a disgraced former leader. China would certainly deplatform someone like that.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by secfirstmd on Saturday January 16, 2021 @05:29PM (#25806127)
Maybe part of the issue is that now is the first time many people in the US actually notice this. When in reality Facebook and similar have been censoring voices for many years. For example Palestinian ones https://jewishvoiceforpeace.org/fb-stop-censoring-palestine/
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by Gibbon1 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @02:48AM (#25809008)
Can also point out censoring Kurd's and Hezbollah. While at the same time allowing ISIS to use their platforms for recruitment.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by intended on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:08PM (#25807396)
Right now everything seems to travel to the intersection of "Free Speech" and "Dangerous speech", creating a massive pile up of conversations going no where.

Arguably this logjam resolves itself if you assume:

1) Everything is content, True/false, wrong/right being labels we use after consuming it.

2) All our social media, every new type of it, all UI/UX, payment models, subscriptions, memberships - simply Amplify or Suppress the propagation of content.

This makes our tech discussions relatively value agnostic, and moves the question to whether

i) the use of these tools was just ii) The extent of force used was just

So yes, all our major firms have this power. ANY firm can have silencing or amplifying power.

The question is how we define the norms, and the empirical evidence we generate that shows us what choices are better than others.

A step below that is the empirics and informational tools we have to do the science.

I used my masters dissertation as an excuse to explore whether a particular rule change on a forum worked. Honestly while it was fun to reach some conclusion, there are major gaps in our toolkits to explore these issues.

Sentiment analysis corpuses for non-english corpuses are definitely one of the data sets we need more off, and we need ways to constantly update these dictionaries. Dealing with code mixed language is another problem.

I'm sure someone has solved this, one of the issues is precisely that cross talk on experiments is low and every discipline is looking at this space.

But that is something you can invest your time in if creating this evidence matters to you.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by 8bitsrule on Sunday January 17, 2021 @01:02AM (#25808558)
Is "censorship" what newspaper editors have done with letters to the op-ed pages for over a century? (Some made it, how many didn't? Most) How many TV News stations air viewer responses? Is that censorship? Those businesses were mostly one-way from choice.

In the same 'over a century' lots of people reacted by starting their own newspapers. Those papers too were 'echo chambers'. How are 'social media' more public? Is 'we guarantee to air everything' part of their TOS? Else, nothing new here.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by quantified on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:08PM (#25807712)
Let’s note that while a bar has to allow the public entry, if your speech or actions inside the bar starts a fight, they can bounce you. No written terms of service needed. Just threatening the bartender might be enough.

People might be deplatformed, but they can still write, publish anywhere that will accept their writing, call people on the phone... do anything they could do in the year 1999, 207 years after the Constitution was established.

Shunning might be just fine in society, it always has been accepted. Look at the racial history of Chicago in 1919 and early 1950’s. Shunning after norms have been breached AGAINST STATED MORALS has been perfectly fine. We’re not talking races or creeds being deplatformed here. It took a lot of provocation.

Maybe we’re being inconsistent and expedient. Soul-searching is called for. I support the ACLU and admire their consistency, they’ve supported the truly reprehensible. Not sure if they’ve ever been called on to defend the deepest taboos, but they’ve gone deep enough. Yet it would be interesting to work through them defending the speech that, for example, exhorted people to kill ACLU attorneys. I imagine there are limits somewhere.

Trumbo breached someone’s norms and was deplatformed. He forced the world to allow his redemption. Let’s see the deplatformed show themselves worthy of redemption.

And there need to be some well-thought-out movements to address aome of the causes that get folks to go so over the edge. There are many causes, economic, educational, societal. Flat-out bigoted neighborhoods are more likely to crank out flat-out bigoted generations, that’ll be a hard one for a long time. But less “us” v “them” could be accomplished.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by anothernewdude on Sunday January 17, 2021 @02:28AM (#25808934)
Bars do not have to allow the public entry, indeed that's half the work of bouncers.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by quantified on Sunday January 17, 2021 @01:54PM (#25813659)
You’re right, I was thinking of even neighborhood bars. Along those lines, is it not the case that Twitter, FB and all other social-media sites could institute user vetting and behave more like a club? Some services are invite-only already. Obviously changes the business model, just pointing out the perfect legality.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by Mountain_Skies on Sunday January 17, 2021 @04:26AM (#25809397)
Curious how Doctorow justifies the practice of disemvoweling, a passive aggressive form of censorship that boing boing used to silence people they didn't agree with but who weren't violating the terms of service of the site. Also wonder how all of this fits in the depersoning of Violet Blue from boing boing.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by emptysongglass on Sunday January 17, 2021 @08:28AM (#25810480)
This actually happened to me way back in the day when I called out Doctorow on Boing Boing for his relentless use of the platform as a soapbox for self-promotion.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by xhkkffbf on Sunday January 17, 2021 @11:46AM (#25812194)
He can be very weaselly on these things. It's nice that he hasn't lost his general support for free speech -- as some people have done all too willingly. But the disemvoweling is definitely born of fascist impulses.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by ilaksh on Saturday January 16, 2021 @06:34PM (#25806577)
I think the answer is decentralized protocols.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by typenil on Saturday January 16, 2021 @11:47PM (#25808228)
"Go make your own Facebook"

Then AWS takes down Parlor. And so many on Hacker News rejoice.

"Go make your own AWS"

Where does that end? Go make your own domain registrar? Go make your own ICANN? Go make your own ISP? Go make your own internet? Go make your own microchips?

If some virtue signaling Silicon Valley execs want to impress their friends, you're done.

Oligarchy. Has nothing to do with capitalism or democracy. It has to do with internet points and social standing for elite tech executives.

Looks far more like McCarthyism or totalitarianism than anything resembling a free democracy.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by maxerickson on Sunday January 17, 2021 @08:27AM (#25810474)
There's no mechanism to force a private business to do a thing and the comparison you reach for is totalitarianism. It's incoherent.

There probably should be a serious discussion about how access to platforms is mediated, but there's a pretty big chance that you end up asking for an expansion of government powers if you say the companies aren't free to do what they want anymore.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by typenil on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:37AM (#25830363)
If the US antitrust machine hadn't been asleep at the wheel for a couple decades, it wouldn't be a problem.

"There's no mechanism to force a private business to do a thing" - but bakeries have to make cakes for gay weddings - which I'm not opposed to.

If the vast majority of tech companies are based in the echo chamber of Silicon Valley, and they're going to ban any thought that falls outside of that narrow range, then political views need to be the next protected class.

Yes. An expansion of government powers. An added protected class. Or antitrust can come out of hibernation. Either way.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by rufus_foreman on Sunday January 17, 2021 @06:48PM (#25816508)
>> Where does that end? Go make your own domain registrar? Go make your own ICANN? Go make your own ISP? Go make your own internet? Go make your own microchips?

Correct. DIY.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by typenil on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:38AM (#25830371)
Yeah, let's forget that taxpayers paid for the internet and so much of the internet infrastructure in US. But it's cool to cut off the people who subsidized it.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by watwut on Sunday January 17, 2021 @05:15AM (#25809579)
> Then AWS takes down Parlor. And so many on Hacker News rejoice.

That is because AWS takedown of Parler is the one that is best argued. Largely due to Amazon having to respond to Parler suing them, but result is pretty convincing document.

So you kinda now have to make argument for why Amazon should be forced to continue to host Parler despite all that.

> Go make your own AWS"

AWS has 30% of market and Oracle have same API. There are options beside do own. Moreover, Parler have Mercers money funding, they are not poor nobodied without resources and backing.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by permille42 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @02:37AM (#25808969)
You don't need Facebook to communicate your ideas to others.

You don't need AWS either. AWS is actually a backwards development of technology in my opinion because it is anti-open source.

It is quite straightforward to lease your own server and/or build your own and colo. You can even easily setup containers on such, or a cluster of them if you desire.

You also don't need a domain name to host a site. Plain IP addresses work fine in many situations. There are plenty of "shady" countries who will let you register DNS and do whatever you want with it.

Just look at the underground pirate community. None of this weak censorship by silencing Facebook posts is stopping them. Piracy will continue to the end of time, because if you have a bit of tech skill there is very little that can silence a person on the modern internet.

And yes, p2p ( without internet ) file sharing is alive and well. Those in draconian environments engage in it. Swapping 12tb drives is quite effective in sharing data.

Own microchips? Yeah we are heading that way. Hence the popularity of Risc-V and various "open hardware". Typically it is sufficient to use your own software stack on existing hardware though.

SV execs can't do shit about public opinion or the underground community.

The free exchange of information is alive and well. It just doesn't live on Facebook or Parler or any of that crap.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by inglor_cz on Sunday January 17, 2021 @06:27AM (#25809887)
You do not need even electricity. People lived without power for thousands of generations and some still live like that.

It still would not be fine if there was a class of outcasts defined by execs of power distribution companies on whim.

The "you do not need" standard is a tricky one. Modern civilization is built around a lot of network-like structures. Getting kicked off them is a kind of punishment. We generally have some mechanisms that try to prevent capriciousness in punishment.

Would you rather do a year in San Quentin or be completely deplatformed by Big Tech forever? I would probably choose the former. Being prevented, for example, to send any e-mail to anyone with Gmail.com address is a serious problem.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by permille42 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @07:07AM (#25810071)
I would be delighted to be banned from all technology for eternity. I would wear the ban like a badge of honor and devote my life to the advancement of something more noble such as mathematics.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by inglor_cz on Sunday January 17, 2021 @08:15AM (#25810410)
If you are the kind of talent that can make significant contributions alone, that is a viable (and enviable) way of life.

But if you need to co-operate, that is really hard to do without tech. I used to do some work in algebra 20 years ago and mathematicians were one of the first branches to network extensively. It happens all too often that the other person who is interested and knowledgeable about the same arcane problem lives several time zones away.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by permille42 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @09:28PM (#25817487)
As a child I took math books to bed with me.

I only got a single question wrong on the math portion of the SAT, and frankly SAT math is extremely easy. I just wasn't taking it seriously enough.

I took Calculus my first semester and scored over 98 on every test. No one else in the class scored above 80 on any of the tests. The teacher was dumbfounded.

I, of course, have a degree in mathematics... Undergrad math was... boring.

The only reason I didn't continue down the path of high level math is because it isn't profitable. It is also hell on the mind. Few understand that but it is very easy to get lost in a world of math if you are good enough at it. It consumes your entire mind. It is somewhat beautiful in that way, but doesn't lead to one become very balanced as an individual.

Cooperation is for pussies. Those who make the biggest difference in history are those who give zero shits about anyone else and devote their lives to furthering what they pursue. Very few teams can hold a candle to a dedicated prodigy.

There are these things called books. There are tons of them. They hold far more useful information that can be absorbed very rapidly compared to talking to people. Communicating with people live is... slow... tedious... and unrewarding.

Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by benibela on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:12PM (#25812465)
Imagine living in a monastery with no technology besides bolt, chord, and sphere
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by permille42 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @09:30PM (#25817502)
A true visionary does not require technology, or at least definitely not computers.
Re:EFF, Cory Doctorow warn about the dangers of de-platformi... by Mountain_Skies on Sunday January 17, 2021 @04:23AM (#25809381)
>You don't need Facebook to communicate your ideas to others.

Interesting, that is the same point conservative judge Robert Bork used to make, and while not the only reason why he was rejected for the Supreme Court, it was certainly a factor. Weird how someone like Bork, who used to be considered on the far fringe of conservativism, is now part of mainstream liberal orthodoxy.