Similar setup is planned also for the Dukovany NPP but not yet built.
Modern efficient district heating (hot water pipes with thick insulation instead of the old steam based systems) is quite popular around here and thermal power plants or waste incinerators are often run in co-generation mode where they produce both electricity and district heating.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by pfdietz on Friday January 15, 2021 @10:15AM
(#25791854)
A problem here is that heat is very easy to store. So if one can make heat from intermittent power (say, resistively, or with some kind of heat pump) then storage becomes much less of an issue than if one wanted to store the electrical energy itself.
In any environment where renewable power is being curtailed, the cost of using that power to make heat will be very low. Nuclear heat will be competing against a very low cost alternative.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by epistasis on Friday January 15, 2021 @12:09PM
(#25793172)
And for rough napkin math on costs, electricity to heat via a heat pump generates 3x as much heat as electricity used to move the heat. Whereas the nuclear plant goes from 50% efficiency to 100% efficiently, only a 2x gain for using the nuclear reactor for heat rather than for electricity.
So excluding the extra cost of the heat pump, and the cost savings of nuclear not needing a turbine and waste heat rejection system, renewables are starting out ahead. We would really need to see some real world systems to fully evaluate costs.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by pfdietz on Friday January 15, 2021 @02:20PM
(#25795021)
It's been proposed to use this sort of thermal store to store electrical energy, by converting the heat back to power using a thermal cycle. If a heat pump were used the efficiency might not be TOO bad. The per-energy cost of such a system could be an order of magnitude less than batteries.
One interesting side of this is that it admits extremely cheap "assurance" storage. That is: if one has a fuel to heat the thermal store when needed, then this can provide an assured source of power in the event of very rare prolonged outages that deplete the usual store. The marginal capital cost of adding this capability could be a factor of 3 less than that of providing dedicated gas turbines (using hydrogen, say) for that assurance.
that postulates 50% efficiency for five day round-trip storage, and other people think they can hit 80% or so (about the same as pumped hydo). Thanks for the pointer!
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by pfdietz on Friday January 15, 2021 @10:28AM
(#25792001)
Firebrick or silicon carbide. The latter could store heat up to 1800 C, and act as its own resistive heater. Firebrick is century old technology, used for regenerative heating of air in steel making (outgoing gas heated firebrick, then air was drawn through that on the next pass, with two banks of firebrick being used in alternation).
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by LinuxBender on Friday January 15, 2021 @10:38AM
(#25792094)
I learned something new today. I was going to use kiln-fired bricks for a rocket mass heater, but I had never heard of silicon carbide bricks. They cost a lot more $10 vs $3 but for a small project, those are perfect. Thankyou!
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by bassman9000 on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:02AM
(#25792339)
I don't know if you can store that much heat (hundreds of °C), for that long, and with no price fluctuation due to variability of an external heating supply.
One of these SMR hooked to your factory can provide it, at probably higher temps, enabling more processes, 24/7, and at a less variable cost, not having to rely on external supply.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by sradman on Friday January 15, 2021 @12:04PM
(#25793114)
> Recent experience suggest that the SMR producers could face the same cost overruns and delays that have plagued makers of utility-scale reactors. An even bigger challenge could be convincing industries and utilities to forgo cheap natural gas.
Off-the-grid remote locations is the obvious market for electricity generation currently addressed with diesel fuel. Combined electricity/heat for large campuses and remote communities seems like another popular use case.
This article makes the case for high temperature industrial processes like the manufacture of Portland cement. I'd like to see an economic analysis but I can't see this being a viable option unless carbon emissions regulation penalizes fossil fuels.
Geography not only determines what is and is not available on-grid (electricity and/or natural gas) but the regulatory regime which can significantly impact design decisions.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by sandworm101 on Friday January 15, 2021 @12:29PM
(#25793435)
>> Off-the-grid remote locations is the obvious market
The difficulty is that while these reactors are, somewhat, portable they are still massive heavy things. Any "remote location" with a road that could carry one of these things probably has a power line running alongside that road too. It would be great to have one of these at any number of high arctic communities, but getting them there is probably not possible other than by ship to coastal ports. Even then, the crane requirements probably preclude most ports. They need to be lighter if they want to push into remote communities.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by sradman on Friday January 15, 2021 @01:06PM
(#25793932)
Great point. Do we have a comparison point with diesel generators in terms of the largest module that cannot be broken down further? I suspect that there is a seasonality to the roads too and let's not forget that some communities may be accessible by ship/barge.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by sandworm101 on Friday January 15, 2021 @03:44PM
(#25796159)
Ship/barge still require cranes and piers capable of handling such loads. Diesel engines come in literally any size one wants, from suitcase to aircraft carrier. Seasonal roads, soft surfaces roads, probably won't be able to handle such loads even when open.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by toomuchtodo on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:41AM
(#25791454)
This and heating districts with any power provided as an extra benefit are far better use cases for this technology than trying to compete with renewables, batteries, hydro, and transmission, most especially in markets where they absolutely need the heat but are also attempting to avoid CO2 emissions to obtain said heat.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by tomatotomato37 on Friday January 15, 2021 @10:07AM
(#25791754)
I agree. Nuclear is one of our cleanest and most advanced methods of producing heat/steam, but the tech for creating power from said heat/steam is lagging behind the more direct methods seen in newer technologies. In my opinion this is why concentrated solar & geothermal also lag behind their more conventional renewable cousins.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by rich_sasha on Friday January 15, 2021 @10:14AM
(#25791847)
I'm mildly pro nuclear, but even then I'm not sure I'd have one of those near people. Minor incidents happen frequently, but they would be so much severe, or at least scary, if there's thousands of people within a mile of the device.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by gwbennett on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:07AM
(#25792397)
The U.S. Navy nuclear program has developed 27 different plant designs, installed them in 210 nuclear-powered ships, taken 500 reactor cores into operation, and accumulated over 5,400 reactor years of operation and 128,000,000 miles safely steamed. (source Wikipedia)
Many of these have operated in and around the most densely populated ports and cities in the world.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by koolk3ychain on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:23AM
(#25792563)
That said, all of these reactors have been on platforms surrounded by water and are occupied by hundreds if not thousands of trained (some highly trained) crew 24/7. It goes without saying that many of those crew are also armed or directly tasked with ensuring nobody can tamper with the nuclear power source / any part of the platform. I should also add a very good friend of mine is a nuclear engineer who works on submarines.
I'm not sure it's even fair to compare the operational discrepancies of something as simple as a test / training reactor to a nuclear heat source at a concrete plant?
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by jhayward on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:51AM
(#25792904)
You should know, then, that the cost to design, build, and operate those reactors was orders of magnitude higher than any commercial plant that would be competitive.
The problem with nuclear is primarily cost, cost, cost, and then scale, security, and waste.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by gwbennett on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:27AM
(#25792600)
One of the keys to the US Navy's success is standardization of reactor design, components and training. A sailor can go from one sub to the next and find the reactor plant nearly identical in operation and design as the other within the same class of ship.
Nearly every commercial plant is different in design and components. Imagine if every company you worked for designed, built their own operating system and computers.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by toomuchtodo on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:39AM
(#25792745)
Yes, exactly. Have the Navy design, deploy, and operate reactors for that very reason. They've already done it, instead of startups attempting to start from zero. Even if you don't generate a profit, or operate at a reasonable loss, you're projecting soft power a la China's Belt and Road while providing humanitarian and environmental benefits.
You might even deploy them as marine vessels in ports [1], so that in the event of a (hopefully rare!) catastrophic failure, flooding the reactor with water is trivial.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by foxyv on Friday January 15, 2021 @03:20PM
(#25795837)
I try to think about nuclear energy the same way I think about chemical hazards. Chemical spills are happening all the time and we hardly notice unless we are ordered to evacuate. Nuclear seems a lot more scary, but it's not really much more dangerous than a LOT of industrial chemical plants.
In addition oversight for Nuclear is WAY better. If there is a breach we're way more likely to know, rather than wondering why everyone in a certain Indiana town is getting a rare form of cancer from an unreported chemical spill.
Risk tolerance wise, I would rather have one of these running next door, than having a steel plant 20 miles away...
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by walleeee on Friday January 15, 2021 @04:25PM
(#25796732)
Just spitballing, but if we're going to play with things like nuclear reactors, why not keep them and their waste relatively close to human settlements specifically in order to promote a culture of responsible management?
This is founded on the proposition that everyone trying to push ecological costs somewhere else, somewhere "over there", can be way more dangerous to human wellbeing than the occasional natural disaster or accident.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by vosper on Friday January 15, 2021 @01:15PM
(#25794050)
There’s a good Omega Tau podcast episode froma few weeks ago, called “Modern Fission Reactors”, that covers modular reactors (and many other interesting reactor topics)
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by nabla9 on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:52AM
(#25791586)
Technically these only for heating reactors are sound business case. From the investor, regulator, customer perspective there are many problems that are not startup solvable.
1. End-of-life and maintenance guarantees. Transferring nuclear waste and processing them is not cheap. You need to put capital aside to pay for these. Startup going bust and leaving customers to handle with the rest is not an option.
2. Regulations and safety. Just like standard nuclear, you need government subvention (not direct money transfer, but a law that puts upper cap to damages).
You can solve these with scale. If you build 1000s of standardized units of small heating reactors, special waste management and transportation solutions for just this type becomes economical. If they sell only 500, lifetime cost can be astronomical.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by gruez on Friday January 15, 2021 @10:57AM
(#25792276)
>there are many problems that are not startup solvable.
>1. End-of-life and maintenance guarantees. Transferring nuclear waste and processing them is not cheap. You need to put capital aside to pay for these.
Why isn't that solvable? You just provided a solution, ie. rather than charging $100k for a reactor, they'll charge $100k + $20k disposal fee (to be put in a trust or something). Why can't this be done by a startup?
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by samcheng on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:11AM
(#25792455)
The cleanup costs for a nuclear reactor can be more than the construction cost, and novel / experimental reactor types can present major challenges after decommissioning.
Your trust idea is a good one, maybe with some insurance added, but it really does impact the economics of the project.
That said, nuclear reactors as thermal generators are a great idea, particularly for e.g. cement manufacturing, which is a huge producer of greenhouse gasses. This is one area where I support nuclear over wind/solar.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by gruez on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:30AM
(#25792636)
>cement manufacturing, which is a huge producer of greenhouse gasses
AFAIK most of the co2 is from the chemical reaction itself, not the heat source used. From wikipedia:
>First, the limestone (calcium carbonate) is burned to remove its carbon, producing lime (calcium oxide) in what is known as a calcination reaction. This single chemical reaction is a major emitter of global carbon dioxide emissions.[10]
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by nabla9 on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:44AM
(#25792815)
Because of Economies of scale.
There is nonlinear decrease in the cost per unit when the number of units sold increases. The total cost per unit depends on how many units are produced.
If you process the waste from few units, the disposal fee per unit is very expensive. If you sell thousands of units, you can plan for very large scale standardize disposal procedure that drives down price to fraction what it for small number of units.
Customers don't want to pay for startup risk. So first 100 - 500 units sold could be too expensive.
You could solve this problem by selling the company to someone big, like Berkshire Hathaway Energy. They have shoulders to take the risk and money to do the capital investments when the time comes.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by 08-15 on Friday January 15, 2021 @12:49PM
(#25793696)
> Transferring nuclear waste and processing them is not cheap.
Actually, it is, because there is so little of it.
However, in the Nuclear Waste Policy Act of 1982, the US government declared that only the US government can handle nuclear waster, and nuclear power plant operators have to pay into a fund so that the waste handling will be funded. It then spent the following 38 years doing a grand total of exactly nothing, forcing the power plant operators to store the waste. And not for lack of funds, because the Nuclear Waste Fund sits an an unspent $45 billion.
Please stop pretending nuclear waste was either a financial or a technical problem. It's purely a political problem.
> a law that puts upper cap to damages
Which US law places a cap on damages caused by nuclear power plants?
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by ncmncm on Saturday January 16, 2021 @12:23PM
(#25803648)
> ... unspent $45 billion
Which has, of course, long since been spent. When anything is done, we will be taxed for it. $12B was handed over to contractors for work done on Yucca Mountain.
Wikipedia:
> "US court of appeals ruled that nuclear utilities may stop paying into the nuclear waste ... The fee ended May 16, 2014."
> "Lacking an operating repository, the federal government initially paid utility companies somewhere between $300 and $500 million per year in compensation for failing to comply with the contract it signed to take the spent nuclear fuel by 1998. For the ten years after 2015 it is estimated to cost taxpayers $24 billion in payments from the Judgment Fund. The Judgment Fund is not subject to budget rules..."
So, $47b was collected from ratepayers for extra-high-cost power, and sent to the govt. Now, taxpayers are paying out $2.4 billion, every year, directly to nuke operators, who pocket it. ($2.4b would buy a pretty big solar farm.)
When something is determined to do about the waste, there will be no nuke ratepayers left, at several times the cost of renewables -- or operators, except those kept open to collect their $2.4b. Instead, taxpayers will pick up the bill. Again.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by ncmncm on Saturday January 16, 2021 @05:13PM
(#25806017)
"Stolen"? Government subsidized the nuke plants for much more than $47b. The $47b was extracted from ratepayers, but is not being returned to them. If anyone is stealing, it is the nuke plant owners.
Re:Small modular nuclear reactors may help polluting industr...
by jansan on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:09AM
(#25792429)
Trump issued an executive order on Janurary 12th with the title "Executive Order on Promoting Small Modular Reactors for National Defense and Space Exploration"
https://inis.iaea.org/search/search.aspx?orig_q=RN:20085809
Similar setup is planned also for the Dukovany NPP but not yet built.
Modern efficient district heating (hot water pipes with thick insulation instead of the old steam based systems) is quite popular around here and thermal power plants or waste incinerators are often run in co-generation mode where they produce both electricity and district heating.
In any environment where renewable power is being curtailed, the cost of using that power to make heat will be very low. Nuclear heat will be competing against a very low cost alternative.
So excluding the extra cost of the heat pump, and the cost savings of nuclear not needing a turbine and waste heat rejection system, renewables are starting out ahead. We would really need to see some real world systems to fully evaluate costs.
One interesting side of this is that it admits extremely cheap "assurance" storage. That is: if one has a fuel to heat the thermal store when needed, then this can provide an assured source of power in the event of very rare prolonged outages that deplete the usual store. The marginal capital cost of adding this capability could be a factor of 3 less than that of providing dedicated gas turbines (using hydrogen, say) for that assurance.
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2020.0016...
that postulates 50% efficiency for five day round-trip storage, and other people think they can hit 80% or so (about the same as pumped hydo). Thanks for the pointer!
One of these SMR hooked to your factory can provide it, at probably higher temps, enabling more processes, 24/7, and at a less variable cost, not having to rely on external supply.
Off-the-grid remote locations is the obvious market for electricity generation currently addressed with diesel fuel. Combined electricity/heat for large campuses and remote communities seems like another popular use case.
This article makes the case for high temperature industrial processes like the manufacture of Portland cement. I'd like to see an economic analysis but I can't see this being a viable option unless carbon emissions regulation penalizes fossil fuels.
Geography not only determines what is and is not available on-grid (electricity and/or natural gas) but the regulatory regime which can significantly impact design decisions.
The difficulty is that while these reactors are, somewhat, portable they are still massive heavy things. Any "remote location" with a road that could carry one of these things probably has a power line running alongside that road too. It would be great to have one of these at any number of high arctic communities, but getting them there is probably not possible other than by ship to coastal ports. Even then, the crane requirements probably preclude most ports. They need to be lighter if they want to push into remote communities.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_road
Many of these have operated in and around the most densely populated ports and cities in the world.
I helped operate 3 of them. No issues.
I'm not sure it's even fair to compare the operational discrepancies of something as simple as a test / training reactor to a nuclear heat source at a concrete plant?
The problem with nuclear is primarily cost, cost, cost, and then scale, security, and waste.
Nearly every commercial plant is different in design and components. Imagine if every company you worked for designed, built their own operating system and computers.
You might even deploy them as marine vessels in ports [1], so that in the event of a (hopefully rare!) catastrophic failure, flooding the reactor with water is trivial.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_floating_nuclear_power...
In addition oversight for Nuclear is WAY better. If there is a breach we're way more likely to know, rather than wondering why everyone in a certain Indiana town is getting a rare form of cancer from an unreported chemical spill.
Risk tolerance wise, I would rather have one of these running next door, than having a steel plant 20 miles away...
https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/california/articles/...
https://apnews.com/article/27ee93094ce81e2522bd495138db9554
https://apnews.com/article/61b2a91a8e4042f1a8d43e734551f159
This is founded on the proposition that everyone trying to push ecological costs somewhere else, somewhere "over there", can be way more dangerous to human wellbeing than the occasional natural disaster or accident.
https://omegataupodcast.net/359-modern-fission-reactors/
1. End-of-life and maintenance guarantees. Transferring nuclear waste and processing them is not cheap. You need to put capital aside to pay for these. Startup going bust and leaving customers to handle with the rest is not an option.
2. Regulations and safety. Just like standard nuclear, you need government subvention (not direct money transfer, but a law that puts upper cap to damages).
You can solve these with scale. If you build 1000s of standardized units of small heating reactors, special waste management and transportation solutions for just this type becomes economical. If they sell only 500, lifetime cost can be astronomical.
>1. End-of-life and maintenance guarantees. Transferring nuclear waste and processing them is not cheap. You need to put capital aside to pay for these.
Why isn't that solvable? You just provided a solution, ie. rather than charging $100k for a reactor, they'll charge $100k + $20k disposal fee (to be put in a trust or something). Why can't this be done by a startup?
Your trust idea is a good one, maybe with some insurance added, but it really does impact the economics of the project.
That said, nuclear reactors as thermal generators are a great idea, particularly for e.g. cement manufacturing, which is a huge producer of greenhouse gasses. This is one area where I support nuclear over wind/solar.
I hope this works!
AFAIK most of the co2 is from the chemical reaction itself, not the heat source used. From wikipedia:
>First, the limestone (calcium carbonate) is burned to remove its carbon, producing lime (calcium oxide) in what is known as a calcination reaction. This single chemical reaction is a major emitter of global carbon dioxide emissions.[10]
About half, I think (depending on the fuel used).
Cement manufacture is a major destination for supposedly "recycled" plastic, btw. Cement kilns are very flexible on fuel quality.
There is nonlinear decrease in the cost per unit when the number of units sold increases. The total cost per unit depends on how many units are produced.
If you process the waste from few units, the disposal fee per unit is very expensive. If you sell thousands of units, you can plan for very large scale standardize disposal procedure that drives down price to fraction what it for small number of units.
Customers don't want to pay for startup risk. So first 100 - 500 units sold could be too expensive.
You could solve this problem by selling the company to someone big, like Berkshire Hathaway Energy. They have shoulders to take the risk and money to do the capital investments when the time comes.
Actually, it is, because there is so little of it.
However, in the Nuclear Waste Policy Act of 1982, the US government declared that only the US government can handle nuclear waster, and nuclear power plant operators have to pay into a fund so that the waste handling will be funded. It then spent the following 38 years doing a grand total of exactly nothing, forcing the power plant operators to store the waste. And not for lack of funds, because the Nuclear Waste Fund sits an an unspent $45 billion.
Please stop pretending nuclear waste was either a financial or a technical problem. It's purely a political problem.
> a law that puts upper cap to damages
Which US law places a cap on damages caused by nuclear power plants?
Which has, of course, long since been spent. When anything is done, we will be taxed for it. $12B was handed over to contractors for work done on Yucca Mountain.
Wikipedia:
> "US court of appeals ruled that nuclear utilities may stop paying into the nuclear waste ... The fee ended May 16, 2014."
> "Lacking an operating repository, the federal government initially paid utility companies somewhere between $300 and $500 million per year in compensation for failing to comply with the contract it signed to take the spent nuclear fuel by 1998. For the ten years after 2015 it is estimated to cost taxpayers $24 billion in payments from the Judgment Fund. The Judgment Fund is not subject to budget rules..."
So, $47b was collected from ratepayers for extra-high-cost power, and sent to the govt. Now, taxpayers are paying out $2.4 billion, every year, directly to nuke operators, who pocket it. ($2.4b would buy a pretty big solar farm.)
When something is determined to do about the waste, there will be no nuke ratepayers left, at several times the cost of renewables -- or operators, except those kept open to collect their $2.4b. Instead, taxpayers will pick up the bill. Again.
Of course. But not on anything related to nuclear waste. In plain language, it has been stolen by the government.
If you don't like the taxpayer having to pick up the tab left by incompetent politicians, you should have voted differently.
https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/executive-or...
Seems like this will be a thing in the not too distant future.