Re:Signal community: Reminder: Please be nice
by detaro on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @10:33AM
(#25763210)
Presumably if it's a "decent bug report", needing additional feedback etc is less likely, and I assume GP is more talking about bug reports that are not really usable without further information. (Although even if you are careful at providing information, you can easily hit cases where more information is needed)
Re:Signal community: Reminder: Please be nice
by andrew_ on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @11:04PM
(#25771830)
This presumes that all opened issues are decent. It also presumes that the author of the issue responds to feedback. What I would quantify as drive-by issues include poorly written, lacking information, or providing information that results in a follow up reply from other users or maintainers with a fix or ask for more information that goes unanswered.
"library X fails with this input" is great, unless the input is wrong, the usage is wrong, or the environment is awry - and those issues are useless if the author doesn't reply to follow up replies.
Re:Signal community: Reminder: Please be nice
by account42 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:41AM
(#25773776)
Closing bugs because they don't contain enough info and the reporter is not responsive to providing the required info is commpletely fine. Closing based on inactivity alone is just rude.
> "library X fails with this input" is great, unless the input is wrong, the usage is wrong, or the environment is awry - and those issues are useless if the author doesn't reply to follow up replies.
They could still be a hint that the documentation or reported error could be clearer.
Re:Signal community: Reminder: Please be nice
by andrew_ on Thursday January 14, 2021 @10:08AM
(#25777148)
We disagree. My experience with several extremely large projects has yielded the judgement that closing tickets which are years old without activity is prudent, as is setting a reasonable time frame in which an issue is too stale.
I strongly disagree. Follow-up and collaboration are great, but someone taking the time to write a decent bug report is also valuable.