News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by meekmockmook on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:17PM (#25708008)
Every single player in this saga deserves nothing but contempt. Trump is reprehensible and his supporters are brainwashed. Big Tech conglomerates now openly disenfranchise and deplatform millions of people simultaneously through a coordinated effort. The implications for the future of speech and dissent are terrifying. Just disgusting and depressing in every way. An internet utopianist's nightmare.

I don't want to live in the United States of Trump. I don't want to live in the United States of Dorsey, Bezos, Zuckerberg, and Pichai. The only way out is through sweeping antitrust enforcement against the entire tech industry.

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by fooey on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:22PM (#25708077)
Parler is openly and proudly hosting violent content.

Their entire claim to fame is hosting the content no one else will host, but the obvious downside is no one will host you if that's your business plan.

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by dilyevsky on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:27PM (#25708150)
I’m sure yandex, alibaba, tencent and many more smaller us hosters will be happy to host them.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by wila on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:35PM (#25708268)
Most smaller hosters won't do this as their upstream will give them the boot when they do.

Hosting parler with one of the Chinese alternatives would be pure irony.

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by dilyevsky on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:38PM (#25708320)
Source of any tier1s doing this? Hosting on platforms whose employees are like 95% “libs” is already ironic
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by userbinator on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:42PM (#25708383)
...or whoever hosts 4chan currently.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by skygazer on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:37PM (#25708302)
parler.ru or parler.nk might be available.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by dilyevsky on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:40PM (#25708351)
Parler.ru is up for sale for roughly two grand
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by meekmockmook on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:25PM (#25708127)
Facebook and Twitter have been hosting violent content for years and years. Facebook has contributed to mass murder. Twitter to countless suicides. Far more deaths can be attributed to their platforms than some goofy right wing startup. These are facts. Big Tech's scale and power means they can exempt themselves from the rules they create.

Are you really telling me Mark Zuckerberg has less blood on his hands than this John Matze guy? After literal genocides were coordinated via WhatsApp?

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by cmorgan31 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:44PM (#25708433)
No, you have a valid point that social media in general needs consideration from all kinds of angles from mental health impacts to legal requirements of platforms. I think people just don't care at the moment because it's targeting a legitimate bees nest of home grown far right groups which range from comical gravy seals to retired vets. It doesn't invalidate the point that these platforms only took this step when administrations were clearly changing behind the scenes which isn't honestly that surprising if you've seen how they treat foreign nations. So after we finish dealing with the app that's platforming the groups actively announcing plans for an armed round two of Wednesday on Jan 17th we should take a hard look at how much power we yield to technology giants.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by gamblor956 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:32PM (#25708228)
True, but the violent content is an extremely small portion of the content on their sites, and they act quickly (and sometimes over-zealously) to remove such content when they find it.

Parler does not, and in fact their lack of moderation was their key selling point.

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by meekmockmook on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:36PM (#25708284)
So because Twitter and Facebook are larger and have more resources to stamp out illegal activity (which they still do poorly), that means the violence, death, and algorithmic propaganda should be acceptable to host on their platform vs another? Makes no sense.

Rules GAFA creates do not apply to themselves.

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by gamblor956 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @01:48PM (#25718013)
No, that's not what I said and you know it.

Twitter and Facebook don't deliberately host illegal activity, and they stamp it out as best they can. Given that their have hundreds of millions of users in multiple languages posting billions of posts every day, it's a very difficult job and a lot of it requires users to report posts containing illegal activity so they can act on it. (And on that note, I have reported posts on Facebook for illegal or harassing content, and they took down those posts and acted on the offending accounts within 2 hours every time.)

I won't defend FB's or Twitter's algorithms. Based on recent reporting, it appears that internally employees are attempting to change the algorithm so hopefully something will come of that.

Parler and Gab have chosen to market themselves to groups known to engage in violent and illegal activity. Notably, moderate and liberal posts and accounts are immediately deleted or suspended on Parler, while right-leaning posts of any kind and degree of violence remain on those sites indefinitely. This indicates that Parler and Gab have the ability to moderate posts on the basis of content, and simply choose not to.

[dead]
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by dang on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:08PM (#25709787)
Accounts created just for ideological battle aren't allowed here. Please don't create accounts to break HN's guidelines with.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by Tronno on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:28PM (#25708167)
I've been seeing this take a lot, generally without counter recommendations. If ejecting extremists from polite society is not an option, then what is?

Some have suggested seeing things from their perspective, and engaging with them in some way. However, it is clear that they do not want to argue in good faith, and have become completely separated from logic and reality.

No action at all is a decision in favor of the status quo, with the obvious outcomes. What, then, is the alternative?

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by dukeofdoom on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:39PM (#25708341)
Not all of their grievances are crazy. Like asking for an independent audit of votes totals in the contested states. I'm not even American, and I would have loved to see that happen for the sake of transparent elections in the world. Instead we got Gaslighting from the media, and governors that absolutely refused.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by Pfhreak on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:22PM (#25708081)
Wait, should Amazon be obligated to host an app being used to organize anti-government violence?
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by meekmockmook on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:23PM (#25708092)
The entire backbone of the internet should not be in the hands of less than 5 companies.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by MontyCarloHall on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:32PM (#25708218)
AWS is hardly a single vertebra in the entire backbone of the internet. I’ll start worrying when Tier 1 carriers start blocking traffic. Until then, Parler is free to find another hosting solution.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by eropple on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:31PM (#25708205)
The typically suggested counterproposal is state control of what is functionally a utility.

And while the First Amendment definitely applies to political speech, it does not apply to threats, which are a large part of Parler's stock in trade.

So what's your alternative?

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by Pfhreak on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:31PM (#25708214)
That's an answer to a different question. You and I might agree there, but that's not an answer to the question I asked.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by one2know on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:36PM (#25709323)
Exactly, Centurylink demonstrated a couple months ago they alone could take down and disrupt IPV4 traffic worldwide. I'm starting to wonder if that was a simple configuration mistake or a pre-run.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by asiando on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:29PM (#25708184)
Yes. If the content is illegal, it's up to the government to censor it.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by Pfhreak on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:35PM (#25708273)
So, the only content that a company should be able to remove should be illegal content?

Think through that a bit. There is tons of content that we remove from services constantly that isn't illegal.

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by asiando on Sunday January 10, 2021 @01:03AM (#25711150)
And that’s fine? What if AWS doesn’t like your business and gives you 24 hours to vacate the premises?

I think hosting should be treated like ISPs, which cannot force you out of internet.

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by Pfhreak on Sunday January 10, 2021 @11:07AM (#25716022)
I don't see a problem with your question. Yes, if Amazon gives you 24 hours, then you move somewhere else.

What's your concern? Do you think AWS should be required to host violent insurrectionists?

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by CogitoCogito on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:38PM (#25708322)
If you want this to be the case, you're going to need to push for laws to be changed. AWS is absolutely _not_ forced to host code it doesn't want to host.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by Angostura on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:22PM (#25708083)
> his supporters are brainwashed

So, it would seem that there is a problem here. What could possible solutions be? Perhaps attempting to stem the flow of the radicalisation and brainwashing?

> Big Tech conglomerates now openly disenfranchise and deplatform millions of people simultaneously through a coordinated effort.

OK, so you don't like that approach to stopping brainwashing. What is your preferred solution?

Would you like government to instead mandate that web platforms must continue to enable the brainwashing?

Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by asiando on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:22PM (#25708076)
I was ok with Facebook doing it, I'm not ok with a hosting kicking a paying customer out like this.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by loopz on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:24PM (#25708121)
This is what "cloud" means.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by canofbars on Sunday January 10, 2021 @01:52AM (#25711616)
Problem is there is no alternative. You can't just run your own server because your ISP can still cut you off.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by loopz on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:00AM (#25712558)
Which is what free enterprise and privatization means.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by chevman on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:28PM (#25708171)
Easy come, easy go!
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by linuxftw on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:24PM (#25708113)
Hosting companies have been doing this long before the app store or twitter existed. You just didn't hear about it.
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by doodlebugging on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:42PM (#25708388)
I don't see a problem. To me it is similar to the situation where a business is allowed to refuse service to anyone at their own discretion. This has been used to discriminate openly but is still legal. The customers they were refusing to serve were also paying customers.

There has to be a point beyond which some things are simply not allowable. In the past, societies have grown and prospered by codifying sets of standards by which others judge your behavior and then to define and apply sanctions to those who refuse to play by the rules laid down by society. This is how laws came to be passed that allow or restrict behavior widely seen by society as criminal, undesirable, dishonest, etc.

We (any group of citizens or people with a common interest) need to be able to agree upon whether something should be allowed and once that determination is made, codify the law and define appropriate sanctions or punishments for those who choose to color outside the lines.

It is generally accepted that promoting violence, advocating for murder of others because they exercise their right to vote for a different party, providing support to those whose goal is to sow dissent and to divide the citizenry using lies and propaganda, supporting Nazis or other reprehensible characters, etc is simply not copacetic and those who choose that path should face sanctions.

The very least that you should do is to silence the messenger whose goal is to destroy you, your relationships, your society. Use their own message against them to educate everyone about why the things they are promoting are wrong and unacceptable.

Rock and Roll Amazon!

[dead]
Re:Amazon, Apple and Google Cut Off Parler by meekmockmook on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:39PM (#25708343)
I am terrified that Trump supporters will respond to attacks on their ability to peacefully communicate with direct violence. We are entering an era where nobody believes in peace anymore.