News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by throwawaygulf on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:03PM (#25695284)
Can't have any wrongthink out there.
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by SN76477 on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:12PM (#25695414)
Too many conversations inciting violence.
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by throwawaygulf on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:07PM (#25696774)
Everyone repeats this orthodox line as if it's true, but there's rarely any evidence for it.

Can you post three Parlor links that supposedly contain "calls to violence" here?

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by SN76477 on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:47PM (#25697160)
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by throwawaygulf on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:09AM (#25697365)
That is two separate screenshots stitched together from posts that were removed within an hour for inciting violence.

Multiple leftists calls to violence posted on reddit: https://redstate.com/brandon_morse/2019/06/29/reddit-ignores...

I'll ask again, since you didn't even follow the instructions: post three links from Parlor that show calls for inciting violence. I'll wait.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by Proven on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:29PM (#25695584)
So what?

Every platform has them. They get reported and removed.

Fortunately we don't have to use company stores. I use Gab in the Web browser.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by cauthon on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:19PM (#25696128)
I’m confused. You don’t think social media platforms should remove posts inciting violence, because the posts will get removed by the platform?
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by asdf333 on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:34PM (#25696402)
the supreme court has repeatedly affirmed that speech that incites violence is not allowed.
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by akhilcacharya on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:52PM (#25695811)
For those not aware, Gab is notable for having a bunch of QAnon adherents post regularly.
[dead]
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by akhilcacharya on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:19PM (#25696129)
I'm struggling to see where I said that.

I will, however, state the fact that many of the people who participated in the insurrection on Wednesday, of which a large cross-section believe in QAnon and wore QAnon paraphernalia, have been fired from their jobs or have been imprisoned.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by Fjolsvith on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:15PM (#25696079)
Haha, socker moms are fascist!
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by inawarminister on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:09PM (#25696000)
Aye, like the ol' Red Scare. Purges are good an' all. After all, their worldview is too scary to tolerate, beyond the pale.
[dead]
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by chillwaves on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:49PM (#25696594)
You are all over these threads just trolling with nonsense.

That's against our community guidelines.

It'd be a service to the community if HN banned you.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by another_sock on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:54PM (#25696642)
Yes we should ban everybody who shows open disagreement and doesn't take the party line in the serious manner we see fit.

I am not trolling, I am highlighting the absurd manner in which so many HN commenters have suddenly become champions of Stalinistic censorship by all these multinational corporations.

Yes, it's a great idea for the community to ban people who say things which are unpopular. That will lead to a very healthy community filled with free thought and critical thinking.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by shadowgovt on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:32PM (#25705001)
The failure to put any constraint leads to 4chan.

Optimum is probably somewhere between the extremes. But the QAnon conspiracy thrives in the 4chan laissez-faire extreme.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by another_sock on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:54PM (#25706505)
The people who think 4chan is some existential threat to society rather than anti-social people and people with autism blowing off steam and being mean to each other are the people who aren't very familiar with 4chan. 99% of it is just shitposts, the other 0.9% is people who aren't doing anything bad, the 0.1% is removed.
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:37PM (#25696432)
If you'd like to post some wrongthink on my personal blog, or the ardour.org forums, or even right here on HN, just let me know. I'm sure we can arrange something.
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by throwawaygulf on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:25PM (#25696950)
As long as you're honest, philosophically even-keeled, and apply the rules consistently, let's go.

But for some reason, I have this feeling that that's not the case. If you're pro-safetyism, you're anti-truth, anti-facts, pro-illogic, and are against wrongthink.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:35PM (#25697050)
Well, I admit that the first location was a purely rhetorical ploy, because even I don't post on my personal blog anymore, and we'd prefer not to have a forum site about a digital audio workstation cluttered with unrelated posts.

But I think my point is clear: there are oodles of places you can write and post whatever you want. Even here on HN, you can say a great deal of stuff that others will consider wrong without being "censored".

I'm certainly against "wrongthink" which is just a stupid re-use of a literary trick currently being massively over-referenced online in response to various events today. There's wrong, there's false, there's stupid. There isn't any wrongthink in my conception of the world.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by throwawaygulf on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:48PM (#25697175)
>But I think my point is clear: there are oodles of places you can write and post whatever you want.

Awesome, so we agree there are oodles of places BLM and leftists can protest that are not high traffic roads, freeways, main streets, federal courthouses, etc. They can protest in the Mojave desert, they won't be censored there.

>I'm certainly against "wrongthink" ... There's wrong, there's false, there's stupid. There isn't any wrongthink in my conception of the world.

Awesome, so we both agree with the objective fact that Blacks commit more violent crimes per capita than any other race. That's a fact, that's neither wrong, false, nor stupid.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:37AM (#25697619)
Conflating arbitrary electronic messaging systems and public protest, despite obvious relationships between the two, doesn't seem very relevant or useful to me.

And sure, your second paragraph states a fact. But facts are fairly useless without context, and as David Byrne sang 3 decades ago (and no doubt many others wrote in centuries before that) "facts all come with points of view". A fact by itself is just a fact, and in many contexts (particularly if the fact is an observation about human behavior/society), not very interesting. The interesting part is: what do you plan to do with it?

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by throwawaygulf on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:51AM (#25697734)
>Conflating arbitrary electronic messaging systems and public protest, despite obvious relationships between the two, doesn't seem very relevant or useful to me.

There's no conflation, Twitter and Facebook are the modern day public square.

>But facts are fairly useless without context

False.

>The interesting part is: what do you plan to do with it?

Nothing. That mere fact will most likely get [flagged] and [dead]ed within the next 24 hours specifically because it is "wrongthink". If you don't agree with my above post being flagged and deaded due to being an inconvenient fact, then we are actually in agreeance.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:54AM (#25701963)
> There's no conflation, Twitter and Facebook are the modern day public square.

I've argued against this POV here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25648997

That said, I'm not opposed to them becoming the modern day public square. It just doesn't happen because a bunch of people think it already has. New legislation to make social media a public utility? I'd support appropriately constructed forms of that. But de facto isn't de juris, and for now these are private corporations running their own private messaging systems.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by throwawaygulf on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:34PM (#25703771)
>I've argued against this POV here

And spoonjim and ghaff kicked your teeth in.

>That said, I'm not opposed to them becoming the modern day public square.

Saying that "you don't need to use FB/Twitter, you can write your own blog" is like saying in 1789 "You don't need to be allowed to distribute your pamphlets in front of Faneuil Hall in Boston, you can exercise your free speech on the top of a mountain in Colorado."

To which you said: >Being able to speak "only" from one's own blog only makes discovery difficult, it does not limit people's access post-discovery.

This applies to a random mountain in Colorado as well. Discovery is difficult, but after people discover it, they're free to go back ad much as they want.

>But de facto isn't de juris

That's literally how "town square" is defined, de facto, not de jure. You're literally arguing for our position without realizing it.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:41PM (#25704512)
in 17XX, the mountain top in Colorado (a) wasn't even a part of the country (b) even if it was, remained several thousand miles of arduous cross-country travel from the entire population of the newly emerging state. People would almost certainly die en route to hear your pontifications. There's zero comparison with a browser address bar.

Even if you posit the top of Mt. Washington rather than a peak in the as-yet undiscovered (by northern Europeans) Rockies, the difference remains unchanged in more or less every essential way.

And actually, "town square" isn't defined at all, de facto or de jure. In the USA, there's essentially no standing right to speak in a public place. You can't be stopped based on what you say, but you can routinely be stopped from speaking at all.

This is, perversely, one of the things that makes London's Hyde Park Corner so unique: there is an accepted policy (not law) that you can't be stopped from speaking there unless engaged in incitement. This fallacy of "the public square" is just that - a fallacy. Since independence (and certainly before it), there was no freedom to speak in a public space without being blessed by some authority.

It was only the printing press that was really "free speech" , in the sense that you could print anything and make it available and the 1st amendment could not prevent access to it.

And btw, "kicked your teeth in" as a description of that thread exchange seems like a great reason to avoid further interaction with you. ghaff was supporting my POV, and spoonjim's comment was downvoted (and incidentally wrong). Even if they had both disagreed with me and presented a cogent argument supporting their positions, "kicking teeth in" is a particularly violent metaphor that I prefer to see left unused.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by throwawaygulf on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:45PM (#25707660)
>in 17XX, the mountain top in Colorado (a) wasn't even a part of the country

Which is relevant, since Parlor and other small sites may not have servers on the country due to the big corporation squashing them.

>even if it was, remained several thousand miles of arduous cross-country travel from the entire population of the newly emerging state.

Exactly like how there's no promises now that small blogs will be indexed, will be cancelled with AMP, may outright be banned by ISPs and CDNs, etc.

>People would almost certainly die en route to hear your pontifications.

Packets would almost certainly "die" en route as well due to what's laid out above.

>There's zero comparison with a browser address bar.

Wrong, it's really apt. Thanks for fleshing it out actually.

So bring it forward now like I originally stated: BLM and other leftists can protest in areas that are not high traffic roads, freeways, main streets, federal courthouses, etc. They can protest in the Mojave desert, they won't be censored there. The can all drive there easily, by no means dangerous. Probably safer than the "town square" in many of the Democrat ran cities.

>And btw, "kicked your teeth in" as a description of that thread exchange seems like a great reason to avoid further interaction with you.

You admit defeat and don't have a response, that's fine.

>spoonjim's comment was downvoted

Can't have any wrongthink now can we.

>and incidentally wrong

No it wasn't, it was 100% right, and you didn't have a response.

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by awhitehat on Monday January 18, 2021 @10:02PM (#25829515)
What if, like parler or what happened to Alex Jones, there isn't 'oodles of places' to go, because silicon valley acts in a coordinated-like fashion?

Is it censorship then?

Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by SerLava on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:30PM (#25695600)
The CEO said he wouldn't stop crimes happening on there
Re:Parlor has been removed from Google Play by throwawaygulf on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:25AM (#25697950)
[citation needed]