News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by zten on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:58PM (#25653528)
I think people are usually pretty happy with living in those areas. They like being able to drive and park at things easily. It’s just the kids who are less thrilled with needing the mom and dad taxi.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by tolbish on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:38PM (#25653793)
I wonder if this has been studied by researchers. Is this a genuine preference or rather something akin to Stockholm syndrome?

Something tells me the average American who moves to a mass-transit friendly city is happier than someone from a mass-transit city that moves to a car-centric city.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by majormajor on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:53PM (#25653889)
Even in cities with mass transit in the US, there's a substantial wealthy population that chooses car (or helicopter!) commutes (they might not be commuting daily, though, or driving themselves when they do) over transit ones, so with people for the means for either, it's definitely not a 100% preference for mass transit.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by munk-a on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:23PM (#25654048)
It's weird though since in the US people actively fight against mass transit. Even if you're not personally riding on mass transit it's a public service that helps the local economy thrive - people just get silly minded and all the NIMBY arguments start coming out.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by whatshisface on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:30PM (#25654407)
A proven track record of local government incompetence and private-public fleecing makes large civil projects much less popular than they would be in a perfect world.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by astrange on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @02:11AM (#25655341)
Mostly it's because they think black people will ride the subway to their house and rob them. This is why Atlanta suburbs vote down every MARTA extension and fare change.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by whatshisface on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @10:13AM (#25658412)
I guess we have several competing hypotheses, how might we go about finding out the true answer?
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by munk-a on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @01:54PM (#25660855)
I'd take a look at how often crime statistics come up during discussions of expanding public transit options - up here in BC and when I lived in Boston that was the primary argument against expansion... Public transit stations "cause" a raise in crime rate and lower (detached) home values.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by perryizgr8 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:03PM (#25654272)
> It's weird though since in the US people actively fight against mass transit.

It's kind of understandable that people protest against having their money stolen and used to build things they don't like. Why do you think it's weird?

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by epistasis on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:35PM (#25654696)
No, it's completely illogical from every aspect. Even if the person is going to drive no matter what, and only wants to improve their own experience for least cost, the dollar for transit improves their road experience more than a dollar for more road infrastructure. And even those roads are mostly funded by general funds, not through gas taxes. Gas taxes and user fares fund roughly equivalent amounts of roads and public transit, respectively. And 80% of federal transportation money goes to roads.

The only explanation that's possible is extremely short-sighted and self-defeating selfishness: seeing something that's not for them and instinctively opposing it, without thinking of the bigger picture. It's just childish.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by Uberphallus on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @03:31AM (#25655758)
It's not weird, it's just extremely short sighted.

It's exactly like socialized healthcare: somehow the US system manages to be more expensive than anywhere else in the world, ranks among developing nations, yet people will fight fang and teeth against "communism".

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by nine_k on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:41PM (#25654160)
On Manhattan, a taxi is very often slower than subway (especially compared to the express trains), but it gives you more privacy, and more room to put your baggage.

It's a balancing act.

A helicopter is theoretically great, but in practice helipads on Manhattan were removed in 1980s because of several spectacular crashes, so it's only practical between e.g. the financial district and the airports, which is probably where all the customers are anyway.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by runarberg on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @01:03AM (#25655028)
Helicopter commuting is so wasteful and awful it ought to be illegal. Why should I have to suffer the noise pollution of some rich asshole riding a marginally quicker commute? In fact while they are allowing helicopter commute, they should pay everyone in on the commute path $100 in compensation, and then another $1000 to the state for the air pollution and the carbon emission.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by nine_k on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @01:09AM (#25655052)
Maybe this is why helicopter "commute" in NYC mostly happens above water, where a car or a train is not such a good option.

The cheapest I know is $400 from Manhattan to JFK; I could probably use it in a pinch (say, a transatlantic flight with a connection), if split between four passengers.

Police helicopters and fire trucks are much more bothersome sources of noise.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by runarberg on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @03:29PM (#25661977)
I’m fine with the noise pollution if it means potentially saving someones live. However some rich asshole wanting do depart 20 min later then otherwise, to the airport is unacceptable.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by tolbish on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:37PM (#25654132)
Cities with mass transit are still lacking compared to cities across the world. The NYC subway is a very different (and inferior IMO) experience than the London subway.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by colinmhayes on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:47PM (#25654190)
London subway doesn't operate at night which is enough to say new york's is better imo.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by andrew_ on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:21PM (#25654636)
Is that a recent change? I swear my wife and I used it after midnight back in 2016.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by Leherenn on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @02:24AM (#25655397)
Some lines are open on Fridays and Saturdays nights since 2016.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by jgwil2 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @02:01AM (#25655294)
They run night buses along the same routes though.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by refurb on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:07PM (#25654298)
Yup. I spent some time in Singapore which has one of the most extensive mass transit systems in the world. Yet the demand for cars is still very high, even with a massive ($70k USD) licensing fee and 100% import duty (Corolla costs $70k USD).
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by cma on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:39PM (#25654147)
I can't imagine more than 1 in 20,000 helicopter commutes every day in the US, but I couldn't find a number.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by omosubi on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:10PM (#25654311)
I be surprised if 1 in 20k _rode_ in a helicopter every day, let alone commuted
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by nradov on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:08PM (#25654303)
People have a genuine preference for good mass transit, and they also have a genuine preference for large private homes. Those two preferences are in direct conflict.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by zten on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:39PM (#25654715)
This is kind of what I was trying to get at. People have made a choice, because they were forced to make one, and they chose detached suburban living. It has good and bad points, for sure.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by quantumwannabe on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:47PM (#25653850)
Something tells me the average American who moves from a mass-transit city to a car-centric city is happier than someone from a car-centric city that moves to a mass-transit city.

People are allowed to like different lifestyles than you without being victims of Stockholm syndrome.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by supertrope on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:07PM (#25653979)
The US government subsidizes houses in suburbs by guaranteeing mortgages and building toll free highways. Apartments are literally illegal to build in many areas (restrictive zoning). Property developers are mandated to include ample free parking. So in many places you are not allowed to have a different lifestyle than drive everywhere.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by quantumwannabe on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:12PM (#25654600)
First off, you get all the same mortgage benefits with a condo or townhouse; those benefits are not just for single family houses [1]. The Seattle area has an urban growth boundary [2, see the red line] that effectively bans construction of new single family housing. The Seattle government also makes it impossible to get a project approved if it has "too many" parking spots and the the vast majority of the transit system is not paid for by its riders: Sound Transit, Seattle's train and express buses, has around 30-40% farebox recovery of operating costs, and capital costs are fully subsidized [3, Page 8]. King County Metro, the bus system, has a farebox recovery of around 25%, again with capital costs being fully subsidized [4, last graph]. User fees (tolls, car registration, gas taxes, etc.) pay a far larger percentage of roads than this: Washington collects 63.5% of road spending from user fees, which is a figure that includes both capital (new roads) and operational (maintenance on existing roads) costs [5]. So someone living in the Seattle area who wants to have a "different lifestyle" has to pay to subsidize the government's preferred lifestyle. Seattle isn't the only region with a strong bias towards transit (especially with new development), so generalizing across the entire country isn't helpful as different areas have very different urban planning cultures.

[1] https://www.irs.gov/publications/p530

[2] https://www.kingcounty.gov/property/permits/codes/growth/GMP...

[3] https://www.soundtransit.org/sites/default/files/documents/2...

[4] https://kingcounty.gov/depts/transportation/metro/about/acco...

[5] https://taxfoundation.org/states-road-funding-2019/

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by tolbish on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:36PM (#25654116)
Most Americans don't really have a choice. Even the most transit-friendly American cities like Seattle were created with job sites that lie in isolated hovels outside of denser areas. And changing this requires planning across multiple industries, not just the efforts of a couple companies.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by quantumwannabe on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:40PM (#25654447)
Funny you should mention Seattle as it is possible the worst city I have ever lived in with regards to infrastructure, both in terms of amount per capita and maintenance. Most of its white collar jobs are concentrated in one small area (in contrast to other regions which are more distributed) and it has the infrastructure of a much smaller city. The local government believes in only expanding transit infrastructure while leaving roads and bridges to rot, and so far their actions haven't improved travel times at all but they do certainly cost an enormous amount: the most recent ballot proposition allocated almost a billion dollars per mile of rail.

I've found this urban design has created isolated neighborhoods where people without cars refuse to travel more than a mile away from home. An example that comes to mind is friends living in Capitol Hill refusing to visit any restaurant in Fremont, a distance of around 3.5 miles with both locations being located directly on highly trafficked bus lines, but if offered a ride (in a car) they would come. For comparison, when in the car-centric cities I lived in, people were willing to travel anywhere in the metro area. Now this is just a few pieces of anecdotal evidence, and you may reply with examples of people who behave completely differently, but it's no better to assume that everyone hates driving and living less dense areas just because you personally dislike them. I prefer living in an area that doesn't hate cars with a passion, and I'm far from the only one who thinks so.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by runarberg on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @01:16AM (#25655080)
The bus network in Seattle is completely busted. Try riding a bus from Bellevue to the International District on a game night before covid. There is simply not room for more people on the busses, nor is there room for more busses on the Third. Seattle needed this extra rail like 20 years ago.

But I think you are wrong about the focus here. They just opened the downtown tunnel recently, and they are opting to fix the West Seattle bridge even though they won’t be able to fit a train to it. They are also fixing the 520 bridge to Kirkland without a train line. And all the roro ferries have significantly more frequency then the walk on ferries (except for West Seattle). So cars definitely still weigh heavily for the city planners

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by zten on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:57PM (#25654522)
Huh, I came back and found my comment to be more polarizing than expected...

I am unsure where the preference lies. I don't always think there's a preference, but you can get forced into it by other economic factors. Young people move into a city, getting adapted a mass transit lifestyle, but they move to a more car-centric area when they inevitably get priced out of car-free living downtown or on a popular rail/bus line because they want to start a family. Personally I don't really want to give up being able to walk outside and down the street to go to restaurants and shop or connect to transit easily, but it would be short-sighted to say that everyone has the same preferences as me.

There's benefits to living in a detached house with a yard. The price is usually being tethered to a car in the US. If you pick a low density area you're probably not going to have an oppressive commute and running errands will be easy (if predictably lengthy, but knowing it'll always be a 20 minute drive and not 20-60 minutes based on traffic is valuable) because there's large roads and every business was mandated to build a large parking lot.

The problem comes when inevitably other people make the same decision and development happens and more people move in. A Californian pattern of development (and in the many areas of the country that have since copied this pattern) is incredibly hostile to good public transit, but due to the geometry of cars, you inevitably have to do _something_... it's just probably going to suck and get underused. So, an alternative strategy emerges: fight tooth and nail against growth.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by Can_Not on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @12:05AM (#25654816)
> I came back and found my comment to be more polarizing than expected...

You basically said "people who disagree are mostly children".

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by zten on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @01:06AM (#25655041)
Whoops. Wasn't actually trying to say that. But thanks for the explanation.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by trianglem on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @02:46AM (#25655493)
Sharing things sucks. I’ve lived in both situations and much prefer rural-20-minutes-from-a-city to living in a city.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by throwaway201103 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:44PM (#25653831)
I think it's subjective, and maybe related to what you grew up with.

I moved to Chicago in the 1990s, lived there for about 10 years. The mass-transit was very good, but I wasn't happy living there.

Move to a smaller town with basically no useful public transit, but am vastly happier.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by cambalache on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:33PM (#25654101)
But that is not a fair comparison. You need to compare moving from NY, Amsterdam,Berlin, Madrid, Shanghai, Singapore, big cities with good public transportation to any big America city https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ZDZtBRTyeI
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by technothrasher on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:21PM (#25654044)
I'm a definite small town country person. I think even my town of 5300 people is getting too big for me these days, and I couldn't imagine being happy living in the city or even a bigger suburb. But if I had to live in a city, good public transit would be a must. I spent a week in Paris a few years ago getting around everywhere on the subway and enjoyed it immensely. On a later trip I spent one day driving in Paris and was ready to shoot myself.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by mypalmike on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:52PM (#25654762)
Even the buses in Paris are pretty great. About halfway through my last visit, I switched almost entirely from subway to buses. They aren't necessarily the fastest way to get across town, but I found them clean and convenient, and just a great way to take everything in.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by rektide on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:20PM (#25654028)
> I think people are usually pretty happy with living in those areas. They like being able to drive and park at things easily.

yeah people probably are pretty happy with their situation. it probably works pretty well for them. they probably respond extremely negatively to any other possibilities. they'd tell you they wouldn't want to use public transit or bikes or whatever else. they couldn't imagine how inconvenient that would be. that sounds terrible to them.

but like, people across broad parts of Europe don't think of biking as inconvenient. people with good public transit don't think of it as inconvenient. i far prefer getting on the bus to taking my car, negotiating traffic & parking. at my last job, it took a couple months of trying it, but eventually i started to far prefer a bike commute to the bus, even though it was pretty long & hilly.

so much of our preferences is comfortability with the known, familiarity. the expressed preference of society, often, it turns out, matter for very little, reflect primarily bias, not intelligence or wisdom or what makes us (individually or collectively) happiest. and all too often these things we imagine serve us, they hold back society. they feed our id, they feed our ego, and the deny a greater super-ego, a better way, that we could better enjoy.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by rootusrootus on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @12:11AM (#25654835)
> so much of our preferences is comfortability with the known, familiarity

Well that, and weather. Only die-hards like to bike in the Pacific Northwest winter. Frigid, wet, windy. I'd rather bike in snow.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by rpedela on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:14PM (#25654002)
I grew up in Cincinnati. You are correct, however traffic is bad enough now that a subway or light rail would make a big difference. Unfortunately it is unlikely the voters would approve a tax increase to support that.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by mywittyname on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:21PM (#25654373)
It's not that people wouldn't approve a tax increase to support it. The issue is that every politician in the state would attack a light rail project for the city.

The city managed to complete a street car after ten years, but it faced opposition from the mayor, the governor, and federal congressman. The congressman in question even pushed a law that would prohibit any federal funding from going to the operation of the project. How fucked up is that? A congressman who prevents federal funding from flowing into their district.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by mbg721 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @09:55AM (#25658257)
Cincinnati in particular also suffers from a hodgepodge of local government entities that don't really get along. The bus system is run at the county level, but the city limits end before that. Anecdotally, a friend of mine claims that his family voted against the early-2000s light-rail plan on the basis that it would have resulted in the City of Deer Park being downgraded to a village.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by bernawil on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:49PM (#25654484)
But is it fair to compare light rail with subways? Seems to me light rail is the worst of all worlds: Slow, low carrying capacity, subject to the same traffic as cars and probably expensive.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by mywittyname on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:58PM (#25654529)
On a technical level: no.

On a political level: yes.

The political opposition to the project had nothing to do with preferring a technically superior form of public transportation. Instead, it was opposition to public transportation in general.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by bernawil on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:27PM (#25654660)
That sounds fair, but another pov: I'm pretty much in favor of subways but I'd be opposed to any light rail project in a heartbeat.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by astrange on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @02:14AM (#25655353)
Light rail works great downtown. In particular, slowness is a good thing for local businesses. Fast travel like cars does not encourage people to go to your store, it encourages people to drive past it. This is why e.g. Melbourne has a free transit zone in the CBD.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by minot on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:47PM (#25654476)
Car dealership campaign contributions?
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by zten on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:08PM (#25654573)
I agree. If you wait until traffic is bad enough, then transit might end up getting pushed -- but it's just to appease people who want to maintain their car-driven lifestyle. Everyone currently sitting in their car on the freeway doesn't think they're the "other" person who should be taking the bus or train. The next step is outright fighting any growth, if they already haven't been.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by scythe on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:14PM (#25654331)
The problem is that the huge suburban "exclusion zone" around cities means that central parts of the metro are very far from open green space. Compare e.g. the development pattern around Cologne-Essen:

https://www.google.com/maps/place/Cologne,+Germany/@51.20163...

to Houston:

https://www.google.com/maps/place/Houston,+TX/@29.759369,-95...

In the one case you are never more than five miles from green space, in the other you may be 20+ in the middle. It's a tragedy of the commons -- no one driveway thinks it caused the flood (literally, in some cases!). Even Paris is more compact than Houston despite having 2x the population!

This can affect air quality, urban heat islands, mental health, etc.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by zten on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:28PM (#25654665)
Yeah, I understand it's not a good pattern of development for huge metro areas. But someone managed to get the laws on the books to basically require the US to develop in this way, and people aren't fighting _too_ hard to change it. It's not hard to imagine, then, that there might be some competitive advantages to a car-centric lifestyle for individuals to live in that situation even if it's worse for the collective.