News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by nnx on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @01:57AM (#25642898)
Why are some proven simple yet _useful_ preventative measures not taken? Like, promoting self blood oxygen monitoring with those (cheap!) finger oxymeter devices for all at-risk persons...

This would avoid lots of late emergency calls in critical condition due to silent hypoxia that developed in them for days/weeks...

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by stordoff on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:37AM (#25643130)
FWIW, silent hypoxia can onset quite quickly. I was monitoring my oxygen levels following a positive test, and my O2 sats dropped from 95+ to 78 in about 12 hours (I'd more or less stopped monitoring it as I generally seemed to be recovering, hence the long gap between values).
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by throw473388 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:11AM (#25642973)
Please, next time you will tell people to exercise and not to be morbidly obese.

BTW read the article, it talks about already dead people with no pulse.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by brodie on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:18AM (#25643013)
On a more serious, thought out note: It is kind of interesting seeing the rise of home pulse oximeter products (due to the pandemic).
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by multjoy on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:28AM (#25644834)
They are so cheap now that there really is no reason to not have one in the bathroom cabinet.
[dead]
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by dang on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:23PM (#25649787)
Would you please stop posting ideological flamebait to HN? You've done it repeatedly, and it's not what this site is for. Taking threads on flamewar tangents is particularly destructive.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Edit: actually it looks like this account is being used primarily for political and ideological battle. We ban that sort of account, and eventually people's main account as well if they keep doing it. I've banned this one. Please don't create accounts to break HN's guidelines with.

If I've misread you and you actually want to use HN as intended, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by gizmo686 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:46AM (#25643196)
It is not the mainstream liberal position that obesity is not a health issue.

Michele Obama is still one of the most popular figures in American politics; and her signature issue was fighting childhood obesity.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by throw473388 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:54AM (#25643234)
That is not really a problem, but acceptance is. Making your child obese should be treated as a child abuse. Obese people should be treaded the same way as smokers, not to get disability benefits.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by adrianN on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @03:29AM (#25643418)
I'm pretty sure people with smoking related COPD get disability benefits.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by throw473388 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @03:52AM (#25643539)
Good luck with SSA application, if you refuse to stop smoking :)
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by dawnerd on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:53AM (#25643231)
Yea I think you got the sides mixed up there. The only time I’ve heard a liberal defend obesity was in response to body shaming - which is a problem and doesn’t help the person get in shape.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by adrianN on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @03:30AM (#25643422)
How strong is the data that body shaming doesn't help people get in shape?
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by rsynnott on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:08AM (#25644281)
If you're pushing a weird idea that on the face of it makes no sense, then the onus is probably on you to demonstrate that it works, not on other people to demonstrate that it doesn't.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by adrianN on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:39AM (#25645949)
Wait, which is the weird idea? That telling people they should lose weight doesn't make them lose weight, or that telling people that they're healthy and beautiful at their current weight helps?
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by VBprogrammer on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:13AM (#25643661)
I know your comment is coming from the right place here but it reads to me like "how strong is the evidence that straight conversion doesn't work for homosexually?".

I think these is some merit to the arguement that we should treat obese people (in the interest of full disclosure I'm usually in the overweight category by BMI) in the same way we treat smokers. Reduce temptation, avoid glamourising unhealthy foods, remove hidden sugers etc.

Fat shaming is like going up to each smoker you see on the street and screaming "eww that stinks" in their face.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by adrianN on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:43AM (#25643810)
I'm also in favor of being excellent to each other.

I think discussing this topic is quite difficult because there is no agreed upon definition of "fat shaming". I'm pretty sure that there are people who would count any measures to reduce obesity as fat shaming (i.e. "cancelling fat culture" or something ridiculous like that), and the discussion tends to get emotional very quickly.

I think we have fairly strong evidence that gay shaming doesn't make people less gay (there are homosexuals even in places where that carries the death penalty). I don't think we have equally strong evidence that telling people they'd look better and reduce their risk for cardiovascular disease if they lost weight doesn't help (at least some of them) to actually do it. At least I'm not aware of any and I believe the confounding variables with anything related to nutrition are so numerous that gathering solid data is extremely difficult.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by VBprogrammer on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:03AM (#25643915)
I think we're largely in agreement. I think the definition of fat shaming I was working from was more on the "Omg, look at [insert c list female celebrity], she's (gained|lost) 10lbs!" end of the scale.

There is also a problem on the low side of body weight. A lot of the models we see are unhealthily thin and/or are photoshopped to look that way. While a lot of attention has been given to how this affects body image for people who end up with eating disorders like anorexia, I wouldn't be at all surprised to find that the same images contribute to people feeling like they will never look like that and going the opposite direction.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by JCharante on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:36AM (#25643778)
> Fat shaming is like going up to each smoker you see on the street and screaming "eww that stinks" in their face.

I'm not pro fat shaming, but spending time in East Asia and getting called fat publicly (even by close friends, but especially strangers) has led to lifestyle choices that have me down 50 lbs from when I first came. I saw that society here (in this unspecified country, not trying to make a blanket statement about East Asia) views fatness very differently, and that I needed to assimulate.

Being fat in the US, where I grew up, is viewed very differently and is normalized.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by VBprogrammer on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:51AM (#25643858)
I accept your own experience but realise that this isn't necessarily the whole truth.

For example, in Canada I found myself accidentally ordering a large out of habit. What arrived was invariably more than I could eat. Easily one and a half times your daily calorie requirements in one meal.

In Spain I don't even remember a large being an option.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by JCharante on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @12:52AM (#25654986)
Ah that's true. During a layover in Amsterdam I was "frustrated" at how a bottle of coke was only 350ml at a restaurant compared to the 750ml you'd find in the US "in the worst case". I didn't order another because I realized that I was probably consuming excess amounts and should instead take this opportunity to realize that optimally I wouldn't even be consuming it.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by ReaganFJones on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:51AM (#25644182)
To a certain extent, there is substantial amount of "smoke shaming." A lot of the smoking mass media ads involved second hand smoke which was largely a shame campaign. By demonstrating the damage you cause others, you invoke shame in the action of smoking.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by throw473388 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:31AM (#25643749)
Contries with lower obesity acceptance have much lower obesity rate. Compare US & UK to rest of the world.

Comparing yourself to gays is just #&#+$+

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by dang on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:21PM (#25649762)
Please stop posting flamewar comments, and definitely please don't create accounts to post flamewar comments.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:21AM (#25646409)
I would bet that acceptance follows the rate, not vice versa.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by free652 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:56AM (#25643245)
Liberal? Why throw politics into this? I am going to bet that conservatives are fatter on average than liberals.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by covid21 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:27AM (#25643732)
Why?
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by rsynnott on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:12AM (#25644311)
Assuming they're talking about the US, where being older rather than younger, being rural/exurban rather than urban/suburban, and being male rather than female are all indicators for both political conservatism and obesity, this is very likely to be the case. Hard to prove without some very peculiar polling, but it is statistically very likely.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by vkou on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:30AM (#25644429)
There hasn't been a liberal belief that obesity is some optimal state of being, but it is a polite society belief that crapping on an obese person is rude.

Most people aren't stupid. If they aren't in shape, they know it. They generally appreciate not being mocked about it by random strangers.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by lisper on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:03AM (#25642931)
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by taxicabjesus on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:04AM (#25642939)
The commonly-used treatments for hypoxia are incredibly damaging. In the beginning "ventilation" was the go-to treatment to pump oxygen into patients' lungs. Doctors eventually realized invasive ventilation was a death sentence. Now they're trying to just use lots of oxygen, but that doesn't work either.

A lot of people had COVID-19 before tests were available. What happened to make the disease so much more deadly? I think most the early patients (December 2019, January/February 2020) toughed it out on their own at home.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by jsnell on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:20AM (#25643024)
A lot of people did not have Covid before the tests were available. You know how we can tell? Because we did not have a lot of people hospitalised or even die with an undiagnosed mystery pneumonia. (There are other ways we can then cross validate that.)

You have somehow internalised a gross mistruth as a fact, have realized it is inconsistent with reality, and are now trying to patch up the inconsistencies by positing that the virus became more deadly. That way lie conspiracy theories.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by Der_Einzige on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @03:31AM (#25643426)
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by adrianN on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @03:54AM (#25643549)
For varying amounts of "a lot".
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by watwut on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @03:28AM (#25643403)
> lot of people hospitalised or even die with an undiagnosed mystery pneumonia

They would have diagnozed pneumonia. Like, pneumonia is not mystery whether you know it is caused by covid or not. And it is diagnkzable.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by taxicabjesus on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:59AM (#25643260)
> (There are other ways we can then cross validate that.)

Tell me more, I'm interested.

> by positing that the virus became more deadly.

I posit that inappropriate treatments make the virus more deadly than it has to be.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by Robin_Message on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @03:59AM (#25643579)
Inappropriate (or rather, best-we-can-think-of-at-the-time-which-we-later-improved) treatment still saved many lives compared to the toughing it out at home approach.

Doctors already know ventilation is bad for people; they were only doing it for people who would otherwise die.

In the UK at least, we're seeing a fatality rate of perhaps 50% what it was in March due to some drug treatments and better use of ventilation (especially prone).

But without treatment, the virus would be perhaps 2 or 3 times more deadly (as was seen in Wuhan when hospitals were overwhelmed).

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by jsnell on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:12AM (#25644725)
Sure, here's a few ways to cross-validate:

If we had a high prevalence of Covid before there was any testing, we'd expect that the moment testing started, we'd see a high prevalence everywhere. We didn't. Most places saw only a small proportion of tests come back positive to start with, which then increased over time. (When looking at this kind of testing that's been done using antibody tests, it's good to remember that even a 99% specific test will mostly be returning false positives when the prevalence is very low).

We can re-test historical samples of various kinds for Covid. That has been done, and while they can find individual cases from a month or two before the first confirmed "live" case, there's no sign of it being widely spread.

We can also deduce the transmission patterns of the virus from the phylogenetic tree. If the virus had been widely circulating outside of China in 2019, sequencing would have show variants that are common in the west branch off from the Chinese ones earlier than they did.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by tylerhou on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:19AM (#25643016)
> Doctors eventually realized invasive ventilation was a death sentence.

Do you have a source that ventilation itself worsens outcomes, and isn't just correlated with already poor-performing patients?

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by tehjoker on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:39AM (#25643144)
The problem was that for a healthy person, ventilation just moves your lung physiologically, but for very sick patients parts of their lungs are like inflamed tissue paper so the forced inflation could cause problems.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by tylerhou on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:52AM (#25643860)
Ventilators are highly complicated pieces of medical grade machinery that cost upwards of $50,000. They are not just regular old pumps with tubes attached. "Forced ventilation" does not properly describe the delicate nature of their operation.

If used properly by trained medical professionals, they are better than the alternative — no ventilation at all.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by tehjoker on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @03:12PM (#25650382)
The perspective I share is one that comes from a doctor that works in the ICU (not me). I am not against ventilation, but there are attendant risks when treating COVID-19 specifically.
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by robbiep on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:15AM (#25644330)
This is correct and well established; prone positioning and non invasive ventilation was shown fairly early on to have a significant survival benefit. Not that I agree with the rest of the OP’s attempt at making some sort of statement
Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by taxicabjesus on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:42AM (#25643169)
Lots of sources. This one is from April 23, 2020:

Special Report: As virus advances, doctors rethink rush to ventilate - https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-ventil...

This is not even a good source, just something that I linked to in a previous comment here.

Remember how the governments were rushing Ventilator production, then those efforts got memory-holed? This was because the professionals realized they shouldn't try to ventilate every COVID-19 patient in their hospital.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by tylerhou on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:59AM (#25643899)
From your article:

> The picture is partial and evolving, but it suggests people with COVID-19 who have been intubated have had, at least in the early stages of the pandemic, a higher rate of death than other patients on ventilators who have conditions such as bacterial pneumonia or collapsed lungs.

> This is not proof that ventilators have hastened death: The link between intubation and death rates needs further study, doctors say.

A summary: we shouldn't ventilate everyone because ventilation has risks (like all medical treatments). Nowhere does the article claim that ventilation is a "death sentence" as you originally claimed.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by baskire on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:34AM (#25643115)
Here’s a good summary of some findings.

“ Among the 2,634 patients for whom outcomes were known, the overall death rate was 21%, but it rose to 88% for those who received mechanical ventilation, the Northwell Health COVID-19 Research Consortium reported.”

“ Ventilators are typically used only when patients are extremely ill, so experts believe that between 40% and 50% of patients die after going on ventilation, regardless of the underlying illness.”

https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20200422/most-covid-19-patie...

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by tylerhou on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:56AM (#25643874)
1. This is from April.

2. The cited study only measures outcomes and does not claim that ventilators worsen patient outcomes. Covid patients who are hospitalized have a higher rate of death [citation needed]. Does that mean hospitals kill Covid patients?

[1] https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2765184

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by robbiep on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:34AM (#25644447)
There is some weird sort of logic with 2.

For example, when I worked in Cairns (cape York Australia, which serves a massive area with a large indigenous population), aboriginals have a belief that people going to the hospital go there to die (because people who have been sick enough to go to hospital... die). So yes, hospitals kill covid patients, because patients sick enough to need to go to hospital are sick enough to die. I know you’re kind of writing in jest and looking for sources but the fact remains that admittance to ICU (when I did my ICU term, at least in Australia and at least when I did it - my brother is an ICU trainee and I raised this number with him and he said it’s lower than that now, here) carries an all source mortality risk of 30%. 30% of those who are wheeled through the doors go out in a bag.

To relate this to COVID, generally ventilators don’t cause an increase in mortality just because you are on one. This was a surprising finding during the early days. It is also contrary to what we find in influenza patients, where it is usually life saving when a patient gets too tired to breathe in their own but still has enough good lung function to be able to respire with their lungs (the alternative being ECMO, or artificial blood gas exchange). I’m on mobile and it’s late so am not at liberty to pull up the research but I recall the consensus being that there was a contradiction: patients who were sedated and ventilated were being so done on the basis of a rapid deterioration in o2 sats; but generally we’re still alert and potentially orientated. It was quickly found that prone positioning (putting a patient on their front to get more gas exchange to the apexes of their lungs) could keep then unventilated and they did better - a lesson learned pretty quickly as regions of Italy and the UK ran out of ventilators

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by baskire on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:16AM (#25644333)
Don’t disagree. However there’s some evidence that ventilators might not have been the best treatment.

The data itself is incomplete in the linked study.

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by stordoff on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:41AM (#25643160)
> Now they're trying to just use lots of oxygen, but that doesn't work either.

Do you have a citation? I was hospitalised with Covid-19, and that was my primary treatment (100% oxygen CPAP was required to keep my O2 sats above 90% - high flow nasal oxygen would cause it to dip below 90).

Re:LA: Ambulance crews to not transport patients with little... by taxicabjesus on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:57AM (#25643247)
> Do you have a citation?

Visit my HN profile, then my submissions... The one from 8 months ago (April 2020 or so) was a study about how aggressive oxygenation to get patients' oxygen sats above an arbitrary threshold was not helpful.

Physiological stress makes it hard for the body to use oxygen efficiently, and just pumping more oxygen into people doesn't fix the fundamental problem. I'm glad you survived -- suffice it to say that I think everyone who hasn't yet reached their expiration date has tremendously more potential to recover.