Agree the trend of decommissioning nuclear plants is counterproductive for other reasons though.
Is that really true when much of the employed population falls on a relatively uniform commute schedule?
I'd expect similar congestion to what's seen on roadways to recur on an inadequate power grid.
I recall a study that if 80% of cars were electric in the U.K., it will increase the load on the grid by 10-20%.
When only charged at home it's just an overnight charging window.
We don't have gas pumps at every parking spot and drivers are generally content with the current situation.
Also, most people live in cities. Most people in cities don't have a charger at home.
Cities are full of cars during the day, but the parking lots empty out at night. They live in less-dense suburbs, where it's comparatively easy to park and comparatively easy to have a charger installed. In the city, many of those who are willing to afford a car at all will also find ways to charge it (including sharing a few charging stations at their garage).
2. At least one but perhaps several orders of magnitudes more expensive than doing it at home. In part because you can charge overnight when pricing is the lowest.
I'd guess most people that have a EV-vehicle have a charger at home.
a) Politicians love them
b) Politicians really don't understand power grids
c) They don't seem to be that "green", after all, if you consider the life span and the co2 emissions from the concrete manufacturing.
https://www.factcheck.org/2018/03/wind-energys-carbon-footpr...
A metaphor if I may engage, is you cannot get a six pack with pure calorie counting, you have to have a bit more sophisticated system in nutrition and work outs for that. Same thing applies for The Grid, a wind mill of same specification at two different locations will give different yields, at different time of day and have completely different effect on system as a whole.
He participated in research on low cost rocket designs. His take away was the actual design wasn't as important as building more rockets rather than less.
With solar you make panels by the 100 million. Wind turbines by the tens of thousand. Nuclear by the low digits. Per year.
https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parc_automobile_fran%C3%A7ais
Cars are parked 95% of the time.
Even a smallish 2 kW car to grid capacity would give 80 GW of instantaneuous dispatchable power to the grid. And cars are distributed on all the territory.
If average battery is about 50 kWh that gives a whole day of France max demand.
And of course on the other way 80 GW of dispatchable demand.
For reference electro-nuclear production capacity is 62 GW in France.
A fully electric car fleet means the grid will just never go down.
This is all software controlled, all new cars in Europe have a SIM card (eCall law), electric cars are computer on wheels, nothing is missing but the will to do it.
My Tesla model 3 SR+ has 50 kWh of NCA batteries with about 1000-1500 cycles, so about 600k km (to 70% of original capacity). Petrol car leave the european market with about 200-250k km on the odometer (source: discussion with a car journalist).
If you buy a Tesla model 3 SR+ right now in Europe it's made in China with LFP chemistry which is much more durable 3000-6000 cycles to about 2 millions km.
That gives plenty of room to play with car batteries without too much detriment.
And I assume you'll be able to limit discharging to some value to avoid getting stuck on your parking :).
Do you have a link to Ireland law about eCall?
In Europe GDPR force to require consent for personnal data use like most car data is, once consent is given I see no reason not to use the already present SIM for eCall for other purposes.
1x Windmill, 3.6MW for 500 m3 concrete [0, 1]
1x Hinkley Point C base, nameplate 3.2GW for 18,000 m3 [2]
I don't know how much Hinkley Point overall might use, because a lot might go into the shell, so say the overall build is an order of magnitude more than the base. That is 180k m3 of concrete or about 360 windmill foundations in Hinkley with some rather unfavourable assumptions. So a 3.2 GW nuclear reactor might match up to ~1.3 GW of Windfarm.
Depending on how much goes into the base vs the shell it is probably somewhere between 3x to an order of magnitude favouring nuclear. Not considering relative lifetime, although I expect a nuclear concrete pour has better long-term prospects (how would they replace the windmill without re-pouring the base?).
[0] https://www.wagner.com.au/main/our-projects/sapphire-wind-fa...
[1] https://www.sapphirewindfarm.com.au/
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinkley_Point_C_nuclear_power_...
See also: https://archinect.com/news/article/150240752/recycled-concre...
Your argument completely ignores the fact that nuclear has the highest energy density and availability of all currently available energy sources.
We should definitely try and reduce the amount of embodied CO2 in wind turbines. But it is hardly a differentiating factor when comparing nuclear and wind. Both are fantastic in terms of co2 when compared to the fossil fuels they are replacing. We only talk about embodied co2 because the other emissions are so non-existent!
Emissions from concrete are a problem which needs to be addressed separately to energy production. Other industries need to do their bit and provide alternatives.
We are basically building back wind farms and not building new ones.
The article below gives a reasonable overview of the causes:
https://m.dw.com/en/german-wind-energy-stalls-amid-public-re...
https://www.cleanenergywire.org/news/modest-wind-power-expan...
But I was responding to another argument: the parent claimed that wind power is actually removed. Except for some fear mongering that it might happen in the future I can't find any evidence for this. So still waiting on a citation on that original claim.
Starting with 2021 old wind farms will be build back, since there is a new rule about 1000m,new ones cant be build, hence reducing the available area.
Renewables clearly have no place when it comes to generate a lot of energy. They're interesting in a few cases where there's a lot of wind, or where there is no power grid and you need a little power.
Others advocate reducing energy consumption, but if we reduce co2 emissions from transport, we will need more electricity.
Sweden in November: 38.7%, up 2.7x YoY
https://cleantechnica.com/2020/12/02/swedens-ev-sales-hit-ne...
I worry about the current trend of both France and Sweden shutting down nuclear plants without building any replacements though. Wind power is great, I suppose (the jury is still out on the sustainability of the hardware - but it's not looking great at the moment - massive amounts of concrete needed causing kinda huge co2 emissions during the chemical manufacturing processes), but it's no good as a baseline power for days when there's no wind and the hydro power is running on low. The fallback for that scenario is burning coal or oil.