News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by WJW on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:29PM (#25617201)
Damen shipyards is on record for stating that they regularly tweak warship designs to "look sleeker and meaner" because it both makes the admirals happy and also reaffirms the beliefs of the public of how warships are "supposed" to look. I'd be very surprised if military aircraft designers did not do something similar.

In any case it's also good military thinking. Sun Tzu already said that the pinnacle of warfare is to gain victory without fighting, and one of the ways to do so is to look so menacing that your opponent does not want to engage. Sleek, powerful looking military hardware has that effect much more than bloated and clunky stuff.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by Animats on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:57PM (#25617431)
That was an issue with US guided missile cruisers when vertical launch came in. The launchers just show as little hatches in the deck. There's usually a modest gun turret, the only visible weapon. There are some Close In Weapons System units, but they just look like machine guns.

The USSR built ships with much more visible armament on deck, facing outward. Partly because it looked fierce, and partly because they didn't quite trust their missiles not to launch straight up and come back down on the ship.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by doovd on Saturday January 02, 2021 @06:36PM (#25617744)
> they didn't quite trust their missiles not to launch straight up and come back down on the ship.

This sounds like some ridiculous cold war propaganda, source?

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by chipsa on Saturday January 02, 2021 @07:27PM (#25618112)
It's an artifact of the technology they use. US launchers are hot launch: the motor ignites in the cell, and then leaps out under its own power. This has some disadvantages with having hot exhaust inside the ship.

Soviet launchers used a cold launcher. They pushed the missile out first, then ignited the motor after it was out of the cell. This is good for reducing exhaust impingement. But you can end up with a live missile not actually going up if the motor igniter fails. Angling the launcher ensures your live missile lands in the water, instead of on deck.

I've seen video of this, but having no luck searching for it.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by WJW on Sunday January 03, 2021 @04:14PM (#25625302)
Fun fact, due to the same design choices US-designed missiles are vulnerable to a failure mode called a "hang fire" (see for example https://www.navaltoday.com/2018/06/25/sm-2-missile-fails-to-... ) where the rocket engine has ignited but the missile is stuck inside the ship for some reason.

The VLS designers had to massively overengineer the bottom part of the VLS "plenum" (the bottom part) to be able to withstand the largest missile that will fit inside a VLS to fully burn out inside it without melting through the bottom and endangering the structural integrity of the ship it is in.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by aaaxyz on Saturday January 02, 2021 @07:49PM (#25618246)
You'd have more luck searching for videos of FGM-148 launches. It's smaller and ground-based but works similarly.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by josst on Saturday January 02, 2021 @07:55PM (#25618290)
I think there is a few factors at play here.

Firstly its a misconception that that VLS has anything to do with this. VLS has only really been mounted on ships from the 80s onwards. The first US ship with VLS was the Ticonderoga class cruiser launched first in 1980, however the VLS was only used for anti aircraft missiles and the Harpoon anti ship missiles were positioned in quad launchers at the rear of the ship. The Soviets did in fact deploy VLS earlier than NATO on the Azov class cruiser, but kept external anti ship / submarine missiles on many designs. Indeed throughout NATO it was common to mount anti ship weapons externally just as the Soviets did right up until the mid 80s. If you think about it, anti ship missiles want to go sideways rather than upwards so it makes sense to point them at where the enemy will be.

Given that the majority of anti ship missiles were external on both sides I suspect the difference in prominence and perception comes from two linked points.

1: The majority of NATO ships were not designed as surface combatants, rather as escorts for carriers

2: Soviet anti ship missiles tended to be bigger with higher speeds and larger warheads.

On the first point the main priority of the US navy is power projection. As such it is generally reliant on carriers to provide strike capability through sorties. This is suplemented by submarines for anti shipping capbilities. THe majority of NATO surface combatants are geared towards allowing those carriers to be deployed unimpeded, as such they have a lot of anti air and anti missile capbility which by nature fires upwards.

The Soviet navy was more focused on area denial as they did not develop a significant carrier force. As strike capbility was not provided by naval aircraft (at least to the same extent) a greater emphasis was put on sinking enemny combatants. As such their ships were designed for surface to surface roles to contest the baltic and black sea. This required them to be able to sink NATO carrier groups themselves which in turn required more powerful missiles with higher speeds and bigger warheads. These therefore which appear far more prominently on their ships. I'd also note that the Soviets tended to put large missiles on smaller ships such as corvettes which made them appear even more prominent.

Russian missile systems were during the cold war (and perhaps still are) superior in many ways to NATO counterparts. The USSR had no problem devloping reliable rocket motors and had some pretty fearsome weapons. I think the idea that they put their missiles on the side to prevent self damage is a little far fetched.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by ckozlowski on Saturday January 02, 2021 @09:30PM (#25618787)
Completely agree with all of this. When you're looking at firing missiles like the P270 and P-700 AShMs that have a mass close to a small fighter aircraft, there's nothing to be gained by vertical launch here.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by baybal2 on Saturday January 02, 2021 @09:39PM (#25618831)
> I think the idea that they put their missiles on the side to prevent self damage is a little far fetched.

All Union's VLS are designed slanted exactly to prevent that.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by doovd on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @03:36AM (#25643450)
Very interesting, thank you!
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by Animats on Saturday January 02, 2021 @07:26PM (#25618100)
Wikipedia has that, but it's uncited.

The USSR and Russia were late getting into vertical launch from surface ships. When they did, it was with larger missiles than the US used, but fewer of them. There were some interesting designs, such as a missile that carried a torpedo, a ramjet-powered missile, and a missile which operated in a group of other missiles with one of them in charge. The USSR built some giant nuclear-powered battlecruisers to carry all those large weapons, and put large vertical launch tubes on some aircraft carriers.

Now, like everybody else, Russia mostly uses vertical launch in new systems.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by ckozlowski on Saturday January 02, 2021 @09:25PM (#25618761)
It happens: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_9-LjeoOpeM

That said, I think it's more propaganda than a rule. Especially since plenty of Russian vessels utilize vertical launch systems. I believe the necessity of the angled launch systems like what you'd find on the Kirov, Slava, and Kara classes were more due to the immense size of those missiles. Look at the U.S. Talos and UK "Sea Slug" missiles for western examples. As missile technology became better and more miniaturized, you start seeing more vertical launch systems where it makes sense.

The one area I've seen consistent arguments for horizontal launch are in places where a missile failure (see above) would be much more dangerous, such as on a carrier deck. This is why I believe you still see Sea Sparrow and SeaRAM systems placed on the wings and below the deckline, so that a failed launch won't land back on a deck full of fuel and ordinance. The ranges that point defense systems are working at can't allow for a missile body to "tip over" and still hit the target at range.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by stretchcat on Saturday January 02, 2021 @07:27PM (#25618105)
I'm under the impression the Kirov-class battlecruisers have vertical launch tubes. On the other hand, the concern seems somewhat warranted: https://youtube.com/watch?v=V88sUJKgOsk
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by baybal2 on Saturday January 02, 2021 @09:35PM (#25618811)
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by sandworm101 on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:36PM (#25617258)
Sun Tzu didnt have stealth aircraft. In many ways, if they see enough of you to be intimidated then they can see enough of you to kill you. The f-35 wants to make the kill before the target even realizes it is in danger, let alone sees the aircraft comming. I doubt Sun Tzu would have encouraged his spies or saboteurs to stand out from the crowd.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by stretchcat on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:40PM (#25617294)
The enemies of America are presumably meant to see American stealth aircraft in movies and TV shows, not over their capitols.

However, I think these airplanes are indeed designed foremost for function. The similar appearances of the B-1 and Tu-160 suggest that when two planes are designed using similar technology with similar mission requirements, they tend to have a lot of similarities. (In the years since they were initially designed, the way these aircraft are used has changed. But they were initially designed to meet similar requirements.)

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by asdff on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:55PM (#25617422)
How many decades will it be before we see an F35 used in film?
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by dragonwriter on Saturday January 02, 2021 @06:40PM (#25617778)
> How many decades will it be before we see an F35 used in film?

Rounded to the closest whole decade, -1; the first movie to use actual, not CGI/model/etc., F-35s on film was Man of Steel (2013).

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by robbiep on Saturday January 02, 2021 @09:36PM (#25618815)
I’m pretty sure there was also a couple of B’s in Die Hard 4
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by euler_angles on Sunday January 03, 2021 @01:02AM (#25619880)
There was (bad) CGI of an X-35B in that movie.

Real F-35Bs don't have an internal gun, and if they did, the guns wouldn't fire from the intakes, and if the aircraft took a large chunk of concrete directly into the LiftFan it wouldn't shudder and slowly fall out of the sky, it would be a catastrophic and near instantaneous loss of aircraft and likely aircrew life.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by chipsa on Sunday January 03, 2021 @07:23AM (#25621368)
You can see the same error in The Avengers: F-35B hovering and firing guns from the intakes.

I think it's a bad job of converting from a AV-8, which does have internal guns, located under each intake.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by dragonwriter on Sunday January 03, 2021 @03:55AM (#25620567)
> There was (bad) CGI of an X-35B in that movie.

Models (both miniature and full size) were used.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by euler_angles on Sunday January 03, 2021 @10:44AM (#25622372)
Ah, my mistake. Shame to put that much effort into putting something on film and have it look so awful that you think it must be CGI
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by stretchcat on Saturday January 02, 2021 @06:05PM (#25617481)
F-35's have been depicted in numerous Hollywood movies already, though it seems not always in the most positive light. To get an actual F-35 filmed for a movie would probably require the cooperation of the US military though, so probably the next time a sufficiently aggrandizing American war movie calls for one? The US military has helped out Hollywood like this many times before, if they think the movie shows them in a good light.

https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2011-aug-21-la-ca-mi...

https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/why-f-35-stealth-figh...

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by ben_w on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:41PM (#25617302)
On the other hand, the foreign government may see pictures of the plane and go “that’s scary” and not start the fight which the less-scary-more-stealthy alternative can win better.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by pjc50 on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:45PM (#25617328)
Not in the skies, in Jane's Defense Weekly.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by pjc50 on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:43PM (#25617313)
Used to be done with uniforms. Hence the Pope's guards with Michelangelo uniforms, and the Nazis with Hugo Boss.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by stretchcat on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:56PM (#25617429)
I could be wrong, but IIRC Hugo Boss was one of the companies that made Nazi uniforms, but did not design those uniforms.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by Judgmentality on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:32PM (#25617229)
> In any case it's also good military thinking.

Or more likely enemies see it as posturing and strike full force, thinking they can pierce the superficial veil of technological supremacy.

Come on, security theater is bullshit. How many people actually think the TSA does anything useful? If anything it lulls people into a false sense of safety, making us weaker.

If our enemies are so easily deterred that our appearance matters more than our capability, then they are not enemies worth taking seriously.

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/06/the-tsa...

https://www.heritage.org/transportation/commentary/heres-how...

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by wtvanhest on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:37PM (#25617269)
Hijackings were extremely common prior to flight security. TSA was another level, that was extremely frustrating throughout the 2000s, but at a minimum it prevents wildly unstable people from boarding with weapons

Check out this list https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aircraft_hijackings

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by ceejayoz on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:56PM (#25617423)
> at a minimum it prevents wildly unstable people from boarding with weapons

The TSA reliably fails penetration tests; they miss between 70% and 95% of them. https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelgoldstein/2017/11/09/tsa...

What's likely caused hijackings to fall off a cliff is a) reinforced cockpit doors and b) the knowledge of crew and passengers that the hijackers might be homicidal.

Pre-9/11, advice was to cooperate, get the plane on the ground, and negotiate/assault, with pretty good overall results for the passengers. That is... not the advice today.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by wtvanhest on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:51PM (#25638702)
Reinforced cockpit doors were not implemented on planes until around 2002. Meanwhile, hijackings fell dramatically after only basic fight security that was implemented nearly 20 years before that.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by kens on Saturday January 02, 2021 @08:17PM (#25618424)
I don't think people realize just how common hijackings were in the early 1970s, with sometimes two hijackings on the same day. (Between 1968 and 1972 there were over 130 US hijackings.)

But after a hijacker threatened to crash a plane into a nuclear reactor in 1972, the FAA introduced passenger screening and metal detectors. Before that, there was basically no security.

An interesting article: https://www.vox.com/2016/3/29/11326472/hijacking-airplanes-e...

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by Zigurd on Saturday January 02, 2021 @07:27PM (#25618111)
There are more-plausible theories of why hijackings are now rare. One of the most plausible is that armored cockpit doors and the policy that they should never be opened during a hijacking has put hijackers out of business.

TSA security checkpoints are a gift to the business models for autonomous vehicles. If you can have your car do the driving for you, an overnight car trip will be a good alternative to flights under 500 miles ad possibly all short-haul flights in the US.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by Judgmentality on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:49PM (#25617369)
I wrote a rebuttal with sources but on second thought, I think you make a good point. I should look at the data more and revisit my stance.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by toyg on Saturday January 02, 2021 @07:08PM (#25617981)
Common-er, yes; “extremely” seems a bit excessive. It’s not like there was a hijack a day. And as others said, what stopped the trend is more likely to be the fact that passengers’ cooperation is now impossible.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by landryraccoon on Saturday January 02, 2021 @06:17PM (#25617593)
One angle you're missing is the effect appearances have on your own soldiers, not the enemy.

Battles and wars can be lost because of poor morale. Maintaining high morale and combat readiness in your very-human fighting force is critical to achieving victory.

If soldiers feel happier and more ready to fight with cool looking equipment rather than shoddy looking gear, then it's easily a good investment.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by anonisko on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:42PM (#25617306)
It's not complete bullshit. Against other sophisticated actors, yeah, it's bullshit. But posturing and intimidation is important to keep less sophisticated actors in check.
Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by Judgmentality on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:45PM (#25617336)
Who are the less sophisticated actors willing to attack a military based solely on appearance of 'not looking intimidating?'

We're talking about a fighter jet, not a security guard.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by anonisko on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:57PM (#25617432)
I'd see it as more about PR.

If poor desperate people regularly see these kinds of badass weapons that a foreign power has, it's just going to be that much harder to recruit for organizations that violently resist oppression, because the individuals you need are fearful and demoralized.

Then you need crazy things like religious indoctrination that promises rewards in heaven for fighting such an unassailable power.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by Judgmentality on Saturday January 02, 2021 @06:01PM (#25617450)
I guess you could make the argument the PR is effective against idiots.

My point is letting the PR call the shots objectively makes us weaker (the F-35 program is a clusterfuck), so it's harming us against enemies that aren't idiots. I'm pretty sure China loves the F-35 program because they know it's an enormous weakness in the US military.

But yeah, you have a point. Idiots can be harmful too, and they should also be considered as potential threats.

Re:Pentagon Puts F-35 Full-Rate Production Decision on Hold by HPsquared on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:46PM (#25617339)
Human factors are real.