News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by roenxi on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:48AM (#25602061)
This is a silly law. If someone feels like sending a courier to buy take away then that should be legal.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:51AM (#25602079)
The problem is not sending a courier. You can use Apps to send someone there without a problem.

The problem is them impersonating the restaurant and giving customers the impression that the restaurant is offering the delivery service themselves.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by roenxi on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:26AM (#25602242)
Unless there is some rather serious context I'm missing - and as I said in another comment - the linked bill says:

> A food delivery platform shall not arrange for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility.

I don't think you can use Apps to send someone there without a problem. They have to get 'express authorisation' from the restaurant before they can accept your order. That is silly.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:31AM (#25602251)
As I answered to another poster, I believe the keyword here is "take orders".

You can't take orders on behalf of others, but you can freely arrange for someone in an app to "make an order" for you and then fetch the meal. That's my interpretation.

Of course it could/should be better worded, though.

EDIT: Also, someone also mentioned that courier apps are not "food delivery platforms", so the first few words of the paragraph you quoted already excludes them.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by Dylan16807 on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:05AM (#25602408)
> You can't take orders on behalf of others

This law does not say that at all. It's completely silent on whether the platform can take orders. It prohibits a single specific action, and that action is arranging for the delivery of an order.

> you can freely arrange for someone in an app to "make an order" for you and then fetch the meal.

You can arrange for them to make an order if you want to. That's allowed. But "fetching" sure sounds to me like they are delivering the order. They can't deliver it unless they have the specific authorization from the restaurant.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:13AM (#25602440)
The text that has been quoted all over this thread does say "to take orders and deliver meals". Sure it could be better worded, but it seems that the intent here is quite clear: to stop the practice that was being done by DoorDash/Postmates.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by Dylan16807 on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:50AM (#25602605)
Look at how the law is formulated: "A food delivery platform shall not X without Y."

X is the action the law allows or prohibits.

Y decides whether the action is allowed or not.

If "authorization to take orders and deliver meals" exists, then they can deliver. If "authorization to take orders and deliver meals" does not exist, then they cannot deliver.

"take orders" does not appear in the law anywhere else. It's only in the phrase "authorization to take orders", and in that context the law is only checking if that authorization exists. This particular law does not say when taking orders is allowed or prohibited. This law does not care if a platform is taking orders. It cares about whether the platform delivers, and it cares about whether the platform has "authorization to take orders and deliver meals".

-

Edit: Pretend for a second the law said "A food delivery platform shall not arrange for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to own puppies and deliver meals prepared by the food facility."

Would that law have any effect on whether the food delivery platform can own puppies? Nah. The restaurant has to say "you are allowed to own puppies" before the platform can deliver, but that law is not imbuing the puppy clause with any other power. It neither allows nor disallows actual puppy ownership.

-

So my main point is not that a platform should get cheeky by trying to take orders but not deliver, or something.

It's that even if they're not taking orders, this law blocks them from delivering. If they don't have the authorization, they can't deliver, end of story. The restaurant didn't say they can have a puppy, so they can't deliver, and it doesn't matter whether there actually is a puppy.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @07:22AM (#25602764)
Like I already said, it could be better worded, but, to me, its intent seems to be quite clear. You make good points, but I still have a different interpretation.
[dead]
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:51AM (#25602330)
Uber Eats or Uber Taxi? Uber Eats doesn't engage in the practices this law is trying to curb since they already have agreements in place with the restaurants (AFAIK), so you won't have to phone up anyone if you use Uber Eats.

If you're taking about Uber the Taxi app, or some courier service, then this law doesn't apply to them since they're not "food delivery platforms", and you can just ask them to order on your behalf without phoning anyone.

EDIT: Btw I'm not making any argument in favour or against the law, I'm just doing my best and trying to interpret it.

[dead]
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:27AM (#25602508)
The general agreement here is that the law was made because Doordash/Postmates were impersonating restaurants without authorization from them and taking orders in their behalf, so it's not exactly similar to your shoes examples.

Most people find the impersonation and lack of transparent unreasonable. Whether the law is the best tool to fix it or whether it will have side effects is what's in debate, but the main intention of the law seems pretty clear to everyone.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by GauntletWizard on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:04AM (#25602148)
I disagree with this law, like I've disagreed with many laws before it: the creation of a specific law implies that what came before was not fraud. It was fraud. Prosecute it as such.

Offering to courrier food from place A to B, including ordering the food from place A, should not be illegal. Pretending to be A to engage in that business is fraud, because you pretended to be A. It's that simple. This law is a giveaway to the companies that have already engaged in fraud.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:17AM (#25602207)
Good point, I agree with you.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by throwawaysea on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:53AM (#25602092)
Someone else posted the below excerpt of the law that also prohibits couriers (who are not impersonating anyone) unless they have permission from the restaurant. That seems like a ridiculous restriction to me.

> 22599. A food delivery platform shall not arrange for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:56AM (#25602104)
I don't think sending someone to perform a task is the same as taking an order, though. The restaurant is still the one taking the order for the food itself in the case of a courier.

Also the law seem to only include "food delivery platforms", which exclude couriers.

(Of course, I might be wrong, but it seems that the intent of the law is to stop impersonation, not couriers).

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by throwawaysea on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:01AM (#25602139)
Why can't I pay someone to place an order and pick it up for me? Can't I have someone go shop on my behalf at non-restaurant businesses? And if so, isn't it reasonable that a menu of options be shown with items and the costs? I agree that there should be transparency about who is delivering the food, there should be no impersonation of the restaurant, no false listing of phone numbers, and so on. But allowing restaurants to deny a courier without prior agreement seems like a government overreach.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:09AM (#25602173)
I think you misunderstood my reply: I don't think the law is forbidding someone making an order on your behalf and picking it up for you. I doubt it will affect normal courier services.

What I believe the law is forbidding is the lack of transparency, the false listing of phone numbers and taking orders on behalf of someone else.

EDIT: Btw, I'm not downvoting you as I can't downvote replies. I have upvoted to counter it.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by lkbm on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:54AM (#25603251)
Sure would be nice if the law mentioned something about impersonating the restaurant rather than merely adding restrictions on who can be a courier.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by foobar1962 on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:05AM (#25602158)
The problem is that if food isn't handled correctly it makes people sick. This law is about food safety.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by foobar1962 on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:01AM (#25602135)
Say you're the restaurant, I'm the delivery guy. I pickup your meals and deliver them to your customers. On the way the meals go cold (or hot) and get damaged. Your customers aren't happy and want their money back.

My actions have made your service look bad, your customers unhappy and cost you money. You didn't know I was delivering your food!

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by kflzufkrbzi on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:03AM (#25602397)
As someone who is working on food delivery in Europe it's weird to even consider someone delivering food without the restaurants approval. I guess it's the only way to scale extremely fast but still it seems counterproductive to me.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by jopsen on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:38AM (#25602566)
Isn't this exactly the kind of thing trademark laws is supposed to cover?

I'm pretty sure that if you tried to resell food at scale from a major fast food franchise without proper licensing, you would get sued.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by enragedcacti on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:31AM (#25603905)
The major fast food franchises aren't the people this law is protecting, its Joe Blow's Pizza Shack that can't afford a lawsuit against Doordash.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by toast0 on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:06PM (#25605171)
Trademark law could prevent me from pretending to be the restaurant. If they had a defensible trademark and time and money to litigate.

It doesn't really prevent me from acting as a middle man. I'd need to be careful about using their trademarks and making it clear that I'm not connected.

The concept of first sale certainly applies, although health code makes it complex. There's also the concept of the right to refuse service.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by josefx on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:05AM (#25602156)
On the one hand the law seems overly broad, on the other there was apparently no way for restaurant owners to protect their names against bad third party delivery services.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ehnto on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:53AM (#25602086)
You could still do that without the app listing the restaurants without their permission.

There is a clear exploitation happening here, I think it's right to find a way to stop it. We should get better at iterating on policy though, maybe this doesn't work out or stops some other kind of less exploitive business from operating and they need to adjust it.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by roenxi on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:05AM (#25602157)
The linked bill says

> A food delivery platform shall not arrange for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility.

Nothing there is talking about apps or listings.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ehnto on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:10AM (#25602174)
That wording leaves room for personally arranged general couriers in my opinion, but that would end up getting defined in court at some point down the road.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by Ekaros on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:19AM (#25602220)
I think key question here would be definition of "food delivery platform". Generic courier service or personal assistant or even taxi driver is likely not to qualify under such title.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by roenxi on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:32AM (#25602254)
The linked bill is not verbose, it is effectively 4 paragraphs.

> Food delivery platform” means an online business that acts as an intermediary between consumers and multiple food facilities to submit food orders from a consumer to a participating food facility, and to arrange for the delivery of the order from the food facility to the consumer.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by darawk on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:56AM (#25602106)
What is the exploitation exactly?
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ehnto on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:18AM (#25602217)
The delivery platform represents a business relationship with a restaurant that doesn't exist, and uses it to pull value out of the services the restaurants offer. As a business you get to choose which other businesses you work with, and on what terms. In this case they haven't given the restaurant the opportunity to negotiate terms.

It's new ground sure, but I think it's pretty clear that the delivery platform is a service provider to the restaurant and as such the restaurant should have some negotiating power. What if they want a cut of the delivery fee, or guaranteed delivery windows for their customers? Probably wouldn't get it, but that's a negotiation they should be able to have.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by yeskia on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:01AM (#25602137)
Exploiting the customer my misrepresenting a restaurant as a partner when they are not.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by throwawaysea on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:57AM (#25602114)
I'm not sure I understand the suggestion. Why shouldn't a courier service be allowed to list a business to get something from. That's like saying "people can't use mapping services". This doesn't feel like exploitation to me but maybe I don't understand your position fully.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ljm on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:05AM (#25602161)
They've been known to go as far as buying domains for the restaurants and hosting the menus on them, basically inserting themselves as a middleman, then threatening the restaurant with consequences if they don't pay up for the favour.

This might be accompanied by the service taking their cut out of every meal ordered through the site, forcing the restaurant to lose money on the orders.

That's not just listing, it's a racket.

GrubHub was caught doing this, I believe.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by Lucasoato on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:05AM (#25602155)
Well, it should be clear that the restaurant has nothing to do with the delivery service.

You shouldn't be able to exploit the restaurant brand, logo and reputation without their consent, otherwise they wouldn't have any mean to protect themselves from bad reviews that would damage their image even in other platforms.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by sumthinprofound on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:22AM (#25603830)
This happened to a friend of mine who is a restaurant owner. One day he gets a call for take out, for "Jeff" lets say $60. A DoorDash courier shows up (nothing indicating they are from DoorDash, restaurant assumes this is the customer) and attempts to pay with a credit card. Credit card comes back declined. Courier mentions he's going to step outside to get the issue resolved and will be right back. Half an hour goes by, another call comes in for the exact same order, $60. Another courier comes in, acts like he placed the order, tries to pay with a similar looking credit card, gets declined. 2nd courier leaves without the food. The owner thinks its some time of scam. When the third exact same order comes in via phone, the owner starts asking questions. All three were for the same DoorDash customer, all called in on the phone by DoorDash assuming the identity of the customer who placed the order via the DoorDash website using a menu that DoorDash just found online and posted on their website. It was an outdated menu with outdated prices. Apparently DoorDash would load their credit cards with the exact amount for the purchase (based on outdated prices) so both couriers cards were declined for the purchases. Meanwhile, the actual customer is waiting over an hour and a half for their order to be delivered and the restaurant owner has to eat 2 $60 sales because the food is no longer presentable. Owner was never contacted in advance by DoorDash regarding any business relationship, they just found a menu and included it on their site. Ultimately I believe they covered the cost of their screwup, and the restaurant owner required they pay over the phone when calling in the order before any food was made. I would absolutely consider this exploiting the restaurant brand and reputation without consent.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by danielheath on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:59AM (#25602122)
A courier can still collect food. They can’t impersonate the restaurant anymore.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by AmericanChopper on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:29AM (#25602246)
The law prohibits a courier from being commissioned to place an order, collect it, and deliver it to you. It’s just criminalizing a perfectly legitimate form of arbitrage. The law isn’t about couriers impersonating restaurants either, because that’s just fraud and it’s already illegal. It’s just another example of a terrible law created at the behest of businesses that aren’t competent enough to keep up with changes in the market. But why would they bother when they can just seek a legislative solution?
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ehnto on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:02AM (#25602387)
This is going to sound a bit curmudgeonly, but why should hospitality bend over to some tech middlemen? Not every industry needs to "innovate" their way into surviving the VC bubble's attempts to disrupt it. Hospitality is a fundamental service that's been provided for centuries, and is a cornerstone of the economy.

Second to that, the law doesn't prohibit it, it just makes the delivery service seek an arrangement first. I am not terribly saddened by the fact that the delivery platforms have to do some groundwork instead of just web scraping a bunch of menus and making money off splitting all the risk between restaurants and customers.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ghaff on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:19AM (#25603043)
If these companies provide such a valuable service for people who can't get up from their computers to get or cook food, I'm sure restaurants will be lining up to sign up for their services.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by AmericanChopper on Friday January 01, 2021 @03:56PM (#25607001)
> This is going to sound a bit curmudgeonly, but why should hospitality bend over to some tech middlemen?

Because that’s what their customers want, and providing something that their customers want should probably be one of the most important things for a business to do.

The only genuine harm that can be caused to these businesses by the delivery companies, is if the delivery company is legitimately impersonating the restaurant. Which as I said, would already be illegal.

The actual “harm” that this law addresses is somebody making a profit of providing a service that the restaurants think they deserve a cut of (just because?...). Hilariously, this type of arrangement is the most beneficial thing the restaurants could have. Because they’ll find if they’d try and make one of the arrangements with a company like UberEats, that what actually happens is the delivery company will be demanding a cut of their revenue instead.

Criminalizing a type of customer based on whether they intend to on sell the product after purchase is just entirely stupid. It’s one of the many stupid laws we have that only seek to protect dead business models that consumers no longer want. Just like the DMCA and all of the car dealership laws we have.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ehnto on Saturday January 02, 2021 @04:40AM (#25611526)
Their customers want easy delivery options that's definitely true. But if you could ask them if they think restaurants deserve a chance at fair negotiations they would probably also say yes.

All the bill is asking for is cooperation up front, not afterwards if at all. It's not criminalizing the business model of DoorDash and friends, it's just forcing them to treat their business partners like business partners.

I think it's fair to say I have some bias here though. I am a little bit too cynical toward these companies to believe they're just out here trying to better the world. They're doing their best to spin a buck before going public and peacing out. Case in point, DoorDash just IPOd with no profit and no projection for profitability, even in it's best case scenario (massive increase in online ordering).

So obviously the service is extremely useful, people find it useful while it's subsidized but no one has yet bared the full cost of these platforms.

In my opinion we need to protect existing businesses who are profitable and thus have a proven place in the economy, while these disruptive companies flail about free from the shackles of actually fitting into the economy, just in case it turns out they wouldn't.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by AmericanChopper on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:27AM (#25611782)
If you’ve sold something, why would you expect to have any right to negotiate what the buyer plans to do with it? The delivery businesses have simply found some value that customers are willing to pay for. If the restaurants want to capture that value for themselves they have every right to attempt to do so.

It’s also silly to say that these delivery apps are trying to make the world a better place. They’re just providing a service to consumers. They’ve certainly changed the takeout food market significantly (and in a way that is very beneficial to consumers). But they’ve also made it harder for takeout food businesses to operate, because they’ve massively increased the competition they face. Takeout restaurants used to only compete with other nearby take out restaurants, for the business of customers within a convenient distance from their location. Now they have to compete with businesses from miles away too.

This is fantastic for consumers, which is generally who should benefit most from these sort of regulations. This law is an absolute affront to consumers, and serves only to protect bad businesses from having to address innovation. It’s understandable that these businesses want a slice of that value, and I’m sure you could tell a very sympathetic story about them. But they did nothing to create this value, and the law shouldn’t exist to shield them from competition.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by danielheath on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:42AM (#25603183)
In practice, every single one of these services has impersonated restaurants and harmed many of their reputations by doing so.

Perhaps the law is poorly written. That happens sometimes; more often when you behave in a way that invites regulation.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ghaff on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:57AM (#25604115)
None of these Uber-for-X things are an issue at small scale, like a courier or other type of shared assistant ordering and delivering a pizza for you. Absolutely no one cares no matter what the letter of the law is. (And it's not really a food delivery platform at that point anyway.)

The problem is when it's a growth-oriented SV company.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by AmericanChopper on Friday January 01, 2021 @03:36PM (#25606774)
Do you have a reason for why you think that is the problem?
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by Dylan16807 on Friday January 01, 2021 @02:19PM (#25605878)
Oh boy I love selective enforcement.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ghaff on Friday January 01, 2021 @02:40PM (#25606095)
Scale does matter. There are a ton of things that people can and do do for a bit of cash under the table like give a haircut even though they don't have a license, rent out an apartment to a friend of a friend for a few weeks because you'll be traveling, etc. And those same things would probably be a problem if they were pursued as an ongoing business. Which, the general silliness of some occupational licensing aside, I don't really have a problem with.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by AmericanChopper on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:37AM (#25611843)
The silliness of haircut licenses existing seems like a very reasonable thing to have a problem with.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by CodeWriter23 on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:52AM (#25602084)
What’s even sillier, every company doing this in California was getting consent from the restaurant to publish a number as if they were said restaurant BEFORE this law was even conceived. Of course, it was a click-wrap agreement that nobody read.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by boomboomsubban on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:38AM (#25602277)
> If someone feels like sending a courier to buy take away then that should be legal.

Should it be legal for a business to ban somebody for any non-protected reason?