News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:51AM (#25602079)
The problem is not sending a courier. You can use Apps to send someone there without a problem.

The problem is them impersonating the restaurant and giving customers the impression that the restaurant is offering the delivery service themselves.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by roenxi on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:26AM (#25602242)
Unless there is some rather serious context I'm missing - and as I said in another comment - the linked bill says:

> A food delivery platform shall not arrange for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility.

I don't think you can use Apps to send someone there without a problem. They have to get 'express authorisation' from the restaurant before they can accept your order. That is silly.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:31AM (#25602251)
As I answered to another poster, I believe the keyword here is "take orders".

You can't take orders on behalf of others, but you can freely arrange for someone in an app to "make an order" for you and then fetch the meal. That's my interpretation.

Of course it could/should be better worded, though.

EDIT: Also, someone also mentioned that courier apps are not "food delivery platforms", so the first few words of the paragraph you quoted already excludes them.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by Dylan16807 on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:05AM (#25602408)
> You can't take orders on behalf of others

This law does not say that at all. It's completely silent on whether the platform can take orders. It prohibits a single specific action, and that action is arranging for the delivery of an order.

> you can freely arrange for someone in an app to "make an order" for you and then fetch the meal.

You can arrange for them to make an order if you want to. That's allowed. But "fetching" sure sounds to me like they are delivering the order. They can't deliver it unless they have the specific authorization from the restaurant.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:13AM (#25602440)
The text that has been quoted all over this thread does say "to take orders and deliver meals". Sure it could be better worded, but it seems that the intent here is quite clear: to stop the practice that was being done by DoorDash/Postmates.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by Dylan16807 on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:50AM (#25602605)
Look at how the law is formulated: "A food delivery platform shall not X without Y."

X is the action the law allows or prohibits.

Y decides whether the action is allowed or not.

If "authorization to take orders and deliver meals" exists, then they can deliver. If "authorization to take orders and deliver meals" does not exist, then they cannot deliver.

"take orders" does not appear in the law anywhere else. It's only in the phrase "authorization to take orders", and in that context the law is only checking if that authorization exists. This particular law does not say when taking orders is allowed or prohibited. This law does not care if a platform is taking orders. It cares about whether the platform delivers, and it cares about whether the platform has "authorization to take orders and deliver meals".

-

Edit: Pretend for a second the law said "A food delivery platform shall not arrange for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to own puppies and deliver meals prepared by the food facility."

Would that law have any effect on whether the food delivery platform can own puppies? Nah. The restaurant has to say "you are allowed to own puppies" before the platform can deliver, but that law is not imbuing the puppy clause with any other power. It neither allows nor disallows actual puppy ownership.

-

So my main point is not that a platform should get cheeky by trying to take orders but not deliver, or something.

It's that even if they're not taking orders, this law blocks them from delivering. If they don't have the authorization, they can't deliver, end of story. The restaurant didn't say they can have a puppy, so they can't deliver, and it doesn't matter whether there actually is a puppy.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @07:22AM (#25602764)
Like I already said, it could be better worded, but, to me, its intent seems to be quite clear. You make good points, but I still have a different interpretation.
[dead]
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:51AM (#25602330)
Uber Eats or Uber Taxi? Uber Eats doesn't engage in the practices this law is trying to curb since they already have agreements in place with the restaurants (AFAIK), so you won't have to phone up anyone if you use Uber Eats.

If you're taking about Uber the Taxi app, or some courier service, then this law doesn't apply to them since they're not "food delivery platforms", and you can just ask them to order on your behalf without phoning anyone.

EDIT: Btw I'm not making any argument in favour or against the law, I'm just doing my best and trying to interpret it.

[dead]
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:27AM (#25602508)
The general agreement here is that the law was made because Doordash/Postmates were impersonating restaurants without authorization from them and taking orders in their behalf, so it's not exactly similar to your shoes examples.

Most people find the impersonation and lack of transparent unreasonable. Whether the law is the best tool to fix it or whether it will have side effects is what's in debate, but the main intention of the law seems pretty clear to everyone.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by GauntletWizard on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:04AM (#25602148)
I disagree with this law, like I've disagreed with many laws before it: the creation of a specific law implies that what came before was not fraud. It was fraud. Prosecute it as such.

Offering to courrier food from place A to B, including ordering the food from place A, should not be illegal. Pretending to be A to engage in that business is fraud, because you pretended to be A. It's that simple. This law is a giveaway to the companies that have already engaged in fraud.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:17AM (#25602207)
Good point, I agree with you.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by throwawaysea on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:53AM (#25602092)
Someone else posted the below excerpt of the law that also prohibits couriers (who are not impersonating anyone) unless they have permission from the restaurant. That seems like a ridiculous restriction to me.

> 22599. A food delivery platform shall not arrange for the delivery of an order from a food facility without first obtaining an agreement with the food facility expressly authorizing the food delivery platform to take orders and deliver meals prepared by the food facility.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:56AM (#25602104)
I don't think sending someone to perform a task is the same as taking an order, though. The restaurant is still the one taking the order for the food itself in the case of a courier.

Also the law seem to only include "food delivery platforms", which exclude couriers.

(Of course, I might be wrong, but it seems that the intent of the law is to stop impersonation, not couriers).

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by throwawaysea on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:01AM (#25602139)
Why can't I pay someone to place an order and pick it up for me? Can't I have someone go shop on my behalf at non-restaurant businesses? And if so, isn't it reasonable that a menu of options be shown with items and the costs? I agree that there should be transparency about who is delivering the food, there should be no impersonation of the restaurant, no false listing of phone numbers, and so on. But allowing restaurants to deny a courier without prior agreement seems like a government overreach.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by ratww on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:09AM (#25602173)
I think you misunderstood my reply: I don't think the law is forbidding someone making an order on your behalf and picking it up for you. I doubt it will affect normal courier services.

What I believe the law is forbidding is the lack of transparency, the false listing of phone numbers and taking orders on behalf of someone else.

EDIT: Btw, I'm not downvoting you as I can't downvote replies. I have upvoted to counter it.

Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by lkbm on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:54AM (#25603251)
Sure would be nice if the law mentioned something about impersonating the restaurant rather than merely adding restrictions on who can be a courier.
Re:California law bans delivery apps from listing a restaura... by foobar1962 on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:05AM (#25602158)
The problem is that if food isn't handled correctly it makes people sick. This law is about food safety.