News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by cocktailpeanuts on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:07AM (#25601028)
This is a brilliant piece of work. As someone who has thousands of tabs open, I've always wanted to "close all tabs with a single command", or view all the open tabs and mass select them and close, for years. Otherwise, going through them one by one and deleting takes forever. Now somebody make a vim pluggin so I can delete tabs by visual selecting a bunch of them and typing "d".
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by tobestobestobes on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:11PM (#25605222)
It's a huge leap forward in browser management. Not exactly a replacement for headless browsing/scraping etc, but for personal use, nothing compares. A big contribution to the "personal data management" toolbox.

In the realm of tab management, I use this one liner in console of chrome://inspect every once in a while, then just close all of my tabs:

  collection = document.getElementById("pages").getElementsByClassName("subrow"); final_output_tsv = "title\turl\n"; for (let item of collection) {final_output_tsv += `${item.children[0].innerHTML}\t${item.children[1] ? item.children[1].innerHTML : "N/A"}\n`}; copy(final_output_tsv)
Substitute "devices" for "pages" to get android chrome tabs

This way I can backup all my tabs in simple, non-bookmark format and search them using python etc.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by dsp_person on Sunday January 03, 2021 @02:12AM (#25620165)
cool this seems handy, but when I try my chrome://inspect/#pages only contains a small subset of tabs out of the few dozen windows I have open. Any tips?
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by tobestobestobes on Sunday January 03, 2021 @11:25AM (#25622692)
Looks like only recently opened tabs (or some variation on that) show up here. To test, reload all tabs In one window (I used an extension) and check out chrome://inspect again. It's all there. Maybe there's a good reason for not showing all pages in inspect. Who knows. Another problem is that my script grabs page subprocess urls also. I've mainly used this for grabbing my android tabs.

This is an adapted version that skips grabbing subprocesses

  collection = document.getElementById("pages").getElementsByClassName("subrow"); final_output_tsv = "title\turl\n"; for (let item of collection) {if(new RegExp("([a-zA-Z0-9]+://)?([a-zA-Z0-9_]+:[a-zA-Z0-9_]+@)?([a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\\.[A-Za-z]{2,4})(:[0-9]+)?(/.*)?").test(item.children[0].innerHTML) === false) final_output_tsv += `${item.children[0].innerHTML}\t${item.children[1] ? item.children[1].innerHTML : "N/A"}\n`}; copy(final_output_tsv)
edit: I used reload all tabs extension with reload all tabs in all windows option turned on. This could get messy.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by m463 on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:39AM (#25604426)
I keep a few tabs open, and close the browser regularly.

A friend of mine keeps basically infinity tabs open. I sort of rolled my eyes, but accepted his rare behavior.

However as time has gone on, I've been surprised to find I may have the rare behavior and it is common for people to work this way.

So.. maybe this is a way he can backup his "filesystem" and not suffer a nervous breakdown when his machine reboots or some othe browser failure where he loses his world.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by weaksauce on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:53PM (#25607590)
I am like your friend... basically tabs are a "working memory" that you don't want to store permanently in bookmarks. each window or sets of windows is typically a different topic that is being research on with a bunch of middle clicks to open tabs. I have so many open that I wrote a small webext for it that shows a page of all your tabs that you can click on to navigate to that tab with a click. just a nicer interface to see all the windows open and all the tabs. https://github.com/fiveNinePlusR/tabist
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by jsrcout on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:05PM (#25609968)
This is the extension I didn't know I needed, thank you!
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by weaksauce on Saturday January 02, 2021 @01:13PM (#25614877)
I hope you find it useful :) if you have any suggestions let me know. i have been working on a small upgrade to it where the tabs can be closed with a middle click and reordered in the windows but i don't work on it very often as it's quite useful as it stands for my needs

edit cmd-shift-e/ctrl-shift-e will open up the extension which I guess I should update on the homepage.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by loceng on Sunday January 03, 2021 @07:48AM (#25621464)
Hey cool, thanks, I've installed it now too - it'll be quite useful!

I'd love if you could have a link on the Tabist page that shows a popup allowing for copy/pasting of a text box to show list of titles/URL or just URLs for either easy sharing of a grouping of tabs or so I could do an occasional backup of URLs? Not sure if this person's code is useful for that: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25605222 ?

Maybe a global link for all windows and one per window?

Edit to add: I have a dream of someday contributing financially to a bunch of open source organizational tools that I'd like to see/would use and depend on heavily, let me know if interested in hearing more - can email me [email protected] if curious.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by weaksauce on Sunday January 03, 2021 @09:34PM (#25627402)
Awesome! I'm not sure if the version on the store has the tab backup feature enabled or not but there is a backup feature that is under the options area. It just dumps a json file with all your tabs and a restore feature where it opens up all those tabs again but that is really slow if you have a lot of tabs.

Interesting idea on the popup; I'll give that some thought.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by loceng on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:39AM (#25633716)
Cool, thanks. Another use case other than backup I was thinking is if just wanting to share a window of tabs (so all relating to a project) by copy/pasting it to someone in a message/email; I guess on flip side too, if person receiving the links also had Tabist then could have another popup to "open links" (maybe there's a way to do that in Chrome easily but I'm not aware); could eventually create a centralized service that just pushes the links to them and perhaps auto-opens them - obvious potential security issues there but arguably person you're receiving links from would be trusted by you.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by nicklaf on Saturday January 02, 2021 @06:35AM (#25612092)
> A friend of mine keeps basically infinity tabs open. I sort of rolled my eyes, but accepted his rare behavior.

For those in the comments who are like myself (and parent's friend) and have hundreds or even thousands of tabs open, I highly recommend the Panorama Tab Groups extension for Firefox:

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/panorama-tab-...

This extension adds back in the functionality that was removed from Firefox half a decade ago. It gives you a visual, 2D-map of arbitrary groups of tabs in a tile layout you can view with "Ctrl-Shift-F". Combined with the backup feature (just in case it crashes or gets corrupted, although this has yet to happen to me) and Firefox's built-in tab session saving option, so long as you have enough memory (I bought 40 gigs of RAM for this laptop after terrible memories of running Firefox on a Chromebook with 4GB of soldered RAM), you can basically browse as though you'll never have to close a tab again, AND also be able to stay organized.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by coliveira on Friday January 01, 2021 @02:34PM (#25606020)
I can have as much as 100 tabs open, depending on what I'm doing.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by kapilkaisare on Friday January 01, 2021 @02:28PM (#25605951)
Is having several tabs open in a browser rare? My social circle - which comprises mostly software engineers, admittedly - sees browsers with 30+ tabs open as normal.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by ksec on Friday January 01, 2021 @03:29AM (#25601739)
Same here, currently sitting at 300 tabs ( Lost about 800 a few weeks ago from Safari crash again ). I just wish the Show All tabs on Safari put up a list of tabs so I could quickly navigate through them ( and selectively close them ). Right now Show All Tabs Reloads all the tabs. That is the same on macOS and iOS. Your phone gets quite warm doing it.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by theelous3 on Friday January 01, 2021 @09:57AM (#25603648)
> Lost about 800 a few weeks ago from Safari crash again

Sounds like someone taking a corner at 200 mph and rolling their eyes when they hit the crash barrier. Not often is the following true, but - you're using that tool wrong.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by ksec on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:13AM (#25628814)
The crash has nothing to do with 800 tabs. Most of those Tabs are not active. And a crash, whether it has 1 tabs or 10000 tabs that lost the previous sessions is not using the tool wrong.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by theelous3 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:08PM (#25652512)
It wasn't designed for that kind of use, and it's being used that way. There are extensions, bookmarking tools, session savers, other browsers and all of their extensions, which are better able to handle this kind of thing.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by zeckalpha on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:17AM (#25603780)
Safari maintains a list of tabs in a plist. You can’t delete while Safari is running, but at least you can extract the list to back it up.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by ksec on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:40PM (#25604943)
Yes. I immediately check that after it happened except the plist was empty.

Firefox used to have similar problem with their json so after a few bug report with them they fixed it with another json.bak as redundancy. ( The good days of Firefox )

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by saagarjha on Saturday January 02, 2021 @05:19PM (#25617110)
Time Machine has saved me more than once in this case.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by lilyball on Friday January 01, 2021 @03:52AM (#25601829)
Show All Tabs on iOS definitely does not reload tabs. I know on macOS it used to force all tabs to load but I had the impression lately that it wasn’t doing that anymore (though I rarely use this feature).
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by ksec on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:37PM (#25604921)
iOS reloads them ( or partially load them ) as you scroll through it to get a screenshot. I tried it just now. Or they somehow saved a Screenshot of it. ( But then there is no reason why macOS safari isn't doing the same. )

macOS does the same except without the scrolling.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by lilyball on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:07PM (#25638916)
iOS saves screenshots of tabs. I scrolled through my own and found a bunch of old tabs (didn't realize I had so many) that just showed pure black.

macOS saves screenshots too, to show when hovering over a tab. Curiously, it doesn't seem to use these saved screenshots in Show All Tabs. Also I just tested, Show All Tabs on macOS is no longer loading unloaded tabs. I have a window with 13 tabs right now, only two of which I've visited since launching Safari, and the others just remain as blank in Show All Tabs.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by yudlejoza on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:16AM (#25601308)
1 - Right-click empty space next to the tabs and select 'Bookmark all tabs'

2 - Name the bookmark folder (within the top-level bookmark folder) something like: 'Tab-mess-from-<date-time>'

3 - Ctrl-F4 close them. Press and hold Ctrl, then F4 them one at a time. You can close 200+ tabs in a minute. (or as other suggested, right-click any tab and use the option 'close other tabs').

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by mulmen on Friday January 01, 2021 @02:38AM (#25601554)
I open a new window for each "task" and open tabs in that window, if it is non trivial I also move that window to a new Desktop/Space. When I want to shelve a task I bookmark all the tabs in that window into a dedicated folder then close the whole window and the desktop.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by catchmeifyoucan on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:14AM (#25603763)
you should try amna, which basically automates that process. You make a task, it gives you a chrome window for the task and syncs your work. You can then close the browser, and the data is saved.

http://getamna.com

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by frombody on Friday January 01, 2021 @03:59AM (#25601854)
There is a browser extension called onetab that does this for you.

The issue i find is that even if you create the perfect system, you still rarely m go back and revisit these tabs kept open.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by catchmeifyoucan on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:17AM (#25603781)
Try amna - https://getamna.com.

It can make this a little better by storing the tabs as part of a task. Soo you can get back to them as part of a context rather than just a link.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by _flux on Friday January 01, 2021 @03:27AM (#25601724)
I've used this extension for doing mass closes: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/sorted-tabs/

As a bonus you can arrange URLs by name, url, or time next to each other, so it's usually fast to churn through related or duplicate tabs.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by rohan1024 on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:55AM (#25601431)
> Ctrl-F4 close them. Press and hold Ctrl, then F4 them one at a time.

Ctrl-F4 shuts down entire browser, Ctrl-W closes each tab with a press of w. This is behavior in Ubuntu and it holds true for most application windows.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by _flux on Friday January 01, 2021 @03:25AM (#25601713)
Alt-F4 closes the entire browser, and indeed Ctrl-F4 closes the current tab. (Just tried it out, I've always used Ctrl-W for that.)
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by rohan1024 on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:07AM (#25602164)
My bad now I tried the Ctrl+F4 and yes it works exactly the way OP said. I assumed he was talking about Alt+F4 :)
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by rasz on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:46AM (#25601196)
>thousands of tabs open

yeah about that, are you sure they are open and not hibernated? Chrome had proactive-tab-freeze-and-discard , later renamed to proactive-tab-freeze and finally forced On in 80 with no option of turning it off. 'hibernated' tabs are merely a bookmark without loaded content. I dont think this extension would be able to work with non loaded tabs without forcing them all to load. 300 tabs is able to easily eat 16GB of ram, Im scared to think what would happen with 1000 tabs loaded in Chrome.

I remember good old Opera 12.x where you could sit on 200 actually loaded and active tabs and RAM usage was somewhere around 2GB.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by superkuh on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:03AM (#25601258)
Using single process Firefox forks I often load in 500 tabs plus another 500+ suspended in under 4 GB. Of course I'm also running NoScript temp whitelist only and most sites are websites not web applications. But 1000 loaded tabs is certainly doable in way less than 16GB of ram if you don't use a multi-process browser. It's just a shame this is written as a chrome style extension (which modern FF supports) and not a firefox extension.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by eitland on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:18AM (#25601931)
Which fork do you use?

I'm starting to get seriously tempted to go with one of the forks. I seriously miss the old extensions.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by superkuh on Saturday January 02, 2021 @11:07AM (#25613687)
Pale Moon. Although I usually try to not say which fork aloud on HN because anything but FF gets massively downvoted.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by mcdevilkiller on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:15PM (#25605250)
You can use auto tab discard. I've done 1500 tabs on an 8GB windows machine.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by saurik on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:00AM (#25604134)
Somehow, Chrome doesn't seem to actually do this despite claims to, which is why I use The Great Suspender (a Chrome extension that actually hibernates tabs).
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by herewulf on Saturday January 02, 2021 @03:06PM (#25615983)
WARNING: The Great Suspender as distributed from the Chrome Web Store appears to come with malware. See this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25615971
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by db48x on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:18AM (#25601080)
If you just want to close all tabs then in Firefox right click a tab and select "Close Other Tabs". Also, you can control-click on tabs to apply commands the the whole set, such as closing them, sending them to your phone, etc.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by drran on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:48AM (#25602599)
In Firefox, you can click at tab bar and select "Select all tabs", then bookmark them all, then close them all.

Also, "Auto discard tab" plugin does a good job by keeping unused tabs closed, to save resources.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by db48x on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:46AM (#25604489)
I'm not sure an addon is necessary for that. Firefox automatically unloads any tab that hasn't been used in a while.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by axbytg on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:52AM (#25601213)
> As someone who has thousands of tabs open

This behavior always confuses me. To what end? Have you ever derived any value from a tab you chose not to close?

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by wutbrodo on Friday January 01, 2021 @02:09AM (#25601475)
Hm, I'm kind of confused by your perspective here. Do you only have a single thread of tasks you're doing at any given time on your machine, all of whose resources are torn down and rebuilt from scratch when needed? I use my current laptop both for work and personally, and in my personal workspaces alone, I have at least half a dozen browser windows with ~20 tabs representing research that I'm doing or a task that I'm organizing; everything from gift-buying to medical devices for a family issue to building a new workout routine for the pandemic. You can rack up tons of relevant tabs pretty quickly in these scenarios, and there's really no advantage to closing them in any well-managed environment (ie one that has non-rudimentary window management and a browser/extension that handles idle tabs with negligible ongoing resource use).

I probably have hundreds of "productive" tabs open, and that's before even getting to tabs that are serving as an "L1 cache" version of a read-it-later service. And all of this comes with extremely quick clean-up; once I buy the gift/finalize the routine/purchase the item, it's trivial to close the entire window for that task.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by samb1729 on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:19AM (#25602218)
I cannot speak for the user you replied to, but to answer this question:

> Do you only have a single thread of tasks you're doing at any given time on your machine, all of whose resources are torn down and rebuilt from scratch when needed?

Yes, absolutely, at least when it comes to my web browser.

I run Firefox Nightly and intentionally use its prompt to restart for an update as a prompt to consider whether I should close the things I have open. I'll sometimes ignore the update for a few hours, but not usually longer than that.

If I need to retain some information over a period of more than a few hours, I'll transfer it to a note-taking app or something similar. Habitually not keeping a large number of tabs open helps me maintain focus to some extent, and deliberating over whether to close a tab or window presents and opportunity to think about extracting a snippet for storage elsewhere.

To me the idea of keeping an entire webpage open as a method of storing what is likely a very small subset of what it contains just doesn't seem "right", regardless of actual resource consumption on the computer I'm using.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by mark_l_watson on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:33AM (#25602259)
I do the same. In a notes app, I have a TODO note where I save links and a few word description of what a link is. This gives me one place to maintain a reading list.

I also have notes for current projects/tasks. I have structure and search to find things.

As a life-hack to make better use of my time, I use the Freedom.io service to block all social media and “time wasting” sites so that I can only access them before work, first half hour of lunch time, and after end of work day. In practice what this means is that I scan HN and Twitter early each morning for tech stuff that is useful/interesting and add any useful links to my notes. Every few days I edit my notes to discard material.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by samb1729 on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:08AM (#25602423)
On the topic of blocking distractions, I've found that creating a separate user account for focus time helps quite a bit, since it's sufficiently annoying to remove that particular barrier. Choosing not to configure a keyboard shortcut for account switching was a good call, too.

I tried using multiple Little Snitch profiles or different browsers on the same user account in the past but switching between them is way too low effort for my easily distracted brain. Getting back into distraction mode can be performed on autopilot in those cases.

That little delay in waiting for my watch to unlock my user account is just long enough to make me stop and think, and the vibration is like a gentle slap on the wrist.

My focus account has a single Little Snitch profile configured to block the time-vampires I know I'm susceptible to, along with Firefox configured to clear history on close. I don't need to be reminded Twitter exists just because I opened my browser and pressed T, they should at least have to pay for the privilege of advertising to my brain!

In general I think that taking full advantage of computers to make absolutely everything instantly accessible is in many ways actively harmful to many types of brains. We live in an economy and too many of us just give that stuff away.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by masa331 on Friday January 01, 2021 @02:34AM (#25601544)
Having hundreds or thousands open tabs also confuses me and always seems like a mess to me.

The way i work: I mostly work on a one thing at a time. For that i can have probably at max 40 tabs open. Once it gets past some threshold(i don't recognize or remember what's in them) i tend to start to close the obsolete ones. If there is something i find useful i bookmark it. If there is something i think i would like to read in future i also bookmark it. Once the work is done i close all the tabs. In general i like my tabs closed, it brings peace to my mind.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by samb1729 on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:30AM (#25602247)
> it brings peace to my mind.

Mine too.

My thoughts on this kind of thing aren't in any way backed by studies or research (I know some folks are sticklers for that sort of thing), but they essentially boil down to reflecting on human history.

The ability to store a huge amount of information and near-instantly recall it with these computery things we all love is an incredibly new development that I don't really consider compatible with my brain. If the brain is a somewhat general purpose computer that's been really slowly optimised by evolution, the alternative approach to ours is akin to* scheduling hundreds of threads on a small number of hardware threads. Doable? Sure. Ideal? Doesn't feel like it to me.

I've tried allowing myself to just continuously spawn tabs and it makes me uncomfortable much like it does to see a Windows desktop used as a dumping ground for whatever a person happens to want to save on their machine. Fortunately I almost never see the latter these days, and I'll choose to believe people don't do that anymore without verifying that assumption...

*this is really hand-wavy, please don't shoot.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by franga2000 on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:37AM (#25602013)
I don't think I go into thousands, but easily accumulate a few 100 tabs. The way I work, I rarely have a task truly done in one go. Besides various side projects, I work on multiple websites for multiple clients and constantly need to put one on hold and wait for feedback, so I go work on another one. If I expect feedback withing a ~2 day period, it really doesn't make sense for me to close the related tabs. Not only does it save time when picking up the task again, but helps me reconstruct my train of thought without having to take notes.

The way I think of it is kind of like swap memory. Instead of wasting effort saving to disk and verifying the saved data (taking notes), I chuck the data somewhere it isn't in the way (a new virtual desktop) so I can pick it up later. In fact, this is exactly what happens with the tabs at the system level. Since I'm constantly running out of ram and have a stupid amount of swap space set up, my OS gladly swaps the relevant browser processes and unswap the relevant set.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by iam-TJ on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:27AM (#25601971)
May I recommend Zotero [0] to you?

"Your personal research assistant

Zotero is a free, easy-to-use tool to help you collect, organize, cite, and share research."

Like you I am an avaricious multi-tasker over extended periods of time and was heading towards the same state you appear to have reached.

I realised it was not optimal and did some research and discovered Zotero. I use it personally and require it at my businesses.

It adds several wonderful abilities - best is the ability to share and collaborate on research at will.

[0] https://www.zotero.org/

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by wutbrodo on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:47PM (#25609418)
> Like you I am an avaricious multi-tasker over extended periods of time and was heading towards the same state you appear to have reached.

> I realised it was not optimal

I will take a look, thank you! Would you mind briefly elaborating on what you found suboptimal about the workspace/window/tab hierarchy for organizing your tasks? So far it's working very well for me, and the low friction is a really important part of it. Though it's completely possible that I have blind spots around my pain points, or am about to run into a wall. Thanks in advance for your thoughts?

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by iam-TJ on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:41PM (#25610174)
My issues with tabs, even with extensions that organise them:

  * sheer mental challenge of quickly relocating related tabs and the context for why they were kept and relationships between them

  * inability to easily add WIP notes and commentary

  * difficulty of sharing tabs and context with others

  * possibility of losing them if power lost unexpectedly (during extended suspend for example) or accidentally close a single window instead of doing File > Quit

  * moving between different devices and different browsers

  * efficiency; affect on the browser and system of keeping tabs open for long periods of time (without quitting browser)
I don't use workspaces for the same reason I don't like tabbing between applications on the same monitor. I use multiple monitors so I only need to move my eyes to switch focus.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by wutbrodo on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:28PM (#25610388)
This all makes sense, thank you. The friction-free aspect of browser windows is still pretty critical to my workflow, but I'll look into whether it makes sense to grow the habit of "migrating" a task to Zotero when it gets heavy-duty enough.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by iam-TJ on Saturday January 02, 2021 @07:11PM (#25617996)
I first discovered Zotero via the Mozilla add-ons search whilst looking for an extension to help me. Using the Firefox/Chromium connector puts it a context-click away:

Zotero Connector > Save To Zotero > "Web Page with Snapshot" / "Web Page without Snapshot"

So I can both maintain the tab workflow whilst 'tracking' progress with Zotero application itself.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by catchmeifyoucan on Saturday January 02, 2021 @03:30PM (#25616204)
This describes Amna quite well. I think you'd love it! It's still early, but a lot fo the things you mention, we're working on.

https://getamna.com

It's designed like a todo list which is a layer out to keep that context

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by iam-TJ on Saturday January 02, 2021 @07:20PM (#25618059)
The promo looks slick but there are two blockers for me:

  1.  Not FOSS (Hard requirement *)
  2.  Basic/Free version doesn't claim Firefox connector
* I insist all my businesses use only FOSS for core functionality and we have on-premise capability (no 'cloud'). As well as putting us in control of our own destiny (we have the talent) we can add specific functionality at-will and do contribute that back to projects as well as buying support contracts or making regular donations.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by catchmeifyoucan on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:50AM (#25619824)
Thanks for calling it out! Open Source is a consideration, but we're not there just yet with it. You still have 'On' Premise with Amna. All data is stored on your machine.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by benedikt on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:58AM (#25602363)
> well-managed environment (ie one that has non-rudimentary window management and a browser/extension that handles idle tabs with negligible ongoing resource use).

Can you elaborate on this? Which extensions are you talking about?

I also rack up hundreds of tabs and my browser is often the main resource hog for me. I’ll often have to kill -9 it to force it to start with “oops we crashed, here are your previous tabs in an unloaded state”, but it sounds like you have a better way of doing this

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by wutbrodo on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:40PM (#25609364)
I currently use the Great Suspender on Chrome, which will suspend a tab that's been open for a while. The suspended tab just shows a Great Suspender icon, so it takes up ~0 RAM. I've whitelisted certain domains and sites (eg Messenger apps).

I know there are a ton of extensions aimed at this problem, including OneTab (which will collapse many tabs into a single page of links), but TGS works the best for my workflow.

I also use Session Buddy to periodically backup my current window/tab state, which I find more reliable and powerful than the default tab-restore functionality.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by herewulf on Saturday January 02, 2021 @03:04PM (#25615971)
DANGER, Will Robinson!

I could really use something like the Great Suspender. However, looking into it, I found quite a bit of controversy surrounding its new (since June) "maintainer". This issue sums it up well: "SECURITY: New maintainer is probably malicious"[1]

Here is the gist of it:

> Using the chrome web store version of this extension, without disabling tracking, will execute code from an untrusted third-party on your computer, with the power to modify any and all websites that you see.

So, installing from the Chrome Web Store is a complete no-go.

One can still install the extension from GitHub, but with Chrome constantly evolving and the now, unmaintained-on-GitHub extension having known issues with losing all your tabs (to which there are workarounds), I'm very wary of using this extension.

[1]: https://github.com/greatsuspender/thegreatsuspender/issues/1...

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by wutbrodo on Sunday January 03, 2021 @02:11PM (#25624172)
Thank you for the heads-up! The way extension stores work always made me a little uneasy about using smaller ones like this.

Edit: haha, someone seems to have seen your comment and made a post that made it to the Frontpage of HN

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by herewulf on Sunday January 03, 2021 @05:29PM (#25625828)
You're welcome! Yes, it's quite problematic and there are numerous ways malicious code can abuse the sandboxed environment.

That's great news about that article! Thanks for pointing that out.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25622015

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by fuzxi on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:06PM (#25608257)
The Firefox extension "Auto Tab Discard" is what you're looking for. Not sure about equivalents for other browsers.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by edrobap on Friday January 01, 2021 @02:52AM (#25601604)
I have seen this behaviour repeatedly. Having to many “task windows” makes it difficult to focus. Similar to having to many tasks in Asana or emails in my Inbox. Prioritisation is the only option to come out of this. Unfortunately, I haven’t found a way to tag priority with the “task windows”. And that’s the reason I daily browse through all windows and close the ones that are not urgent.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by wutbrodo on Friday January 01, 2021 @09:11PM (#25609571)
Hm, I haven't found this to be the case. This is probably in part because of my WM/OS setup; I use a tiling window manager and different workspaces for different contexts, so my fan-out factor is never that high in cases where it matters.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by imtringued on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:33AM (#25603129)
I derive close to zero value from bookmarks. The only value they provide is that they appear in the address bar during searches. They are organized in a linear fashion, they require constant maintenance and they are also not immediately accessible often requiring you to open a separate window. Worst of all even if you choose to do something as stupid as manage bookmarks you will now have to have to manage both tabs and bookmarks at the same time.

Tabs? They are easy to organize, easily accessible because they are always visible and they are powerful enough to completely remove the need for bookmarks which makes using bookmarks always inferior because of the downsides of bookmarks.

Now lets get to the actual point:

>Have you ever derived any value from a tab you chose not to close?

I close tabs that I don't need eventually, bookmarks just keep accumulating because there is an easy method to add them, but actually finding or deleting bookmarks is a lot of effort.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by opan on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:08PM (#25604668)
It helps if you use tags more than folders for bookmarks, that way you can have a page marked as "dogs, computers", another as "dogs, pizza" and then filter to dogs to see both. It also helps (in firefox) if you know the special symbols you can put in the address bar for filtering. * for normal bookmarks, I think + for tags, and % works for open tabs. Follow them with a space and your keyword.

I've been using qutebrowser mainly for a couple months now, and I find the way bookmarks and quickmarks fit into the standard open or open in new tab dialogue feels very powerful. I often am just hitting O to open in new tab, typing a few characters, and picking a result from bookmarks or history. Searching and going to a URL happens there too. I try to use either descriptive names like "guix-bug-issue" for quickmarks so they show up when I type any of those bits (bug and issue intentionally redundant so if I think to search either, it comes up), or I use very shorts strings like "lfm" for my last.fm profile. In the case of these shorter ones, you get the added advantage of being able to go there without looking. If you type an exact quickmark name in the box and hit enter, it goes straight there, you don't have to wait and look over the suggestions in the box.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by Firerouge on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:12AM (#25601293)
Chrome only preserves browsing history for 90 days. Keeping tabs open can work around that limitation
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by samb1729 on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:07AM (#25602163)
Without even bothering to check, this seems like it can't possibly be true. You are surely not saying that the billions of Chrome users worldwide have no browsing history from September or earlier, right?
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by ossopite on Friday January 01, 2021 @09:17AM (#25603402)
That's absolutely right, at least in terms of the Chrome browser history. I always found this limitation astounding.

I use the History Trends Unlimited extension to work around this (https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/history-trends-unl...)

With 5 years of history the stats page is a bit slow to load but the search feature works great and it can export to CSV

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by brw on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:14AM (#25603014)
"Your History page shows the webpages you've visited on Chrome in the last 90 days."[0]

Google's My Activity[1] stores everything though.

[0] https://support.google.com/chrome/answer/95589

[1] https://myactivity.google.com/myactivity

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by saurik on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:01AM (#25604145)
Damn, that's ridiculously evil... why the hell am I only able to get basic functionality through a cloud service?!
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by saagarjha on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:00AM (#25601244)
Yes–I go back and read them occasionally. By keeping things open I get frequent reminders to look at things and sometimes I do.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by rohan1024 on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:58AM (#25601437)
I used to do this now I just search again and occasionally I will bookmark a page that is too valuable to miss in future searches.

This keeps my bookmarks clean.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by eitland on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:21AM (#25601947)
> Have you ever derived any value from a tab you chose not to close?

Not GP but of course!

Why would we close something we are going back to?

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by blackrock on Friday January 01, 2021 @03:47AM (#25601802)
I open a new window to research a specific topic. Then I open up all the links on sub tabs.

This encloses all my research for this subject in one window. Often times I have upwards of 10+ windows opened. Since some of the work spans over several days or weeks.

I also take screenshots of relevant information. Which gets automatically labeled by date and time into a screenshot folder, and sub-sorted into months.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by tveyben on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:54AM (#25602347)
This is where I miss to be able to name each group-of-tabs (the window) with a name so I can manage (eg when alt-tab’ing) quickly.

So window ‘topic-1’ have 10 tabs relating to ‘topic-1’ and the property ‘topic-1’ is visible in my WM.

Is this possible (I have not -yet - searched ‘enough’ for this functionality...)?

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by tveyben on Saturday January 02, 2021 @10:07AM (#25613257)
I am very happy to have shared my thoughts here (and received good feedback and suggestions!), but the best is that it finally made me look into this need - and I am not the first (big surprise :-)

It turns out that just very recently exactly what I need was made possible in Chrome (currently only "experimental") just set this flag [1]. I especially like that it's possible without the need of third party SW.

This page [2] is what alerted my attention to the solution.

NB.: It does make me wonder why this feature have not existed until now as it seems so obvious, I mean ever since the introduction of the TABbed interface in browsers (which started pre 2000 IIRC) the (over-) usage pattern of tabs existed.

Anyway - even if I have missed something pre-existing I am now extremely happy to be able to name my TABS in Chrome!

[1] chrome://flags/#window-naming

[2] https://winaero.com/how-to-name-a-window-in-google-chrome/

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by noisy_boy on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:36AM (#25602557)
I use Window Titler[0] for this because I use the same workflow of opening a new window for each "topic".

[0]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/window-titler...

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by catchmeifyoucan on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:21AM (#25603823)
Try Amna. https://getamna.com.

You can do this per chrome window and bubble the tasks up to a task.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by noisy_boy on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:37AM (#25602562)
This is exactly how I "partition" my work; makes closing logically related tabs super simple too - just close the window related to the "topic".
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by polm23 on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:27AM (#25601345)
Onetab is great for dealing with that.

https://www.one-tab.com/

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by npongratz on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:03PM (#25605143)
With vim's netrw plugin [0], I'm able to do this:

  $ cd ~/tmp/foo
  $ touch a b c d e
  $ vim .
Then select the file(s) you wish to delete, press D (must be capital "D"), confirm the deletion, and Bob's your uncle.

[0] https://www.vim.org/scripts/script.php?script_id=1075

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by ssalka on Saturday January 02, 2021 @01:26PM (#25615012)
FWIW in Chromium-based browsers you can shift+click tabs to select multiple, then close all selected at once or drag selected to new window
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by aoeusnth1 on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:53AM (#25601218)
Vim already supports a decent file explorer view, if you edit a directory instead of a file. It’s sort of like emacs’ dired (DIRectory EDit).
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by eitland on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:13AM (#25601907)
> I've always wanted to "close all tabs with a single command", or view all the open tabs and mass select them and close, for years.

In Firefox you can right-click on a tab and close

- all tabs

- or all tabs to the right

If you use tree style tabs you can also close a tree or a subtree.

Edit: and there is an extension (yep :) to the tree style tab extension to allow you to export a subtree as a nested list of links - in Markdown!

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by franga2000 on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:23AM (#25601951)
Since recently, you can also ctrl- and shift-select them and either move or close just those tabs. Sounded like a gimmick when I first saw it, but it has proven to be a huge time saver when I neeed to split a window in two because my browsing session has expanded far beyond the original scope or kill a bunch of tabs in the middle somewhere because a thread of searching has proven fruitless.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by nine_k on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:20AM (#25602224)
In Firefox, you can install the Tree-Style Tabs extension, and have a reasonable tree of tabs. It does resemble a filesystem tree a bit.

I think it's the most important extension for people who do heavy browsing, research things online, etc.

Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by netsharc on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:39AM (#25602027)
Vivaldi has a tabs panel that lists all open tabs (as well as recently closed ones) like files in Windows Explorer, you can multi-select them and hit delete, or indeed hit Ctrl-A and delete. Sadly afaik there's no filter to e.g. select all Stack Overflow tabs.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by bayesianbot on Saturday January 02, 2021 @03:59PM (#25616476)
You can a) right-click a stack overflow tab, stack them and then close them all or b) control-ddubleclick one site and Vivaldi will autoselect all from same domain.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by Shared404 on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:14AM (#25601058)
This does seem like a brilliant idea, doesn't it. I'm thinking about how difficult it would be to setup something like 'surf' but using chromium/firefox, and then driving it completely off the CLI. It honestly sounds like my dream browser.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by twobitshifter on Sunday January 03, 2021 @09:15AM (#25621865)
The author mentioned dired for emacs which is the perfect tool for this. Is there an equivalent file plugin for vim?
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by frob on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:14AM (#25601061)
You can kinda do that with the vimium plugin. Select a bunch of tabs and press "x", but it doesn't support visual selection of tabs.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by Havelock on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:12PM (#25604709)
I have the same problem. I'm currently testing out the new tabmanager.io extension that seems to have a lot of potential.
Re:TabFS: Mount your Browser Tabs as a Filesystem by jmercouris on Friday January 01, 2021 @07:18PM (#25608827)
This is possible in Nyxt browser, :-)