News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by rkagerer on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:02PM (#25598831)
I bought my smartphone from Hong Kong, in part because I wanted a specific variant that would be more likely to work with open-source ROM's.

The seller initially requested payment via Transferwise, who sought crazy amounts of personal information and bullied me into a privacy-hostile customer agreement. Days went by and they still hadn't activated my account.

Growing frustrated, I convinced the seller to accept Bitcoin, which was comparatively instant. The phone arrived a few days later, meanwhile the Transferwise morons still had their heads up their arses with no movement and no good explanation. I'm not a financial risk; I'm a good little citizen with no red flags. Reading between the lines my sense was their staff were overloaded or their onboarding system was simply broken.

Bitcoin was incredibly helpful for me that day, and my favorite feature about the phone is the way I paid. In addition to a great story, I've got to admit there was something liberating and empowering about giving what felt like a big middle finger to the slow, decrepit, old-fashioned institution who couldn't even deliver on their core business proposition. Like saying "screw you, I don't need you and your crappy service anymore, come back when you can compete on merits".

Whatever else you criticize about Bitcoin, it's still "cash you can email", and even if that's all it ever amounts to I still find it a bloody useful innovation.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by freewilly1040 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @11:21PM (#25600819)
In payments the 99% case where everyone acts in good faith and no one makes a mistake is the easy part. It's when eg the seller refuses to send the phone that the extra overhead of the traditional payment system comes into play.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by bigphishy on Thursday December 31, 2020 @11:39PM (#25600904)
Establishing trust between seller and buyer is not a new problem. The same scenario that you described could be had with mailing checks, physical cash etc. wherever there is not a trusted escrow service.

Ironically, blockchain technology is the first technology that actually solves the age old problem of how to establish trust within a truestless system.

imho Bitcoin is a novel implementation of open-source technology, cryptography, and decentralized networks. I realize hackernews community has a disdain for greed and the avarice that is commonly connoted with "cryptocurrency" aka crypto-assets, but the reality is that bitcoin and crypto-assets are here to stay, and I for one am glad they are open-source.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by freewilly1040 on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:20AM (#25601087)
My critique is not about greed. My critique is about crypto proponents claiming it does things it doesn’t do.

The GP complains about the overhead and data collection of traditional solutions, implying it’s a bunch of unnecessary cruft. In fact it’s to comply with local laws and protect the consumer and merchant from fraud. GP used Bitcoin to get around this hassle, renouncing any rights in the event of a dispute.

Now, maybe that’s a win, but it’s a much more nuanced and less generalized win than is put forth by crypto proponents.

Notice also the goalpost move of declaring Bitcoin a win over mailing cash. Ok, have you ever done that in your life? I have not been involved in mailed cash transactions aside from receiving $5 from my grandma in the mail 20 years ago.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by bigphishy on Friday January 01, 2021 @02:31AM (#25601540)
actually yes, every month I pay my rent by mailing a check. Also, what is the acronym 'GP' ?
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by xapata on Friday January 01, 2021 @03:54AM (#25601838)
Mailing a check is not mailing cash. I'm sure you're familiar with the differences.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by raindropm on Friday January 01, 2021 @02:54AM (#25601609)
GP = grand parent. The topmost parent comment we’ve reply (or refer)to.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by Macha on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:05PM (#25609969)
> The same scenario that you described could be had with mailing checks, physical cash etc. wherever there is not a trusted escrow service.

Isn't that exactly why this mailing cash/cheques fell out of favor compared to bank transfers, credit cards, PayPal, all these centralised systems that bitcoin posits are a problem

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by majewsky on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:39PM (#25599194)
Can we have "cash you can email" that doesn't consume as much electricity as several nation states combined?
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by cesarb on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:24PM (#25599719)
Here in Brazil, we have that since last month. The new money transfer system (Pix) allows anyone to send money to a key, which can be a person's CPF (the tax ID number nearly everyone has), a phone number, an email, or a randomly-generated number. These all map to a bank account (you can also use Pix to send directly to a bank account number); the directory with these mappings is kept by the Brazilian Central Bank, and the mappings are inserted by the participating financial institutions.

So assuming my email was [email protected], and I had asked my bank to map the Pix key "[email protected]" to my bank account, anyone could "send cash" through Pix to my [email protected] email; the cash would arrive at my bank account nearly instantly (even during weekends and/or holidays).

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by Kinrany on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:11PM (#25600109)
From this description it sounds like just name resolution that still uses the regular banking system.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by cesarb on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:59PM (#25600390)
The name resolution is just part of it (though the most visible part); there's also a new message exchange protocol, over the national inter-bank network, which does the instant transfers (before this new protocol, inter-bank transfers were only instant during banking hours, not on nights/weekends/holidays).
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by bigphishy on Thursday December 31, 2020 @11:50PM (#25600952)
Fascinating, this is the first time I've heard of Pix. Can you own the private key? Can you create an account without having a bank account?
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by ignoramous on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:17AM (#25601072)
Can't talk for Pix, but UPI, a similar system implemented by Indian banks, wouldn't accept "private keys" or not having a bank account. No international payments either.

UPI is more like venmo on steroids, but it is no crypto-currency replacement.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unified_Payments_Interface

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by luizparreira on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:03AM (#25602962)
No, PIX is directly tied to your Bank Account. You need to have a bank account opened with an institution that connects your account to PIX.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by biolurker1 on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:03AM (#25601865)
Can you get banned from Pix?
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by luizparreira on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:05AM (#25602971)
Thats a good question. PIX is directly tied to your bank account, so I imagine if your bank decides to ban your account, you won't be able to use PIX through that account/bank anymore. But, I suppose you could open another account in another bank, move your previous PIX keys to it or create new ones.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by biolurker1 on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:28AM (#25603103)
Not how it works.. One banks bans you and you are screwed for life. That's the value proposition of bitcoin
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by luizparreira on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:45AM (#25604482)
Oh, didn't know that. Can you point out where it says that? From what I understand of PIX, it is tied to your transactional bank account. If you have multiple bank accounts and you are banned by one bank, your account on the other banks are not automatically banned and you can still transact with it, I would imagine PIX would still work.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by everfree on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:08PM (#25599547)
Many coins are experimenting with alternative consensus algorithms, the most promising imo is proof of stake.

No wasted energy beyond the cost of running a normal computer.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by majewsky on Thursday December 31, 2020 @11:41PM (#25600915)
Is this 2021 or 2015?
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by nmlnn on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:54PM (#25600372)
Sure, you just need to trust people.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by biolurker1 on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:04AM (#25601867)
You got Pos wrong there is no trust involved
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by nmlnn on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:19AM (#25601934)
Sure, not until some entity gets over 50% of the stake
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by biolurker1 on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:57AM (#25602358)
Sorry you do not understand how the system works. You can't buy 50% because the price would be worth more than all world gdp since each order is incrementally how gher and the supply of coins is not unlimited. Good to dig into things before you mindlessly dismiss them. Did you actually believe that people are designing and talking about Pos as a breakthrough when the main idea is "nobody rich enough will want to buy 50%"?
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by mareko on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:04AM (#25602151)
For newer PoS protocols, they would need over 66% and they would lose money if they misbehaved making it likely uneconomical to do so. This is the big advantage of PoS over PoW. There are both positive incentives (e.g. block rewards) but also negative ones (e.g. getting slashed for trying to stage a double spend attack).
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by nyhc99 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:44PM (#25600317)
Polkadot, Cardano, Stellar, soon to be Ethereum 2.0. Proof of Stake is where it's at if you are concerned with the power consumption of Proof of Work.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by wyldfire on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:08PM (#25599551)
Yes. Proof of stake coins like nano don't require any proof of work. Peercoin, too. Ethereum is considering PoS IIRC.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by DennisP on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:42PM (#25608030)
Ethereum has a proof of stake chain in production right now, in the sense that it is running with over a billion dollars worth of real ETH. But it won't run user transactions and contracts until the EVM migrates over, probably late 2021, and that's when PoW will go away.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by mareko on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:05PM (#25600056)
What about cash that you can send like an SMS on a network that offsets its CO2?

Celo is proof of stake based and also issues part of its block rewards to Project Wren. It has a native stablecoin and a decentralized phone verification protocol that lets you send money to any phone number.

Check out celo.org and ValoraApp.com

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by xur17 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @11:12PM (#25600780)
Is this vulnerable to sim swap attacks?
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by mareko on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:58AM (#25602115)
No. Funds are still protected by a private key once you create an account, so stealing a phone number doesn't help you spend someone's money.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by DeafSquid on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:50PM (#25599330)
How much electricity do you think traditional money printing and transfers consume?
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by graeme on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:01PM (#25599451)
Much less? Bitcoin currently powers almost none of the world’s transactions, yet consumes all that energy.

The entire us consumes 75 twh in a year, the same as bitcoin’s global energy use.

Of that, the entire commercial sector is about 12 twh. That’s not just banks. That’s every company. Banks alone are surely far less. Maybe 2-3 twh? And the us is 15% of global gdp. So, global finance might consume about 14-32 twh.

Again, that is while doing all of global finance. Bitcoin powers a rounding error of transactions yet consumes 75 twh.

There’s just no comparison energy wise. My math could be off by several orders of magnitude and bitcoin would still consume more if it were actually powering the world’s transactions.

https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/us-energy-facts/

https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by blake1 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:04PM (#25600050)
The US consumes about 4 PWh/year, so bitcoin isn't comparable with the nation as a whole. However, that is more power consumption than many individual states, so your overall point remains completely valid.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by matt-attack on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:19PM (#25610056)
Your units are funny. Using W-hr (energy) and then making it a rate by making it per year which gets you back to power. You could have just said, “the US consumes energy at a rate of 450 GW”.

There’s no need to introduce hrs and years to the mix. Watts describe precisely what you’re attempting to quantify.

https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=4+PW+hr%2Fyear+in+GW&o...

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by graeme on Thursday December 31, 2020 @11:28PM (#25600858)
Whoops yeah that should have been 9.4 quadrillion BTU. The online calculator I used for TWH conversion was very wrong. Looks like the correct value is about 2,000 twh for the us commercial sector?

If we assume banks are 10% of that, then it’s 200 twh. 3x bitcoin. But also, handling literally all finance and banking in the US. Vs essentially nothing for bitcoin, compared to the scale of the us economy.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by issamehh on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:13PM (#25607209)
It'd be really nice if I could find a study on this, but just because bitcoin doesn't power the majority of the transactions doesn't mean it couldn't do so without the energy needs scaling linearly with transactions. If anything I'd imagine it could become more efficient as more transactions were taking place. I see people argue this a lot and I think it's too narrow of a view on the situation.

Of course it'd be much better for us to adopt a crypto currency that uses a different algorithm that has even less energy usage. Even without that though I think it could prove to be more efficient than existing financial systems.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by phaemon on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:11PM (#25600106)
Your numbers are totally wrong. The fact your own link suggests that bitcoin uses as much electrical energy as Chile should tell you it's not close to the USA. Recheck?
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by biolurker1 on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:04AM (#25601868)
Bitcoin transacted way more money that PayPal etc
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by graeme on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:34AM (#25603131)
People actually buy stuff on paypal. They processed 2.5 billion transactions in 2020. Bitcoin processed about 250 million transactions.

The total amount of reported money transacted might be higher for bitcoin but that doesn’t come from contact with the real economy. So that depends on the valuation of bitcoin rather than economic impact.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/277841/paypals-total-pay...

https://www.statista.com/statistics/730806/daily-number-of-b...

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by cool_dude85 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:11PM (#25599589)
When confronted with relatively concrete studies on Bitcoin's wasteful energy use, are you going to point to the fact that physical money printer energy use has not been studied to muddy the waters? The reason it hasn't been studied is that it doesn't use a huge amount of electricity.

Anyway, as another way of answering your question, physical money printing and transfers require no electricity at all, predating the invention of electric power by thousands of years.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by syshum on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:20PM (#25599677)
Pretty sure the modern machines that

1. Print the money

2. Harvest the Cotton and other raw materials

3. Transport the money

4. Secure the money (even in electronic form)

5. and about 100 other things

All use "energy" the point of the OP's comment was about "wasted energy" which i would image is tied to climate change

The idea that "printed money uses no energy because it is old tech" is just ignorant

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by davidgerard on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:09PM (#25600083)
Zero bitcoiners going "BUT WHAT ABOUT CONVENTIONAL MONEY HUH" provide numbers.

Since you're too lazy to, I will:

* Bitcoin: 0.1% of all electricity in the world, 7tps.

* THE ENTIRE REST OF HUMAN CIVILISATION, EVERYONE IN IT AND EVERYTHING THEY DO: 99.9% of electricity, a hell of a lot more than 6,993tps.

Bitcoin is the most inefficient payment system in history.

Bitcoiners' usual objection at this point is to claim that transactions per second is a bad measure, for some reason - though if you're comparing how much each system achieves for the resources it uses, it's precisely the obvious and correct measure.

But if tps doesn't matter, then the entire bitcoin ecosystem should be replaced with a small rock. A whole country's less electricity use, and only 7tps less! Also, it'd be hard currency.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by ric2b on Friday January 01, 2021 @07:13AM (#25602729)
> Bitcoiners' usual objection at this point is to claim that transactions per second is a bad measure, for some reason

You've probably been told before but I'll tell you the why again. Bitcoin's energy consumption is not proportional to the number of transactions it's processing.

The energy used is proportional to the block reward, the reward that miners get from mining a new block roughly every 10 minutes. They won't spend more money on energy than they get from mining, or they would go out of business. That mining reward goes up with price, (because it's paid out as a fixed amount of BTC) and goes down with each halving event (every ~4 years the block reward is cut in half in BTC terms).

The network can be doing 7tps or 7 million tps, doesn’t really matter for energy use, although higher usage can have indirect effects on price or other things.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by phaemon on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:29PM (#25600225)
> * Bitcoin: 0.1% of all electricity in the world, 7tps

And? Who are you to tell anyone how they should use their electricity? Do you want my advice on what you should be doing in your home?

> Bitcoin is the most inefficient payment system in history.

I think the "hauling big rocks between islands" currency was probably less efficient, at least on a per capita basis.

> then the entire bitcoin ecosystem should be replaced with a small rock

Then go ahead and do that. If people have trust in your rock then that will work fine.

You appear to have written two books about money. Do you not understand how it works yet?

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by kmeisthax on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:58PM (#25600388)
The vast majority of dollars in circulation exist only in accounting records and do not exist as actual physical tokens. Printed money uses no energy because we do not print money anymore, we write it in a SQL database (or, god forbid, an Excel spreadsheet).
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by TulliusCicero on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:59PM (#25599435)
A lot less per transaction than Bitcoin?

But I'm no expert.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by ineedasername on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:43PM (#25599244)
Looking solely at that criterial, ACH transfers work.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by syshum on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:17PM (#25599651)
ACH is US Banking only. You can not do Direct person to person transfers, you must go through a US Bank for ACH

ACH is also SLOW and painfully insecure relaying on the banking institutions to stop gap the security and its built in slowness to allow for reversals of fraud or error transfers

ACH is not a model people should be promoting as good method to do money transfer

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by ineedasername on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:44PM (#25599886)
Thanks, I didn't know ACH was US only. As for slow, I've had things go through literally instantly, where I make the transaction, login to my bank account, and see it posted. When it's been slow, that always seems to be a factor with the sending entity (like PayPal) not my receiving bank. (Could be bank specific though)
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by Izkata on Thursday December 31, 2020 @10:31PM (#25600583)
Might be something else going on (wire transfer, maybe?); ACH payments are batch-processed a couple times a day, and so can't be instant.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by IshKebab on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:09AM (#25601890)
Bank transfers don't have to be slow. Within the UK they are almost always instant.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faster_Payments_Service

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by justusthane on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:04PM (#25599499)
Does it work internationally though?

Edit: Or I should say, “Could it work internationally?” Because afaik it does not currently.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by wmf on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:50PM (#25599335)
Not across countries.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by bob33212 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:28PM (#25599076)
Western Union is also very useful, but the vast majority of transactions are not made by Western Union because it has tradeoffs that make other things like credit/debit cards and checks a better option.

Bitcoin Evangelists are trying to pump up the price by advocating that bitcoin will be the best method of making payments for a huge variety of use cases.

I'm not going to call it a pump and dump scam because I think that a lot of these people truly think that it is going to 500k and beyond and that they will never need to dump it all.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by tluyben2 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:43PM (#25599246)
WU is very expensive though; btc, if you know what you are doing, does not come close. WU is a horrible but unavoidable evil for millions of workers worldwide. This is one of the cases that should be disrupted.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by jiggawatts on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:16PM (#25600147)
I just checked, it seems that WU charges approximately 1% for transfers relative to the nominal exchange rate.

I don't transfer money much, but superficially that doesn't seem too expensive considering the volatility risk to WU due to fluctuating exchange rates combined with the overheads of regulatory requirements.

It seems to me that Bitcoin is only as cheap as it is because it sidesteps those regulatory overheads. So it's great, I suppose, as long as everyone is fine with it being used to launder money from human trafficking, the drug trade, corruption, or whatever...

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by tluyben2 on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:40AM (#25601380)
I am not a big btc fan, I made some money with it and I like the concept somewhat for the purpose it is meant for.

But this btc is used for drugs, human trafficking etc is getting somewhat weird: sure it is, but normal money is far more. So you do not use that either? That is in fact regulated and more expensive and still human traffickers use it all the time. So I do not see the point: in the end btc is easier to follow than a suitcase of dollars coming from Medellin where it was taken from children in the sex trade. So not sure what you mean there besides parotting this point. Private groups and govs have advanced systems for doxxing Btc accounts: they were a bit late to start but now that mining is basically impossible, it is far easier to follow than dollar bills.

Also WU cash point to point money is quite well known for being off the taxes radar in most countries (for some reason): the remittance to the homeland of (illegally) earned money via WU and evade taxes back home is probably it's biggest usecase which is why they can use these depressingly bad rates.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by 55555 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @11:10PM (#25600776)
IME, the real fees charged by WU often add up to 10-20%.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by jiggawatts on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:13AM (#25601055)
How? The pricing calculator literally says $0.00 fees for me, the only charge is the 1% spread on the exchange rate.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by tluyben2 on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:01AM (#25601250)
I know WU from the dropoff points where cheap labour bring their money to send home; they use an extremely bad conversion rate. Like paypal but even worse. Sources: official WU dropoff points in HK, SG, TH, NL and ES. The exchange rates + fees are indeed 10-20% removed from what they really are. Maybe if you send online it is 1%, but most use it to bring cash (from cleaning houses etc) to families abroad.

Edit:

> The pricing calculator literally says

Please go to a meatspace WU point and compare the conversion rates with the inter bank rates.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by jiggawatts on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:22AM (#25601329)
I don't think you'd be able to convert some weak currency from cash to cash in another weak currency efficiently with Bitcoin either. Last time I checked, its API didn't extend to collecting wads of bills!

I know a lot of immigrants that send money home, they all use bank-to-bank transfers. Whether they use WU or not, the overheads seem to be in the 1% range...

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by tluyben2 on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:47AM (#25601397)
Bank to bank sure, WU is much higher in all cases I have seen. But he, we are just some people on the internet. I can send you pics of conversion tables in WU cash points in HK which are off by 5-20% from the inter bank rate. Banks can do this cheaply (and you still get screwed with most banks but indeed 1-2%, not 5+) so WU definitely does something bad there.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by dkersten on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:05PM (#25599513)
Yeah, I had to transfer a few hundred dollars between Australia and Eurpoe last year and both bank transfer and WU would have cost a lot more and taken longer than using btc. With bitcoin, the transfer was complete in about 30 minutes and due to price volatility, I was able to cash out when the price was up enough to cover all fees. It was definitely very helpful.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by bigphishy on Thursday December 31, 2020 @11:49PM (#25600943)
bitcoin has beaten western union, international wire transfers for years now and will continue to do so as notoriety and adoption of crypto-asset grows. However, that in no way justifies its marketcap, which is just over 500 billions. However overvalued it is, and however many times the price crashes dramatically, it is likely that the blockchain will continue to exist in 50-100 years. As long as computers and the internet still exist that is.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by reactspa on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:46PM (#25599279)
Interesting story.

Question: was there any possibility of escrow here? What if the phone never showed up?

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by rkagerer on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:16AM (#25602201)
I took on the counterparty risk. To be honest, the sellers I've dealt with with the last few years have turned out to have head-and-shoulders better customer service than their intermediaries like PayPal etc. I think escrow (and other risk mitigation techniques, e.g. reputational ratings) are definitely opportunities for enhancing the crypto ecosystem.

Long term I suspect some sort of arbitration mechanism may play a role in crypto realizing its full potential (law and commerce are deeply intertwined, and the proliferation of hacks suggest a potential thirst for more effective justice) but I don't yet know what that would look like and many hard core enthusiasts would balk at the suggestion.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by steeve on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:19PM (#25600167)
That must have been one expensive phone.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by ineedasername on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:41PM (#25599219)
It wasn't so much Bitcoin that saved the day, but a choice of payment processor by the seller that caused the problem to begin with. Heck, PayPal works in HongKong. Ultimately bitcoin made your transaction much smoother, but it was a sufficient, not a necessary condition in making it smoother.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by kikimora on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:15AM (#25602199)
Being deeply rooted in financial system payment processors often compete not with service quality but with how they can deal with various stupid or intentional government requirements and restrictions. Bitcoin and crypto is an ultimate alternative which (I hope) triggering change in this industry.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by Jenda_ on Friday January 01, 2021 @07:19AM (#25602752)
You can find lots of stories about PayPal freezing accounts for random reasons. With well-known projects this usually resolves by public shaming, but I guess this can be impossible to solve for a small seller in a non-US/non-West-Europe country.

Example: https://neo900.org/news/paypal-trouble-delays-project

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by rkagerer on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:22AM (#25602230)
Fair point, for sure! Though I've gained a lot of frustration toward PayPal the last few years, as both a buyer and seller. Their platform has really gone downhill from my perspective and I wish there were enough alternatives in use out there that I could sever the business relationship (particularly for eBay transactions). Non-crypto competitors are just as welcome.