Ironically, blockchain technology is the first technology that actually solves the age old problem of how to establish trust within a truestless system.
imho Bitcoin is a novel implementation of open-source technology, cryptography, and decentralized networks. I realize hackernews community has a disdain for greed and the avarice that is commonly connoted with "cryptocurrency" aka crypto-assets, but the reality is that bitcoin and crypto-assets are here to stay, and I for one am glad they are open-source.
The GP complains about the overhead and data collection of traditional solutions, implying it’s a bunch of unnecessary cruft. In fact it’s to comply with local laws and protect the consumer and merchant from fraud. GP used Bitcoin to get around this hassle, renouncing any rights in the event of a dispute.
Now, maybe that’s a win, but it’s a much more nuanced and less generalized win than is put forth by crypto proponents.
Notice also the goalpost move of declaring Bitcoin a win over mailing cash. Ok, have you ever done that in your life? I have not been involved in mailed cash transactions aside from receiving $5 from my grandma in the mail 20 years ago.
Isn't that exactly why this mailing cash/cheques fell out of favor compared to bank transfers, credit cards, PayPal, all these centralised systems that bitcoin posits are a problem
So assuming my email was [email protected], and I had asked my bank to map the Pix key "[email protected]" to my bank account, anyone could "send cash" through Pix to my [email protected] email; the cash would arrive at my bank account nearly instantly (even during weekends and/or holidays).
UPI is more like venmo on steroids, but it is no crypto-currency replacement.
No wasted energy beyond the cost of running a normal computer.
Celo is proof of stake based and also issues part of its block rewards to Project Wren. It has a native stablecoin and a decentralized phone verification protocol that lets you send money to any phone number.
Check out celo.org and ValoraApp.com
The entire us consumes 75 twh in a year, the same as bitcoin’s global energy use.
Of that, the entire commercial sector is about 12 twh. That’s not just banks. That’s every company. Banks alone are surely far less. Maybe 2-3 twh? And the us is 15% of global gdp. So, global finance might consume about 14-32 twh.
Again, that is while doing all of global finance. Bitcoin powers a rounding error of transactions yet consumes 75 twh.
There’s just no comparison energy wise. My math could be off by several orders of magnitude and bitcoin would still consume more if it were actually powering the world’s transactions.
There’s no need to introduce hrs and years to the mix. Watts describe precisely what you’re attempting to quantify.
https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=4+PW+hr%2Fyear+in+GW&o...
If we assume banks are 10% of that, then it’s 200 twh. 3x bitcoin. But also, handling literally all finance and banking in the US. Vs essentially nothing for bitcoin, compared to the scale of the us economy.
Of course it'd be much better for us to adopt a crypto currency that uses a different algorithm that has even less energy usage. Even without that though I think it could prove to be more efficient than existing financial systems.
The total amount of reported money transacted might be higher for bitcoin but that doesn’t come from contact with the real economy. So that depends on the valuation of bitcoin rather than economic impact.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/277841/paypals-total-pay...
https://www.statista.com/statistics/730806/daily-number-of-b...
Anyway, as another way of answering your question, physical money printing and transfers require no electricity at all, predating the invention of electric power by thousands of years.
1. Print the money
2. Harvest the Cotton and other raw materials
3. Transport the money
4. Secure the money (even in electronic form)
5. and about 100 other things
All use "energy" the point of the OP's comment was about "wasted energy" which i would image is tied to climate change
The idea that "printed money uses no energy because it is old tech" is just ignorant
Since you're too lazy to, I will:
* Bitcoin: 0.1% of all electricity in the world, 7tps.
* THE ENTIRE REST OF HUMAN CIVILISATION, EVERYONE IN IT AND EVERYTHING THEY DO: 99.9% of electricity, a hell of a lot more than 6,993tps.
Bitcoin is the most inefficient payment system in history.
Bitcoiners' usual objection at this point is to claim that transactions per second is a bad measure, for some reason - though if you're comparing how much each system achieves for the resources it uses, it's precisely the obvious and correct measure.
But if tps doesn't matter, then the entire bitcoin ecosystem should be replaced with a small rock. A whole country's less electricity use, and only 7tps less! Also, it'd be hard currency.
You've probably been told before but I'll tell you the why again. Bitcoin's energy consumption is not proportional to the number of transactions it's processing.
The energy used is proportional to the block reward, the reward that miners get from mining a new block roughly every 10 minutes. They won't spend more money on energy than they get from mining, or they would go out of business. That mining reward goes up with price, (because it's paid out as a fixed amount of BTC) and goes down with each halving event (every ~4 years the block reward is cut in half in BTC terms).
The network can be doing 7tps or 7 million tps, doesn’t really matter for energy use, although higher usage can have indirect effects on price or other things.
And? Who are you to tell anyone how they should use their electricity? Do you want my advice on what you should be doing in your home?
> Bitcoin is the most inefficient payment system in history.
I think the "hauling big rocks between islands" currency was probably less efficient, at least on a per capita basis.
> then the entire bitcoin ecosystem should be replaced with a small rock
Then go ahead and do that. If people have trust in your rock then that will work fine.
You appear to have written two books about money. Do you not understand how it works yet?
But I'm no expert.
ACH is also SLOW and painfully insecure relaying on the banking institutions to stop gap the security and its built in slowness to allow for reversals of fraud or error transfers
ACH is not a model people should be promoting as good method to do money transfer
Edit: Or I should say, “Could it work internationally?” Because afaik it does not currently.
Bitcoin Evangelists are trying to pump up the price by advocating that bitcoin will be the best method of making payments for a huge variety of use cases.
I'm not going to call it a pump and dump scam because I think that a lot of these people truly think that it is going to 500k and beyond and that they will never need to dump it all.
I don't transfer money much, but superficially that doesn't seem too expensive considering the volatility risk to WU due to fluctuating exchange rates combined with the overheads of regulatory requirements.
It seems to me that Bitcoin is only as cheap as it is because it sidesteps those regulatory overheads. So it's great, I suppose, as long as everyone is fine with it being used to launder money from human trafficking, the drug trade, corruption, or whatever...
But this btc is used for drugs, human trafficking etc is getting somewhat weird: sure it is, but normal money is far more. So you do not use that either? That is in fact regulated and more expensive and still human traffickers use it all the time. So I do not see the point: in the end btc is easier to follow than a suitcase of dollars coming from Medellin where it was taken from children in the sex trade. So not sure what you mean there besides parotting this point. Private groups and govs have advanced systems for doxxing Btc accounts: they were a bit late to start but now that mining is basically impossible, it is far easier to follow than dollar bills.
Also WU cash point to point money is quite well known for being off the taxes radar in most countries (for some reason): the remittance to the homeland of (illegally) earned money via WU and evade taxes back home is probably it's biggest usecase which is why they can use these depressingly bad rates.
Edit:
> The pricing calculator literally says
Please go to a meatspace WU point and compare the conversion rates with the inter bank rates.
I know a lot of immigrants that send money home, they all use bank-to-bank transfers. Whether they use WU or not, the overheads seem to be in the 1% range...
Question: was there any possibility of escrow here? What if the phone never showed up?
Long term I suspect some sort of arbitration mechanism may play a role in crypto realizing its full potential (law and commerce are deeply intertwined, and the proliferation of hacks suggest a potential thirst for more effective justice) but I don't yet know what that would look like and many hard core enthusiasts would balk at the suggestion.
Example: https://neo900.org/news/paypal-trouble-delays-project
The seller initially requested payment via Transferwise, who sought crazy amounts of personal information and bullied me into a privacy-hostile customer agreement. Days went by and they still hadn't activated my account.
Growing frustrated, I convinced the seller to accept Bitcoin, which was comparatively instant. The phone arrived a few days later, meanwhile the Transferwise morons still had their heads up their arses with no movement and no good explanation. I'm not a financial risk; I'm a good little citizen with no red flags. Reading between the lines my sense was their staff were overloaded or their onboarding system was simply broken.
Bitcoin was incredibly helpful for me that day, and my favorite feature about the phone is the way I paid. In addition to a great story, I've got to admit there was something liberating and empowering about giving what felt like a big middle finger to the slow, decrepit, old-fashioned institution who couldn't even deliver on their core business proposition. Like saying "screw you, I don't need you and your crappy service anymore, come back when you can compete on merits".
Whatever else you criticize about Bitcoin, it's still "cash you can email", and even if that's all it ever amounts to I still find it a bloody useful innovation.