Received this email outside of my standard working hours (ET)? That means I’ve chosen to do some work at this time; it’s not an expectation that you do the same.
As someone prone to working odd or odd hours, I’ll often preface slack or email messages I send with a bold ‘not urgent’ or similar, in the hope that the recipient will feel comfortable ignoring it until their working hours.I think if more people clearly set response time expectations, off hours messages would read as less of an intrusion, even to people with fewer firm boundaries.
I have no work mail or chat on my private devices and actually move all incoming mail to a temp imap folder which I don’t sync to my phone or laptop. Then a cron job moves it to my inbox between 8 and 8.
Yes, it’s 2am in India. Yes, I want the whole thread to be in one tool. No, I don’t want to notify the person until they’re at their desk.
Slack does have a suppress notifications setting that the recipient can set. That doesn’t help when they haven’t set it.
90% of the emails I send are because this feature is missing.
I think it's a phenomenon similar to the whole 'panopticon' idea: I'm pretty sure not picking up the phone will be fine, but because of the not knowing for sure I still often end up letting the interruption happen. We humans prefer removing uncertainty to an irrational degree, I guess?
On a couple occasions I came in at a reasonable time only to have missed an extra-early meeting or call that someone scheduled at 7:00pm the night before. A polite "yeah I didn't see the email until 8 this morning" seems to send the message "what the fuck were you thinking" without any complaints from anyone. They learn, and hopefully question they own constant availability.
I've heard it said that in the U.S., the only reliable way for a non-union worker to get real protection from abuse is to personally hire a labor attorney.
There's no need to involve anyone else.
I work with people from different time zones and people who like to keep different schedules, some waking up very early or working very late, and I myself wake up pretty late. It just doesn't make sense that I should demand people message according to my schedule, but I'm also not going to wake up early or work late to match theirs.
The easiest way to clear this up is to just talk to your manager and get on the same page about what is expected.
Some of the reasoning I've heard from these employees is that they believe they're the only one who can solve an issue. They're the ones who jump on it when it comes up during the regular day so if it re-appears they feel the need to jump on the grenade - explaining to them that other people can (and will) fix the problem helps, though it usually takes a few go arounds to get the point.
There are times I'm on call, and I'll be pretty pro-active. Even if I don't get paged but major events are going on, I'll be keeping an eye on them. On the other hand when I'm off call? Unless someone picks up a phone and calls me, it's not even on my mind.
Have you ever been in situations where you really are the only person who can solve the issue? Or, at least the only one who can solve it a) in a reasonable time frame and b) without creating multiple other problems?
I've been in those situations before - not all the time, but it's happened. First time I sort of liked it - seemed like a bit of 'prestige'. But then ... I took a 3 day vacation. Flew hours away. Checked in to hotel. Light on the phone in the room was beeping with a message to call the office, because there was a bug no one could figure out. Even though I was at a 'big company', I was (literally) the only person on the project, and couldn't have 6 hours away without the world crashing down. Really poor management on everyone's part.
I've been in a couple other situations since then where I'm the only person who can do X, and I recognize it, and lobby for someone else to be able to step in. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. I've also had a couple of situations with competent team mates who all started before me, and had a wide diverse set of skills, supported each other, and I was not expected to be some sort of 'superhero'. I appreciated those environments more as an older person who's previously experienced the 'superhero' environments.
These "many other people can do what you do" teams I've been a part of have been nice, but also comparatively rare.
Whatever else can be said. I went on a week cruise with zero stress about work.
Knowledge was so well spread around that no one was a point of failure. Several of us were the best for specific issues, but our pair would then get better at it.
Yes, those setups are often best - for people and for the business - "no one point of failure". It also seems harder for businesses to commit to paying for that redundancy, at least up front.
I admit I haven't really done this for a while--though I came close last year. But TBH, I'll keep vaguely in touch these days when I conveniently can and deal with anything that's urgent or really can't wait. (Like I did an interview from a B&B room that really needed to be done--an then wasn't used of course.)
IMO, a lot of people put way too much pressure on themselves to be available 24/7/365 who don't need to. And if that really is the expectation maybe they should look someplace else unless it's their company or something something really special to them.
Everyone is (usually) an adult, just talk it out and build that understanding.
I wouldn't mention that not taking care of their health would reflect poorly on their performance review. In fact I wouldn't want them to think about the performance review. The goal is for them to rest, recharge, and not get burnt out,
I know you are trying to be considerate, but please do not ever assume people “are not taking care of themselves”, even if true. In the US, there is always a deeper story to it. Generally speaking 50% of the American population has a pre-existing condition. 30-50% of Americans avoid some medical care yearly due to the cost of care.
The third leading cause of death is believed to be preventable medical errors (caused by the for-profit nature of our system: our doctors and nurses have excellent training), and the vast majority of these victims likely had pre-existing conditions. We just don’t attribute “preventable medical error” as a cause of death on US death certificates like we should. See: https://www.bmj.com/content/353/bmj.i2139
Also, the system is not designed to ensure the health of the populace, even if you are “rich” and “have good insurance” and “can afford to pay for healthcare with insurance coverage”. Pretty much every other industrialized and developed country is outpacing us in longevity.
The system is not meant to prevent disease and it is very ineffective at it. It profits on the already sick. It really is a grotesque system. For more info on this (and the previous 2 paragraphs consult the publications on http://healthdata.org
According to the book, “Dying for a Paycheck”, the fifth leading cause of death in the US is overwork: https://www.baltimoresun.com/health/bs-hs-workplace-cause-de...
When your health insurance is tied to your work, you are screwed if you have a pre-existing condition.
This is why I will never work in the US, as a dual US|EU citizen with 2 rare immune mediated neurological diseases affecting my peripheral nervous system plus type 1 diabetes (autoimmune and insulin dependent). The neurological diseases are in remission, but I have to take a certain blood product, administered in a certain way, in large quantities, for life. It is known as subcutaneous immunoglobulin. It is far easier to access this is western/Northern European countries than the US, too.
My higher ups were shocked when I presented them with >540 hours of overtime accumulated from mid March to September.
Not that I didn't more than once tell it in different video meetings with my team lead as well as managing directors.
But they only reacted shocked when there was a paper trail. Before that telling them that I would run up to that amount of overtime did nothing.
that's a lot of people mate. Over half of the workforce doesn't have a degree, half doesn't have any or barely any savings and cannot cover a few hundred bucks emergency, and if you have at least one kid or a family member who is dependent on you good luck. Most people cannot risk forgoing even a month without a salary, including a lot of white collar workers even with an undergraduate degree or similar.
The particular person here runs a charity for inmates, and if you're self-employed or own a business in a sense ironically enough you have even less control over your schedule because you can't just dial the numbers down and people depend on you, in this case both workers and clients.
I agree, but I think my point still stands even if it doesn't apply to everyone, or even a majority of people.
> The particular person here runs a charity for inmates, and if you're self-employed or own a business in a sense ironically enough you have even less control over your schedule because you can't just dial the numbers down and people depend on you, in this case both workers and clients.
This is a manifestation of the same problem of not setting boundaries. People only depend on you if you agree to take them on as clients. It might be heartbreaking to have to make those kinds of decisions when it comes to something like working with inmates, but I do believe you'll help a smaller number of inmates much more effectively if you're well-rested and take care of your health. And, again, that actually is entirely within your control. You can certainly choose to help more people at the expense of your health, but that may not be the best decision for yourself (or the people you're trying to help) in the longer run. But it's still a choice.
I include myself in this
We are in the middle of a once in a century pandemic that's pushing many healthcare systems, and lots of the involved people, to the maximum of their limits and often even past those limits.
In that context it seems a bit tone-deaf to make the problem out as people just not wanting to "leave the fast track/go to B league", as for many HCW these are not even realistic options or prospects because there's really not that much of a career ladder/B league for occupations like nurses and others in the sector.
This is something that took me 1.5-2 decades to figure out. My first "worst project" was around 2007 and it was hell. It cost me a lot (health, it became a large factor in losing a good relationship). I couldn't see the forest from the trees. I couldn't say no to the sleazy sales manager who would ignore me all week only to become my best friend for a 60 second conversation every Thursday: "Maaaate! Can you work Saturday?"
The wounds were very expensive but after some time to heal became something to laugh at, lightly. When someone in a room full of developers at 9 PM snaps and says, "This is the worst project I've ever been on!" half the room will immediately agree, only for the the other half to grin politely and disagree. "Really?!" At best sharing these stories can be a bonding exercise. Some of the anecdotes are now quite funny jokes.
Then a decade past my worst ever project and it was happening all over again! Only this time I was cognisant of the machinations around me. While being older might mean more capable, it also means we can't do the same long hours any more. The absolute worst thing was I saw it coming. I gave my manager (who had all the authority) unambiguous advice to avoid this project. After it went bad they needed me. I said no, but then they weren't asking and suddenly I was involved. Deeply. Drinking after work was no longer 2 beers on a Friday, but 2-4 every day at our desks (but after 8 PM when the place was mostly abandoned). Other negatives I was putting up with for the $$$ also broke the threshold (mostly the insane daily travel, but the place was generally a crap client site all round).
I'd work hard to the deadline then be done with it. January became February, March, then April. I was burnt out. I quit before it was done and became the bad guy. I didn't care. I never wanted to see any of these clowns ever again.
I went overseas for a year without working. Didn't work for another year after returning, and very casually waited for the right, quite different, role to come through my jokingly tiny social network.
I worked with a POC who the CEO told me point blank to give them extra leniency with regards to them not performing their duties (an ongoing complaint of mine) because a "diverse face" on the pitch deck helped us raise money.
My underlying point was that it's too broad to say that you'll be negatively discriminated against for setting strict boundaries. Some (more progressive) places will let you get away with more based on your ethnicity or gender.
So, it sounds like the CEO is using this person of color in order to earn a certain credibility and get more money from investors.
And, maybe this person of color is either, a) working hard, but not very experienced yet/able to complete their tasks. Or, they are wrongfully neglecting their duties/have no interest in doing their job. Or, some other nuanced situation, I don't know. You believe they are benefiting though.
But either way, exactly what is your point? To be honest, reading this, it seems like you are biased against people of color, and you view this situation as evidence that all people of color do not work hard/are given unfair advantages in life, and therefore, your bias is warranted. In other words, you appear to believe in a common racist trope. To you, it is true, based on this story.
Or, you are not biased against people of color, and simply think it unfair that this person, regardless of their ethnicity, is being given a free pass on not doing their work. If the latter, isn't your CEO partly in the wrong here? They are capitalizing on the identity of this person of color, which shouldn't matter, by your logic.
You judged me guilty of all of that because I provided an anecdote that some companies bias positively (not always negatively) towards people based on their race and/or gender? Do you expect me to respond and defend myself against each accusation? Because you don't have the right to pressure that from me, especially as an anonymous throwaway account.
What do you think this anecdote means? What do you think about this situation?
I think that you want people to draw a conclusion from this story.
Yes, that conclusion is exactly what I already said, which I worded very precisely: "some companies bias positively towards people based on their race and/or gender". So we should not automatically assume, as the person I was replying to suggested, that someone will be biased against because of their race or gender for affirming work boundaries.
You reading into that to try to sniff out hints of racism and prejudice says more about your motives and your intentions here than it does mine.
>You believe these companies "bias positively". Which may or may not be true.
I didn't say "these companies", I said "some companies." And "some companies" is true, because I have personal experiences at "some companies" that show backroom positive biases towards employees and interview candidates, without their knowledge, explicitly because of their identity (both race and sex).
You seem to disagree that my experiences are valid, and if they are valid, that I must be sexist or racist for even sharing them.
I would not consider the scenario you described to be positive bias. It's still negative, and it still hurts the employee in question, even if they still get to draw a paycheck for a time. It's just a... different... kind of bias than the kind I mentioned.
> So we should not automatically assume, as the person I was replying to suggested, that someone will be biased against because of their race or gender for affirming work boundaries.*
My original comment didn't suggest that we should automatically assume that, just that it was a possibility. And I'd still expect my possibility to be more likely and pervasive than the scenario you described.
What I disagree with is that there is such a thing as 'biasing positively'. People seek to build diverse teams. In my opinion, your colleague wasn't necessarily being done a favor if it happened they were performing poorly and didn't have a good feedback loop. Your CEO may have been profiting from this situation at the long-term expense of your colleague.
I just don't think we should be biasing our judgments of a person's value or competency based on their sex or race though, and unfortunately, I have a few experiences that point to conscious decisions in that direction. I'm not saying you are making this argument, but if there is an argument that "we need conscious decisions to counterbalance the unconscious biases," then I really wholeheartedly disagree with that approach. Like you suggested, we're not doing people favors when we shield them from honest feedback about their output.
The excuse I always hear is that if they don't work that hard, they'll get fired and replaced with someone who does. I'm sure that's true for some jobs, but a) it's likely very few of them, and b) why would you want to work for/with people who have so little respect for you and your health in the first place?
Sure, promotions might come less often and raises might be smaller, but that's a trade off you can consciously make: more money, or better health and family/friend relationships. And you also set an example for your peers: if they start complaining about their health or about burnout, you can show them that it's a problem that can be solved. And the more that people do this, the more people will realize it's possible and the right thing to do.
And yes, there are some who live paycheck to paycheck, hold multiple jobs, will take any job they can get, and don't have much choice. I'm not talking about people like that... though that is another conversation that should be had more often; no one should have to be stuck in a situation like that, but so many are! And yes, there's unfortunately sexism and racism involved; I expect women and POC will get looked upon less favorably if they set stronger boundaries than white men will. But I don't see that as an argument to destroy your health.