News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by stiray on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @12:34PM (#25572274)
> Google's choice to bump these prices made me realize that they could do the same thing with their compute cloud pricing or other APIs, again with little notice. That, in turn, led to the realization that we needed to remove our reliance on Google's entire stack, and quickly, or we'd be in a terrible bargaining position later.

Yes. You are right. The whole cloud deal is a try to rule out on premise infrastructure and once it is gone and everyone is dependent on it (due to lost of knowledge, and for cloud providers ideally when hardware vendors are no longer selling hardware to non cloud entities) harvest the dependent businesses left at their mercy and charge dearly (including for all the years before that). It is actually not even a complicated plan but it is staggering how many people are putting cloth over their eyes.

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by jimkleiber on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @12:44PM (#25572411)
These two comments make me see SaaS more like paying rent for housing:

If we become fully dependent on a service (shelter) and then the provider (landlord) jacks up the price, we may be quickly forced to switch services (homes) or be out of business (homeless).

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by Joeri on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:23AM (#25581423)
In many places landlords cannot suddenly jack up the price, but can only increase it in small amounts year by year. One could similarly imagine rent controls on digital services, where sudden price hikes are simply not allowed, and terminating the rental agreement one-sided is similarly restricted. The practical downsides of that kind of legislation would probably end up quite similar to rent controls.
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by jimkleiber on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:18PM (#25588862)
Yes! I've found that I sometimes will keep a subscription, even if I'm not currently using it, because I've been locked in at the old price, and can feel really annoyed when they increase the price by a significant amount or percentage and force me to adopt it.

About rent control, yup, it may have the ups and downs of real estate rent control :-)

I'm also wondering, with physical real estate, there is a tangible limit to how many people can rent the space, whereas SaaS seems to make up arbitrary user limits. But maybe I'm wrong, and there is a limited number of users because each user has variable costs—in the housing analogy, utilities like water, space, wear & tear on the place, etc., and in the SaaS space, customer service, server space...I can't think of any more but maybe they're there...

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by thesz on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @01:31PM (#25573073)
Do not forget that in the case of cloud services you have to pay "landlord" for the stuff you move (bandwidth and volume needed to migration).
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by jimkleiber on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:20PM (#25588876)
Ha, good point, perhaps that'd be like paying your landlord for utilities like water or electricity usage, but could also be paying for every time you have guests visit the house or you go up and down the stairs.
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @06:49PM (#25576551)
unfortunately when we switch services(homes) all of our electrical devices(code) now need to be changed to work with the different way the new service(home) is wired. At this point the analogy breaks down.
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by jimkleiber on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @04:17PM (#25586219)
Hmm. Maybe it's a spectrum, where some situations are like moving homes and others are like like moving cities (need to find a new dentist, doctor, etc) or moving countries (need to learn a new language, learn new laws, get new electrical outlet adapters, etc).

Do you think those resonate better?

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @04:28PM (#25586327)
I think as the size of the application increases and the API you are switching out increases in importance to the functioning of that application then the analogy of moving from home goes up from moving apartments(my small side project), to moving cities (my small side project turned into a startup that has been running half a year but isn't especially profitable yet), to moving countries (my application that many large organizations use with all sorts of different functionality built in to support the needs of those organizations)
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by jimkleiber on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:06PM (#25588768)
Well said. As it becomes more complex and intertwined, technologically and socially (employees, customers, etc), then it becomes harder to change. Thanks for helping to refine the analogy!
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by franklampard on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @01:47PM (#25573269)
I like this analogy. I think a good idea is to sign a long term (1 year to multiple years) contract with cloud providers.
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by jfim on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:21PM (#25575189)
A long term contract pretty much guarantees that the company will lose the institutional knowledge to run things on premises.

Think about it, if the company has sysadmins that have been with the company for some years, have racked and are running most of their infrastructure, and all of a sudden they sign a long term contract with a cloud provider, why would they stay?

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by franklampard on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:29AM (#25583028)
There are different use cases.

It’s possible that the company do not have all that infrastructure at all.

I also don’t see the importance of ‘knowledge to run things on premise’ for most people.

Technologies change very fast and if I can pay a reliable provider with a fixed price for the years that I intend to use it, why do I have to know how to use it?

If I can hire a gardener to take care of things for a reasonable price, I don’t care if I have any knowledge.

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by robertlagrant on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @04:46AM (#25580184)
This is a danger, although the cloud is still just VMs and networks that still need configuring and patching. Agreed people who would run physical hardware would be gone.
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by entee on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @12:51PM (#25572507)
I think there's a risk here but I'm not sure it goes as far as you suggest. There are still plenty of entities, particularly larger ones, that buy their own metal because at some scales it becomes far cheaper to run in a COLO (at least acc to near monthly articles posted on HN). I'd therefore put the risk that only big vendors will be able to buy hardware as low. That said, as ARM or custom chips gain market share within cloud providers, there's a risk that x86 or standard suppliers will struggle, but AMD/Intel see this too and surely one or both will adapt.

On skills I think there's a small risk of people not knowing how to manage/set up their own racks, but doing a passable job there isn't that hard. On general sys-admin stuff, cloud infrastructure seems to have parallels to hardware infrastructure, so it shouldn't be completely unfamiliar to set up a hardware router/network/linux server. There are definitely skills and details missing (remote admin tools for hardware maybe), but this doesn't seem like a big gap to bridge if $$$ is on the line?

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by stiray on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:19PM (#25575165)
If those entities would be any risk, they would already be bought.

Or they will be long gone due to google/aws/microsoft price dumping. In meanwhile, the openly accessible technology / know-how will be gone or hired by them and there will be no one left. Just look around, how many people you know that are capable of handling on-premise server? What about farm of servers without using any of google/aws/microsoft technology?

This just isn't something new.

It is just another case of "historia magistra vitae". We had this, 30-40 years back, we had centralized environment (have you heard about mainframes before?), due to huge price pumping the decentralized environment came in (personal computers, internet, on premise servers, storage, ...). IT needed almost 20 years to get out of the hooks of corporations and now we are all diving in into the latest "cool" thing - centralization, now backed up by advertising revenues and shady practices like not showing your company on google search.

This is not a joke: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_litigation

And you can bet the history repeats itself.

---

Let me show you my point and where it is going, lets do a tiny experiment - use your router/firewall/whatever you are fond of and block the following ASNs:

  AS40873,AS396982,AS395973,AS394639,AS394507,AS36492,AS36385,AS36384,AS36040,AS36039,
  AS26910,AS26684,AS22859,AS22577,AS19527,AS16550,AS15169,AS13949,AS6432,
  AS19448,AS16591,AS45566,AS43515,AS41264,AS394699,AS36987,AS139190,AS139070
then:

  AS16509,AS14618,AS7224,AS19047,AS395343,AS62785,AS58588,AS9059,AS8987,AS39111,AS38895,AS10124,AS264167,AS17493,AS135630
and:

  AS8075,AS8074,AS8073,AS8072,AS8071,AS8070,AS8069,AS8068,AS6584,AS63314,AS6291,AS6194,
  AS6182,AS5761,AS45139,AS40066,AS397996,AS397466,AS396463,AS395851,AS395524,
  AS395496,AS36006,AS3598,AS32476,AS31792,AS30575,AS30135,AS26222,AS25796,AS23468,
  AS22692,AS20046,AS17345,AS14719,AS13811,AS13399,AS12076,AS35106,AS8812,AS200517,
  AS58862,AS59067,AS52985
Now try to surf the internet. Casual style. As nothing happened.

Baidu (China) and Yandex (Russia) will still work from search engines. Duckduckgo not (shame on you). As any other you know. "The internet" as you know it will stop to exist for you. You know what you have blocked with those ASNs? Only 3 companies. Google. Amazon. Microsoft.

For complete experience you can also throw in AS714,AS6185,AS2709 and AS63293,AS54115,AS32934 (Apple, Facebook), but those two are not really relevant.

Maybe this will be eye opening how much we have f* up the internet, something that should survive 3rd world war is now mostly in the hands of 3 companies. Now imagine they pull the switch.

Oh yeah, that bad it is.

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by TeMPOraL on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:05AM (#25580963)
> Maybe this will be eye opening how much we have f up the internet, something that should survive 3rd world war is now mostly in the hands of 3 companies. Now imagine they pull the switch.*

I see people frequently quoting the bit about how the Internet was designed to withstand a nuclear war. But that quote was about packet switching. I.e. layer 2/3. Not layer 7. Application layer is, as you nicely demonstrate, very centralized, and was never immune to nuclear war.

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by entee on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:56AM (#25579320)
Admittedly I know few, but not zero. That said they’re all relatively older and have been in the business for a while. I used to manage a team with 4 racks, ~40 machines at a COLO. When we hired for new people, it was usually older folks who had the experience necessary. Maybe you’re right and I agree the concentration is disturbing.

My only response is that when I look at bigger orgs and places like Fortune 500 cos I still see/hear about home built server farms, so those people must be out there. I think maybe we get blinded in startup/SV land and only see people using cloud infrastructure but miss a huge, silent mass of people.

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by fpoling on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @04:17AM (#25580029)
Depending on the nature of the business it can be cheaper to run own servers even for smaller companies. I see that in Norway quite a few places see that and the pool of qualified people to run them is not small.
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by pldr1234 on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:46PM (#25575448)
HN is missing a `word-break: break-all` on their `default p` class.

(Your reply with an unbroken word that spans larger than the page width forced my page to grow (horizontal scrollbar))

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by stiray on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @05:17PM (#25575741)
Sorry, I didn't notice it, thank you for reminder, I have added manual breaks.
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by dang on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @07:02PM (#25576670)
I've added some more. Sorry; it's our bug.
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by mjgs on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @06:00AM (#25580666)
I wonder whether there will emerge some design patterns in apps to enable easy switching between on-premises and cloud infra.

Thinking about it logically, the safest approach is always going to be build for on-premises infra first (or standard VPSs), then modify the code to support cloud services in addition, to get the added benefits of scaling at cheaper costs.

That way you can always switch back to on-premises if the cloud provider starts behaving terribly. Perhaps there is a performance hit, but at least you have an option.

Worth mentioning that there are some use cases that are only possible using cloud infra due to scaling constraints.

This is the approach I took building my SaaS. It’s more difficult initially, but I had an infra that could easily be moved. I was using my own version of backend queues etc, so modifying the code to switch to Amazon SQS would theoretically have been possible:

https://blog.markjgsmith.com/2020/11/26/looking-back-at-link...

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by TeMPOraL on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @06:59AM (#25580936)
> It is actually not even a complicated plan but it is staggering how many people are putting cloth over their eyes.

These are changes that are happening on a timescale much larger than the average lifespan of a cloud-based product/system. I think people building things in the cloud know it, or at least feel it, and so just don't care about long-term - because in the long term they expect to be rich and/or doing something else. In the meantime, ooh cheap compute, billable as opex - let's build everything on it!

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by tybit on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @02:58PM (#25574076)
AWS is already incredibly profitable while continuing to lower prices over time. What makes you think they would choose to run this scheme and forever ruin their reputation?
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by multjoy on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:27PM (#25574478)
The point is that nobody expected Google to just hike their price for mapping by 1400% overnight. If they can do it with one product, what’s stopping anyone else in a similar dominant market position doing the same?
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by danielheath on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:35PM (#25575337)
Culture, and the reputation it earns.

I’m no amazon apologist, but one thing I trust them to do is keep my things running as they are.

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by multjoy on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @05:10PM (#25575672)
And what’s your contingency if they decide that they’re going to hike the price because Jeff’s underwater lair has sprung a leak?
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by regularfry on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @08:22PM (#25577246)
This got downvoted for (I presume) triteness, but there's an important underlying point: Amazon's actions (or anyone else's) don't have to look rational from the outside to really mess up your day.
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by katbyte on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:51AM (#25579900)
I’d actually worry more about post bezos Amazon, he’s been running the show for years, it’s predictable- after..
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by panta on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:41AM (#25579842)
In a world where there are three players, culture and reputation are not worth much, if not only at the beginning. Maybe 5/10/15 years from now the software and competencies to manage bare metal will be only behind the doors of those three companies, and at that point it will be economically convenient for them to act as a cartel and increase prices.
Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by fgonzag on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:43PM (#25589028)
I don't see that happening. As someone who manages bare metal, there's not that much to it besides using a pxe installer. Didn't even use that before we got 20 servers, would just configure IPMI physically the mount the ubuntu ISO via IPMI and manually install the OS at the office.

Ubuntu is actually heavily investing into MAAS (metal as a service) and so is Redhat with cobbler and foreman. So I'm guessing there's enough demand to justify their development (as every major cloud provider uses in house tools AFAIK)

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by baskire on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @02:35PM (#25573825)
That’s one of the arguments for multi vendor sourcing. The same price negotiation tactic occurs in other industries.

It’s why google buys non intel chips. Come negotiation time there’s a serious threat they can leave. And there’s a serious rfp out to other vendors for pricing. Bringing their intel chip costs down.

Re:Google Maps' Moat Is Evaporating by rorykoehler on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @01:18PM (#25572916)
If that happens I know of a few young companies who will step in and fill the void at a cheaper price.