Self-learning piano is, overall, a boondoggle. You want a teacher.
I started learning piano in December 2018 at the age of 27. For the first couple months I stayed on my own to build up at least some base knowledge before getting a (remote) teacher in April 2019. I mostly used a service called Flowkey (sorta like Synthesia for the web), the book Music Theory for Dummies, and a course on Udemy by Ben Westenra.
I highly recommend getting a teacher, even remote, using a site like TakeLessons.com. They'll keep you motivated, answer your questions, and set accomplishable goals.
> I have tried learning piano and I found a lot of stuff irritatingly hard to get right and got bored. Like for some reason I am not able to transition to other keys well when I am using both hands or when some finger involuntarily moves because of motion of neighboring finger.
Cumulative hours of practice are necessary to learn even a single piece, and short of Matrix-style skill uploading, there's no shortcut to putting the time in.
> Also, I seem to get finger fatigue which is surprising considering the amount of time I spend on keyboards anyway.
Not all keys are the same. :) Your fingers are getting a much different and more intense workout by playing.
Edit- Updated language since someone focused on pulling a "gotcha" on me for upvotes over the context (in this case, piano.)
“I play the guitar. I taught myself how to play the guitar, which was a bad decision because I didn’t know how to play it, so I was a [bad] teacher. I would never have went to me.”
I'm told it's easier to self-learn the guitar, but you're working against your own interests if you're violently opposed to the idea of a teacher, no matter the instrument.
This is false. If you want to strum some chords, then, yes. Guitar's difficulty curve starts out very gentle. But then it quickly gets really, really steep. I self taught classical guitar for a couple of years (after already having played violin for many years), and it's easy to get yourself to the point where it's hard to advance without a teacher. And the harder you push on that knee in the curve by yourself, the more time you'll probably have to spend unlearning bad habits.
Piano's difficulty curve is more even. It starts steeper than guitar, and has a long stretch at about that same slope, before it starts getting steep, too. Compare that to violin which starts basically straight up, but once you get past that initial cliff is fairly gentle for a long, long way.
Watch some slow piano music being played by a concert pianist, and you'll see that - except for the odd flourish - they move fingers and wrists as little as possible. The hands float, they don't hover in a tense way.
It also depends on the keyboard you're using. There's a big difference between a soft and fast keyboard action and a piano action with real or simulated hammers. The latter is much harder on your fingers to start with, but gives you more control and stamina later.
One of the many things a good teacher will help you do is avoid technical pitfalls. If you do this on your own unchecked, chances are you will end up blocked somewhere down the road and having to relearn basic techniques.
Another thing is they will have plenty of interesting musical practice material that suits your skill level and interests.
They'll also help you manage your expectations.
I've got quite a few students who were very uneven in their growth. They've had to learn basic things in one area while very advanced in another. More often than not, they've had to relearn things they learned to do the wrong way from scratch.
Learning to play a musical instrument is usually not easy. If you can afford the investment of time and/or money, get a teacher. The good ones are worth their weight in gold, and the good news for you is, they're relatively cheap. They get paid peanuts in comparison to you as a techie.
Piano fingering technique is very important. That's not just which finger hits which key, but also the posture of your finger. That could be what's straining your fingers and giving you trouble reaching keys.
I found a local piano teacher and took weekly lessons. The piano teacher caught these bad habits like finger technique, but also how hard to hit the keys and other things that I wouldn't have noticed on my own.
If you are set on self-learning, getting a few lessons every once in a while will help you stay on track.
I picked up clarinet a few years ago, and while I made good progress just from practicing it was not until I engaged with a tutor I really got going.
Please, please, find a tutor and be amazed about what he or she can make you accomplish.
Can I real sheet music? Nope. Do I understand all the fancy words describing techniques? No. Am I good at this? Good enough that when I play, people dance. That counts as a success in my book.
Just something to think about... :)
I have come to dislike this method. It gets the student focused on looking at the fingerboard and using the small lateral muscles in their fingers to try to reach for the tape rather than finding the large muscle positioning and biomechanics that produces in tune fingerings.
Hold up your hand with fingers straight. Try spreading your fingers and then pulling them together fast. They kind of "pop" between the two positions, and if you look at the spread position, they're basically the same distance apart. So if you can arrange your arm so that spread drops an in-tune whole step on the fingerboard and together drops an in-tune half step, you will play in tune.
You do that by rotating your elbow under the instrument. The farther toward your back the elbow is, the more your hand is angled from the neck, and the closer the spacing between where your fingers fall on the fingerboard. The more your push your elbow forward, the more your fingers fall farther apart on the strings. There's an in-tune position for each of the four strings, and kind of inbetweens for double stops. Training your gross muscle memory to find that position is vastly easier than searching for tapes, you don't get in the habit of looking at the fingerboard (because there's nothing there that makes a difference), and you don't get slowed down later because your lateral muscles in your fingers are tense and making your fingers move slower.
The funny thing is that I think this was described in Geminiani's treatise, which was the first manual of violin playing ever.
Fundamentally, technique differs a lot based on size of the player. Ricci vs Perlman vs Shaham vs Midori vs Hahn vs Paganini, they all make the technique looks effortless. And the a lot reason why is because they've spent a lot of time removing bad tension from their playing.
While elbow positioning does matter, it is more a function of string and third vs fifth hand position. The fingerboard is curved, not flat, and you want the finger to land normal to the board for any given string.
Look for the work of Sol Babitz, or if you can't find it, Borivoj Martinic-Jercic's forward to his exercises.
For me, what helped the most was removing the shoulder rest during practice. You become accutely aware of the the delicate balancing act that needs to occur, and the forces you put on the instrument. With time, you can develop balance in the left hand and achieve better dexterity than before. For anyone with sufficiently long neck, you can no longer rely on continual holding, and need to support the instrument (in fixed position sections) via the thumb. This encourages you to release pressure on the digits as you play. :-)
But like OP said, they're happy so why mess with what works for them. :-)
P.S. what rep are you working on? Feel free to drop me an email if you're interested in discussing more.
I'm not sure about this. I'm tall and have huge hands, but I've seen the same approach work for quite small people. The actual technique you end up with can look quite different, but I think the goal is pedagogy that directs attention to the right things and let the rest fall in place around it.
> you want the finger to land normal to the board for any given string.
It's not clear to me why that would be.
I don't have access to a music library anymore, so the Babitz stuff looks like it might be hard to find, but the Martinic-Jercic book looks really interesting. Thanks!
> For me, what helped the most was removing the shoulder rest during practice.
When I decided I didn't have time to maintain both a Baroque and a modern technique, I ended up merging them. Haven't used a shoulder rest in years, but I do use a low, center mount chinrest with a gel pad on it.
I'm actually starting on the Bach two part inventions on piano these days in my small amount of time I allocate to music. I haven't touched my violin in months, sadly.
>
> It's not clear to me why that would be.
Tone and tension. You have to use a lot more force to push the string down, if you hit it at an angle. To clarify, I mean normal mostly in the plane perpendicular to the string (across the body). If your elbow is rotated too far backwards and you're trying to play on the G string, your finger will end up nearly parallel with the fingerboard. To reach the G string, you'll have to extend the fingers (at least, with my sized hands). Do not avoid the higher string though, as this too will affect tone.
The strongest and also most relaxed hand position is naturally curled (mostly a fist, but you can't really play the left hand that way... You can the right hand however). By rotating the elbow, you preserve that relaxed hand position on all strings in lower positions.
> When I decided I didn't have time to maintain both a Baroque and a modern technique, I ended up merging them. Haven't used a shoulder rest in years, but I do use a low, center mount chinrest with a gel pad on it.
When you seek left hand balance, you want to minimize downward force, so you can apply equal upward force with your thumb (this is roughly balance). With a shoulder rest (or I fear, a tall chin rest), you can also apply supporting force via the chin and the rest, but that's a source of tension if you're not careful.
You can still perform many shifts with little downward pressure, if you leave the thumb immobile during the shift (either moving before or after). Some shifts where both move are still possible. After lots of practice (perhaps less for you, since you are already accustomed to playing without a shoulder rest -- I wasn't yet), you can get it to a minimum even in Concertos like the Tchaikovsky.
> I don't have access to a music library anymore, so the Babitz stuff looks like it might be hard to find, but the Martinic-Jercic book looks really interesting. Thanks!
I have a PDF of the Babitz that I scanned while at school if you are curious. It's a collection of his short articles in other publications. And to clarify in case it might not've been obvious, I studied under Boro. I don't have any monetary interest in his book, but I do think he made a lot of sense.
Ah, we're talking about exactly the same thing. Just a question of how we phrase it.
> After lots of practice (perhaps less for you, since you are already accustomed to playing without a shoulder rest -- I wasn't yet), you can get it to a minimum even in Concertos like the Tchaikovsky.
I tried to go full Baroque first where I shifted around an immobile thumb. Despite having big hands, there's that down shift in the first movement of the Mendelssohn. I spent a few weeks trying to figure out how to reliably make that shift without using the chin, and never found a way.
So at this point I ideally only apply pressure to the chin rest when I need to do a downshift, and only just enough to keep it the violin from pulling away from my neck. I've found Ricci's recommendation of glissando scales to be a great way of training this (as well as so much else): ascend without touching the violin with your chin. Descend with as little pressure on the violin as you can manage.
It's not totally crazy. Fretted, bowed instruments have a long history, such as the viola da gamba. The frets there have more to do with tone than pitch, though.
> I have tried learning piano and I found a lot of stuff irritatingly hard to get right and got bored
This maps to my first experience. Your first obstacle is the UI and getting your hands to do what your brain wants them to do without thinking about it. For myself learning guitar, this was the hardest obstacle. Once you sort out the mechanics of playing without thinking, you can start thinking about the music and actually having fun.
My only question is, do you really want to learn the piano?
Cause you need to want it, to get through those first few weeks/months of getting used to the UI. Until you break that barrier it's going to be un-fun and sound terrible and be very frustrating. The desire to play needs to be great enough to push through that. If you don't want it, you'll struggle to force yourself to push through.
To answer your actual question, Youtube and other musicians are what I feel most help me grow right now. I've done in person classes, bought books, bought multiple online classes and trawled Youtube for endless hours looking for lessons and song play alongs (getting a sense of the pattern of how important really wanting to learn to play is?). It wasn't until I started playing with other musicians that my abilities and understanding really took off.
The key for me was to forego all theory learning and just have fun with it. Eventually, I got into it enough to go through all the memorization bits.
If piano sounds appealing to you, I recommend using software like Synthesia to make the first few months as easy as possible, to get excited about it.
I have the impression that many people learning instruments, and sadly also many teachers, take an approach that kills motivation. It seems to me that very few people want to become professionals, and that most just want to be able to play a few songs and have fun. For that you don't need perfect posture, or learn all the scales, sight read, etc.
I believe guitar is a very accessible instrument and an electric guitar is easy to practice silently late at night, relatively cheap (Squier Stratocaster Pack etc.) and easy on the fingers compared to, for example, an acoustic guitar.
With learning 4-5 chords, you can perfectly cover lots of great songs. Learning pentatonic scale is not that hard for improvising soloing over those chords with a cheap loop pedal. All under 200-250$ and half an hour a day for, let's say, a year.
I self-tought to about an ABRSM grade 1 level before getting a teacher, but I had done a little bit (less than a year) as a small kid.
Particularly the early stages are very hard and it takes a lot of practice to do seemlingly trivial things. It is a differnet skill from touch typing. I find the "Dozen a Day" books of studies really good for training your fingers to do what you want them to, instead of what they want to do.
Why don’t we have more beginner-friendly and ergonomic instruments? Is it just because they’re seen as ‘cheating’?
I play a lot of instruments (have been playing guitar, bass, woodwinds, and singing since age 10), and my practice routines on various instruments have a lovely way of informing my development and expression on others.
Yeah, I've learnt piano and drums just last few years (I'm 28). I'm no professional, but I also had difficulties with using both hands, involuntarily movements and fatigue in different parts of the body.
Best thing I done was just to practice, practice and more practice. Practice with one hand first until you know it without thinking, then add the other hand slowly. Same goes from drums (and other instruments I'm assuming), start slowly until you know it by heart, then speed up.
No strict schedule, I just play when I feel like it. If I want something intense I play drums. If I feel like melodies, I play piano. Otherwise I mostly use a Novation Circuit and Octatrack (and some other smaller gadgets for bass lines etc) for playing electronic music, mostly just improvisation.
Sometimes you just picked the wrong instrument.. The day I officially gave up piano (with RSIs from piano even) I bought a guitar as a consolation "I didn't really give up" thing.
That was about 6 years ago.. I've taken guitar lessons the last 4 years and have had great success compared to piano. I would say my guitar teacher is a much superior teacher than the piano teachers I had though.
Sometimes you just picked the wrong instrument. I don't miss piano at all really. I still love the piano but it wasn't for me.. and guitars are far more affordable which is very nice.
The muscle memory can only be developed by constantly doing the same thing over a long period of time, every day. Every time you sleep is when the skill learned during the day is actually "saved" and increased.
Trying to do everything perfect at once from the start is impossible. Only once something gets into your muscle memory you can focus on other things. At first you might not be able to find the correct key and have to constantly look at the keyboard, but once you are over that you can now focus on coordination, rhythm or other stuff.
Learning and getting better is just the process of constantly embedding something in your muscle memory so you can consciously focus on something else.
More precisely, a good teacher, will constantly keep you in the slightly uncomfortable phase of not too easy, not too difficult practice.
I have tried learning piano and I found a lot of stuff irritatingly hard to get right and got bored. Like for some reason I am not able to transition to other keys well when I am using both hands or when some finger involuntarily moves because of motion of neighboring finger. Also, I seem to get finger fatigue which is surprising considering the amount of time I spend on keyboards anyway.