News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by projektfu on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:41PM (#25512244)
As a US veterinarian, I hold a nuanced view of spay/neuter. Nevertheless, I generally recommend it as default for most pet owners, as it goes along with their expectations of what their pet's life will be like. People who elected to leave their dogs intact are often shocked by something down the line.

1. Pyometra. Dogs do not have menopause, but they may stop cycling. When they do they can develop a uterine infection that can become life threatening in hours.

2. Perineal hernias. Unneutered, aging dogs are at risk for pelvic floor weakness that results in specialty surgery (and neutering), costing thousands of dollars.

3. Hit by car. Unneutered pets are much more likely to escape randomly and get hit by cars. Even pets that normally do not run away from their owners.

4. Mammary tumor. Unspayed or late-spayed females are at significantly more risk than those spayed at 6 months.

5. Pregnancy. Shocked pikachu face when the unspayed chihuahua actually did get knocked up by their friend's unneutered chow.

6. Bleeding. All bitches bleed during proestrus.

7. Behavior. The dog-park behavior people like in their pets is the behavior of neutered dogs. Unneutered dogs are much more likely to attempt to dominate the other dogs and get into fights.

That said, it's a trade off. Unneutered males definitely have a different growth pattern and develop a stockier build. They also seem to have significantly fewer issues with the cranial cruciate ligament in the stifle (knee). There are some other, more hand-wavey associations of cancer in golden retrievers related to neutering, but it's hard to tell if that's just an artifact of the data as it's more likely unneutered dogs appear at teaching hospitals for injuries (hit by car, fights) rather than for cancer.

I would love to just recommend people be responsible adults. I wish that the US could be like Norway, where people don't seem to abandon their unneutered animals, and they don't seem to have problems with their bad behavior.

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by nradov on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @12:15AM (#25514606)
My father-in-law had an intact Labrador Retriever show dog who escaped over a high fence and swam across a large river in order to visit a bitch in heat. They found him days later, filthy and with some minor injuries. The instinct to reproduce will drive dogs to do crazy things.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by Ma8ee on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @12:57AM (#25514838)
It’s not only dogs. I remember some stupid shit I did as a teenager.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @03:48AM (#25515726)
I'm an adult male and if it weren't for the corporate soul sucking 9-5 job eating away most of my time and energy I'd still engage in stupid shit just for mating.

I think males are biologically programed to stay in heat way longer than females, at least until the first baby is born, just that modern society has figured how to tame us by placing us in a financial rat race where it all about chasing material things, hobbies and lifestyles or the next big career rather than the next potential partner.

As a kid I never really understood the point Fight Club was trying to make but as an adult, I do now.

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by f6v on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @05:42AM (#25516318)
Imagine a society where 99% of work is done by robots/AI...
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @07:36AM (#25516916)
Then the rest of the 99% of workers would compete for the remaining 1% of jobs based on how things have gone so far.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by siberianbear on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @05:06AM (#25516150)
And it's not just you, either. I'm lucky to be alive after the crazy shit I did as a teenager.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by smusamashah on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @03:26AM (#25515618)
A friend in military told us that as part of their training they are given injections to curb sexual desire. They can't even masturbate. Its given regularly every month or so until their training is complete.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by swebs on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @06:37AM (#25516592)
That's an urban legend. Some variations also say the drug is in the food.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by staticman2 on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @10:06AM (#25518282)
Extremley strenuously exercise is known to lower testosterone. I wonder if people believe this urban legend because their bodies are in shock and they lose libido due to basic training exercises?
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by m0nty on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @05:45AM (#25516330)
I took my three-year old, intact bearded collie for a walk where we met a couple with a spaniel bitch. They carried on walking, and about 10 minutes later (when they were a good distance away) we let ours off the lead. He raced off towards them at high speed, which is not unknown for him but largely under control these days. We eventually got him back and (almost as an aside) the owner of the other said "ours is in heat at the moment." Could have warned us pal, we'd never have let him off.

About eight weeks later, I took him for a walk along the same canal and let him off. Rounded a corner where he'd got a bit ahead, and he was just gone, disappeared without a trace. I started off as quickly as I could down the canal, passing various people who (as if it were some kind of joke) said things like "oh yes, going very fast that way". Eventually, got him back because a cyclist had the common sense to apprehend him and wait for me - "my dog does this all the time." This was after almost a mile, so the dog hadn't been hanging around.

Beardies have a reputation for going AWOL, but on this occasion I can only presume he had some memory of that fine young spaniel he'd pursued previously, and decided to rejoin the chase. I haven't been back there since. Have considered getting him neutered but we basically like him as he is and have learned to be super-careful at any time. Helps to be warned if someone has a bitch who is likely to be especially interesting at a given time, most owners are good about it but a few just don't seem to understand.

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by bloodorange on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @06:30AM (#25516562)
You are taking your dog for a walk off leash and feel that others who are walking their dogs ought to do something to ensure you dog does not run off? Otherwise they don't understand the issue?

I assumed "off leash" because if he can run off even when on a leash, then it's worse than I imagined.

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by thatguy0900 on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @11:28AM (#25519257)
Not to pile on, but ""ours is in heat at the moment." Could have warned us pal, we'd never have let him off." is a pretty extreme sense of entitlement, you should really reconsider how much other people should care about your dog and it's behaviors, ideally it should be none
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by astura on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @10:50AM (#25518811)
Stop letting your dog off it's leash... Wtf?
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by tomcam on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @09:50AM (#25518118)
Why... why did you let an intact male off leash at all?
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by EL_Loco on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @06:45AM (#25516635)
I saw a schnauzer jump from a (high) second-floor balcony to go after a bitch in heat.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by ambivalents on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @06:04PM (#25512484)
Thank you for sharing this. Regarding behavior, do intact male dogs also attract aggressive behavior towards them? My (intact male) dog isn't aggressive, but a few times now other dogs have attacked him (not resulting in serious injury, but was super scary). I was told by a trainer that he could be emitting hormones that cause this behavior in other dogs.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by projektfu on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:07PM (#25513960)
Yes, and it could simply be a matter of things like postural cues that you think aren't aggressive but nevertheless are asserting behavior that other dogs don't like.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by aerosmile on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:01PM (#25513603)
In short, yes. Boarding places require neutering for that reason even if your dog passes all behavioral tests.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by Niten on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:44PM (#25512276)
> 3. Hit by car. Unneutered pets are much more likely to escape randomly and get hit by cars. Even pets that normally do not run away from their owners.

Is there evidence of a causal relationship here?

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by astura on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @12:37AM (#25514725)
Most people I personally know/knew didn't spay/neuter their pets when I was growing up.

I've seen animals do some absolutely bonkers crazy stuff while in heat. I know an intact female pet that literally broke a screen window to jump out said window in order to mate. This was a second story window, yes she jumped out of a second story window!

So I don't doubt it for even a second.

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by sjg007 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:47PM (#25512315)
They are running off to sow their oats.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by Talanes on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @08:03PM (#25513308)
The inference is obvious, I assume the poster is looking for actual data.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by nbadg on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:46PM (#25513859)
I want to preface this by saying: veterinary science is just that, a science. Your vet has spent their career, hopefully anyways, learning what the best veterinary minds know about veterinary medicine. And your vet is probably a whole lot more trustworthy than random comments on the internet like this one. But with that said, I agree completely with the above: citation sorely needed. Show me the data.

One of the first conversations I had with my vet was about when I could start running with my dog. There's a lot of conversation online about how you need to wait until growth plates fuse to avoid future health issues (or similar variations on the same theme).

Her response was, to paraphrase:

> This is all just folk wisdom. There's no proper scientific evidence to support that conclusion, and it doesn't make sense to me. What distance are you running? Do you think a wolf could run that distance at your dog's age? You know your dog, just pay attention to her; play it by ear, don't take it too hard, take it easier on harder surfaces like concrete, and get her used to running before pushing hard.

When she said that, something really clicked in my head. We're finally, finally starting to talk more about evidenced-based medicine when it comes to humans, but when it comes to animals... The plain fact of the matter is that much of veterinary medicine is really just our best guess at things. All of the problems that human medical research have are magnified substantially in the veterinary world, even if just because of how much more resource-constrained it is.

I'm having a really tough time coming up with hard numbers here -- I can't find anything at all from the US -- but I found a UK report from about a decade ago [1] that, adjusting for inflation and currency conversion, suggests that $230mm USD was spent in the UK on all veterinary research, with a heavy emphasis on agriculture over pets (extremely unsurprising!). Meanwhile, about $3bb USD was spent on human medical research [2], with about $866mm USD spent for cancer research alone[3].

Think about how many conflicting studies we hear about cancer risk in humans. Now imagine how much worse it would be with less than 1/10 the budget. And again, most of veterinary research is specific to agriculture, not pets, so now imagine how much more worse it would be if most of that research money was spent on treating other species in completely different environments, with no interest in how it relates to humans.

So again: veterinary medicine is a scientific field, and part of your vet's job is to keep abreast of the literature, and they can almost certainly do a better job of it than you or I. But if you've ever been hit by the thought "man, there is just soooo much we do not understand about human biology" or caught yourself saying "anecdata isn't the same as medical research"... when it comes to veterinary medicine, the situation is much, much worse.

[1] https://www.rcvs.org.uk/news-and-views/publications/veterina...

[2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/298897/united-kingdom-uk...

[3] https://www.stroke.org.uk/sites/default/files/sa-research_sp...

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by projektfu on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:22PM (#25514046)
The going joke is that everything we know was true for 8 beagles. Veterinary studies are often small in scale and not made of representatives of the whole population.

I don't feel like digging through PubMed to back up an assertion like "unneutered dogs are more likely to roam and get hit by car." At best I'll be able to give you a records-review type of study and it's a low quality of evidence. Also, trends don't mean that your specific animal is going to be the same. I work with an unneutered labrador patient who is never going to get hit by a car, and I have definitely treated neutered ones who have. This association, though, does have a basis in animal behavior and is familiar to vets who work in emergency rooms.

The level of evidence that suggests that neutering is positively associated with cancer is extremely poor. Yet, there are people running with it like it's 100%. Meanwhile, we have stronger evidence that spaying prevents mammary cancer and castration prevents testicular cancer.

Good on you for jogging with your dog. Be mindful of their limits, because they will hide pain. Keep them in athletic trim and you should be fine, in my opinion.

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by nbadg on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @02:05AM (#25515217)
Oh to be clear, I think it's perfectly plausible (and even likely). You can boil the question down to "does smelling a female in heat lower impulse control in intact males", and, well, yeah, I can believe that without batting an eye. But it was a convenient place to make a larger point about the lack of good evidence in a lot of veterinary medicine, which I think is something we should talk more about (I'd levy the same critique against medicine for people, too!). Anyways, I probably should have been clearer in my original post, that my point was really: it seems completely plausible, but we need to be better about citing research in medicine and being explicit about corresponding confidence levels, and veterinary research is woefully under-funded.

I think my personal biggest complaint about the overwhelming prevalence of desexing in the US is that we're not really being honest with ourselves about why we're doing it. I would argue, based on my experience, (I realize the hypocrisy in using sociological anecdata immediately after complaining about medical anecdata), the vast majority of pet owners who desex their dogs do so out of convenience, and the vast majority of policy encouragements for it (eg: shelters requiring it or cities assessing 10x licensing fees for intact dogs) are done because most US dog owners aren't responsible enough to prevent unwanted pregnancies and have a horrible habit of abandoning unwanted litters. That's not to say that there aren't medical reasons; some of them are even on really solid footing (eg using spaying as a way to stop frequent painful false pregnancies), but I don't think most US dog owners are even aware of that being a thing, much less making medical decisions in response to it.

I think we are starting to see a discussion of sterilization vs desexing, which is great, but even so, as it stands today, spay/neuter is standard practice in the US. I almost never see an acknowledgement that, particularly for females, we've more or less mandated a very substantial, very invasive medical procedure, mostly just because dog owners in the US just don't want to deal with a particular part of canine biology. And I personally think that raises ethical concerns around treatment of animals.

Also, thanks! She's an almost-90-pound ridgeback, so... running is one of the few things keeping us (relatively) sane!

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by randycupertino on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @12:35AM (#25514710)
It's a growing market, though! I work in human biopharma clinical research and was recently recruited for a vet med clinical research position.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by Hnrobert42 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:31PM (#25513780)
I wonder how you would collect that data.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by redtexture on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:54PM (#25513903)
7 of the best GPS dog collars and trackers to keep tabs on your pet

https://mashable.com/roundup/best-gps-dog-collars/

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by Hnrobert42 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:11PM (#25513986)
But how would you test the inference with that data? You don’t need to know when the dog crossed the road but why.

Which reminds me of this Far Side cartoon: https://www.pinterest.com/pin/251990541629282256/

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by mjevans on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @12:15AM (#25514607)
I suspect a study to prove the exact means of connection is very difficult.

A retrospective study would be easier. Based on a survey of a given vets files (not quite a random sample, but for this case it might be good enough to establish a bias in facts), could trace the incidence rate of 'yard escape injuries' between 'intact' and neutered males, as well as 'intact' and spayed females.

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by postalrat on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:09PM (#25513648)
After owning an unneutered dog when I was a kid I can't imagine the data shows anything else.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by jeromenerf on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @05:52AM (#25516369)
> I would love to just recommend people be responsible adults.

Always a good recommendation.

Neutering dogs and cats seems the consequence of "owning" in an urban or otherwise densely populated area. It feels wrong to me. I would personally get a farm before I get pets.

Then, I have horses. Neutering males is common here for our breeds, as stallions are pretty difficult to manage. It is said that Portuguese breeds are often left intact, as a result of behavioral selection.

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by Balgair on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @01:24PM (#25520458)
Hey, just want to say thanks for being on HN! It's great to have other voices outside of SW here.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by realsimplesynd on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @06:00PM (#25512449)
> 6. All bitches bleed during proestrus.

The word “bitch” has changed so much in cultural meaning during the last 50 years or so that somehow it feels more offensive to call a female dog a “bitch” then a human.

How is “bitch” used in veterinary hospitals?

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by perardi on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @08:33PM (#25513453)
It’s still used extensively by breeders, including what amounts to the highest authority, the American Kennel Club.

https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/dog-breeding/choosing-a-br...

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by projektfu on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:24PM (#25514050)
I can't respond to the GP directly, but it is a very normal word in veterinary medicine when talking about a reproductive-age female dog.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by OJFord on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @08:53PM (#25513563)
No it hasn't, stop giggling at the back of the class.

The only thing that's arguably changed is the extent to which 'dog' is a genderless generic term.

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by t-writescode on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @08:24PM (#25513414)
It hasn’t. That’s the source of the word, and you likely haven’t been in circles where the real word is used intentionally for the real word’s purpose.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by gwd on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @06:02AM (#25516419)
Or to put it in a way which might connect better with gp:

By continuing to use the word "bitch" for its original meaning, vets, dog breeders, and the like are fighting against the appropriation (and degradation) of their culture by the world at large.

Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by ubertoop on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:22PM (#25513726)
That won't stop them from trying to redefine or eliminate the word entirely.
Re:How neutering dogs became the norm by runawaybottle on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:18PM (#25513705)
I’d feel ill calling my dog a ‘bitch’. We humans ruined the word, so not sure why your post is invisible.