News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by bawolff on Sunday December 20, 2020 @02:18PM (#25488783)
> classical debates that have no end like guns and abortion.

I think this is a pretty american centric point of view. These debates don't have anywhere near the same back and forth in other countries (thinking of canada in particular) that they do in USA.

I imagine how taboo porn is is also very much a cultural phenomenon that varries a lot place to place.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by k__ on Sunday December 20, 2020 @02:39PM (#25488928)
This.

The debates in the US sound ridiculous to me.

It's like the US is a first world country full of people from a few centuries ago.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by chaosharmonic on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:37PM (#25489309)
I mean. That statement tracks pretty well if you look at our government, where the elderly are represented in elected offices at double or even triple their actual share of the population.

According to the 2010 census Americans over 65 make up under 15% of... well, Americans[0], but currently occupy 147 seats in the House (out of a possible 435) and 48 in the Senate (out of 100), along with executive branches in 15 states (out of 50).[1]

[0] https://www.census.gov/prod/cen2010/briefs/c2010br-03.pdf

[1] https://www.quorum.us/data-driven-insights/the-115th-congres... (note that this was originally posted in 2017, but was later updated for the 116th)

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by hn_throwaway_99 on Sunday December 20, 2020 @04:33PM (#25489736)
Sure, but the implication that congressional representation should closely track percentage of the population is ludicrous. I mean, according to a quick Google search, nearly 40% of Americans are under age 30, the minimum age for a US Senator. Should we be mad none of them are Senators, or heck, that not one of the nearly a quarter of Americans who are under 18 (aka children) are in Congress?
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by toyg on Sunday December 20, 2020 @07:56PM (#25491063)
You are trivializing what is an actual worldwide issue: even in democratic countries the young are completely not represented. Not “underrepresented”, not represented at all. It’s a massive, massive problem that very few countries actually tried to tackle. The young are the future, but governments can (and mostly do) completely ignore their needs, and simply run everything into the metaphorical ground - they’ll be gone by the time the real impact of their choices will be apparent, anyway.

This dovetails nicely with another big problem of most political systems: the cursus honorum for politicians is often very slow, meaning that, by the time a person gets to call the shots, the world has already changed significantly. This could simply be considered folklore when the world moved slowly, but we’ve effectively lost that luxury about 100 years ago. And when we go the other way, and elect mid-life people, we end up with revolving-door issues and poor selection criteria (looks over brains etc).

So yeah, age-representation is a big unsolved problem of democratic government.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by pksebben on Sunday December 20, 2020 @08:51PM (#25491357)
I don't think it's taking the point too far to say that this will be one of the horsemen when the end comes for our current form of governance. Communications technology speeds social change, and government digs it's heels in because it's run by people who "know better" because they feel like their experience is more important than actual fact.

And then we laugh at people like AOC, because nothing makes us feel better about our ignorance than demeaning smart people who want to fix it for us.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by tyre on Sunday December 20, 2020 @04:23PM (#25489651)
It’s less bad than that. 24% in the 2010 census were under 18 and 9.9% were 18–24.

I don’t put those under “should be in Congress”, and constitutionally they’re not allowed to be until 25. So it is 13 percentage points out of 66 percentage points — about 20% of the population with 34% of the seats in the house.

Senators have to be 30 so the over 65 crowd would be an even greater share there.

Given that experience probably gives you _something_, it’s still out of whack but not crazy.

All of that said, personally I believe it’s far too skewed and we should have an age cap in Congress.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by bawolff on Sunday December 20, 2020 @04:52PM (#25489870)
I'd note that its not like these are recent events in canada. Trudeau (the current Prime minister's dad) introduced the bill that semi-legalized abortion (under restricted circumstances) and introduced some gun control, 52 years ago. (Among other things like legalizing homosexuality and contraceptives). Then 20 years later the remaining restrictions on abortion were ruled unconstitutional.

All these senior citizen lawmakers in the usa were pretty young when all this went down, so i dont think age is an explaining factor for the differences.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by k__ on Sunday December 20, 2020 @06:07PM (#25490465)
Yes, I don't know either.

In Germany we are ruled by old people and conservatives, but they are nothing compared to the US.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by morelisp on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:07PM (#25489097)
The abortion debate still happens (at varying intensities and varying degrees of public view) in much of Europe.

The gun control debate is largely settled but I suspect it will start up quite loudly if the EU ever tries to normalize gun laws across member states. The difference between say, the Netherlands (low ownership, very hard to get a license), Austria (moderately regulated and lots of unlicensed ownership), and Finland (very high ownership rate but strictly regulated) is probably wider than any US state, because the US constitution has been interpreted to set a fairly high bar for any regulation.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by mbrodersen on Monday December 21, 2020 @06:41AM (#25493990)
Yep you are absolutely right. Abortion and guns is a non-issue in most of Western Europe. And Australia.
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by syshum on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:18PM (#25489181)
Largely because the extreme end of one side already "won" the debate on those other nations, and actively suppresses and/or oppresses any dissent
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by xg15 on Sunday December 20, 2020 @05:06PM (#25489970)
Where is there active suppression of debate on gun control in western nations?
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by Torwald on Sunday December 20, 2020 @06:49PM (#25490744)
For example in the media.

Let's take major newspapers like _The Times_ or the _Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung_ as examples.

You will not find any article that mentions 2nd amendment rights while not taking side against gun ownership. Every time the American practice is mentioned, it is scoffed at. At least by implication.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by pksebben on Sunday December 20, 2020 @09:04PM (#25491430)
Perhaps there's a good reason for that. Not all ideas are created equal, and the proliferation of mass shootings in the states should serve as a strong signal that our gun laws are dumb.

Somehow, the conversation has stalled here because some people actually believe they're going to protect their freedoms with violence. You know, by fighting against a government equipped with stealth bombers and death drones and navy seals. With their hunting rifles.

I served in the army. The idea that civilians could put up anything of a fight is a fantasy more ridiculous than kung fury. What keeps you safe from "the government" is that soldiers are taught that they are there to serve and that American citizens are off-limits, not that they are somehow quivering in their boots about losing a fight with your cute little club of weekend warriors that play dress-up in the woods with walkie talkies.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by mbrodersen on Monday December 21, 2020 @06:57AM (#25494084)
Agree. It doesn’t matter how much ammo you store in your little hut in the woods, the number of guns you buy, the amount of Tactical Toothbrushes in camouflage paint you squirrel away. The government doesn’t even have to use the army. It can simply declare you to be a terrorist (using one of the secret courts), and send in the local gun crazy SWAT guys to take you out. And if you as much as look at one of your Tactical Toothbrushes when they burst through your bedroom door at 4am, they will shoot you so full of holes that not even your mum will recognise you. Followed by a press conference where the government will proudly declare to the world that they have eliminated yet another terrorist and back slaps all around for the brave boys who pumped you full of lead.
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by fuzxi on Monday December 21, 2020 @01:02AM (#25492496)
Interesting that a soldier is ignoring both A) the incredible power of guerilla warfare (see: Vietnam War), and B) the horrifyingly bad optics, and possible sanctions, that would result from the US actually utilizing unrestrained military might against their own citizens.
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by pksebben on Thursday December 24, 2020 @11:17PM (#25534145)
A) We are engaging, currently, in a number of asymmetric (read: guerilla) wars right now, with an unfathomable level of success - see Afghanistan, Iraq et al. We have learned a lot and gotten a lot better at things since Vietnam (not to mention, we train on American soil, so the guerilla advantage is more or less lost, there).

B) That's exactly what I'm saying! It's the optics and the structure of political ownership that prevents such a civil war, not deterrence, as the second amendment was designed to implement.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by worik on Sunday December 20, 2020 @11:09PM (#25492049)
I have heard that American knife murders are as high, and out of step with other countries, as for gun murders.

Perhaps there is something deeply violent (deeply wrong IMO) in the USA's culture?

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by mindslight on Sunday December 20, 2020 @10:20PM (#25491844)
I agree with you on the practical utility of the 2nd amendment for defending against tyranny (and if anything it seems to be more of a distraction, encouraging tyranny to developed unchecked with the idea that it will be fought at some future breaking point). But with regards to school shootings there is a much more prominent and straightforward cause - mass media itself, both news and entertainment. And they're continually working to write themselves out of the narrative by directing focus at inanimate objects.
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by mbrodersen on Monday December 21, 2020 @07:04AM (#25494127)
I am not sure I understand your argument. Are you saying that it was actually journalists that were running around shooting the kids, and not kids wanting to take revenge with guns they had easy access to? And that without easy access to guns the kinds would have killed the same number of people with, say, a kitchen knife? Really?
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by mindslight on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:24AM (#25496335)
It seems like you willfully misunderstood my argument, as talking about journalists shooting kids is some obvious caricature.

Society is held together by people's values and individual adherence to shared rules - aka culture. Kids, like everyone else (eg cops), are acting out cultural norms, being mostly defined by mass media.

Entertainment media mostly consists of easy-to-write fight scenes where the main characters dispose of some endless supply of nameless "bad guys". A few hits or shots, that one is gone, move on to the next one. No scenes showing henchman #17 hugging his kids goodbye that morning, or henchman #31's parents grieving. Just purely transactional force-of-will violence - sound familiar?

Furthermore, news media then glorifies shooting events when they do happen, showering the perpetrator with attention and making sure they go down in infamy - it's actually a quite precocious way to get one's 15 minutes of fame.

And of course there's that other uncomfortable issue of why school environments cause kids to want to kill their peers in the first place!

But there's no straightforward approaches to those, and they're held in place by entrenched incentives (lazy writing, clickbait advertising, ass-covering school administrators), while the people speaking up for the inanimate objects are easy to write off.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by mbrodersen on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:50PM (#25513878)
Most rich western countries don’t have mass shootings in schools. Even though the media you describe is the same. So obviously the media is not the reason why. So what is the difference then? It’s simple: kids in the US have easy access to guns. Not so in other rich western countries. If kids in other rich countries had easy access to guns, there would be school shootings there as well.
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by GoblinSlayer on Monday December 21, 2020 @04:45PM (#25499991)
You basically say that rebellion can never be successful.
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by pksebben on Thursday December 24, 2020 @11:18PM (#25534149)
That is precisely what I am saying.
Re:The Internet Is for Porn by belorn on Sunday December 20, 2020 @08:53PM (#25491376)
A German news paper like Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung has little reason to mention the 2nd amendment rights, because there are no 2nd amendment rights in Germany.

What most countries in EU has is gun ownership license, similar to a driving license, and thus the default right that people without a license has is no rights. Permission is given by the government, and thus the government set the terms.

In the US this power relationship is the other way around. People have a default right to bear arms, and so government have to take away rights in order to enforce gun control.

One could easily imagine a country where driving a car would be part of a constitution, in which case a driving license would be a hot discussion. How, when and where should the government be allowed to step in and remove peoples right to do with their car property as they wish? People from other countries would look at the debate and find it a bit odd.

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by EdwardDiego on Sunday December 20, 2020 @10:12PM (#25491796)
People outside the US scoff because of the ridiculous amount of harm done by overly easy access to firearms in the US and your inability to discuss it seriously as a nation, as profoundly ridiculed by the Onion[1].

As people outside the US are fond of pointing out, your right to bear arms came from the 2nd _amendment_ so you know, you could always make another amendment.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%27No_Way_To_Prevent_This,%27_...

Re:The Internet Is for Porn by bawolff on Sunday December 20, 2020 @08:43PM (#25491314)
So? make your own newspaper.

A newspaper (especially a privately owned one) not agreeing with you hardly amounts to suppression.