I'm convinced if you want to keep the level of discourse up, you can have a (mostly) homogeneous group of commenters and a large scale site or a small group of heterogeneous commenters, but you cannot have both scale and heterogeneity.
By charging your users to comment, you're probably going to reduce scale.
Most newspapers require letters to the editor that appear in their print editions to be signed with the person's real name, and they suffer no shortage of letters as a result of that policy. I see no reason why they can't hold online users to the same standards.
It seems like it's combining different audiences at once - the red ones are transmission of random teenage angst (better to put in any pseudonymous journal site or tumblr), the gold ones are positive reviews (seems like they're safe on Yelp), and no black ones have actually appeared in the time I've had this window open.
It's nice that the page live-scrolls, but then why does Read More reload the page?
> Yet, if somebody has something interesting to say about pornography
They might not care whether you think it meets your standard of good taste?
We will use registered users to help us moderate our content. We also want to work, eventually, on creating a network of trust. By the way, user accounts are optional, not required to create spots or comment about them.
> It seems like it's combining different audiences at once...
The fundamental difference between our service and tumblr, yelp, etc, is that our main content (the spots) must be anonymous. We don't want to know who is the author of a spot. Anonymity is the core of what we do because what matters to us is only what people think.
So far, about 50% of the spots are goldspots, and the other 50% evenly divided between blackspots and lovespots. The fact that goldspots are dominating makes us happy.
> why does Read More reload the page?
Read More takes you the the page of the specific spot.
> They might not care whether you think it meets your standard of good taste?
Common sense is common (pun intended). If a spot doesn't look "publishable" to us at Spottiness, the probability that it will look the same to the majority is high.
Thanks for taking the time to look at our site!
My problem with the site is that my intuitive malware/scam heuristics would get a false positive on the site, if you hadn't vouched for it here on Hacker News. If you changed the design, it might help a little, but you obviously still need to figure out the market for the service.
On the positive side, companies are starting to realize that they aren't handling comment systems very well.
One of the first things you learn on SA is to "grow a thicker skin", because there aren't enough moderators with sufficient time to stop users from ganging up on some people and giving them a hard time. And as a result, moderators also allow a harsher tone.
The moderators are vital, but I wouldn't say that they are moderating heavily.
It does show the relevance of communities like SA versus random gatherings of visitors that most comment systems on websites constitute.
http://coding.pressbin.com/50/10-web-start-ups-all-mine--and...
Check out the blurbs on Truyoo, Utopic, and ioFeed.
I think your analysis of the situation (No Co-Founder, Not fully invested) was true for both of us, but I also, particularly after reading your ioFeed post.. We're creating technical solutions to problems.
That's not enough. Saying "I can improve on Facebook" doesn't take into account the huge network effect, and it doesn't solve the problem of getting people onto your site.
It's a good reminder that the tech isn't enough by itself.
Right. You're doing it wrong.
Stop moderating reader comments. Let readers moderate reader comments.
Stop creating one way comment systems. Create ways for readers to converse with reporters.
At hacker news for example, all sorts of entrepreneurs come by and all sorts of startup wannabe employees come through as well.
When was the last time you saw a reporter have any serious interaction with his readers in the comments?
Works for some brands -- not for others.
A few years back, I tried to come up with a solution. I created Truyoo (http://www.truyoo.com), which essentially requires a user to pay a one-time nominal fee (less than $2) to confirm their identity. They would then be issued a Truyoo ID, which could be used to comment on any site that used Truyoo.
For legitimate, constructive commenters, this is extremely inexpensive -- but it quickly becomes very expensive for spammy/abusive users.
Unfortunately, Truyoo never gained traction, largely because no publisher was willing to ask its users to pay even a tiny one-time fee to comment.