Re:Comments Are Dead. We Need You to Help Reinvent Them
by jdp23 on Saturday May 14, 2011 @02:07PM
(#2548185)
It's a great point that there aren't any obvious examples in the US of large heterogenous groups with good comments. That said I also am not aware of any attempt to do even Slashdot-like crowdsourced voting (including explanation of reasons for voting, meta-moderation) at scale, or to take the next step and provide a richer user experience to make it easy for users to be able to filter out what they don't want do see.
Re:Comments Are Dead. We Need You to Help Reinvent Them
by fredBuddemeyer on Saturday May 14, 2011 @02:48PM
(#2548282)
it has a lot to do with anonymity. simply look at techcrunch and what happened overnight with real names- quite large and homogenous too.
Re:Comments Are Dead. We Need You to Help Reinvent Them
by luminous00 on Saturday May 14, 2011 @02:23PM
(#2548217)
From a publisher's point of view, it has a lot to do with anonymity. Ever try to block a determined troll?
I'm convinced if you want to keep the level of discourse up, you can have a (mostly) homogeneous group of commenters and a large scale site or a small group of heterogeneous commenters, but you cannot have both scale and heterogeneity.
By charging your users to comment, you're probably going to reduce scale.