News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comments Are Dead. We Need You to Help Reinvent Them by zecho on Saturday May 14, 2011 @01:33PM (#2548122)
Something Awful is also heavily, heavily moderated and it's a group of fairly like-minded people, especially in the subforums outside GBS. If I remember right, I think the $10 charge was more to recoup costs of running the site. Keeping out crazies is a side effect.
Re:Comments Are Dead. We Need You to Help Reinvent Them by kmfrk on Saturday May 14, 2011 @02:01PM (#2548175)
It's not very heavily moderated, but it does have moderators that can be summoned with the report buttons.

One of the first things you learn on SA is to "grow a thicker skin", because there aren't enough moderators with sufficient time to stop users from ganging up on some people and giving them a hard time. And as a result, moderators also allow a harsher tone.

The moderators are vital, but I wouldn't say that they are moderating heavily.

It does show the relevance of communities like SA versus random gatherings of visitors that most comment systems on websites constitute.

Re:Comments Are Dead. We Need You to Help Reinvent Them by samengland on Saturday May 14, 2011 @06:33PM (#2548720)
I think heavy, but not overly up-front moderation is the key to building a good discussion - this simply means clearing out comments which are superfluous - thereby creating richer, more readable content.