News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by krmboya on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @02:21PM (#25447186)
I can't understand how Mozilla failed to execute on Firefox OS.

From where I am at it was a massive opportunity for Mozilla and Web developers all round the world. They didn't have to take on Android and iOS directly, but may have gotten there eventually thru 'worse is better'.

Imagine a web developer learning just a few APIs and being being able to customize their web app for smart TVs

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by heavyset_go on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @02:47PM (#25447556)
> Imagine a web developer learning just a few APIs and being being able to customize their web app for smart TVs

This was WebOS in 2009.

Windows Phone, WebOS, Meego and Ubuntu Phone all "failed" around the same time period as Firefox OS. I have a hard time laying blame solely on Mozilla there.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by chrisseaton on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @05:15PM (#25449517)
MeeGo was a bizarre affair. There was I think Maemo, Moblin, LImo, SLP, Bada, Leste, MeeGo, Mer, Tizen, Sailfish, Nemo... all forks, merges, reforks. They seemed to spend all their time and energy continually rebranding, forming and disbanding consortiums, creating new websites and logos. They never just got on with it.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by ethbr0 on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:49PM (#25450908)
> seemed to spend all their time and energy continually rebranding

So, what would have happened to Android, if Google didn't have the Maps / Play Store big stick?

Every device manufacturer wants to differentiate. None of them are good at it.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by ahartmetz on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:14PM (#25451562)
Except one time they did and it was wonderful - the N9. Then Elop came and canceled it, as ordered by the the Nokia board that hired him.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by usr1106 on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:58PM (#25451879)
Well, wonderful... It was a huge mess. Maemo was gtk based until Nokia bought Qt. Guess there was some friction in the conversion. Maemo was deb based until Nokia management brought Intel into the boat for no technical reasons, then they switched to rpm. Well, the packaging is a relatively small detail, but many other parts of the distro saw similar switches from choice A to choice B for no real benefit. Friction after friction.

Elop was an incompetent leader, but he had not been involved in creating the mess. He went for a worse option, but that does not say that Meego would have ever succeeded.

Yes, I am stuck in the past myself, typing this on SailfishOS. But one has to see the realities.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by ahartmetz on Thursday December 17, 2020 @07:58AM (#25455144)
The main problem with Meego etc was that they never released a damn phone. The N9 was both released and a very good phone. That was the "wonderful" part. I know that it was a bit of a mess technically behind the scenes. But it was also a mess that was possible to clean up.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by TheAdamAndChe on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @03:02PM (#25447770)
What was the hard part that caused Android and iOS to win? Was it convincing manufacturers to ship with them? Or was it just the first mover advantage for iOS and the network effects of the Play Store with Android?
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by boogies on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @04:02PM (#25448609)
Some part of it was MS buying Nokia and killing Meego, just as the N9 won glowing praise and awards with it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_N9#Reception

> The Nokia N9 was announced at Nokia's Connections event in Singapore, June 2011. The reception for the device has been very positive, citing the MeeGo v1.2 Harmattan UI, pseudo-buttonless design, polycarbonate unibody construction and its NFC capabilities. Still, many reviewers did not recommend to buy the N9 only because of Nokia's earlier decision to drop MeeGo for Windows Phone for future smartphones – often questioning this decision at the same time. Engadget's editor Vlad Savov said in June 2011 that "it's a terrific phone that's got me legitimately excited to use it, but its future is clouded by a parent that's investing its time and money into building up a whole other OS." In a later review, Engadget writes: "Love at first sight — this is possibly the most beautiful phone ever made," and "MeeGo 1.2 Harmattan is such a breath of fresh air it will leave you gasping — that is, until you remember that you're dealing with a dead man walking."

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by TedDoesntTalk on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @04:15PM (#25448792)
Yes. Mozilla couldn’t get the mobile operators to sell a phone pre-loaded with FirefoxOS. And no one is going to buy a phone and reimage it.

> I can't understand how Mozilla failed to execute on Firefox OS.

This is naive. They did execute, and failed. That’s different than not executing at all. You can’t break into this segment without cooperation from the mobile phone operators... even in India and Southeast Asia whom were the primary target markets (less disposable income than Americans)

I had a Firefox OS phone. There was nothing great about it. It was average (by intention in order to work on restricted devices). I never used it to make calls, I used it for development. And it only had a wifi connection because I did not buy service for it.

There was nothing really “disruptive” about it as I recall. $20 Android phones destroyed any hope after the mobile operators turned a blind eye.

p.s. I still have the phone.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:10PM (#25451544)
> And no one is going to buy a phone and reimage it.

People do this all the time. I did it with my first android phone, a Nexus S, despite having bought the phone with no intention of doing so. The Chinese crapware it came loaded with didn't really leave any alternative.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by zamadatix on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @04:33PM (#25449024)
So I guess the question is what made KaiOS able to succeed instead of fail if we're saying the problems FirefoxOS faced weren't execution? Was it simply different timing and now more operators are willing to partner?
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by fabrice_d on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @05:19PM (#25449565)
The GP is mostly wrong. What killed FxOS in the market is the lack of official support for one extremely popular messaging application starting by W.

Then Mozilla's leadership didn't have the patience to wait for the right opportunity.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by zamadatix on Thursday December 17, 2020 @12:22PM (#25457682)
This doesn't really answer the question any it just adds more speculation in between again. But to rewrite the question with the new speculation - what made KaiOS able to succeed in starting without WhatsApp support and eventually getting it (last year) instead of failing on both counts like FirefoxOS did?

I.e. if you've got something to claim as the reason it can't also apply to KaiOS unless there was something KaiOS did right that Mozilla didn't.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by fabrice_d on Sunday December 20, 2020 @08:04PM (#25491112)
KaiOS got enough users thanks to Jio Reliance in India. That convinced Whatsapp to build an app for it.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by TedDoesntTalk on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @06:16PM (#25450106)
Lack of WhatsApp support did not kill FirefoxOS.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by fabrice_d on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @06:28PM (#25450197)
Commercially, it totally did. Without Whatsapp we could not sell enough devices, but without enough volume Whatsapp was not interested to build an official app. Chicken, meet egg!
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by mortenjorck on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:06PM (#25451512)
If it was literally make-or-break for the entire platform, especially in the markets it was targeting, I’m surprised Mozilla never volunteered to subsidize or build a WhatsApp port.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by fabrice_d on Thursday December 17, 2020 @12:34AM (#25452866)
Why do you assume didn't try anything?

We actually:

- have been friendly to 3rd party clients developers, like Loquim (https://loqui.im/). Once WA turned on e2e encryption, the situation for 3rd party clients changed from "difficult but fun" to "mostly impossible".

- wrote a JVM in JS to run the S40 version of WA (https://github.com/mozilla/pluotsorbet).

- partnered with a company specialized in bringing android apps to other OSes (they had Windows Phone support for instance).

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by toastal on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:47PM (#25450891)
I wonder what markets WhatsApp is important to. In the UK quite a few people used it while briefly lived there, but in the US, Thailand, Vietnam, et.al. I didn't see anyone using or ever talking about it.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by sobani on Thursday December 17, 2020 @05:10AM (#25454208)
In the Netherlands WhatsApp is so ubiquitous that it always surprises me to hear other countries are not 100% WA. (Besides China, for obvious reasons it doesn't surprise me China has their own app.)

The only people I know who don't use WhatsApp are very privacy focused and therefor use Signal.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:17PM (#25451581)
Adding on to the other comments, I understand it is the default messaging app in Australia / New Zealand.

More roughly, my understanding of the messaging space was:

- USA: Facebook Messenger

- Japan, Taiwan: LINE

- China: WeChat

- Everywhere Else in the World: WhatsApp

And the comments here seem to basically bear that out.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by Firehawke on Thursday December 17, 2020 @11:51AM (#25457326)
I'm seeing a lot of push towards Discord in the USA as well; it's a bit awkward in that kind of usage, but when basically everyone is already using Discord on PC it's not hard to convince people to use the phone app.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by toastal on Thursday December 17, 2020 @10:57PM (#25463647)
Thailand is very much LINE and a close second is Messenger
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by zhte415 on Thursday December 17, 2020 @12:31AM (#25452848)
I find it curious a lot of friends are getting back to Skype, for personal use, across continents, and not CorporateSkype/OC. Is this a huge selection bias thing? Don't know. Several have also recently deleted GMail.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by zem on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:50PM (#25451367)
it's huge in india. a phone that did not support it would definitely be a non-starter.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by toastal on Thursday December 17, 2020 @11:02PM (#25463700)
These answers have been insightful. Not sure why asking got me downvotes.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by FelipeCortez on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:16PM (#25451576)
It is _the_ chat app in Brazil. Brazil is pretty big
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by shp0ngle on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:29PM (#25451652)
India. I'm pretty sure they mean India.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by abrowne on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:00PM (#25451456)
European countries.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by jagger27 on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @06:15PM (#25450095)
Firefox OS predates the 'F' acquisition of 'W' by about a year, right? Did that have anything to do with it, in your opinion?
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by fabrice_d on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @06:24PM (#25450176)
No I don't think this is related in any way.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by postingawayonhn on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @06:28PM (#25450204)
Apps. Google refused to build apps for Windows Phone. Microsoft even went as far as building a YouTube app for Windows Phone themselves (a very good one at the time) but Google quickly forced them to remove it.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:09PM (#25451534)
> Windows Phone, WebOS, Meego and Ubuntu Phone all "failed" around the same time period as Firefox OS. I have a hard time laying blame solely on Mozilla there.

I've seen a number of comments on Windows Phone since then (on HN), and one and all they emphasize how much better and nicer Windows Phone was -- from a consumer perspective -- than any other phone.

What was the failure? This isn't a retrospective that makes any sense.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by heavyset_go on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:25PM (#25451631)
I feel the same way about webOS: it was better and nicer than Android or iOS, and we had to wait half of a decade before Android and iOS adopted some of the features it shipped with in 2009.

As of 2019, however, 52.4% of the mobile OS market belongs to iOS, and 47% to Android[1]. Neither of our favorite mobile phone OSes have succeeded in comparison.

[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/266572/market-share-held...

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @10:12PM (#25451978)
> As of 2019, however, 52.4% of the mobile OS market belongs to iOS, and 47% to Android.

This doesn't pass the sniff test, unless you're doing something weird like measuring the mobile OS market in dollars spent on phones.

> Neither of our favorite mobile phone OSes have succeeded in comparison.

To be clear, I have no experience of Windows Phone. I'm just bemused that 100% of comments about what it was like are so glowing. For some other product, you'd expect to see some comments saying "this was the greatest product ever to be commercially available" and some others saying "no, I had one of those, and it sucked". That doesn't seem to happen for Windows Phone.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by cozzyd on Thursday December 17, 2020 @12:31AM (#25452849)
The source is for the US, where it's at least plausible.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by lenkite on Thursday December 17, 2020 @06:42AM (#25454686)
Google forced Microsoft to remove Youtube and other apps. Also Microsoft kept 're-inventing' the phone OS multiple times requiring app authors to keep rewriting the app to new API's.

A lot of patent fees paid to Apple and Google for every phone sold.

Windows Phone was really good and it had millions of fans. It would probably do well in today's duopoly market if relaunched but MS has lost interest in phones presently.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by addicted on Thursday December 17, 2020 @03:27AM (#25453717)
WebOS wasn’t tried in any meaningful sense. It was abandoned within less than a single product lifecycle by the various companies under which it operated.

Windows Phone was an epic disaster in how badly it was rolled out. It was Ballmer at his worst. MS kept oscillating between whether they wanted Windows Phone to be an iPhone competitor or an Android competitor. They picked the worst of all worlds, by choosing to focus on distributing through 3rd party vendors, but refusing to allow them to make any changes to the interface, therefore basically eliminating any major vendors from adopting and promoting Windows Phone. It’s still amazing that MS was unable to unseat Android at a time OEMs were desperate for an Android alternative thanks to the uncertainty around the Oracle lawsuits (and were already paying more to MS than Google for Android! thanks to MS’s OS related patent portfolio).

Ubuntu Phone never made any sense, targeting the most expensive niche of the market as it did.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by nemothekid on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @11:55PM (#25452631)
>What was the failure? This isn't a retrospective that makes any sense.

Windows Phone had great, snappy, intuitive UI (which was really surprising coming from Microsoft). However it had no apps. If you look at the top 10 iPhone apps in the app store, only Facebook and Netflix were officially supported on the platform. I recall there being (great) 3rd party apps for apps like Instagram, but there was a dearth of anything else.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by addicted on Thursday December 17, 2020 @03:28AM (#25453728)
Windows Phones biggest problem was a lack of major OEM support.

They needed Samsung and HTC to have adopted them at the time.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by chrisseaton on Thursday December 17, 2020 @09:42AM (#25455965)
> What was the failure? This isn't a retrospective that makes any sense.

People didn't buy it. Simple as that.

Doesn't matter how much better people think the consumer experience is if nobody's buying it.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by thaumasiotes on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:48PM (#25459543)
Except that, again, that makes for a completely nonsensical theory of what happened. You can't just say "it was vastly superior to everything else, so it failed because no one would buy it". You need to explain why no one would buy it, because the only data in your model says that people should be buying it in droves.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by chrisseaton on Thursday December 17, 2020 @05:06PM (#25461139)
> You need to explain why no one would buy it

I don’t need to do anything!

The only thing that matters is people didn’t buy it. It wasn’t a success.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by skinkestek on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @11:47PM (#25452573)
> What was the failure? This isn't a retrospective that makes any sense.

No YouTube, no Snapchat etc.

With YouTube Google used their position to keep it that way.

It also wouldn't surprise me if someone told certain app developers that "that's a nice app you have there, it would be shame if there was a bug in the Play store that made it hard ro find".

When it comes to App Store I have heard it is pretty well established that you won't get featured, no matter how great your app is if it is available on other platforms.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @11:49PM (#25452587)
> No YouTube, no Snapchat etc.

> With YouTube Google used their position to keep it that way.

YouTube is available to anyone with a web browser, such as people using a smartphone.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by lolinder on Thursday December 17, 2020 @12:52AM (#25452972)
Yes, but YouTube on mobile (in Firefox at least) is crippled in comparison to the mobile app or the desktop site, probably intentionally.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by jdc on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @03:00PM (#25447745)
FWIW webOS is still alive and well.

https://www.webosose.org

https://github.com/webosose

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by heavyset_go on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @03:13PM (#25447907)
LG also has it running on smart TVs. I had the Pre over a decade ago, and having webOS in my pocket was great.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by Yhippa on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @03:14PM (#25447924)
Hey, thanks for this link. I was a huge fan of webOS since the days of the Palm Pre. I noticed that this runs on the Raspberry Pi 4. Do you know what the use case for this is? Store displays?
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by unparagoned on Thursday December 17, 2020 @04:10AM (#25453912)
The lg smart TVs use webOS as their OS. So I guess everything you do with the TV uses it
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by jdc on Thursday December 17, 2020 @04:28AM (#25453989)
Also see Enact, the Enyo framework's sucessor.

https://enactjs.com

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by apozem on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @05:19PM (#25449575)
Bill Gates explained why everybody but Google and Apple failed at mobile OSes:

> “In the software world, particularly for platforms, these are winner-take-all markets. So the greatest mistake ever is whatever mismanagement I engaged in that caused Microsoft not to be what Android is. That is, Android is the standard non-Apple phone platform. That was a natural thing for Microsoft to win. It really is winner take all. If you’re there with half as many apps or 90 percent as many apps, you’re on your way to complete doom. There’s room for exactly one non-Apple operating system."

https://www.theverge.com/2019/6/24/18715202/microsoft-bill-g...

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by Brakenshire on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @05:30PM (#25449676)
Looking at wikipedia KaiOS seems to be the second mobile OS in India now, ahead of the iPhone. I don’t think those rules apply to a system which relies of web technologies, because you have such an enormous base of developers and development infrastructure.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by tjoff on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:03PM (#25450505)
KaiOS is a joke though... More akin to your desk calculator than a phone that we have become accustomed to. They sell because they are cheap, not on any other merit.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by Bayart on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:16PM (#25450635)
Being cheap is the greatest merit of any consumer tech.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by stjohnswarts on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @10:59PM (#25452285)
you'll never convince apple of that.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by arvinsim on Thursday December 17, 2020 @07:01AM (#25454797)
Was he implying that a duopoly in the mobile space was a foregone conclusion?
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by old-gregg on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @03:15PM (#25447930)
> I can't understand how Mozilla failed to execute on Firefox OS.

Because this product could only be sold to a hardware maker. It doesn't matter how good it was/is, because hardware makers are smart enough now not to rely on a 3rd party supplier of an OS, in fact they've been working hard on degoogling Android as much as possible.

Another failed alternative that comes to mind is WebOS, and yes indeed, it got acquired by LG for the reasons above.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by pfraze on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @03:08PM (#25447841)
Well you know what's really tragic: FFOS is a pretty big success. It was forked and became KaiOS, which has decent market-share in India.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by higerordermap on Thursday December 17, 2020 @06:28AM (#25454602)
It didn't need to be KaiOS. The OS on jio phones is severely crippled and it could be any OS with a webview. I don't count it as success of FFOS, at least on technical merits.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by dkdk8283 on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:34PM (#25451240)
Remember launching a phone just isn’t FirefoxOS: you need a device to load it on, a carrier willing to support it (this is the biggest hurdle by far), and to negotiate the baseband blob that you have absolutely no reason idea what it does and has DMA.

I have personally gone through carrier negotiations and they’re the reason why Android phones come with bloat ware and people go to such lengths to build and distribute minimalistic Android systems.

When the pandemic is over and the world opens again go visit Mobile World Congress. Bring a tissue because the industry might make you cry.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by lenkite on Thursday December 17, 2020 @06:38AM (#25454667)
They just needed a bit of persistence. In a 5K run, they sprinted for 2K and then gave up and threw away the baton. Other companies picked what they ditched and profit now. Deeply irritating.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by Narishma on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @03:56PM (#25448516)
> I can't understand how Mozilla failed to execute on Firefox OS.

Wasn't it initially too slow and bloated for the hardware they released it on?

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by rewgs on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @11:08PM (#25452343)
I didn't pay much attention to the project at the time, but:

Might it have something to do with the word "OS" in the title? It's never worked except for Apple, but because Apple is selling a whole product, not an OS, it doesn't seem to hit in the same way.

Marketing something as "____ OS" appears to more or less guarantee a marketing failure.

Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by zelly on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:59AM (#25453603)
A lot of smart TV apps are already HTML and JavaScript webviews. You can create a webview app on Android, iOS, Windows, Mac, a ton of proprietary devices like cars or TVs. What benefit would Firefox OS bring here, besides creating another kludgy abstraction layer over the vendor hardware?
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by aduitsis on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @02:24PM (#25447236)
For some reason, yesterday's HN post "I can't keep up with React" came to mind :)
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by julenx on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @02:55PM (#25447676)
Out of curiosity, which post is that? I cannot find it.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by aduitsis on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @04:19PM (#25448842)
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by O_H_E on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:05AM (#25453355)
The techAltar youtube channel might have some useful content on the subject.
Re:Firefox Was Always Enough by jshen on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @10:19PM (#25452038)
The short answer, they were too late.